Thinking of becomming excommunicated

  • Thread starter Thread starter Meemai
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
M

Meemai

Guest
A disclaimer I have had quite a lot of beers and am rather drunkish, though let that not withold you from reading this. Unless your a radical fundamentalist your going to hate me but I do hate fundamentalism with a passion! So we would have to hate each other. let’s start since even if I’m drunk heavily (Yes I’m an beginning alcoholic) I am not addicted but I need it to get trough my life. But my intellect is 100% alright so I am not going to say weird things.

On this forum I have been called a troll, a heretic and maybe more things but this time I am going to share my believes and what I do not like about the church. Maybe I’ll remain catholic but I have to set the problems I have with the church straight and I decided to start doing that here. I will also talk about it with my pastor but let’s start.

The church I see it as a big organisation that has amassed a lot of wealth. Also a place that was rather strong and has abused it’s position multiple times in medieval times. Everyone that has read Machiavelli knows very well that the church in that time also was a sort of powerhouse that you should not mess with. The church was you could maybe even say corrupt. Sins could be forgiven by giving money to priests and such. Now it’s no wonder Martin Luther started his protest and formed a new form of christianity. I can understand Martin Luther and I do respect him. Sadly after him there was no more leader and thus protestantism has been left without a clue.

Back at our chuch so where God has promised the church would never be corrupt there has been a lot of corruption going on. I am not saying the church is corrupt but it would be stupid to say that there is no corruption in the church. To those that now say to me your stupid the church is not corrupt. Please look at the child abuse scandles. I don’t like the scandles but it shows me that the church is not 100% saintly nor holy. Take it or leave it.

So let’s jump in the now, things that I cannot live with.

I have attempted suicide yes I have stood with one leg in my grave. But I failed, which I still regret. Now it has been said it is a sin to take your own life. But can you really blame people that take they’re own life? No one takes hir or her own life for fun. But for a jew with no where to go and Hitler with his nazi’s on the rise? I can pretty well understand that people want to sucide. Also those without money in the weimar republic used gas to kill themselves because they had no money and debts would rise and government was not being nice. Yes I am using German examples here a lot because I know of them.

So let’s say everyone in Germany in the weimar was poor and had nothing to eat the church would still be fine. A priest would still be well and would stand above the people He would say and preach that all will become fine but well isin’t it a bit of a hypocritic action when I as a western white man go to the poor Africa. And tell them all will be fine? While I am feasting on a big piece of meat?

Abortion and condoms use.

I have a personality disorder which would make it so that I can never ever get a girlfriend nor get married. Because a marriage with me would end up in divorce it would go all wrong I don’t want to hurt someone like that. However I sometimes might want sex or something so yes I would have one night stands with women and use condoms. Because those women would do more one night stands and you don’t want to make childeren with them nor would you want any stds. Now the church is against this. All of Africa is crippled with hiv and the church keeps telling them to not use condoms.

I have flipped trough the bible and could not find anything about condoms. Except this which I have taken of the internet because I did not know how to formulate it myself: The Bible says nothing about condom use. It only makes a vague reference to not spilling your seed on the ground - and, that was directed to the Hebrews whose numbers had supposedly been greatly diminished and wasting reproductive fluids was seen as counterproductive to the goal of having children.

Alright so where does the bible say I cannot use condoms? Why does Africa have to suffer with hiv? I also believe the pope did say prostitutes can wear condoms. Well what do you know?

Then let’s get abortion, no one aborts they’re kids for fun. But to call a single female that got raped and then decides to abort, to call her a murderer? Do you think it’s easy for her to kill her own child? She was raped she didn’t want it, it cannot seem justified to have that child which will remind you of your rapist every single day. How can the church or someone else even have an opinion on this? Your all outsiders you don’t know ****, so I hate radical christians that go about and call them murderers. THEY SHOULD BE ASHAMED. They are outsiders they have no right to judge someone else.

