Hello,
How do respond to arguments that find confession not to be a necessary part of your Christian life? Why would somebody go to confession instead of performing an act of perfect contrition (that’s the correct term, right?)?
Thanks,
fish90
Let’s look at the definition of an Act of Perfect Contrition. One element of any act of perfect contrition is precisely the resolve or desire to go to confession when/if such is available.
So someone who is on a plane going down might say ‘God, I am sorry for all my sins … so sorry that if I get out of this alive, I promise I’m gonna go straight to confession!’ Such would save him, even if the desire or resolve is implicit and not expressed in words.
Of course if their resolve is sincere they will follow through on it. So if they DID survive, they’d have to actually go through with their resolution and get themselves to the confessional sharpish.
If he simply says 'God, I am sorry for all my sins … ’ and says or thinks ‘but not sorry enough that I’d want to go to confession for them, even if I could’ - that ISN’T an Act of perfect contrition.
So it’s not even a question of having a choice between Confession and an APC. An Act of Perfect Contrition by itself won’t save us in circumstances when confession is available.
It only applies in circumstances where confession ISN’T available, and must comprise, in part, of a resolve or desire to go to confession as soon as possible, which we must then follow through with if the opportunity presents itself.