The true reality of Islam.

  • Thread starter Thread starter Sam_777
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Indian people are imported there as slaves. Their passports are taken and they can’t escape. I have heard this complaint many times.

I wonder if the reason Indians hire cheap domestic labor and treat them harshly is a left over from Muslim rule centuries ago. Anyone have any clue.
 
After being in Saudi Arabia myself I can say that no one abused me, or withheld my passport. There must be reasons why this happens.

Islamic cuture is very strict, People must understand the culture and respect it, when they don’t all kinds of problems arise. I have been to many other Islamic countries and nothing bad has ever happened to me.

Saying that all Muslims are bad is a vague statement: It could be compared to people saying that all Catholic priests are child abusers, which obviously isn’t true. Live and let live, don’t be so quick to judge based on what a minority does.
 
Let him with out sin cast the first stone—Jesus
pointing out the reality of what goes on in Muslim countries is not casting the first stone.
Pointing out the reality of practice, its history, how it was spread (by violence and forced conversions starting with his own tribe) is not casting the first stone. It is morally and intellectually dishonest to think and say that we can say or point out anything because of a few bad apples Christians. This kind of thinking that we are all equivalent so lets just shut up is what lead to evil taking over. We are called to truth as well as love and it is not loving when we shut up and hide away from truth.
 
After being in Saudi Arabia myself I can say that no one abused me, or withheld my passport. There must be reasons why this happens.

Islamic cuture is very strict, People must understand the culture and respect it, when they don’t all kinds of problems arise. I have been to many other Islamic countries and nothing bad has ever happened to me.

Saying that all Muslims are bad is a vague statement: It could be compared to people saying that all Catholic priests are child abusers, which obviously isn’t true. Live and let live, don’t be so quick to judge based on what a minority does.
First of all, were you there working as a manual or domestic help? I am sure you were not free to wear a cross. If you were there during Ramadan, you would have been force to practice that fast whether you were Muslim or not. Slavery is still alive and well in the Muslim world and it is hidden like all the rest of the stuff.
 
Indian people are imported there as slaves. Their passports are taken and they can’t escape. I have heard this complaint many times.

I wonder if the reason Indians hire cheap domestic labor and treat them harshly is a left over from Muslim rule centuries ago. Anyone have any clue.
They are offered job opportunities and money and when you are from a poor area what they offer looks good. It is the same thing that happen when eastern European women are lured into coming over here and they end up into forced prostitution. However, we have laws against that stuff and they don’t. Our country tried to fight this and in Saudia Arabia it is institutionalized.
 
Slavery is still alive and well in the Muslim world and it is hidden like all the rest of the stuff.
Let us not forget that slavery was a live and well in our own “Christian” country until 1865.
 
“Saudi Arabia is a destination country for men and women subjected to forced labor and to a lesser extent, forced prostitution. Men and women from Bangladesh, India, Sri Lanka, Nepal, Pakistan, the Philippines, Indonesia, Sudan, Ethiopia, Kenya, and many other countries voluntarily travel to Saudi Arabia as domestic servants or other low-skilled laborers, but some subsequently face conditions indicative of involuntary servitude, including nonpayment of wages, long working hours without rest, deprivation of food, threats, physical or sexual abuse, and restrictions on movement such as the withholding of passports or confinement to the workplace.” Link.

I see this in the united states how we treat Hispanics and Chinese to a surtain extent. Open up your eyes it’s going on here right in Seattle !!
 
Let us not forget that slavery was a live and well in our own “Christian” country until 1865.
Yes but many Christians were opposed to it. That was true in England as well and it was one member of parliament that fought for over 30 years to abolish it. Popes throughout Church history have always spoken out and against slavery. Christian Europe was built on the ashes of the Roman collapse which used slavery extensively. But as Europe grew, it did not incorporate slavery. The slavery you are pointing out came from Protestant countries not Catholic.
 
“Saudi Arabia is a destination country for men and women subjected to forced labor and to a lesser extent, forced prostitution. Men and women from Bangladesh, India, Sri Lanka, Nepal, Pakistan, the Philippines, Indonesia, Sudan, Ethiopia, Kenya, and many other countries voluntarily travel to Saudi Arabia as domestic servants or other low-skilled laborers, but some subsequently face conditions indicative of involuntary servitude, including nonpayment of wages, long working hours without rest, deprivation of food, threats, physical or sexual abuse, and restrictions on movement such as the withholding of passports or confinement to the workplace.” Link.

I see this in the united states how we treat Hispanics and Chinese to a surtain extent. Open up your eyes it’s going on here right in Seattle !!
that what happens when people bring in groups of illegal immigrants. They are used and abused when they are here illegally.
 
