The re-thinking of music and the Mass continues

  • Thread starter Thread starter VociMike
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Thank you, VociMike, for this great link! I will be making a hard copy of it for my music notebook to use the next time I have a problem articulating why certain music should not be used at Mass even if the lyrics are acceptable. I was also relieved to learn that the Bishop’s new document on music would only be addressing texts, not music. Since I am out of the US, I haven’t read much about this new document except in these forums or on liturgical blogs. Where can I find out more about it?
 
Thanks, Mike. It was a good read. As I have written in other threads in this forum, everything that he said as Cardinal Ratzinger is now coming into play as Benedict.

I sent a copy of an aritcle written in the Adoremus website to our superintendent of Catholic schools You can find it in this month’s edition of the Adoremus bulletin at www.adoremus.org. The piece discusses Sacred Music and takes its cue from Benedict’s document, Sacramentum Caritatis.
 
Thank you, too, Benedictgal for your link. I enjoyed it very much. We serious church musicians have our work cut out for us. Have you looked at the posts in the Popular Media forum “Does anyone have a favorite hymn?” Many of the hymns mentioned certainly do not fit the criteria of these articles, and the posters are our faithful Catholic brothers and sisters of the Catholic Answers forums. It is as if we are discussing the merits of different kinds of delicious pastries while they are content to eat sugar out of the box. We need to help them with patience and charity. I hope that I am up to it.
 
Thank you, too, Benedictgal for your link. I enjoyed it very much. We serious church musicians have our work cut out for us. Have you looked at the posts in the Popular Media forum “Does anyone have a favorite hymn?” Many of the hymns mentioned certainly do not fit the criteria of these articles, and the posters are our faithful Catholic brothers and sisters of the Catholic Answers forums. It is as if we are discussing the merits of different kinds of delicious pastries while they are content to eat sugar out of the box. We need to help them with patience and charity. I hope that I am up to it.
There is also a powerpoint presentation made by the Bishop’s Committee on Liturgy. The Bishops are going to be hammering out a new document during next week’s meeting. You can find it here: usccb.org/liturgy/MUSIC%20FDLCnew.ppt

Now, Marysanne, I don’t know how the Patriarch handles music for your part of the world. I say Patriarch because I’m not sure if he is the primate of Israel or if your country has its own bishops’ conference. At least the power point is food for thought.

Just a brief note on the power point. The BCL took a random survey of some of the hymns. Only 10% refer to God as Father. Virtually none have any reference to the Blessed Trinity. Roughly 55% emphasize the needs of the Church and only 10% offer any praise and adoration to God.

I suspect that the hymns you mentioned fall under the category of questionable music.
 
Benedictsgal, I hate to disillusion you, but the Patriarch has nothing to do with English Masses. As far as I know, no Church authority takes any interest in what is done in Masses that are attended primarily by foreigners. Most who attend these Masses are tourists or third country nationals such as diplomats or laborers. Fortunately our Masses are celebrated by good orthodox priests, but they just don’t have any interest in music. My husband is in the foreign service, and we have lived in six different countries. Music at English speaking Masses in every one of the countries (countries which are not English speaking) in which we have lived has come from old Oregon Catholic Press missalettes that someone picked up somewhere. In two of the countries in which we lived, I volunteered to do the music myself, even though I had to play the piano, which I dislike intensely. Here we are lucky to have a British diplomat who is a fine organist, but he does like to go on vacation once in while. On Christmas we will be subjected to the guitar music which is standard at English Masses around here unless we can get seats at one of the small monastaries in the area (where the Mass with be celebrated in French). American diplomats are not allowed to go to Bethlehem. I feel so embarrassed as an American that all of our liturgical bad habits have spread all over the world especially to third world countries. They think that anything from America is just great! Some of members of our community are trying to introduce the St. Michael Hymnal because it has standard hymns that have not been bowdlerized into political correctness, and still has some of the less offensive modern songs for those who want them. There is no budget for this, so we are trying to figure out how to pay for enough books for our little chapel. I can tell you from experience that if we can raise the standard of church music in the United States, it will have an affect all over the world.
 
Let’s hope that for once, the USCCB will get something right and work to raise the bar on liturgical music.

I don’t know if any of our fellow posters have gently used, unadulterated hymnals that we could send to Marysanne. I’m thinking the old Red Worship III (without the new translations).
 
Thank you for the generous offer, but it would cost a fortune to send books to Israel through international mail! I will let you know what finally happens though.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top