The "Very Stable Genius" strikes again

  • Thread starter Thread starter Economist
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
We already have. Now they decide elections even though the Constitution already provides a remedy.
 
So, you think we should toss out the Constitution in favor of politically appointed judges?
No. I was responding to your comment that the Supreme Court claimed its own authority out of the blue. That isn’t credible. A ‘college’ of men framed the constitution and it follows that it’s power and legitimacy only comes through a ‘college’ appointed to interpret and rule on constitutional issues. One can’t exist without the other and have human rights like freedom and equality protected.

I don’t believe Trump understands the value of a body like the Supreme Court because he isn’t a politician, he is an oligarch in the model of Hobbes.
 
Last edited:
Most people are unaware of the origin of our republic.

It is based upon the Roman concept, not the Greek idea of “democracy”. In a republic there are the “rights” given by the state. The state has the legislative and enforcement at its hand, and there were the two “tribunes”, whose life was sacrosanct. They only had one power, called “veto”, and it meant that any law was subject to their approval. They did not need any special argument, all they had to say “veto” (this is the origin of the word) and that was that.

The Framers established the judicial branch and their role is to decide if a law is Constitutional, or not. Unfortunately the process is more complicated, then a simple “veto” power. But that is what we have today.
 
Yes and our Senate has its roots there too. The word Senator is Latin. As is Senatus (the legislative body).
 
Last edited:
You say it’s not credible and yet, that’s exactly what happened. The Constitution never gives SCOTUS this power. It’s a power they claimed for themselves in Marbury v Madison.
 
I didn’t say the Supreme Court isn’t legitimate. I said it is not a legislative body, that the Constitution never gives it the power to veto legislation, but that is a power they claimed for themselves.
 
Getting Democrat Presidential candidates to come out against July 4th and the flag was a pretty genius move.
 
Last edited:
Feel free to show us where in the Constitution it says SCOTUS has legislative powers.
The SCOTUS has become a judicial oligarchy and somehow, we the people have been brainwashed into thinking that those 9 old folks make laws.
 
Well, it’s true it isn’t an enumerated power…but it’s in the spirit of the document. (Why is there no sarcasm emoji?)
 
Last edited:
Not really. The spirit of the document is all about separation of powers, not combining the judicial and legislative branches.
 
Democrats being against anything that celebrates America is their natural state.
 
Not that they did come out “against July 4th and the flag.”
1. Nike announced it’s scrapping an athletic shoe featuring the Betsy Ross flag because, apparently, former NFL quarterback Colin Kaepernick objected to it.
2. The New York Times Opinion section yanked at flag wavers by tweeting a video opinion piece with a caption reading, “The myth of America as the greatest nation on earth is at best outdated and at worst, wildly inaccurate. If you look at data, the U.S. is really just O.K.”
3. The city council of Charlottesville, North Carolina [sic], voted on July 1 that the city "will no longer celebrate Thomas Jefferson’s birthday as an official city holiday…


And this comment seemed especially accurate:

Listening to the Democratic debates, and the depiction of the nation and its economy by the candidates, one would think we were living in the Paris of “Les Miserables” or the London of Charles Dickens.
 
  1. That’s a company, not “Democrats.” I thought Republicans were in favor of big business? Sorry, my mistake.
  2. Another company, not “Democrats.”
  3. Doesn’t mention being “against July 4th and the flag.”
  4. Opinion from an unnamed source, not a quote from any Democrat speaking “against July 4th and the flag.”
 
I believe Pete and Booker both spoke against the colonial flag.
 
That’s a company, not “Democrats.” I thought Republicans were in favor of big business? Sorry, my mistake.
It is a mindset shared by those on the left. I would have expected most people to recognize that. But if you need specific quotes, they are easy to come by:

Gavin Newsom (California governor): “Hey, @Nike — we’re just a quick jaunt over the border. Thank you for doing the right thing. CA is open for business and welcomes those that represent the best of our American values.”

Julian Castro (Dem presidential candidate): “I was glad to see that. And my hope is that they didn’t just do it to do it. They understand the significance there."

Another company, not “Democrats.”
The New York Times is just a company? It is a mouthpiece for the left, and especially Democrats. You may think that is a good or bad thing, but it isn’t rational to dispute that any more than it would be rational to dispute the Rush Limbaugh pushes the conservative (and generally Republican) perspective. Does someone have to be an elected official before you consider him a Democrat?

Doesn’t mention being “against July 4th and the flag.”
I suppose if you take the comment literally, this is true. As for the meaning of what has been said, that is the clear direction being taken by the left.

Michael Eric Dyson (Georgetown professor): “Words matter. Symbols matter, too," Dyson said. "Why don’t we wear a swastika for July 4th?”

Bakari Sellers (CNN): “this country was built on white supremacy.”
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top