The Vatican Dogma

  • Thread starter Thread starter militantsparrow
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
CONTINUED
The real reason that the anathema of Vatican I doesn’t apply to me, as I see it, is because just like they really didn’t mean what they so clearly said in their pronouncements, they probably didn’t really mean it when they anathematized either. That’s why I said it might not be “ethical” for me to remain. If I could believe that they say what they mean, and mean what they say I would instead say something like “in peril of my eternal salvation” instead of “ethical”.
As noted above, this is the problem with trying to wrench dogmatic definitions outside the context of Sacred Tradition as a whole. In fact, the only ones who have ever used the “so the Decree doesn’t really mean what it says” rhetoric in the history of the Church were the heterodox who interpreted the Decrees of the Ecum Councils apart from the light of Sacred Tradition.
I came to believe that the Pope is the universal head of the Church in part because of what St Irenaeus said about Rome as well as other fathers of the Church, but who knows, maybe they really didn’t mean what they said either. Sorry for the sarcasm.
No apology needed. I understand sarcasm as deliberate mockery. It’s obvious your statement is made in light of a genuine concern to arrive at the truth, and not intended to mock.
But when I said that the EO outgrew a need for a pope, it would have been better for me to say that they outgrew the need of a dogmatized pope. Clearly they played that game at the 4th Ecumenical but they grew up since then.
I don’t understand this statement in reference to the 4th Ecum. The necessity of the confirmation of the bishop of Rome is admitted by all the Ecum Councils, not just the 4th.
My opinion would only be of value in the context of a pleasant non-dogmatic conversation. Neither this topic not the one on second-marriages would fly here. Once again, sorry.
We don’t need to discuss your particular views on the papacy right now. What I am more interested in are the general principles you are applying in order to interpret the situation (e.g., that the text of the definitions of Councils is the only thing that matters, and that the context of Sacred Tradition nor the interpretations of the Fathers of those Councils have no bearing on the definition).
Would they be “free” to choose now, after Vatican I?
Vatican 1 asserts simply that it is a doctrinal error to deny that Peter is the Rock. One can hold any other belief of what the “Rock” of Mt 16:18 means (i.e., Jesus, Peter’s Confession, the Church as a whole), only as long as one does not attempt to deny that Peter is ALSO the Rock, or at least attempt to use the other definitions as contradictory principles to the Truth that Peter is the Rock of Mt 16:18…
Yes I did know that. But I’m not going to ask the question “how then can someone be both anathematized and saved” because as I see it it is just proof that they really didn’t mean anything they said. I’m sorry, but this is all pure insanity to me.
How do you arrive at the statement “someone can be both anathematized and saved” from the principles that have been discussed? We have specifically stated that those who are in invincible ignorance are not anathematized. Also, those who are born and raised in the Orthodox Church are not automatically anathematized. Perhaps you are not aware, but an anathema does not automatically send one to Hell. The Orthodox and Catholic Churches have the same patristic understanding of anathema - it is a discplinary proscription, not a condemnation to Hell. Even those who die under anathema are regarded as “being left to the mercy of God” and are not definitively condemned to Hell. This is the common teaching of the Apostolic Churches. To repeat, on what principles do you base your claim that “someone can be both anathematized and saved”?

Blessings,
Marduk
 
40.png
mardukm:
Why should we accept - why should you accept - your claim that the Official Relatio, which represent the OFFICIAL understanding of the text of the V1 Decrees, has no bearing on the proper understanding of the V1 Decrees?
I don’t think I said it had “no” bearing, I believe I said it “didn’t have much” bearing. The pronouncements themselves should be by far the most important part. My primary issue is not so much the exact wording, but rather the adding of the “anathema” for those who don’t except it. Does the Official Relatio also add an anathema to anyone who does not accept its clarification?

My foremost Christian education was in the Russian Orthodox Church. The Russian Orthodox Church Outside Russia, to be exact. I was a member of this Church for 22 years. In 1984 (I think) the bishops issues and “anathema” against ecumenism. Some years later most (not all) of the bishops seemed to regret issuing that anathema and did what they could to economize it away. Some hard-liners saw this as an act of apostasy. In retrospect it might have been apostasy in a few cases, but I think in most cases it wasn’t that they thought that there was something wrong with what was decreed, but rather that the anathema (which essentially made it dogmatic) caused more problems then it solved.
I don’t understand this statement in reference to the 4th Ecum. The necessity of the confirmation of the bishop of Rome is admitted by all the Ecum Councils, not just the 4th.
No I don’t think so.

I still think that the pronouncements of the 4th were a little off base, but still I see that the anathema’s there were what caused most of the problems. There were men condemned either by or because of that council that not only should not have been condemned but I think some of them may even have been saints. Just like Vatican II backed off of Vatican I, just like the Russian bishops backed off of their anathema against ecumenism, both the Antiochian Orthodox and the Roman Catholic Church has backed off of some of what came out of the 4th. In this retrospective light wouldn’t it have been much better if no anathema’s were attached to any decrees?

