M
mardukm
Guest
CONTINUED
Blessings,
Marduk
As noted above, this is the problem with trying to wrench dogmatic definitions outside the context of Sacred Tradition as a whole. In fact, the only ones who have ever used the “so the Decree doesn’t really mean what it says” rhetoric in the history of the Church were the heterodox who interpreted the Decrees of the Ecum Councils apart from the light of Sacred Tradition.The real reason that the anathema of Vatican I doesn’t apply to me, as I see it, is because just like they really didn’t mean what they so clearly said in their pronouncements, they probably didn’t really mean it when they anathematized either. That’s why I said it might not be “ethical” for me to remain. If I could believe that they say what they mean, and mean what they say I would instead say something like “in peril of my eternal salvation” instead of “ethical”.
No apology needed. I understand sarcasm as deliberate mockery. It’s obvious your statement is made in light of a genuine concern to arrive at the truth, and not intended to mock.I came to believe that the Pope is the universal head of the Church in part because of what St Irenaeus said about Rome as well as other fathers of the Church, but who knows, maybe they really didn’t mean what they said either. Sorry for the sarcasm.
I don’t understand this statement in reference to the 4th Ecum. The necessity of the confirmation of the bishop of Rome is admitted by all the Ecum Councils, not just the 4th.But when I said that the EO outgrew a need for a pope, it would have been better for me to say that they outgrew the need of a dogmatized pope. Clearly they played that game at the 4th Ecumenical but they grew up since then.
We don’t need to discuss your particular views on the papacy right now. What I am more interested in are the general principles you are applying in order to interpret the situation (e.g., that the text of the definitions of Councils is the only thing that matters, and that the context of Sacred Tradition nor the interpretations of the Fathers of those Councils have no bearing on the definition).My opinion would only be of value in the context of a pleasant non-dogmatic conversation. Neither this topic not the one on second-marriages would fly here. Once again, sorry.
Vatican 1 asserts simply that it is a doctrinal error to deny that Peter is the Rock. One can hold any other belief of what the “Rock” of Mt 16:18 means (i.e., Jesus, Peter’s Confession, the Church as a whole), only as long as one does not attempt to deny that Peter is ALSO the Rock, or at least attempt to use the other definitions as contradictory principles to the Truth that Peter is the Rock of Mt 16:18…Would they be “free” to choose now, after Vatican I?
How do you arrive at the statement “someone can be both anathematized and saved” from the principles that have been discussed? We have specifically stated that those who are in invincible ignorance are not anathematized. Also, those who are born and raised in the Orthodox Church are not automatically anathematized. Perhaps you are not aware, but an anathema does not automatically send one to Hell. The Orthodox and Catholic Churches have the same patristic understanding of anathema - it is a discplinary proscription, not a condemnation to Hell. Even those who die under anathema are regarded as “being left to the mercy of God” and are not definitively condemned to Hell. This is the common teaching of the Apostolic Churches. To repeat, on what principles do you base your claim that “someone can be both anathematized and saved”?Yes I did know that. But I’m not going to ask the question “how then can someone be both anathematized and saved” because as I see it it is just proof that they really didn’t mean anything they said. I’m sorry, but this is all pure insanity to me.
Blessings,
Marduk