Theology of Getting Things Done

  • Thread starter Thread starter Bubba_Switzler
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
B

Bubba_Switzler

Guest
What is the theology of getting things done? Where does the concern for getting things done stand in Catholic theology?

The best way to illustrate the issue is to examine the subject of charity. Many Catholics regard charity as a fundamental Christian duty: we are called to share the food we have with those who lack. But when it comes to growing th food to share, not so much.

Taken to it’s logical extreme, a theology that requires charity without creation would value giving seed corn to the poor over planting it in the ground.

Catholics often champion policies that do exactly that.

Is this tendency just a misunderstanding or does Catholicism really take this view?
 
What is the theology of getting things done? Where does the concern for getting things done stand in Catholic theology?

The best way to illustrate the issue is to examine the subject of charity. Many Catholics regard charity as a fundamental Christian duty: we are called to share the food we have with those who lack. But when it comes to growing th food to share, not so much.

Taken to it’s logical extreme, a theology that requires charity without creation would value giving seed corn to the poor over planting it in the ground.

Catholics often champion policies that do exactly that.

Is this tendency just a misunderstanding or does Catholicism really take this view?
Well… you are just giving what you already have, not providing but sharing.
 
Sometimes there is not enough time or proper conditions to give the “seed corn” time to grow and be harvested.
 
When someone is starving to death is not the time to give him classes in agriculture.

Feed him first, and then teach him how to grow his own food. The charities that I know about and support take this two-pronged approach - solve the immediate emergency, while planning for success in the future. 🙂
 
Are you being sarcastic?
Not at all!

Providing implies creating (e.g. growing food or holding down a job to provide for one’s family). Sharing implies simply the distribution of goods in hand.

There seems to be a clerical bias in favor of sharing over providing.

Perhaps the only biblical injunction that comes close to the expectation of providing is the parable of the talents but even that is very often interpreted in terms of spiritual gifts as opposed to taleng, generally.

(Imagine the implications of the parable of the talents if it were understood to represent God’s gifts, generally. The Cathoic Church would be teaching that it is sinful not to pursue profit or mastery of skill.)

Providing vs. sharing is a very accurate description of the issue I want to raise here.
 
Sometimes there is not enough time or proper conditions to give the “seed corn” time to grow and be harvested.
Perhaps. But if things are that dire, that would simply mean starving later.

On the other hand, people often demonstrate sacrifice in the short term for gains in the long term (i.e. planting the seed corn and reaping the harvest).
 
When someone is starving to death is not the time to give him classes in agriculture. Feed him first, and then teach him how to grow his own food. The charities that I know about and support take this two-pronged approach - solve the immediate emergency, while planning for success in the future. 🙂
This is an entirely valid point but you are getting sidetracked onto a separate issue (feeding vs. teaching to fish).

What I want to explore in this thread is the choice of sacrificing to provide (or not). For example, I could study to be a doctor or I could spend time on the beach. If I become a doctor I will have more to share. But long before then, I have this choice of whether or not to make the effort to become a doctor.
 
What is the theology of getting things done? Where does the concern for getting things done stand in Catholic theology?

The best way to illustrate the issue is to examine the subject of charity. Many Catholics regard charity as a fundamental Christian duty: we are called to share the food we have with those who lack. But when it comes to growing th food to share, not so much.

Taken to it’s logical extreme, a theology that requires charity without creation would value giving seed corn to the poor over planting it in the ground.

Catholics often champion policies that do exactly that.

Is this tendency just a misunderstanding or does Catholicism really take this view?
You should read Fr. Martin’s new book - “The Jesuit Guide to Just About Everything.” He says that Ignatius Loyola was very concerned with getting things done and that its a big part of the Jesuit mindset. He tells this story/joke (which I am paraphrasing from memory): A Franciscan, a Dominican and a Jesuit were preparing to say Mass when the lights in the church went out. The Franciscan said “what a great opportunity to meditate on simplifying our lives.” The Dominican said “I will give my sermon on Christ as the light in our lives, what a great metaphor this will make.” The Jesuit got a flashlight, and went looking for the fuse box.
 
You should read Fr. Martin’s new book - “The Jesuit Guide to Just About Everything.” He says that Ignatius Loyola was very concerned with getting things done and that its a big part of the Jesuit mindset. He tells this story/joke (which I am paraphrasing from memory): A Franciscan, a Dominican and a Jesuit were preparing to say Mass when the lights in the church went out. The Franciscan said “what a great opportunity to meditate on simplifying our lives.” The Dominican said “I will give my sermon on Christ as the light in our lives, what a great metaphor this will make.” The Jesuit got a flashlight, and went looking for the fuse box.
Thanks for the suggestion, I will look for that book. I hadn’t thought of the Jesuits that way but I can see your point.

