"The Talk"

  • Thread starter Thread starter k8e308
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
K

k8e308

Guest
If you need to have a serious discussion with your husband (or wife) and it is a subject likely to cause an argument, how do you introduce it and manage the discussion so it doesn’t turn argumentative?

If you have several such subjects that need to be discussed, then how do you prioritize and space them? How do you decide what you can compromise on and what you can’t?
 
In my experience, when you need to discuss several issues with a close person, it gets tricky either way. If you unload it all at once, it gives the impression you’re unhappy all across the board and are launching a general attack (or complaint). On the other hand, if you space the issues one by one, it gives the impression that you’re always unhappy and always have something to complain about.

I suppose the best solution would be state clearly that you have a couple of issues and you can discuss them one by one or all, either in one discussion or in several discussions. In practice, either way, you still need to keep some order and keep the discussion brief. You don’t want to be talking about everything at once and turning it into a general emotional indictment. I’d probably at least name all the issues at the beginning of the conversation and then go one by one, as briefly as possible, avoiding inflammatory language, rhetorical questions, vague suppositions or anything similar. It can’t look like a judgement, a verdict, or a match in a mutual rivalry where points are being scored. I would try to avoid giving an impression of totally rejecting the other person, which may be hard when issues are multiple and span across several areas.

Also, there is something I can tell you as a criminal lawyer: no matter how tight a case looks against someone, sometimes a single, small piece of evidence can wreck it all. It is also possible for a very bad looking defendant to be perfectly innocent. Unlike a court and the police, in normal life we don’t follow strict methods of scrutiny, most of us don’t have the training to do so, and our “findings” may be much more leaking, our reasoning may take a few leaps or jump a couple of steps. All the more so if we’re emotionally involved (and even professional judges, prosecutors etc. are or should be removed from a case if they’re emotionally involved). This is why one should always try to keep an open mind and to keep the guessing and suppositions in check. It is also easy to experience a landslide, that is, if you consider someone “guilty” of one wrong, then it’s easier to add another wrong to it with less reflection and so on until someone who really messed up in one thing is turned into some kind of emotional scapegoat or the default guilty party whenever anything goes wrong. I believe this is the case in many sad marriages. Avoid that. (And have a good reason whenever you accuse someone of doing something wrong.)

To an extent, you can use the so called “me language” as opposed to the “you language”, that is telling the other person how you feel as opposed to how bad he or she is. This is a fad among psychologists and some other professionals but it’s overrated because it has the potential to make you look like a self-centred person with a lot of your own problems simply due to your style of talking. However, you can still rely on this when there is a largely emotional problem. For example you can talk about feeling neglected as opposed to your husband or relative or friend being an egoist.

On a final note, I’d probably say use as few words as possible without leaving out anything important. Try to avoid redundancies (when we’re unhappy, we tend to repeat ourselves like a broken record), diatribes (we covered this a while before), moments of indecision that make it look like you’re looking for things or don’t know what yet to add (this is an impression that comes easy to someone who has to hear a list of complaints and the “complaining party” stops or stutters for a while).

Good luck and you’ll be in my prayers.

Edit: Oh, you mentioned compromising. I’m not the best person at it but there are basically two styles of compromising: value splitting and value creating. Imagine a cake. You can divide the cake into pieces of any size, any number. This is dividing the cake or dividing the value. A fixed sum game. Or you can become creative and come up with a solution that doesn’t go 50/50 but rather 70/70 or 60/80 or 80/60 or 65/65 by finding ways in which you and the other person can help each other without having to give up too much. This requires cooperation. An easy illustration from coursebooks is oranges or bananas: two pharma companies need precisely the amount of that fruit which is available, except one needs the skin and the other needs the pulp. If they sue, one gets it all and the other gets nothing. If they make a 50/50 compromise each gets half of what it needs. But if they explore and are creative, they can actually come up with a solution in which everybody’s needs are covered. They just need to explore which parts of that fruit they actually need (as opposed to claiming the fruit without providing any reasons for it). This requires some general openness, as well as an open attitude to your needs and the needs of the other party.
 
As an illustration, suppose you feel neglected because your husband doesn’t tell you what time he’s going to be home (I’m choosing a generic example on purpose, I hope it’ll go down easy). On the other hand, he would feel unduly constricted if he had to account for his time with accuracy to 5-10 minutes. The real problem is not about the timings or the accounting but about showing you that you’re onboard and an important partner, while keeping a breathing space for himself. Both parties will likely need to budge: you will need to give up the idea of having things planned with precision and totally predictable, he will need to give up the idea of total freedom. Probably both of you will realise this is reasonable. From that point you can arrive at a solution in which he will let you know whenever something extraordinary is likely to keep him, while you will be understanding and trusting and won’t make a fuss of small missteps (culpable or not but especially not, e.g. traffic jams). At least this is how a typical mediator would handle it. Myself, I believe the above solution sometimes missses the meat of the issue, while it’s more important to gain an understanding of and some empathy for each other’s position, in this case, for you to understand that your husband (in this example, of course) is not hurting you or turning against you by being a little late and failing to inform you ahead of it, and that this little unpunctuality is not connected with a general disrespect, such that would e.g. lead to cheating in the long term. The husband, in turn, would need to understand that wanting some predictability and a more or less reliable schedule, as well as the need to be kept in the picture, does not necessarily involve undue control. Both of you would need to be open-minded and realise that your respective needs are more important than the way you go about achieving them or that fact you’re doing it your own way. That is, each of you needs to stop insisting that things are done your way or his way. And don’t obsess about the best way, either. Just make sure that you can find a way that works most of the time.