After all Jesus said something about throwing the first stone, yet the church does not seem to mind to throw stones. Heck I think they keep throwing stones at people so much in matter of they’re opinion that I wonder if they even listened to Jesus. Jesus his lesson was that everyone sins. Yet the church deems sin as bad and throws stones add those that do.

When I say that I have used a condom and have had sex with a hooker would that make me a heretic?

I think John Paul II did forgive the one that shot him. Why would you not forgive someone that did abortion? Why is there no forgiving for them? Why do catholics go on the street and show they are against it? Why can’t the forgive like John Paul II did? I really like John Paul II but I cannot agree with everything he says. The condoms etc.

There is a lot more I am dissapointed with in the church. But these are the few problems I liked to adress. When I get to the urge to talk about more I might. I just will keep asking questions and making topics like this till I am 100% sure I will leave church.
 
Like family members, the members of the Church aren’t going to be perfect; but also like a family itself, the Church herself is good, specifically because she provides salvation.

Look up John Paul II’s “Theology of the Body”. I just started reading into it and found it to be an enlightening study on human sexuality. We are called to be fruitful and to participate in God’s creative nature by reproducing, and we are specifically designed as such; it would be an offense against God’s design, therefore, to use contraception because its sole purpose is to thwart the development of human life. But that’s just one of many aspects of JPII’s writing.

As for abortion: why should the child pay for the sins of the rapist? If that legitimizes abortion, should a mother then be allowed to kill her children because they remind her of her promiscuous ex-husband? The floodgates open…

I’ll pray for you, and I hope you stay in the Church. After all, you are one of my spiritual siblings.
 
The church I see it as a big organisation that has amassed a lot of wealth. Also a place that was rather strong and has abused it’s position multiple times in medieval times. Everyone that has read Machiavelli knows very well that the church in that time also was a sort of powerhouse that you should not mess with. The church was you could maybe even say corrupt. Sins could be forgiven by giving money to priests and such. Now it’s no wonder Martin Luther started his protest and formed a new form of christianity. I can understand Martin Luther and I do respect him. Sadly after him there was no more leader and thus protestantism has been left without a clue.

Back at our chuch so where God has promised the church would never be corrupt there has been a lot of corruption going on. I am not saying the church is corrupt but it would be stupid to say that there is no corruption in the church. To those that now say to me your stupid the church is not corrupt. Please look at the child abuse scandles. I don’t like the scandles but it shows me that the church is not 100% saintly nor holy. Take it or leave it.
The Church does have a lot of wealth, although its operating budget is pretty reasonable considering its size. The error of Martin Luther was in thinking the Church should be sinless. The Church’s teachings are completely true, but as a body of people, it is full of sinners. Child abuse is tragic, there is no question. Priests sin too.
I have attempted suicide yes I have stood with one leg in my grave. But I failed, which I still regret. Now it has been said it is a sin to take your own life. But can you really blame people that take they’re own life? No one takes hir or her own life for fun.
I’m sorry that you’ve tried to take your own life and I pray that you don’t try again. I will be praying for you. I assume that you have shared this with a medical professional, but if not that is the first thing to do.

The thing about suicide is that it is grave matter, but we have to believe that it is often not done with full intentionality and knowledge, and therefore is often not a damning mortal sin. People who commit suicide are always in difficult circumstances and generally have some form of mental illness. They often do not see that it is not “the only way out.”
I have a personality disorder which would make it so that I can never ever get a girlfriend nor get married. Because a marriage with me would end up in divorce it would go all wrong I don’t want to hurt someone like that. However I sometimes might want sex or something so yes I would have one night stands with women and use condoms. Because those women would do more one night stands and you don’t want to make childeren with them nor would you want any stds. Now the church is against this. All of Africa is crippled with hiv and the church keeps telling them to not use condoms.
Some of the Church’s teachings are hard to swallow, but chastity in the end, I think, is very enriching. I used to struggle with masturbation, and at times I still “want” to sin (and at other times I still do sin) - but I know that it is not good for me. The sexual act was created for procreation in marriage. That intent is diminished when we engage in sex outside of marriage or using a condom. As you note, you do not want children to come from your sex.