I should also point out that the Catholic society Opus Dei also seems to at least touch tangentially on this in it’s treatment of everyday work as holy.
 
The Cathoic Church would be teaching that it is sinful not to pursue profit or mastery of skill.
:confused:

I always thought that it did teach that - isn’t that why we have to support our Catholic schools, and why we have to receive as high an education as we are capable of receiving?
 
Not at all!

Providing implies creating (e.g. growing food or holding down a job to provide for one’s family). Sharing implies simply the distribution of goods in hand.

There seems to be a clerical bias in favor of sharing over providing.

Perhaps the only biblical injunction that comes close to the expectation of providing is the parable of the talents but even that is very often interpreted in terms of spiritual gifts as opposed to taleng, generally.

(Imagine the implications of the parable of the talents if it were understood to represent God’s gifts, generally. The Cathoic Church would be teaching that it is sinful not to pursue profit or mastery of skill.)

Providing vs. sharing is a very accurate description of the issue I want to raise here.
…in that case please forgive me…
 
I always thought that it did teach that - isn’t that why we have to support our Catholic schools, and why we have to receive as high an education as we are capable of receiving?
I would really love to be corrected on this point. But very often when I bring up this point among Catholics I am accused of “materialism”.

(There is a subtle distinction between utilizing one’s talents for personal gain and for God’s plan but let’s set that aside for the moment.)

Note, also, that your second point is more relevant than the first. Perhaps if you could point me to the most “official” teaching (e.g. CCC) on this that would help.

Here is something that seems slightly relevant:
2429 Everyone has the right of economic initiative; everyone should make legitimate use of his talents to contribute to the abundance that will benefit all and to harvest the just fruits of his labor.
 
I would really love to be corrected on this point. But very often when I bring up this point among Catholics I am accused of “materialism”.
There is a pervasive idea out there that we are all supposed to make ourselves poor. I’m not sure where it comes from, but I’m very sure that it’s not coming from the official teachings of the Church, since the Church needs us to get money, so that we can support the Church, at least, and other worthy causes, as well. How do we do that, though, if we are all living too close to the edge of poverty to be able to spare anything?
(There is a subtle distinction between utilizing one’s talents for personal gain and for God’s plan but let’s set that aside for the moment.)
Ultimately, they may end up being the same thing, but that’s a whole other thing.
Note, also, that your second point is more relevant than the first. Perhaps if you could point me to the most “official” teaching (e.g. CCC) on this that would help.
Rerum Novarum is the most salient document I know of on the subject of Catholics and work. It’s very clear that the worker is supposed to be adequately compensated for his work, and that the worker has a duty to be good at what he does, and to be productive. Time spent at work is meant to be spent producing the goods and services for which the worker is being paid. The wage received should be a just wage, but the money with which the wage is paid should have been produced by the worker himself, either directly (salesmanship) or indirectly (producing that which is sold, at a high enough quality that the customer doesn’t attempt to return it, later). The employer should not need to be independently wealthy.
 
There is a pervasive idea out there that we are all supposed to make ourselves poor. I’m not sure where it comes from, but I’m very sure that it’s not coming from the official teachings of the Church, since the Church needs us to get money, so that we can support the Church, at least, and other worthy causes, as well. How do we do that, though, if we are all living too close to the edge of poverty to be able to spare anything?

Ultimately, they may end up being the same thing, but that’s a whole other thing.

Rerum Novarum is the most salient document I know of on the subject of Catholics and work. It’s very clear that the worker is supposed to be adequately compensated for his work, and that the worker has a duty to be good at what he does, and to be productive. Time spent at work is meant to be spent producing the goods and services for which the worker is being paid. The wage received should be a just wage, but the money with which the wage is paid should have been produced by the worker himself, either directly (salesmanship) or indirectly (producing that which is sold, at a high enough quality that the customer doesn’t attempt to return it, later). The employer should not need to be independently wealthy.
I agree that the idea that being financially or professionally successful is somehow bad is a misunderstanding of Catholic teaching. Like many misunderstandings of our faith, its influenced at least in part by the prevalence of fundamentalism and evangelicalism today. Many Protestants preach that the world is bad and evil, so succeeding in the world is also bad and evil. Catholics believe that the world is good, and that doing well in this world is not only OK - its a good thing if done properly.

Catholics believe that Christian principles apply to everything in life. So financial success becomes a problem when the successful person doesn’t apply the same Christian principles to his professional work and financial decisions as he does to his “religious” life. There is no “religious life,” there is only life, and the same principles guide all aspects of it. You can be successful without being a tyrant. You can be financially comfortable without being a glutton or a miser. Everyone should be generous - if everyone is than the financially successful will give more of his finances than someone who is poor. But being materially successful is not wrong, and teaching others to be successful should be one of our goals.
 
