The tendancy to sin

  • Thread starter Thread starter joecap
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
J

joecap

Guest
Good day to all!

First of all, allow me to preface my question by stating that I am a faithful practising Catholic, I believe in and accept all the doctrines of the Faith without question. I am fully engaged in going to Mass, and understand Jesus’ plan for our salvation.

But my question is purely philisophical:
Because of ‘concupiscence’…the tendancy to sin, as inherited from Adam and Eve, it is quite impossible for us humans to NOT sin. We have no choice in the matter.

I understand we have a choice whether to sin or not, but the DESIRE to sin…this is really not our fault. It is simply IMPOSSIBLE for a human being to not entertain some sort of sinful desire.

Sometimes, even though I have faith and trust in God, when I read that NOBODY is worthy to be with Him…I have to say I take offense at that, God forgive me.
 
I don’t know if I understand your dilemna or not so if I am way off base, forgive me.

There is such a thing as scruplosity where we become overly concerned with every tiny thing we do or do not do and so I think we have to be careful we don’t fall into that category.

That being said, while I believe we need to strive every day for holiness and try our best to conform ourselves to the Will of God, the joy is in the fact that God continuously forgives a truly repentant heart.

SO I would, if I were you, concentrate on that JOY rather than dwell on the ‘hopelessness of holiness’.

Does that make sense?
 
Good day to all!

First of all, allow me to preface my question by stating that I am a faithful practising Catholic, I believe in and accept all the doctrines of the Faith without question. I am fully engaged in going to Mass, and understand Jesus’ plan for our salvation.

But my question is purely philisophical:
Because of ‘concupiscence’…the tendancy to sin, as inherited from Adam and Eve, it is quite impossible for us humans to NOT sin. We have no choice in the matter.

I understand we have a choice whether to sin or not, but the DESIRE to sin…this is really not our fault. It is simply IMPOSSIBLE for a human being to not entertain some sort of sinful desire.

Sometimes, even though I have faith and trust in God, when I read that NOBODY is worthy to be with Him…I have to say I take offense at that, God forgive me.
I believe the phrase is “nobody is worthy of him”. It means roughly the same thing.
The Centurian said something similar “Lord I am not worthy that you should come into my home but only say the word and my servant will be healed.”

It means that we recognize how holy Jesus is and that we are so previleged that he came to us. That just gives us all the more reason to appreciate him, that he was so far above us and yet became one of us, Emanuel. He is so far above us and yet he lowered himself for our sakes. The human spirit seeing this feels “Lord I am not worthy”.

Just a thought.
 
God gave us the life of His only son so that our sins may be forgiven, and that we might have eternal life with Him. Our human nature does include concupiscence, that is true. And even after baptism we still sin and stray from God. But He has mercy on us, forgives and forgets thanks to what Jesus did for us on the cross. And God gave us the church and the sacraments so that we may have access to His graces. We may not be ‘worthy of Him’ but He has given us many ways to aspire to be worthy, and if we die in friendship with Him, we will be made worthy and live with Him forever. Don’t focus on the unworthiness, focus on God’s mercy and love, and the fact that He gives us so many chances to be made worthy.
 
The point of our faith is that we’re not worthy of God because we don’t have Him, so to speak; God was spurned and rejected by man at the Fall-and He was later crucified by man at Calvary. But there He proved His existence and His love and trustworthiness in no uncertain terms-in spite of the fact that He shouldn’t have had to- by suffering in the most humiliating and painful way if that’s what it takes to wake us up from our slumber-to wake us up to the knowledge of God-to the knowledge that He is, and that He loves-and that we need Him desperately after all.

So our unworthiness, our injustice, consists in not being in communion with the highest and greatest good in the universe-because we’re born turned away from Him-pursuing lesser goods-and He knows this and is willing to work with us in order to remedy this injustice so we may turn back to Him-as we’re willing- and have life again-and life abundantly according to scripture. The Good News isn’t bad news-Jesus died for us while we were yet sinners (Rom 5:8)-in spite of our sinfulness. That’s how much God loves man.