The 2nd Ecumenical never admitted that there was a necessity to have the confirmation of the bishop of Old Rome. At that time most saw Constantinople as the New Rome and when Constantine moved the capital city there he also brought with him bishops from Old Rome. They thought of it as being Ecumenical at the time they did it, not much later when Old Rome confirmed it. The other early Ecumenical Councils very much wanted Old Rome to be a part of it, but as I see it it wasn’t until the 4th that the East really started to see the need for the bishop of Old Rome. It was said that at this council that the Eastern bishops wanted to make the Bishop of Old Rome the “universal bishop” but Pope Leo refused the title. Later on the Bishop of Rome started acting more like a universal bishop but the East started to think that it wasn’t such a good idea after all. Eventually there was a split in the Church, which really wasn’t a split as much as it was simply a walling off of inter-communion. The East found that they could function quite well without the help of Old Rome. Still there were many times that the East wanted to return to communion with Rome, but upon doing so were confronted with Rome compelling them to submit. Even today I think inter-communion could be re-established, but only if this dogmatic idea that it has to or else you are anathema is set aside.

As I said before, as an extreme example, I’ve read how even some Jews would be happy to accept Christ, if they didn’t have to. Doing the word is want really matters, not hearing only. Think of the example of the prodigal son.

I think the East is justified in the continued walling off of inter-communion explicitly because of the dogmatizing of the Pope. And any anathema’s will fly out of the mouth of the bishop who pronounces it like a bird and rest on the head of that same bishop.

Blessings
 
So basically you’re saying that because I’m stupid I can go to Heaven, but if I were smart I would go to hell, right? :eek: (rhetorical joke, no need to answer)
Among the baptised, one that has intentionally rejected the friendship of God, having been taught the truth by the Catholic Church, has lost their grace. The same is true for those baptised, that are not raised Catholic, according to their understanding of the truth in their Christian Church. There is more doubt of perfect contrition in some churches which do not have the apostolic sacrment of confession.

I recommend that you read the Vatican articles that I posted the link to earlier.

vatican.va/roman_curia/co…tiones_en.html

Unitatis Redintegratio
 
Dear brother Adrian,
I don’t think I said it had “no” bearing, I believe I said it “didn’t have much” bearing. The pronouncements themselves should be by far the most important part.
This is where we would disagree. I believe, from the example of Sacred Tradition itself, that any new dogma is only just as important as what went on before, not more important. We must give heed EQUALLY to the judgment of the Church in establishing the new dogma as well as the Sacred Tradition on which that dogmatic judgment is based, and from which that judgment can in no way depart.
My primary issue is not so much the exact wording, but rather the adding of the “anathema” for those who don’t except it. Does the Official Relatio also add an anathema to anyone who does not accept its clarification?
It appears we have differing concepts of what an “anathema” is. You seem to think that the purpose of an anathema is to condemn. I would urge you to look at EO sources on the matter, for they most certainly will align with the Catholic sources. Both Orthodox and Catholic sources will affirm that an anathema does not condemn, but is intended for the sake of correction. Anathemas are an aid for the Christian, to help him or her realize the importance of the teaching to which the anathema is attached. A dogmatic teaching can certainly exist without an anathema. The dogmatic Truth and the divine necessity of belief in that dogmatic Truth does not depend on the presence of an anathema in the Decree, but only serves to aid the Christian in identifying the importance of that teaching for the sake of salvation. Even without the explicit warning of an anathema, the divine necessity of that dogmatic teaching will exist.
My foremost Christian education was in the Russian Orthodox Church. The Russian Orthodox Church Outside Russia, to be exact. I was a member of this Church for 22 years. In 1984 (I think) the bishops issues and “anathema” against ecumenism. Some years later most (not all) of the bishops seemed to regret issuing that anathema and did what they could to economize it away. Some hard-liners saw this as an act of apostasy. In retrospect it might have been apostasy in a few cases, but I think in most cases it wasn’t that they thought that there was something wrong with what was decreed, but rather that the anathema (which essentially made it dogmatic) caused more problems then it solved.
Again, I must point out that an anathema has nothing to do with the dogmatic nature of a teaching. The teaching or decree will be dogmatic by virtue of the source of that teaching, nothing more and nothing less. An anathema will not make a teaching or decree any more dogmatic with or without it. The only purpose of an anathema (or any type of proscription that the Church utilizes) is to make the dogmatic nature of that teaching more obvious to the Christian, but does not affect the dogmatic nature of the teaching or decree itself. For example, let us imagine that in your example, the anathema against ecumenism did not exist, and there was simply a statement from the Synod that Ecumenism is not to be pursued (and giving reasons for it). It is by virtue of the fact that the statement proceeds from the Synod that gives it its dogmatic nature for the ROC, not because the statement has an anathema attached to it. Even without the anathema, any bishop can excommunicate someone in his jurisdiction for contravening the statement of the Synod, and he does this not because the statement contains an anathema, but because the authority of the Synod itself made it a dogmatic principle to be followed.

