These Parents Cut Their Daughter Out of Their Will After She Became a Catholic and Begged Her Brother to Give Up His Openly Gay Lifestyle So He Could

  • Thread starter Thread starter mdgspencer
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
There is wrongdoing going on in that family from all of its members. None of them are acting with any compassion for one another.

And it’s sad that the dad thought it was a good idea to put all of that on the internet for the world to see.
 
There is wrongdoing going on in that family from all of its members. None of them are acting with any compassion for one another.
I actually think the daughter is acting with compassion and even courage, although somewhat misguided. She obviously cares deeply about her brother, though he and the parents are choosing not to see it that way.

Granted. begging her brother over and over is clearly not an effective method. And now, having made her beliefs known to him, it would be better to leave the matter in God’s hands while continuing to pray for him. But I maintain that she has demonstrated courage in broaching the subject and clearly cares more about his soul than about herself.
 
Last edited:
Oh yes, I believe she is genuine, but her approach was not a good one at all. And it does matter how she handled her conversations.
 
No one is saying she shouldn’t have spoken the truth. It is the manner in which she spoke it.

The parents reaction was no better.
 
This happens sometimes when you become a follower of Christ. She will have a far greater inheritance in Heaven if she perseveres in living the holiness that God calls her to live.
 
It sounds like things might be getting better, Below is the full Reddit original post (which gives a fuller picture than the news article that cherry picked certain quotes) , with an edit by the father.
My son Jake is gay, he came out when he was 18 and me and my wife couldn’t have been more proud of him! He is now 31 and his older sister Lucy is 37. We’ve all been a happy family until about 6 months ago, when Lucy converted to Catholicism. Neither me, my wife or my son are particularly religious.

Since then Lucy became more distant with her Jake, and I started to notice Jake looking less jolly than his normal self. I decided to ask him about it, because I could sense something was wrong. At first he denied something was up, so I kept asking him what what was wrong until he finally broke down in tears one day. He told me that a few months back Lucy had called him to meet up.

Apparently when they met up she had tried to talk to him about his sexuality. According to my son, she literally begged him to repent and give up his ‘homosexual lifestyle,’ by breaking up with his boyfriend of two years. Since then she constantly rings him and texts him begging him to repent his sin, and has even messaged his boyfriend directly to ‘try and save him from hell too.’ - I was livid.

Me and my wife immediately called Lucy and demanded a ‘family meeting.’ We all sat round the table (me, my wife, Jake and Lucy), and we asked her about it. She literally said in front of us all ‘Jake, I want you to go to Heaven, you’ve got to stop this, its not natural.’ My wife burst into tears and I started to literally shake in rage. After a lot of screaming and crying from everyone, my wife and I eventually said something along the lines of: ‘you can believe what you want, but if you dare to say anything even remotely related to Jake’s life choices ever again, you will not be a part of this family.’ Her response was to look Jake in the eyes and say ‘can you not see what your doing is wrong, it’s a violation, it’s sick.’

After throwing her out of the house and telling her we would never speak to her again, we got on the phone and decided to amend our will. She now gets absolutely nothing. She arrived at our house begging to let her into our lives again, and saying not only are we letting Jake down but we are not respecting her religious beliefs

EDIT: Thanks everyone for your touching words and advice. It’s truly wonderful how supportive everyone has been, both with legal advice and heartwarming comments. Thankyou also to the people who have reminded the importance of forgiveness, we will reach out to her and try and come to an understanding. The main thing we all want to do is to put this behind us. For the people who have suggested family therapy, we are taking that into consideration (obviously with the current situation in the world, our options are limited, but we will see what we can do). Thanks all.
 
Last edited:
It’s even on r/AmITA, where almost every post is fake. Like, several redditors admitted to using the sub as a creative writing exercise to learn how to make good characters.
The odds that a post that dramatic and involved are true are astronomically small.

EDIT: Yeah looking at the reddit op’s profile has convinced me this is fake. He’s only made that one post.
 
Last edited:
Chapter 11 of the book “How To Drive People Away From Catholicism”
 
First of all, why is this in Newsweek.
Next, why are the parents “proud” of their son’s attractions?
Then, why is the daughter badgering her brother ? Evangelism fail!!!
Why would the mother be “shaking with rage”? Over a sibling quarrel?
And then the parents disown her?
What does that prove?
Oh and the useful idiots on reddit giving back-pats and huggies to parents turning their back on their daughter.
Shame
 
Chapter 11 of the book “How To Drive People Away From Catholicism”
Yeah, the way she treated him isn’t how we win people over to Christ. Plus, she seems to be way too obsessed with how her brother lives his life, when there are millions of gay people out there who aren’t following the church’s teachings either.

Although on the other hand, I’m old enough to remember when gay sex was illegal in parts of the US (I had discussions about it with some in my bible study group in 2004, after the Supreme Court decision that changed that) so I guess we might say that her approach is better than that (?)

Edit: I should say, “when there are millions of gay and straight people out there who aren’t following the church’s teachings either.”
 
Yeah, the way she treated him isn’t how we win people over to Christ. Plus, she seems to be way too obsessed with how her brother lives his life, when there are millions of gay people out there who aren’t following the church’s teachings either.
I love my family more than most people, so it matters more to me that they are not commiting mortal sins.

Also, while not true in this case, they may be less likely to sever the relationship.
 
Last edited:
Captain: You gonna get used to wearing them chains after a while, Luke. Don’t you never stop listening to them clinking. Cause they gonna remind you of what I been saying. For your own good.

Luke: I wish you’d stop being so good to me, Captain.

(Cool Hand Luke)

(Please Note: This uploaded content is no longer available.)
 
If this story is true, there is definitely some disfunction going on in the family. Neither the daughter nor the others were listening to each other. They were just getting emotional about a strong disagreement on how to interact…both sides.

It seems the father later realized his overreaction and I would hope the daughter does, too. She also needs to realize that she isn’t owed an inheritance but the father was using that as a punishment.

If cooler heads prevail, they might be able to listen to each other and learn to agree to disagree. The daughter needs to learn that it isn’t her place to demand her brother changes. It sounds like she’s a recent convert and is a bit too much on fire for her new beliefs. With time and hopefully counseling, they can heal together and all be stronger for it.
 
True, though the parents (if real) obviously mastered Chapter 7 of the book “How to overreact, push your children away and destroy your family.” Talk about a bunch of hot-headed foolishness.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top