The Seal of the Confessional Question

  • Thread starter Thread starter ceedre
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
C

ceedre

Guest
Does the seal of the confessional bind the priest from speaking to the penitent outside of the confessional at a later time? I spoke to a priest about my possible vocation in confession today and would like to know if it’s ok for him to talk to me about my vocation outside the confessional. If it’s not, do I need to tell him everything I told him about my vocation again if I would like to talk to him outside confession?
 
You have the right to lift the seal of your confessor as regards to your confession. So, while your preist can’t bring the subject up to you, you can bring it up to him. At which point, he can speak freely, at least about that subject.
 
Does the seal of the confessional bind the priest from speaking to the penitent outside of the confessional at a later time? I spoke to a priest about my possible vocation in confession today and would like to know if it’s ok for him to talk to me about my vocation outside the confessional. If it’s not, do I need to tell him everything I told him about my vocation again if I would like to talk to him outside confession?
No, you do not need to repeat yourself in order to speak to your Priest about things discussed during your confession. However, if you wish to speak to him about it, YOU must approach him. He will not approach you about things discussed during your confession.
 
Does the seal of the confessional bind the priest from speaking to the penitent outside of the confessional at a later time? I spoke to a priest about my possible vocation in confession today and would like to know if it’s ok for him to talk to me about my vocation outside the confessional. If it’s not, do I need to tell him everything I told him about my vocation again if I would like to talk to him outside confession?
the priest cannot discuss your confession outside, take any action based on anything you have said. If you have something to discuss outside confession, make an appointment in the normal way and bring up the topic. It can be something mentioned in confession, but you have to initiate a new discussion and introduce the topic yourself.
 
Absolutely it is your option to approach and discuss this. One think to think about, was your discussion of vocation really part of your confession? If it came between the “Bless me Father” and the absolution I think it was. But I have had some long face to face talks with priests in a confessional setting that were probably not really confined to confession.

What do others think about this? If something comes up during confession that is not related to the confession is it sealed? Example - if the priest says “TMC, how’s your mother?” And I say, “She’s struggling with the flu, Father.” Is that sealed? Can he give her a call?
 
Yes, this is really the situation. It came between the “confess me, father” and absolution, so I assume it’s bound by the seal, but I’m not sure. It’s kind of unfortunate because now if I want to talk to him more, I need to explain everything all over again!
 
Yes, this is really the situation. It came between the “confess me, father” and absolution, so I assume it’s bound by the seal, but I’m not sure. It’s kind of unfortunate because now if I want to talk to him more, I need to explain everything all over again!
I don’t think so. Just say “Father, can we talk about those things about my future I expressed to you last ___(thursday, week, whatever).” Unfortunately he doesn’t hear about vocations everyday so he will remember. If he thinks it improper (which I am sure he wont) he’ll let you know. More likely he’ll make some time to sit down with you. Not a big deal either way. Just give him a call.
 
I don’t think so. Just say “Father, can we talk about those things about my future I expressed to you last ___(thursday, week, whatever).” Unfortunately he doesn’t hear about vocations everyday so he will remember. If he thinks it improper (which I am sure he wont) he’ll let you know. More likely he’ll make some time to sit down with you. Not a big deal either way. Just give him a call.
I have often discussed someting that I brought up in confession after the fact with the same priest. I simply say, “remember when I brought up ------- in confession last week. Can we talk a bit more about that?” I don’t need to explain it all over again unless he forgot what we talked about.
 
Simply make an appointment to speak to your pastor. Tell him at the meeting that you are considering religious life. I would not even broach the idea that it was mentioned during confession. That way you would not place him in a situation that feels conflicting for him. As a new subject you can both feel at ease. I have heard many priests state that one of the grace of Holy Orders is totally forgetting everything that is said during confession.
 
I just met with him today and I wasn’t sure of the exact criteria of the seal of the confessional but that “I’m thinking about becoming a priest” and that I’m ok with him talking to be about it.
He thanked me, and told me it is true that he couldn’t have approached me about it before cause of the seal.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top