In short, the presence of the anathema in the Vatican 1 Decrees really has no relevance for our discussion. You may or may not admit to the authority of the Vatican 1 Council. So the only way to resolve the matter is to determine the Truth of the dogmas themselves. And for this to happen, we should not be focusing simply on the statements contained in the dogmas, but also on the context of Sacred Tradition in which those dogmas were formulated (which is explicitly contained in the Decree on the Infallibility in the form of the historical Proem), as well as the correct understanding of those dogmatic statements as intended by the V1 Fathers themselves (as reflected not only in the Official Relatio of Bishop Gasser, but also in the numerous encyclicals and pastoral communications given by Synods and individual bishops to their flocks after the Council).

CONTINUED
 
CONTINUED
mardukm said:
The necessity of the confirmation of the bishop of Rome is admitted by all the Ecum Councils, not just the 4th.
No I don’t think so.
  • It can’t be denied for the First, since the Latins participated in that Council.
  • The Fathers of the Council that met in 381 requested confirmation from the Bishop of Rome the following year in 382 in these words “We beseech your reverence to rejoice at what has thus been rightly and canonically settled by us…making the confirmation of the Churches of more importance than individual grace or favor.”
  • The Fathers of the Ephesine Council likewise requested confirmation from the Bishop of Rome in these words: “For it is your custom in such great matters to make trial of all things, and the confirmation of the Churches you have made your own care. But since it is right that all things which have taken place should be brought to the knowledge of your holiness, we are writing of necessity to inform you…”
    I’m sure I don’t need to go further (unless you so desire) to demonstrate the Truth of the necessity of the Bishop of Rome’s confirmation for the rest of the Ecumenical Councils, a necessity borne of the RULE OF FAITH which is Apostolic Canon 34.
I still think that the pronouncements of the 4th were a little off base, but still I see that the anathema’s there were what caused most of the problems. There were men condemned either by or because of that council that not only should not have been condemned but I think some of them may even have been saints.
The “problem” with the 4th Ecum was not the anathemas. Rather, it was the lack of understanding between the parties involved. This lack of understanding has been admitted by the OOC and CC to have come from BOTH sides of the divide.
Just like Vatican II backed off of Vatican I,
There was no backing off. What happened was simply that (among other things) V2 finished the intended work of V1 regarding the collegial nature of the ecclesiology of the Church. This is why it is important to understand the background of V1, and not myopically focus on the definitions of V1.
both the Antiochian Orthodox and the Roman Catholic Church has backed off of some of what came out of the 4th.
I’m not sure what you mean. Can you please explain?
In this retrospective light wouldn’t it have been much better if no anathema’s were attached to any decrees?
As stated, the dogmatic nature of the teachings would remain, regardless of the presence or absence of explicit anathemas. We need to focus on understanding the intent of the V1 Fathers.

Tbh, though the presence or absence of the anathemas would not affect the dogmatic nature of the Decrees, I would concede that their absence would have lessened the force of the blow to the sensibilities of the non-Catholic world.
The 2nd Ecumenical never admitted that there was a necessity to have the confirmation of the bishop of Old Rome.
Well. that’s not true, as demonstrated above. Further, the teaching of the 2nd Ecum was actually based on Pope Damasus’ own Tome on the Holy Spirit. His Tome was adopted by a local Synod of Antioch, whose own decrees were thereafter adopted by the Council of Constantinople.
As I said before, as an extreme example, I’ve read how even some Jews would be happy to accept Christ, if they didn’t have to. Doing the word is want really matters, not hearing only. Think of the example of the prodigal son.
The dogmatic force of the Truth exists with or without an explicit anathema. Think of St. Paul’s teachings regarding the Law being written on the hearts and minds of Christians, instead of being a mere legal obligation. A Jew who truly loves the Lord will know that their love exists not merely because “they have to.”

Blessings,
Marduk

P.S. I will be gone for at least a week (perhaps stopping by for short comments if I have time). Please keep me in your prayers, as you will be in mine, for I am expecting the next week or two to be particularly stressful for me.
 
40.png
Mardukm:
P.S. I will be gone for at least a week (perhaps stopping by for short comments if I have time). Please keep me in your prayers, as you will be in mine, for I am expecting the next week or two to be particularly stressful for me.
God bless Marduk, and you will be in our prayers! Hurry back. 🙂
 
…It appears we have differing concepts of what an “anathema” is. You seem to think that the purpose of an anathema is to condemn. I would urge you to look at EO sources on the matter, for they most certainly will align with the Catholic sources…
Let me give you first hand what I learded the word “anathema” means from a Russian Orthodox source… basically it says that an anathema puts you “in the state of hardened evil”… here’s a link to the definition given by St. John Maximovitch:

Anathema according to St John Maximovitch
 
The 2nd Ecumenical never admitted that there was a necessity to have the confirmation of the bishop of Old Rome.
You know better than I do. I was merely stating what I have been taught. Any part of this that might be “non-dogmatic” I am more then pleased to defer to your understanding. 😉
P.S. I will be gone for at least a week (perhaps stopping by for short comments if I have time). Please keep me in your prayers, as you will be in mine, for I am expecting the next week or two to be particularly stressful for me.
You are in my prayers!
 
