The speed of threads

  • Thread starter Thread starter goodcatholic
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
G

goodcatholic

Guest
I’ve been away for a while. Coming back I notice how fast the forum moves. I’m grateful for responses of course but sometimes I feel I am caught in a whirlpool or fast rapids. Does this affect the quality of our communication?
Are we tempted to give pat answers instead of thoughtful replies? I’m not pointing the finger at anyone by the way. Because I have received both.
I’m just sharing this odd feeling with you. It is unique to CA . I think I’m seasick. 🙂
 
Yeah, it is a bit overwhelming at times. I find myself dipping in but there’s just no way to keep up with everything, it would be a full-time job! I’d rather give a few judiciously chosen, thoughtful replies than a hundred pat boring posts.
 
Quality over quantity is what I hope for! I try to only follow a few threads at once, or else you’ll have to spent all of your spare time following topics!
 
Last edited:
I can’t answer as far as other forums are concerned. This is the only one I participate in. I will be interested in the response of others. I had been involved in other groups (Facebook), and found the interaction lacking in detail and substance. I see a variety of answers: some short and to the point, some long and drawn out, some based on thought, and some just strange. I tend to focus on three or four areas while scanning others. I have found that asking questions or clarification leads to conversations that are more satisfying.
 
I am the Way, the Truth and the Life. No one comes to the Father but by me.

There’s nothing wrong with pat answers. What should be of concern is the endless ‘debates’ by Catholics or those who claim to be Catholic on clear teachings of Jesus.
 
Last edited:
Yes, it is compared to the old format. I think it is due to more members, especially those competent computer users. It affects usage as well.
 
You’re absolutely right, goodcatholic. The number of new threads per day, and the number of posts per day, is far too high for the good of the forum. At present, it hardly feels like a discussion forum anymore; it feels more like a social media platform, but without the ability to distinguish friends from non-friends, to subscribe to groups, etc. Just reading all new thread titles is almost too much work to keep up with – let alone actually opening each thread and reading the OP’s post.

I think what a lot of people do here is just look at whatever seems new, either in the general view – which presents topic by recent activity, which means anything more than a few hours ago is likely to be way down the list, and to go unnoticed by most – or in the “new” view, which is configurable in your preferences, but regardless of how you configure it doesn’t work well. In any case, with this approach (“let’s have a look”), the chances of not noticing a thread that would have had your interest, are very, very high. Interaction thus becomes more or less “random”. There is no way of knowing whether you looked at all threads (at least the titles) that might take your interest, unless you spend your whole day on CAF. And worse, there is no way of knowing (or making it likely) that all those who might have been interested in your thread, have at least seen it.

Welcome to the new world, goodcatholic. Fire at will, at random targets, forget, move on. That’s “discussion” in 2018 for ya 😉
 
Last edited:
It doesn’t help that threads close after 14 days. I find it very frustrating that I post something and have no facility to go back and update it at a later time if it drops off the radar for more than two weeks. It’s really contributed to the sense of quick, scattergun, get your point in asap or forget about it. And I think it reduces the usefulness of the site, tbh.
 
It’s really contributed to the sense of quick, scattergun, get your point in asap or forget about it. And I think it reduces the usefulness of the site, tbh.
Yes. As I see it, when a discussion forum works well it naturally becomes a storehouse of information organized by topic. This forum isn’t becoming that, because it’s so hard to find anything that’s “gone cold”. Only what’s “trending” now, what’s “hot” now, will show up on most people’s radar, and will get some attention. And what’s hot and what’s not changes by the hour – literally.

In a way this forum is a good anology of the entire modern world: it effectively, if not intentionally, subscribes to the view that if it’s not recent, it’s irrelevant. History is reduced to a couple of hours, a day at most.
 
In a way this forum is a good anology of the entire modern world: it effectively, if not intentionally, subscribes to the view that if it’s not recent, it’s irrelevant. History is reduced to a couple of hours, a day at most.
You guys are really articulating well my whole point of view on this. It’s almost like a disease. And yet our faith is supposed to subscribe to the very opposite.
 
If the threads go too fast, would there be a thread boom?
Like a sonic boom?
 
You guys are really articulating well my whole point of view on this. It’s almost like a disease. And yet our faith is supposed to subscribe to the very opposite.
Precisely. I have also recently returned to this site, initially with the expectation that it would be a home-coming. It hasn’t been. Rather it’s been a varied experience, at times very unpleasant, at other times somewhat valuable. Overall, I’m afraid the bad overshadows the good, but not yet enough to call it quits today.

The reason I’m sticking around is that I believe I’m learning something from participating on this site again. It offers a good view of what the global Catholic community is today, where it stands, and where it’s going, where real support comes from, and who the real enemies are. It’s not a pleasant discovery, but I believe it’s better to know the truth about where and how things stand, than to continue on with a perception of the RCC that holds no basis in reality.
 
Last edited:
I think if you come to deepen your faith here, you might be disappointed. It’s basically an information sharing place. I’ve learnt a lot from this one and another Christian forum site. I suspect the reason some people come to these sites is to pass on their “superior knowledge”. I can pass on my mediocre to below average knowledge sometimes. 🙂
 
i have been in forums for more than 15 years. And it is always the same dynamics. CAF is no exception.

Your can’t embrace the whole forum. So simply try to keep track of the topics and users you like and you’ll be fine.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top