The Robe (1953)

  • Thread starter Thread starter CyrilSebastian
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
C

CyrilSebastian

Guest
The Robe is a drama set during the Crucifixion of Jesus.
Code:
I like the role of the character that Jean Simmons played.   

What did you like about The Robe?
 
The Robe was a book published in 1942. It quickly rose to #1 on the New York Times bestseller list for nearly a year and stayed on the list for another two years.
The reason it was such a bestseller was the Protestant style preaching in the book. I read the book and this stuff was, shall we say, like listening to a sermon. It is because of this preaching that the book sold so well probably among the Protestants of the Bible Belt. There is no mention of the Catholic Mass, Eucharist, sacraments or any of that.

The movie dropped all the preaching and many scenes associated with it.

In the book, the final last scene with Caligula was nowhere near as interesting as the movie. Caligula just wanted to get rid of Centurion Galleo, and after condemning him Caligula calmly said he thought he had something to do and walked away.
There was none of the hysteical, crazed Caligula that made the movie’s end so amazing.
In the book the slave Demetrius was never imprisoned in Caligula’s palace and Centurion Galleo never rescued him, or did anything else of a heroic nature. The movie added all that. The book, written by Protestant minister Lloyd Cassel Douglas, had as its sole purpose preaching the Bible. The movie, made after Douglas’s death, had a different purpose, obviously: to make money.

In the book Centurion Galleo spent a lot of time with Christians and learned enough to deserve being called a Christian. In the movie, Galleo seemed not to know a thing about Christianity, and you have to wonder why he sacrificed his life, not to mention Diana who didn’t have a clue what this new religion was .
 
And furthermore,

in both the book and the movie, and also in the 1949 movie Quo Vadis,
Peter is in Rome and is clearly the leader of the Christians. Paul isn’t mentioned.

Then television came in and we saw the rise of the televangelists who want to re-write history.
Today, the televangelists want you to think that Paul was the leader of the Christians and Peter was never even in Rome.
 
Pax Christi!

*The Robe *is the kind of historical fiction I like. It doesn’t contradict Scripture or Tradition, but adds to them.

Check out Theopilus, for instance. I forget the author’s name, but it’s good stuff.

God bless.
 
While I enjoyed the movie, I own a copy, I like the book much much better. More in depth with much of the “back story” taking place that simply is not found in the movie.
 
Generally I like any movie set in the world of antiquity, even those cheesy Italian Hercules movies from the 1960’s! Even 'A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum". Is ‘The Robe’ the one with Paul Newman in his first film role?
 
I can answer my own question – I was thinking of ‘the Silver Chalice.’ Mea culpa.
 
Loved The Robe … and similar films.

My family had certain movies that we’d quote from.

When someone was telling a story about something that happened outdoors … we might break in with Richard Burton’s tortured “Were YOU out there?!” Or when someone was going out Caligula’s screamed line “GO! Go to your Kingdom!” was good for a grin.

Other films of that genre (period films around the time of Christ or just after) include: Barrabas (Anthony Quinn), Ben-Hur (Charlton Heston), Quo Vadis (Robert Taylor and Deborah Kerr), Demetrius and the Gladiators (Victor Mature), The Big Fisherman (Howard Keel as the Apostle Peter), and King of Kings (Jeffery Hunter). ALL of which I liked.

Spartacus (Kirk Douglas, Tony Curtis, Peter Ustinov) dealt with the same period roughly (but BC) … and hence there was no Church or religious theme.

The Robe, Quo Vadis and Barrabas all used the device of a main character on the outside learning of and experiencing the Christian Community and Church under persecution.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top