If we understand that everything we have comes from God - even what we “earn” we earn using the gifts He gave us - gifts of talent and education and opportunity - then we will understand that we are stewards, not owners, of our earthly goods. And if we have that attitude, we will be more inclined to share those gifts with others who are less fortunate.

Under the Old Covenant, the chosen people were obligated to give a tenth of everything to the support of the Levites, and in addition to provide for widows, orphans and aliens. Under the New Covenant we are challenged by Jesus to go beyond the demands of the Law. Sometimes this is going to mean giving someone a meal, sometimes it is going to mean giving them job training. Always it means giving out of love and gratitude, not resentfully or out of obligation.

As always, it’s not either/or, but both/and.
 
If we understand that everything we have comes from God - even what we “earn” we earn using the gifts He gave us - gifts of talent and education and opportunity - then we will understand that we are stewards, not owners, of our earthly goods. And if we have that attitude, we will be more inclined to share those gifts with others who are less fortunate.
This is an important point but it doesn’t address the specific issue that I’m raising here. This is the choice between sharing and not sharing.

What I want to focus on here is the choice between providing and sharing.

The gift metaphor presuposes that what we have, we have and limits itself to how we dispose of what we have.

However, much of what we have is merely a potential to provide. A child is a potential doctor. He can’t share anything yet (except maybe his toys). So before focusing on sharing he has to focus on becoming a doctor, to fulfill his God-given potential.

We can look at it another way: the gift is the potential to be a doctor (or the potential of seeds to yield food) and to share this gift requires nurturing it first.
 
There is a pervasive idea out there that we are all supposed to make ourselves poor. I’m not sure where it comes from, but I’m very sure that it’s not coming from the official teachings of the Church, since the Church needs us to get money, so that we can support the Church, at least, and other worthy causes, as well. How do we do that, though, if we are all living too close to the edge of poverty to be able to spare anything?
I hesitate to say that Catholicism venerates poverty, generally, but it certainly seems to teach (at some level, not necessarily formally) that mediocrity is acceptable. Contrast the Catholic and Jewish traditions with respect to education and professional excellence. I think Catholics are satisfied that they’re not fundamentalists.

There is certainly an ascetic tradition within Catholicism but then there is also a celibate tradition and Catholicism doesn’t teach that sex (in marriage) is a sin, though I have heard some argue that enjoying sex is a sin. In the case of sex, the Church seems satisfied to focus on channeling what comes natural toward marriage and it seems that it’s attitude toward providing is similar.

But the results seems to be that Catholics are much more passive, less likely to swing for the fences for fear of striking out. I don’t think I’ve ever heard a sermon that tells young people that they should provide for the poor by exploiting their God-given potential.
Rerum Novarum is the most salient document I know of on the subject of Catholics and work. It’s very clear that the worker is supposed to be adequately compensated for his work, and that the worker has a duty to be good at what he does, and to be productive. Time spent at work is meant to be spent producing the goods and services for which the worker is being paid. The wage received should be a just wage, but the money with which the wage is paid should have been produced by the worker himself, either directly (salesmanship) or indirectly (producing that which is sold, at a high enough quality that the customer doesn’t attempt to return it, later). The employer should not need to be independently wealthy.
Thanks, I’ll take a look at that. It does sound like it’s more in the direction that I’m exploring here.
 
I agree that the idea that being financially or professionally successful is somehow bad is a misunderstanding of Catholic teaching. Like many misunderstandings of our faith, its influenced at least in part by the prevalence of fundamentalism and evangelicalism today. Many Protestants preach that the world is bad and evil, so succeeding in the world is also bad and evil. Catholics believe that the world is good, and that doing well in this world is not only OK - its a good thing if done properly.
It’s alaways interesting to contrast Catholicism and the various flavors of Protestantism. While you are correct that there are many Protestants who view the world as bad/evil, there are also some that teach (I forget the term) that if you pray hard enough God will make you rich or that if you are virtuous God will make you wealthy (borrowed from the old Hebrew view).
Catholics believe that Christian principles apply to everything in life. So financial success becomes a problem when the successful person doesn’t apply the same Christian principles to his professional work and financial decisions as he does to his “religious” life. There is no “religious life,” there is only life, and the same principles guide all aspects of it. You can be successful without being a tyrant. You can be financially comfortable without being a glutton or a miser. Everyone should be generous - if everyone is than the financially successful will give more of his finances than someone who is poor. But being materially successful is not wrong, and teaching others to be successful should be one of our goals.
One thing I have noticed among Catholics (and people generally) is the tendency to divide Sunday from the rest of the week, to regard making a living as a base activity. I mentioned Opus Dei as an interesting exception to this but by and large, saints are individuals who led ascetic, often celibate lives.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top