The Relationship between the Roman Catholic and Eastern Orthodox Church

  • Thread starter Thread starter SnakeMauler
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
S

SnakeMauler

Guest
So, whats so different about us? Can a Catholic receive Eucharist at an Orthodox church, or could a Catholic and an Orthodox person marry?

Also, there’s like a differentiation between Eastern Orthodox and Eastern Catholic right? Like, Eastern Orthodox is it’s own thing while “Eastern Catholic” refers to churches that aren’t “Roman” catholic but are in full communion with the pope?

Thanks,
Snakemauler
 
Catholics and Orthodoxy intermarry all the time.

Because of the different theologies about who ministers the Mystery–Orthodoxy teaches that it is conferred by the Priest upon the couple–it is preferred that such marriages take place in the Orthodox Church, with the Catholic bishop’s dispensation.

Catholics normally cannot receive the Eucharist in Orthodox Churches, unless separated from ministry of their own church.

Yes, Eastern Orthodox and Eastern Catholic churches are two different families of Churches.
 
So, whats so different about us?
Mostly terminology, but some differences in the understanding of the nature of bishops and synods. The Oriental Orthodox have a slightly different understanding of the nature of Christ, but not sufficiently different as to be heretical by Catholic understanding at present.

There are 3 major “communions” - unions of churches with self-governance of some kind - the Catholic, The Eastern Orthodox, and the Oriental Orthodox.

The Catholics are of several Rites: Roman, Byzantine (aka Constanopolitan, Greek Catholic), West Syrian/Antiochian, East Syrian/Eddessan, Armenian, Alexandrian (aka Coptic)
The Eastern Orthodox are of two rites: Byzantine and Byzanto-Roman.
The Oriental Orthodox include Alexandrian, Armenian, and East Syrian rites. They are headed by Pope Shenouda of Alexandria, Patriarch of the Coptic Orthodox Church.

The Jacobite Churches include both Syrian rites, but I don’t know that they count as a formal communion. They are present in Syria and India.
Can a Catholic receive Eucharist at an Orthodox church,
In exceptional circumstances, yes. Part of those include permission from the pastor of the orthodox parish.
or could a Catholic and an Orthodox person marry?
Generally, Yes, but generally, it must be done in the Orthodox parish. It isn’t advised, but is permitted.

Some Orthodox jurisdictions do not permit it, however.
Also, there’s like a differentiation between Eastern Orthodox and Eastern Catholic right? Like, Eastern Orthodox is it’s own thing while “Eastern Catholic” refers to churches that aren’t “Roman” catholic but are in full communion with the pope?

Thanks,
Snakemauler
The Eastern Catholics are the 22 Churches sui iuris that are in full communion with the pope, and act as part of the synod of the Catholic Church, while retaining self governing status as churches, called Churches Sui Iuris.

Byzantine Rite Catholics and Greek Catholics (14 churches sui iuris) (the terms are synonyms, as is Greek Rite Catholic) are generally portions of the Eastern Orthodox Churches which left the Eastern Orthodox communion and joined the Catholic Communion. 1 has no orthodox counterpart (Italo-Albanian GCC), 1 has an orthodox counterpart that is a schism from the Catholic (The ACROD split from the Ruthenian GCC); the rest have parallels from the time of their split. Two have no hierarchs (Russian and one other).

Other Eastern Catholics (7 churches sui iuris) are of other Eastern Rites, and most have non-Catholic Parallel churches. Some, the majority synod is the Catholic; others the majority synod is the non-catholic.

The Chaldeans (Catholic Communion) are parallel to the Assyrian Church of the East (Oriental Orthodox Communion)

The Syro-Malabar and Syro-Malankar Catholic Churches have parallel Syriac churches and protestant churches using the same liturgical rites.

The Syrian Catholic and Syrian Orthodox churches parallel.

The Coptic Catholic Church split off from the Coptic Orthodox Church.

The Ethiopian Catholic Church parallels the Ethiopian Tehwado Orthodox and the Eritrean Orthodox.

The Armenian Catholics and the Armenian Apostolic Orthodox have an unusual relationship; the Armenian Catholics are in full communion with the other Catholic Churches, but are, as a practical matter, still in communion with their parent Armenian Apostolic Orthodox. Deacons assisting across church boundaries are common; priestly concelebration happens with patriarchal tacit approval. Hierarchical concelebration doesn’t seem to happen…

The Maronite Catholics have no parallel church.
 
Thanks for the info guys… It’s pretty complicated stuff. Why couldn’t our anscestors stay together so we’d all be one church 😦 I get lost in all this terminology.
 
Thanks for the info guys… It’s pretty complicated stuff. Why couldn’t our anscestors stay together so we’d all be one church 😦 I get lost in all this terminology.
Simplified: Eastern Catholic Churches as a generality have direct parallels with the same traditions & liturgical forms in some form of Orthodoxy.

And each of the churches developed autonomously, based upon the local culture and what the apostles and local bishops who taught in the region had emphasized.

Each Church has its own version of liturgy, often still near identical with its parallel on the other side… because most came into existence as Catholic “unitates” between 1700 and 1950. Some go back a LOT further.
 
The Catholics are of several Rites: Roman, Byzantine (aka Constanopolitan, Greek Catholic), West Syrian/Antiochian, East Syrian/Eddessan, Armenian, Alexandrian (aka Coptic)
Somehow, I think the Ethiopians would take exception to being referred to as Coptic. Alexandrene, yes, Coptic, no.
The Oriental Orthodox include Alexandrian, Armenian, and East Syrian rites.
Not exactly. The Oriental Orthodox include Alexandrene, Armenian, and West Syriac. As far as I know, the East Syriac (ACoE) is not formally considered “Oriental Orthodox” and never has been.
They are headed by Pope Shenouda of Alexandria, Patriarch of the Coptic Orthodox Church.
Since when? I’m sure that HH Zakka I, among others, would be thrilled to hear this. :rolleyes:
The Jacobite Churches include both Syrian rites, but I don’t know that they count as a formal communion. They are present in Syria and India.
What? :confused:
The Syrian Catholic and Syrian Orthodox churches parallel.
The preferred term in English is Syriac. This is so in order to remove any question about the involvement of a political state.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top