Let me give you first hand what I learded the word “anathema” means from a Russian Orthodox source… basically it says that an anathema puts you “in the state of hardened evil”… here’s a link to the definition given by St. John Maximovitch:

Anathema according to St John Maximovitch
Quoting from your link: “Anathema is not final damnation: until death repentance is possible. “Anathema” is fearsome not because the Church wishes anyone evil or God seeks their damnation. They desire that all be saved. But it is fearsome to stand before the presence of God in the state of hardened evil: nothing is hidden from Him.”

Also we know that a person may be a material apostate, heretic, or schismatic, and yet not be a formal one, because they are not fully consenting to something that they know to be wrong.
 
I suspect you are British? If so, I would like your opinion on the ecclesiology of Anglicanism (of you are not British, oh well 😃 - please answer anyway).
(1) Would it be correct to say that Anglicanism possesses a Low Petrine ecclesiology?
Ambrose asked me to weigh in on that (I’m both British and Anglican, though I have lived in the States since I was 6 and was not Anglican when I lived in Britain:D).

It’s hard to generalize about Anglicans–the 39 Articles seem to imply a “Low Petrine” view (by implying that the Church of Rome is no different from any other local Church in its propensity to err) but recent ecumenical documents sound more “High Petrine.” You can certainly find Anglicans who hold both views.
(2) Would it be correct so say that those who are attracted to Catholicism in the face of the doctrinal liberalism of Anglicanism feel attracted to the High Petrine view, instead of the Absolutist Petrine view?
Yes, although I wouldn’t say that Anglicans who are attracted to Catholicism are just fleeing liberalism, and some for whom that’s the primary motivation may in fact go over to the “Absolutist” view as the best antidote to Anglicanism’s chaos.

Many of us are drawn to Catholicism on basically ecclesiological grounds, and our discomfort with Anglicanism’s cultural accommodation and doctrinal fuzziness is only part of the picture. (Indeed, on some points I’m fairly “liberal” by Catholic standards myself.)

Edwin
 
Dear brother Steve.

You didn’t answer my question (as usual). Let me repeat it: So you are claiming that because of this, infallibility belongs to the Pope ALONE**?** Would you like to answer it now?
I used pope “ALONE” many times in answering your questions. What was the context?
M:
Incorrect. He does NOT have a special infallibility. What he has is a special assistance from the Holy Spirit to be able to possess the infallibility OF THE CHURCH.
you’re denying the pope on his own, can define matters of faith and morals infallibly?
M:
I think what you mean to say is “not so for any other individual bishop.” The Pope is only a bishop, after all.
“Individual bishops do not enjoy the prerogative of infallibility.” That’s a quote from [LG 25]

What provisions DO make it possible for them to proclaim teaching infallibly?
M:
Exactly what it says: “THEY CONCUR** in a single viewpoint as the one which must be held conclusively.**”

do YOU understand what the words “they concur” mean? Do you understand that the term “they” designates a plural, not a singular?
Yes and yes
M:
Do you understand that the term “concur” designates an agreement between parties (plural), not an imposition of views by one party upon another?
I understand that, concur in a single viewpoint, means no matter how many viewpoints were there in the beginning, in the end, they concur in a single viewpoint to be held conclusively.

Conclusively = putting an end to debate especially by reason of irrefutability
M:
As I have stated repeatedly, neither you nor brother Abu have been able to give a single Magisterial source for your “Pope alone” error.
I gave you exactly the quotes from the docs where “pope alone” is used.
M:
100% is ideal, but is not required.
what specifically IS required?
M:
according to the Rule of Faith which is Apostolic Canon 34, it must at least require the agreement of the head bishop plus others. The teaching of the head bishop alone is insufficient, and the teaching of bishops without the head bishop is likewise insufficient.
how many others need to agree? The canon doesn’t say. So how many need to agree?

Re: canon 34
The bishops of every nation must acknowledge him who is first among them and account him as their head, and do nothing of consequence without his consent…but neither let him (who is head) do anything without the consent of all.

That last part goes against Vat I and II.
with respect to Catholic and Orthodox dialogue, the doc referenced in the previous link “the Ravenna document” there is a note at the top of the document that says

"Thus, the document represents the outcome of the work of a Commission and should not be understood as an official declaration of the Church’s teaching. "

vatican.va/roman_curia/pontifical_councils/chrstuni/ch_orthodox_docs/rc_pc_chrstuni_doc_20071013_documento-ravenna_en.html

from the document which is only a discussion,

[snip]

"Defined thus, the conciliar dimension of the Church is to be found at the three levels of ecclesial communion, the local, the regional and the universal: at the local level of the diocese entrusted to the bishop; at the regional level of a group of local Churches with their bishops who “recognize who is the first amongst themselves” (Apostolic Canon 34); and at the universal level, where those who are first (protoi) in the various regions, together with all the bishops, cooperate in that which concerns the totality of the Church. At this level also, the protoi must recognize who is the first amongst themselves.