Yes but many Christians were opposed to it. That was true in England as well and it was one member of parliament that fought for over 30 years to abolish it. Popes throughout Church history have always spoken out and against slavery. Christian Europe was built on the ashes of the Roman collapse which used slavery extensively. But as Europe grew, it did not incorporate slavery. The slavery you are pointing out came from Protestant countries not Catholic.
Be carful with this argument… Theres one case of a pope receiving a gift of slaves and then dristibuting them to the clergy. Of course, this was a private action, and doesn’t reflect on the office in my opinion.

That said, there no reason or justification for slavery and we are well to call it out when we see it. Not only to help others, but to cement in our own minds and culture that it is wrong.
 
Be carful with this argument… Theres one case of a pope receiving a gift of slaves and then dristibuting them to the clergy. Of course, this was a private action, and doesn’t reflect on the office in my opinion.

That said, there no reason or justification for slavery and we are well to call it out when we see it. Not only to help others, but to cement in our own minds and culture that it is wrong.
What case or Pope are you referring too? With all due respect, if you bring up something like that example, you probably going to have to state who and when. One bad Pope does not undermined the fact that slavery has always been condemned by the Catholic Church and those who dealt in the slave trade were ex-communicated.
 
And most Muslims are horrified by terrorists.
I would like to believe this but their voices are sadly lacking and few. Maybe more in free western countries but there was no condemnation in Muslim countries and in fact there are videos of people going out into the streets and celebrating that America was attacked.
 
So… is anyone else going to point out that this has more to do with an economy based on raw material extraction than religion?

The fact that imported labor is prevalent in the Gulf States (and not, say, Indonesia) should lead us to look for a reason besides Islam. Oil wealth combined with a small population of citizens creates a very rich population. The United Arab Emirates and Qatar have some of the highest GDP per capita in the world, much higher than the United States.

So the Gulf States have populations much richer populations than their economic output per citizen x population would normally create. This wealth surplus:
  1. Stifles democracy and strengthens the Monarchies by creating complacency
  2. Creates a shortage of people willing to do laborious or demeaning work
Thus you have the importation of foreign workers and the lack of rights available to them to prevent exploitation.

Has there even been a greater, lengthier, or more brutal slave trade than that perpetrated by Spain, France, and Portugal to South America and the Caribbean? Again there you had economies based purely on resource extraction. I don’t blame the horrors of the trans-Atlantic trade on Christianity, I blame it on exploitative economics and undemocratic government.
 
Moral relativism ahoy! 😉

While your desire for more charitable discourse is laudable, I think there are times in human history when plain speaking is required, and this is sadly one of them. I know plenty of good Muslim men and women, but the ideology that many of them hold to - the actual “belief system” of Islam - is poisonous.
👍
 
I repeat; we are not in a position to cast the first stone. Our own ‘fruit’ is not entirely unblemished. I do hope this site has better and more life-affirming posts.
This thread about Islam is like all the others before it. What is wrong with criticizing an ideology?
 
I would like to believe this but their voices are sadly lacking and few. Maybe more in free western countries but there was no condemnation in Muslim countries and in fact there are videos of people going out into the streets and celebrating that America was attacked.
Not everybody who dislikes America is necessarily a terrorist. I may not like them, either, but disapproval or even hatred doesn’t mean they would kill innocent people.
 
After being in Saudi Arabia myself I can say that no one abused me, or withheld my passport. There must be reasons why this happens.
I know a fellow whose passport was taken away. He worked for a company that had a contract with the SA government. His company was having a dispute with the SA government, and none of its employees were allowed to leave the country until the dispute was resolved.
Islamic culture is very strict, People must understand the culture and respect it, when they don’t all kinds of problems arise. I have been to many other Islamic countries and nothing bad has ever happened to me. …
On a humorous note, my son recently spent a few days in an Islamic country [not SA] on his way to India. He boarded a train, and unknowingly chose a women’s car. He was arrested and fined $25. 😛
 
pointing out the reality of what goes on in Muslim countries is not casting the first stone.
Pointing out the reality of practice, its history, how it was spread (by violence and forced conversions starting with his own tribe) is not casting the first stone. It is morally and intellectually dishonest to think and say that we can say or point out anything because of a few bad apples Christians. This kind of thinking that we are all equivalent so lets just shut up is what lead to evil taking over. We are called to truth as well as love and it is not loving when we shut up and hide away from truth.
I coould have quoted Mattew 7:1-5 about the standerd we use to judge others, not the one we use to judge ourselves, is the standerd God will use to judge us.:gopray:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top