Africa and HIV are another case. Part of the problem is that condoms do not stop HIV entirely; the fact that HIV is an issue even in places where condom use is prevalent is a testament to this. Chastity and sacramental marriage are the only ways to guarantee you will not get an STD. In practice, these are not perfect solutions, since not everyone will participate in sacramental marriage, but hopefully that clarifies the Church’s position.
I have flipped trough the bible and could not find anything about condoms. Except this which I have taken of the internet because I did not know how to formulate it myself: The Bible says nothing about condom use.
Not every sin is written in the Bible. The Bible says little about homosexuality or abortion (not sure if it says anything about the latter). The Church’s teaching on contraception is derived from the sacredness of the sacrament of marriage and natural law.
 
Then let’s get abortion, no one aborts they’re kids for fun. But to call a single female that got raped and then decides to abort, to call her a murderer? Do you think it’s easy for her to kill her own child? She was raped she didn’t want it, it cannot seem justified to have that child which will remind you of your rapist every single day. How can the church or someone else even have an opinion on this? Your all outsiders you don’t know ****, so I hate radical christians that go about and call them murderers. THEY SHOULD BE ASHAMED. They are outsiders they have no right to judge someone else.
I am not so sure that no one aborts their kids for fun. Disregarding the rape case for now, we will recall that the vast majority of abortions in the US are of pregnancies caused by consensual, recreational (recreational in the “for fun” sense, not the sacramental, reproductive sense) sex. The act of aborting may be fun, but it is undertaken in many cases in order to continue having fun - to continue having consequence-free sex.

As for the rape case, it is an emotionally charged issue. Rape victims have been put through a lot, and any steps should be taken to avoid further traumatizing them. However, the crime of the rape does not have to be compounded by the crime of killing the child. If the child will serve as a reminder of her rape, then she may put it up for adoption (although it seems psychologically unlikely that a child would be a reminder of the rape in the sense of a trigger, since triggers are visceral associations and the child was not visibly present in the way that her rapist was). Furthermore, a lot of people come to regret abortions that they were chided into having, and an abortion can add to the sense of loss after a rape.

Why do we call it murder? Again, this is an emotional case; the woman did not ask to be raped. However, murder is “intentional, unjustified killing.” The Catholic Church teaches that a fetus is ensouled*, so we cannot intentionally kill it for any reason.

As far as anyone being an outsider to the issue of abortion, that is a grayer area. We were all fetuses once. I am thankful that I was neither contraceived nor aborted; the golden rule therefore compels me to oppose contraception and abortion. I cannot wish contraception or abortion upon anyone because I am glad that they were not done to me.

*The Church has taught a few things about ensoulment over the course of its history. It has largely modified its position (slightly) as our scientific understanding of conception and pregnancy have come about. It is not definitive that ensoulment occurs at conception, but ensoulment may occur at conception. The morally safest option for us, then, is to act as though it occurs at conception, since, if we act otherwise, we risk killing ensouled beings. In any case, even if a fetus is not ensouled, it would be morally wrong for the same reasons that contraception is wrong. I believe it occurs at contraception since it, to me, makes the most sense: a human must be ensouled at some point, and conception is the point where it comes into being as an individual.
After all Jesus said something about throwing the first stone, yet the church does not seem to mind to throw stones. Heck I think they keep throwing stones at people so much in matter of they’re opinion that I wonder if they even listened to Jesus. Jesus his lesson was that everyone sins. Yet the church deems sin as bad and throws stones add those that do.
I hope many Christians would be honest about their sins, as we are called to do. Don’t confuse admonishing sinners with throwing stones. I am a sinner, but if you are too, it is better for me to correct you (at least when it is tactful and appropriate to do so). Jesus certainly did not hesitate to admonish sinners. There is an important distinction between being “holier than thou” and being charitable about helping others - even if helping others entails helping them overcome sin. Without being morally perfect as Jesus was, it probably impossible to not, at some point, be a hypocrite.
Why would you not forgive someone that did abortion? Why is there no forgiving for them? Why do catholics go on the street and show they are against it?
The Church is fully prepared to forgive anyone who had an abortion. People are excommunicated for having an abortion because it is a direct disavowal of Church teaching; in this day and age, it is a rejection of one of the largest issues that the Church fights for.