A canon accepted in the East as in the West, expresses the relationship between the local Churches of a region: “The bishops of each province (ethnos) must recognize the one who is first (protos) amongst them, and consider him to be their head (kephale), and not do anything important without his consent (gnome); each bishop may only do what concerns his own diocese (paroikia) and its dependent territories. But the first (protos) cannot do anything without the consent of all. For in this way concord (homonoia) will prevail, and God will be praised through the Lord in the Holy Spirit” (Apostolic Canon 34)."

It appears Can #34 isn’t by itself, a be all to end all canon.
 
steve b:
I used pope “ALONE” many times in answering your questions. What was the context?
I think you are using “alone” to mean that the Pope has the authority by himself to proclaim an infallible doctrine. Marduk, I think, is taking you to mean that the Pope alone, IOW in opposition to everyone else in the Church, can proclaim an infallible doctrine.
 
I think you are using “alone” to mean that the Pope has the authority by himself to proclaim an infallible doctrine. Marduk, I think, is taking you to mean that the Pope alone, IOW in opposition to everyone else in the Church, can proclaim an infallible doctrine.
Marduk can look over my 50 or so posts on this thread. I’ve quoted the Church docs copiously where BOTH pope and bishops can be infallible. BOTH have provisions however, for that to happen. Those provisions are all specifically spelled out from the Church docs I quoted. Since these are technical and legal issues, that’s why I quote so copiously from Church docs. My opinions as you will note from my posts, are at an absolute minimum on this subject. That’s what bugged Marduk so much. As answers to him I would quote canon law, or LG, or Vat I etc, NOT give him my opinion.
 
Re: canon 34
The bishops of every nation must acknowledge him who is first among them and account him as their head, and do nothing of consequence without his consent…but neither let him (who is head) do anything without the consent of all.

That last part goes against Vat I and II.
with respect to Catholic and Orthodox dialogue, the doc referenced in the previous link “the Ravenna document” there is a note at the top of the document that says

"Thus, the document represents the outcome of the work of a Commission and should not be understood as an official declaration of the Church’s teaching. "

vatican.va/roman_curia/pontifical_councils/chrstuni/ch_orthodox_docs/rc_pc_chrstuni_doc_20071013_documento-ravenna_en.html
I think you have made a valid point here [user]steve b[/user].

The only part that I am unhappy with is making any one specific view of the papacy dogmatic.

I’m beginning to see pattern. I’d like to compare the Vatican Dogma to the issue of the addition of the filioque.
  • 1a) The majority of people who confess “…the Holy Spirit, who proceeds from the Father & the Son…” understands that to mean double-procession.
  • 1b) The majority of people who read, “If anyone says that the Roman pontiff has merely an office of supervision and guidance, and not the full and supreme power of jurisdiction over the whole church, and this not only in matters of faith and morals, but also in those which concern the discipline and government of the church dispersed throughout the whole world; or that he has only the principal part, but not the absolute fullness, of this supreme power; or that this power of his is not ordinary and immediate both over all and each of the churches and over all and each of the pastors and faithful: Let him be anathema”, understands that to mean the Absolutist Petrine view is the correct view.
  • 2a) According to official sources, such as the Counsel of Florence and others, double-procession is not the correct understanding, rather the correct view is that the Holy Spirit proceeds from the Father through the Son. No effort is made to correct Protestants who hold double-procession’s views when they wish to become Roman Catholics.
  • 2b) According to official sources, such as the Official Relatio and others, the Absolutist Petrine view is not the correct view, rather the correct view is High Petrine view. No effort is made to correct Orthodox who may come to believe (based on a simple understanding of Vatican I proclamations) the Absolutist Petrine view and wish to become Eastern Catholics.
  • 3a) The fact that the filioque was added to the Creed sure seems to make it dogmatic, and yet its use is optional.
  • 3b) The addition of an anathema for anyone who does not accept Vatican I sure makes it sound dogmatic. I can’t see however that it isn’t optional, seeing that Absolutist, High, and Low Petrine views abound everywhere and how can anyone be corrected in there view seeing that the official view of the Church is virtually unknown!
Why do I make this comparison? Because I’m wish to acquire a correct opinion without having to undergo seemingly endless studies, and a way to do that is comparing the opinions on this forum with each other and looking for patterns. In the comparison I made between Vatican I and the filioque I see a pattern. I see this pattern in other areas too, such as looking for an official list of Ecumenical Councils. All Ecumenical Councils, it is said, must be accepted by the faithful, and yet no one can come up with an official list. What does this pattern say about the role of the Roman Church in the Universal Church? I am answering this question for myself and forming an opinion.

I don’t think it can be said that this thread has clearly spelled out with clarity to all an understanding of “The Vatican Dogma”. Advocates of the Absolutist Petrine view think they made it clear to all that their view represents the teaching of Vatican I, but Advocates of the High Petrine view think they made it clear to all as well that their view represents the teaching of Vatican I. In the final analysis the teachings of Vatican I, in a practical way, really can’t be dogmatic. But because many see it as dogmatic there can never be peace and agreement.