And it helps to be generally open to the idea that the other person or his or her needs may be completely innocent, just different from our own. For example a person who needs to go off the radar and unwind at a drink after work isn’t necessarily an alcoholic or a potential cheater. A wife (or husband) that feels the need to be informed is not necessarily controlling or clingy. And so on. I’m not giving other examples on purpose.
 
I suggest reading the books Crucial Conversations (which is a business book but has personal life application) and For Better, Forever by Greg Popcak (which is a Catholic book on marriage and communication).
 
Avoid the pronoun “you.” Instead use “I” and “we.” As in “I feel”, not “you did” or “you did not.”

Choose words carefully so that you avoid sounding accusatory. If the spouse feels accused, rather than a partner in the discussion, he then becomes defensive, and rather than listening he will mentally prepare defenses. The issue is then lost. So, no discussion should sound as though it’s coming from accusation, even when that’s not the intent.

Prioritize. What is the most pressing or important that it be solved before it causes more harm to the family? If you examine these issues closely first before discussing them, some might be something that that is not so important, or can be put on a back burner, or is solved when solving a more or most important issue. One at a time.
 
If you need to have a serious discussion with your husband (or wife) and it is a subject likely to cause an argument, how do you introduce it and manage the discussion so it doesn’t turn argumentative?

If you have several such subjects that need to be discussed, then how do you prioritize and space them? How do you decide what you can compromise on and what you can’t?
I can tell you that the answer to that is different for every couple. For me, it would even be different if I were married to someone else. Your wife is different from everyone else. Your own way of dealing with conflict and deciding how to come to a decision when there isn’t an easy consensus is different from everyone else, too.

IMHO this is a question to ask your spouse. “When I come to you with some beef with you or if your way of handling something is not what I like or I don’t like how you’re handling me or whatever, what works for you and what doesn’t? I’m asking because I think sometimes my way of raising these issues actually starts arguments when all I wanted to do is to have a discussion. Maybe I don’t have a good idea of how to choose a time and a place and a way of doing that, and I thought maybe I’m missing something from your side. Maybe I’m coming off very differently than I intend to.”

Then comes the hard part. Listen to what she has to say and try to make sure you specifically understand what she thinks she wants from you. Remember that old “repeat back what they just said” thing they used to tell couples? Well, that isn’t a bad idea…not that you repeat what she said verbatim (which I find annoying and useless), but that you put her thought into your own words as ask if you are understanding her correctly. If she gets defensive, then say, “OK, let’s try again until I get it the way you meant it. If you’re not saying X are you saying Y?” Then flesh out the questions: “Do you mean that to apply in this situation? How is that different?”

Then, when she is satisfied that you’re getting her, you can tell her what you imagine would work for you. Especially lean on instances when you think her way of approaching you was particularly good, when you came away feeling, “we are a couple that knows how to work things out.” You can talk about times you raised a question and the discussion went better than you had hoped, and ask her if she had a similar or different experience of the same conversation. That is very useful feedback, because it combines what you each like with methods that you have already learned.

IOW, I’m suggesting that the first serious discussion to tackle is a discussion about how your discussion methods have been working for each of you. That could be a real eye-opener. It is also a topic worth re-visiting from time to time, as the relationship evolves.

If you have that discussion and come away feeling that you have something to learn about managing the inevitable points of difference with your spouse, and maybe even if you think your situation already works rather well after that talk, I’d recommend “Ten Lessons to Transform Your Marriage: America’s Love Lab Experts Share Their Strategies for Strengthening Your Relationship” by John Gottman, Julie Schwartz Gottman, and Joan Declaire. The book has examples of couples having discussions before and after coaching, and goes down point by point concerning how each comment either helps or hurts the relationship and the course of the discussion. It does this by treating ten different common sticking points in marriages, so reading the conversations can be useful in a specific way, as well.

That is just one title I happen to have read, and it is well-known enough that our local library has it. I also like it because it is based on field research with real marital relationships. I think it is a good book because it can teach you how to listen to the way you talk yourself, and how different ways of putting the same thing can totally change both the interior and the exterior results of a discussion. I’d recommend paging through it.
 