The ironic thing is that our tendency to sin comes from being separated from God; man wasn’t meant to determine morality for himself; he dies when he does so because in that act he separates himself from God by attempting to takes Gods’ place, to be God. Man must be subjugated to God and in communion with Him. So Adam lost control by trying to take control-and concupiscence is the result.
 
Well, we are nothing but poor, wretched sinners. We are not worthy of God’s mercy. Why take offense at that? We are born without sanctifying grace - which we gain through Baptism - and due to the *three concupiscences * we will always fall, and if the sin is mortal we lose sanctifying grace again.

That is why we know that there is another gift, called “actual” or “auxiliating” grace, which God grants us temporarily in order that we may be able to repent…it is truly through His infinite mercy that we are saved.

Why are we not condemned from the beginning? Or when we fall again? Thanks to Jesus Christ, Who came among us, took over us the full burden of sin, and experienced the ineffable sorrows of the Passion. That is why we can receive sanctifying grace again and again: through the mercy and by the merits of Jesus. Of our own, we did not do anything to deserve it - which is why nobody is worthy of God.

While when I am offended by that statement I accuse myself of my inclination to pride, I think you are instead moved by your great love for God, that love that makes us call Him “Abba’, dad!”

St. John of the Cross considered Himself a terrible sinner and repeatedly stated his unworthiness…yet he wrote wonderful poems of love, one of which says:
Where have You hidden Yourself,
And abandoned me in my groaning, O my Beloved?
Oh! who can heal me?
Give me at once Yourself,
Send me no more
A messenger
Who cannot tell me what I wish.
Reveal Your presence,
And let the vision and Your beauty kill me.
Behold the malady
Of love is incurable
Except in Your presence and before Your face.
Love truly divinizes us! For as sinners we are truly nothing, but as souls in love, we are the mystical Bride…

I have found very edifying the reading “The Spiritual Combat” by Fr. Lorenzo Scupoli:
And this will be made clear to thee by the effect produced on thy mind by a fall. If thou art so saddened and disquieted thereby as to be tempted to despair of making progress or doing good, it is a sure sign that thy trust is in self and not in God. For he who has any large measure of self-distrust and trust in God feels neither surprise, nor despondency, nor bitterness, when he falls; for he knows that this has arisen from his own weakness and want of trust in God. On the contrary, being, rendered thereby more distrustful of self, more humbly condent in God, detesting above all things his fault and the unruly passions which have occasioned it, and mourning with a quiet, deep, and patient sorrow over his offense against God, he pursues his enterprise, and follows after his enemies …]
When you have been wounded by sin …] Turn to God with a great and humble confidence saying: “See, O Master, what I am able to do. When I rely on my own strength, I commit nothing but sins.” Meditating on this, recognize the extent of your humiliation and express to our Lord your sorrow for the offense committed. With an unperturbed heart, indict your vicious passions, especially the one that has occasioned your fall, and confess: “O Lord, I would not have stopped at this had not Your goodness restrained me.”
Place yourself in the merciful arms of God, and plunge into your usual duties, as though nothing had happened. …] This will dismay your enemy because it is pleasing to God. The devil will be thrown into confusion, baffled by one he has so often overcome.
The way to recover this peace is to forget, for the moment, your fault and to concentrate on the ineffable goodness of God and His burning desire to pardon the gravest sinners.
Though grieved when he falls into a fault, (the humble man who trusts in God) is neither surprised nor disquieted; for he knows that his own misery and weakness, already clearly
manifest to himself by the light of truth, have brought all this upon him.
 
The Father thought we were valuable enough that He sent His only Son to die in our place and pay the price. We may not be worthy in ourselves but through Jesus, WE ARE.
 
I say let the “tendency to sin” work for you. Let it roll around in the recesses of your mind and put the flesh mind to death like St. Paul describes in Rom 7.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top