If everything that comes from Rome is optional, then Rome itself is optional. Nothing changed in the Eastern Churches on the day that Rome finally confirmed the Second Ecumenical Council. There was peace and agreement in the East both before and after it’s confirmation. This thread has helped me to see things this way and my opinion has formed accordingly.
 
I think you have made a valid point here [user]steve b[/user].

The only part that I am unhappy with is making any one specific view of the papacy dogmatic.

I’m beginning to see pattern. I’d like to compare the Vatican Dogma to the issue of the addition of the filioque.
  • 1a) The majority of people who confess “…the Holy Spirit, who proceeds from the Father & the Son…” understands that to mean double-procession.
  • 1b) The majority of people who read, “If anyone says that the Roman pontiff has merely an office of supervision and guidance, and not the full and supreme power of jurisdiction over the whole church, and this not only in matters of faith and morals, but also in those which concern the discipline and government of the church dispersed throughout the whole world; or that he has only the principal part, but not the absolute fullness, of this supreme power; or that this power of his is not ordinary and immediate both over all and each of the churches and over all and each of the pastors and faithful: Let him be anathema”, understands that to mean the Absolutist Petrine view is the correct view.
  • 2a) According to official sources, such as the Counsel of Florence and others, double-procession is not the correct understanding, rather the correct view is that the Holy Spirit proceeds from the Father through the Son. No effort is made to correct Protestants who hold double-procession’s views when they wish to become Roman Catholics.
  • 2b) According to official sources, such as the Official Relatio and others, the Absolutist Petrine view is not the correct view, rather the correct view is High Petrine view. No effort is made to correct Orthodox who may come to believe (based on a simple understanding of Vatican I proclamations) the Absolutist Petrine view and wish to become Eastern Catholics.
  • 3a) The fact that the filioque was added to the Creed sure seems to make it dogmatic, and yet its use is optional.
  • 3b) The addition of an anathema for anyone who does not accept Vatican I sure makes it sound dogmatic. I can’t see however that it isn’t optional, seeing that Absolutist, High, and Low Petrine views abound everywhere and how can anyone be corrected in there view seeing that the official view of the Church is virtually unknown!
Why do I make this comparison? Because I’m wish to acquire a correct opinion without having to undergo seemingly endless studies, and a way to do that is comparing the opinions on this forum with each other and looking for patterns. In the comparison I made between Vatican I and the filioque I see a pattern. I see this pattern in other areas too, such as looking for an official list of Ecumenical Councils. All Ecumenical Councils, it is said, must be accepted by the faithful, and yet no one can come up with an official list. What does this pattern say about the role of the Roman Church in the Universal Church? I am answering this question for myself and forming an opinion.

I don’t think it can be said that this thread has clearly spelled out with clarity to all an understanding of “The Vatican Dogma”. Advocates of the Absolutist Petrine view think they made it clear to all that their view represents the teaching of Vatican I, but Advocates of the High Petrine view think they made it clear to all as well that their view represents the teaching of Vatican I. In the final analysis the teachings of Vatican I, in a practical way, really can’t be dogmatic. But because many see it as dogmatic there can never be peace and agreement.

If everything that comes from Rome is optional, then Rome itself is optional. Nothing changed in the Eastern Churches on the day that Rome finally confirmed the Second Ecumenical Council. There was peace and agreement in the East both before and after it’s confirmation. This thread has helped me to see things this way and my opinion has formed accordingly.
John,

Thanks for your comments. You’ve done yourself well in a specific and thoughtful, commentary.

I’ll get back to you. I don’t have enough time right now to give you a reply.
 
Dear brother Steve,

I’ve got several hours of unexpected free time to kill, so…
I used pope “ALONE” many times in answering your questions. What was the context?
In the context of an Ecumenical Council or the College of bishops:
(1) Is the Pope ALONE infallible?
(2) Is the authority of the Ecumenical Council or College of bishops dependent on the agreement of the Pope ALONE, or is it ALSO dependent on the agreement of the rest of the bishops?

In the context of the papal exercise of the infallible Magisterium:
(1) Is the Pope’s infallibility separated from the infallibility of the Church?
(2) Can the Pope make a definition that is opposed to the PRESENT PREACHING OF THE WHOLE MAGISTERIUM?
you’re denying the pope on his own, can define matters of faith and morals infallibly?
As already explained, the executive and judicial elements of a definition ex cathedra belong to the Pope alone, but the legislative element does not, and rather belongs to the WHOLE MAGISTERIUM. What part of that is hard for you to grasp?
“Individual bishops do not enjoy the prerogative of infallibility.” That’s a quote from [LG 25]
Are you being deliberately obtuse? You really have no idea what “collegial” means, do you? That is probably the source of your errors.
What provisions DO make it possible for them to proclaim teaching infallibly?
You already gave the quotes. Which is why I can’t understand why you adhere to your “Pope alone” error. Your quotes say that the agreement of the bishops TOGETHER WITH the head bishop is necessary. You keep insisting that the agreement of the head bishop ALONE is necessary.
Yes and yes
I ver seriously doubt that! You have absolutely no concept of what collegiality means, if any of your past (and present) posts are any indication.
I understand that, concur in a single viewpoint, means no matter how many viewpoints were there in the beginning, in the end, they concur in a single viewpoint to be held conclusively