Wonderful replies so far. Thank you, you’ve given me much to think about concerning our discussions and topics where there is no right or wrong.

Now, what about topics where there is a right and wrong? Religion and Church teaching for example. I’m trying not to be detailed about the disagreements in my marriage, so allow me to create a hypothetical situation:

The god of math has started a church, called it his own, and promised that it would never be wrong. As time goes on, there are dissenters. A faithful mathematician believes the church’s teaching that 2+2-1=3. She marries a dissenter, who converts to being a mathematician. Despite his conversion, he still argues that 2+2-1=5. It is what he has been told all his life, and he believes it with everything that he is. He even dismisses the teaching of the church he claims to be a part of, because that is the way he was taught. He was taught that no one authority can have all the truth about math, and so it does not occur to him that there is indeed a body with such authority. To him, it is the height of ignorance and arrogance to say that such a body exists. Further, while math is everything to her and she tries to consider it and place it at the forefront of her life always, it seems to mean little to him. While he staunchly argues that 2+2-1=5, he just as stubbornly refuses to see what impact such a belief has on his life and behavior.

How in the world can such a chasm be crossed? You can say, of course, that such things should have been discussed before marriage, but they were not (or only briefly) and that cannot be helped now. What is do be done now?
 
I can tell you that the answer to that is different for every couple. For me, it would even be different if I were married to someone else. Your wife is different from everyone else. Your own way of dealing with conflict and deciding how to come to a decision when there isn’t an easy consensus is different from everyone else, too.
.
I just want to second the idea that it is different in every marriage. Some will tell you to choose your wording carefully. That is not what works for my wife and I. We have “come to Jesus” meetings if something needs to be addressed. Point Blank, “this has to change period.” Sometimes my wife hits me with it sometimes it is my turn but my wife and I rarely fight and we find that marriage is so much easier if you are very clear about what it is you need from the other person. There are no ultimatums, just frank and clear talk. I’m not a mind reader or decoder, I just need to know what to do and I will do it even if I feel a tad defensive or accused.
We always address these things late at night when the kids are down and it is solved before we sleep. Sometimes that means we watch the sun rise;) But most of the time many issues get cleaned up in one shot and it should never get nasty.
 
Ask him when is a good time to get into these heavier conversations. Some people are wide awake the second they open their eyes, and are willing to have any sort of conversation at that point. Others are barely stumbling to the coffee pot and their brains are not even fully operating for at least a few hours.

I can tell you for SURE when NOT to get into these discussions, and that is late at night, after a full day, when both of you are tired. It’s the WORST time to argue/discuss anything. I always try to avoid it but sometimes hubby just won’t take no for an answer…

😦

I really hate going to sleep with bad feelings floating around…Try your level best not to get into a fuss at bedtime.

I take it your husband’s heart was not in his conversion? And that he does not accept … what? The Pope as ultimate authority? That’s what it sounds like from your story. You can just tell us directly you know.

If that’s the case, I probably wouldn’t even bother with the discussion, because you are just going to become more polarized. The more you try and convince him, the more he will resist you and make his stand on that hill. The more he resists, the more frustrated you will become.

Is there any way he will read some Catholic apologetics?
 
How in the world can such a chasm be crossed? You can say, of course, that such things should have been discussed before marriage, but they were not (or only briefly) and that cannot be helped now. What is do be done now?
Prayer. I know it works and you can find help through prayer. Also, you may want to make an appointment for a private discussion with a priest before pursuing a topic, in order to prepare. A talk with a priest may calm your spirit and help you see this in a more helpful and loving way. Take one or two really important issues. As I said before, some are small and can wait. A priest may have other suggestions as to how you can negotiate and not argue. But, do pray to find the right words.

Keep in mind that it’s the resolution of the issue that’s important – something you can both live with – and it’s not an accusation. We too often get into arguments because we present our distress over an issue in a manner that seems to be accusing of the partner.

God Bless.
 
I take it your husband’s heart was not in his conversion? And that he does not accept … what? The Pope as ultimate authority? That’s what it sounds like from your story. You can just tell us directly you know.

If that’s the case, I probably wouldn’t even bother with the discussion, because you are just going to become more polarized. The more you try and convince him, the more he will resist you and make his stand on that hill. The more he resists, the more frustrated you will become.

Is there any way he will read some Catholic apologetics?
Agree here. That’s why prioritization is important. If it were such a thing as a matter of doctrine, such as Papal Infallibility, there might be no winning here and may cause more discord. You may drive him further into his resistance to hearing you. You may pray for him to see it the way you do, and he may not see it – or maybe he will eventually.

For this a discussion with a priest, I think, will help you see religious differences in a different light as it relates within your own marriage, and ways that are helpful to the marriage. A priest would know if the matter of disagreement in faith can be worked out in a loving manner, or if you have the preparation to do so. If those matters of faith also cut into the temporal life, then he can help you separate the two.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top