Conclusively = putting an end to debate especially by reason of irrefutability
Here’s a perfect example of your utter ignorance of the concept of collegiality. I focus on the collegial nature of the term “concur” (agreement between parties). You, on the other hand, focus on the concept of “a single viewpoint.” It excuses your mind from grasping the reality of collegiality in the Church.
I gave you exactly the quotes from the docs where “pope alone” is used.
Yet not a single one of those quotes indicates that the Pope ALONE is the authority in an Ecumenical Council or College of bishops, and not a single one of those quotes indicates that the Pope ALONE is infallible in the same context, NOR in the context of the papal exercise of the infallible Magisterium. Nice try, but no cigar.
what specifically IS required?
I already stated it in my last post. Do us a favor and quote it, so we don’t have to play your game.
how many others need to agree? The canon doesn’t say. So how many need to agree?
So you need an exact number to understand the concept of collegiality? Talk about Latin Catholic legalism!
Re: canon 34
The bishops of every nation must acknowledge him who is first among them and account him as their head, and do nothing of consequence without his consent…but neither let him (who is head) do anything without the consent of all.
That last part goes against Vat I and II.
You only say that because of your cafeteria Catholicism. The V1 Fathers explained it, and I, with others, have quoted the Official Relatio, demonstrating that your statement is false. The Fathers of V1 and V2 use “consent” in the context of the papal exercise of the infallible Magisterium to mean “judgment” or “consultation/counsel.” It is these things that are not required by the definition of V1. But the Official Relatio asserts that Apostolic Canon 34 (the agreement of all) is the RULE OF FAITH that applies EVEN TO DEFINITIONS BY THE POPE.

So what we have here is the authority of the Fathers of the Vatican Councils, against the personal interpretations and cafeteria Catholicism of brothers Steve and Abu.
*]John VIII sees that, albeit he isn’t happy about it,
He’s still asking questions about it. He’s pointed out that if, at the end of the day, your position is actually true, then he should probably leave the Catholic Church.
I’ll take the authority of Bishop Gasser as the official spokesman of the Commission De Fide at V1 over interpretations of Bishop Kallistos Ware any day.
"Thus, the document represents the outcome of the work of a Commission and should not be understood as an official declaration of the Church’s teaching. "
Yes, the Ravenna Commission definitely employed a High Petrine paradigm. Which demonstrates that the Absolutist Petrine error has no place in a united Church, nor in the Church’s work of ecumenism.
It appears Can #34 isn’t by itself, a be all to end all canon.
Who said it was? Nevertheless, it most certainly applies to the ecclesiological teachings of the Catholic Church, as the Official Relatio of V1 asserted, contrary to your cafeteria Catholic misinterpretations of the Decrees of V1.

Blessings,
Marduk
 
Marduk can look over my 50 or so posts on this thread. I’ve quoted the Church docs copiously where BOTH pope and bishops can be infallible. BOTH have provisions however, for that to happen. Those provisions are all specifically spelled out from the Church docs I quoted.
Your quotations of these documents are part of the reason why there is no room for your Absolutist Petrine error according to orthodox Catholic teaching. And I pointed it out to you and brother Abu, every time you gave your quotes. All you demonstrated was the propensity for self-refutation among advocates of the Absolutist Petrine view.
Since these are technical and legal issues, that’s why I quote so copiously from Church docs. My opinions as you will note from my posts, are at an absolute minimum on this subject. That’s what bugged Marduk so much. As answers to him I would quote canon law, or LG, or Vat I etc, NOT give him my opinion.
What bugs me so much is your Cafeteria Catholicism. You give these quotes and underline only SPECIFIC portions to defend your error. You try to impose your erroneous opinion with this myopic focus on selective portions (as I have consistently demonstrated).

Blessings,
Marduk
 
Dear brother JohnVIII,
The only part that I am unhappy with is making any one specific view of the papacy dogmatic.
All orthodox Catholics agree that the agreement of the head bishop is necessary, a dogmatic principle established by Apostolic Canon 34.

QUESTION - do you doubt that the agreement of the head bishop is necessary according to Apostolic Canon 34? If you agree with this ancient Rule of Faith, then you are within the pale of orthodox Catholicism (the Low Petrine view which claims that the agreement of the head bishop is not necessary is not Catholic).

What is NOT dogmatic is the Absolutist Petrine principle that the agreement of the head bishop is the ONLY thing that is necessary.

I pointed out in the very quotes given by brothers Steve and Abu by underscoring those portions of the quotes they gave that they deliberately neglected, portions that demonstrate the collegial nature of the Church’s ecclesiology.

QUESTION - Do you agree that brothers Steve and Abu were only utilizing selective portions of the quotes they gave to defend their position (you can see this by the selective portions they underlined)?

Ex. - In Canon 341 of the Latin Code, brothers Steve and Abu focused on portions that indicated the necessity of the Pope’s agreement and confirmation in an Ecum Council to prove their erroneous opinion that ONLY the Pope’s actions are necessary for the validity, authority, and infallibility of an Ecumenical Council (or College of Bishops). In response, I pointed out that the very same Canon affirms that the agreement of the rest of the bishops is ALSO necessary for the validity, authority, and infallibility of an Ecumenical Council (or College of Bishops). Just from the canonical, textual perspective, who is correct? Does Canon 341 state that ONLY the Pope’s actions are necessary for the validity of an Ecumenical Council? Or does the text itself indicate the necessity of the agreement of the rest of the bishops AS WELL? Please respond, even if only for the sake of putting your mind at ease on this particular part of the debate.
I’m beginning to see pattern. I’d like to compare the Vatican Dogma to the issue of the addition of the filioque.
I understand your concern. What we have here are two positions: One that takes Sacred Tradition into account, and another that denies Sacred Traditino. I would only ask you - WHICH POSITION DO YOU HOLD. Do you personally, according to your conscience, accept the position that takes Sacred Tradition into account, or do you accept the position that denies it? I would humbly suggest that you hold and defend what your conscience affirms. If others have a different opinion, hold fast to what you believe, firmly planted on the rock, instead of being a reed in the wind (sorry if that sounds pedantic).
I don’t think it can be said that this thread has clearly spelled out with clarity to all an understanding of “The Vatican Dogma”.
Hold and defend what your own conscience affirms would be my suggestion.
Advocates of the Absolutist Petrine view think they made it clear to all that their view represents the teaching of Vatican I, but Advocates of the High Petrine view think they made it clear to all as well that their view represents the teaching of Vatican I. In the final analysis the teachings of Vatican I, in a practical way, really can’t be dogmatic. But because many see it as dogmatic there can never be peace and agreement.
Is it really true that just because someone may have a different interpretation, then dogma no longer exists? Did the existence of Judaizers in Scripture mean that the Gospel message was not dogma? Did the existence of the Pneumatomachi mean that the Nicene Creed was not dogmatic? There are numerous examples. Are the V1 Decrees not dogmatic just because there are different understandings?
(a) All orthodox Catholics believe that the head bishop is necessary. That is dogmatic.
(b) The necessity of the other bishops, not just the bishop of Rome, for the validity of the authority of an Ecumenical Council and the College of Bishops is at least canonical, if not dogmatic.
(c) That the Pope cannot contradict the sensus fidei of the Church even for definitions ex cathedra is dogmatic.

If you agree with these three points, remain a Catholic. The Absolutist Petrine opinions of brothers Steve B and Abu, which oppose points (b) and (c), are not dogmatic, but are an example of Cafeteria Catholicism. That’s all you have to know.
If everything that comes from Rome is optional, then Rome itself is optional. Nothing changed in the Eastern Churches on the day that Rome finally confirmed the Second Ecumenical Council. There was peace and agreement in the East both before and after it’s confirmation. This thread has helped me to see things this way and my opinion has formed accordingly.
Two things:
(1) “Peace and agreement” in the East is a bit of a red herring. The Pneumatomachi persisted for a while even after the Second Ecum Council. The Arians also persisted despite the First Ecum Council. Are you going to deny the dogmatic nature of the Decrees of the First Ecum because of that? Please respond.
(2) The confirmation of the bishop of Rome may not have had an immediate practical effect, but on the level of Faith, it did grant the Second Council its ecumenical status for future generations to recognize.

Blessings,
Marduk
 
Dear brother Adrian,

I wanted to repeat a matter to which you never responded. It has to do with the idea that a dogma can be understood apart from Sacred Tradition.

I gave you examples from the history of the Church to indicate that dogma can never be understood apart from the Sacred Tradition within which it is formulated.

The Vatican Decrees itself - in the form of the historic Proem (i.e., not just the Official Relatio) - specifically asserts this.

I want to ask - why do you feel that the dogmas of Vatican 1 can (or should) be understood or interpreted apart from Sacred Tradition?

You have claimed that the dogma is so powerfully worded that it appears to you that they must be taken apart from Sacred Tradition. But is it not true that the dogmas of the Ecumenical Councils in the first millenium are also “powerfully worded?” They contained anathemas as well. Nevertheless, this did not immediately stop certain groups from interpreting those dogmatic teachings in different ways, nor did it stop the Orthodox Catholic Fathers from affirming that those dogmas must be interpreted in light of the Sacred Tradition that came before them.

Hopefully, I have demonstrated to you that the V1 dogmas can indeed be interpreted in the light of Sacred Tradition. In fact, that’s the only way to do so. Please don’t be influenced by brothers Steve and Abu who claim otherwise, and who have never even attempted to appeal to Sacred Tradition in their arguments.

Blessings,
Marduk
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top