But anyone who is contrite about their sins can receive forgiveness. Many who have abortions are not contrite and do not want forgiveness.
There is a lot more I am dissapointed with in the church. But these are the few problems I liked to adress. When I get to the urge to talk about more I might. I just will keep asking questions and making topics like this till I am 100% sure I will leave church.
I hope you reconsider. I will pray for you.
 

I stopped reading after this.
Frankly, the OP has a lot of legitimate concerns that are stumbling blocks for a lot of today’s Catholics. Even if he was drunk when he wrote the message, he will be sober when he reads the responses. I hope he’s not put off from staying in the Church because a few Catholics decided not to listen to his concerns.
 
Were condoms even invented in biblical times? Scripture doesn’t talk about internal combustion engines either.
 
I am with polytropos. I hope you do come back and read this. I will be praying for you too. Please seek help for your “personality disorder”, when you are more comfortable, come back and we can discuss your other questions. By the way, you might seek out an AA group there. There are even groups for people with both Alcohol and mental health problems. God be with you! 🙂
 
Nobody in Holy Mother Church is a fundamentalist, so relax.

Let us begin by one simple fact: addictions are bad for you. No matter what shape or form they take. I don’t mean to sound like a grandma, but not only I’ve been there to some degree, I’ve also had friends who’ve had a very, very hard time and have managed to come out clean of several addictions (including drugs and one-night stands) with the help of the Sacraments and the community life that is found in our Church.

Being catholic is not about setting the problems with the Church straight. Being catholic is about belonging to the apostolic Church founded by Jesus Christ. Realizing that this one Church is not an institution, not an organization, but rather it is a mystical body of which you, me, the Pope and everyone else are but members, and the head is Christ, our Lord and God. It so happens that the Church is holy and it is a divine society. This does not mean - and has never meant - that the members of the Church are impeccable. Christ spoke to His apostles and said: “have I not chosen you, the twelve? Yet one of you is a demon!” Traitors, evildoers, people who abuse their authority for thirst of wealth, lust, or further “power”, are found in the Church as in every other place. What truly matters is that regardless of their presence, which is the work of an enemy, the Church is holy. Its teachings are holy. Its Sacraments are holy. And it makes people holy.

Let me tell you about the world as it stood before the Church. We had three broad categories of peoples: those who had no specific belief in God or divinities, those who had a strong religiosity based on polytheism, and those who believed in one God. Now among the latter came Christ and the Church was founded, yet even amidst these there was something wrong. Christ would address this inconsistency between their teaching - a holy teaching of a holy people - and their behavior as follows: “be careful in doing what they tell you, but do not imitate their example, for they do not practice what they teach”.

The early Church was not exempt from problems, or from problem-makers. The Church has never been a place of impeccable saints, but a hospital of sinners. A boat in the midst of a storm. Despite this, the Church - after going through a time of very, very harsh persecution and many being slaughtered along with their families for their refusal to deny Christ and worship false divinities - was able to transform society. Consider the Roman empire. Do you know about their morals? The highest peak of civilization was the Roman magnanimitas: the mightiest would be generous with the weak. The Church brought forth a different concept: caritas. In the weak, the poor, the sick, the widow and orphan we see the face of God. That which we do to them, we do to God. Thus it is our duty to not just help them, but in fact, to serve them. As for our enemies, it was our duty to be ready to forgive them inasmuch as we were the first ones in need of forgiveness.

The Church went from an age in which all sorts of horrors and abuses were committed to one in which the dignity of the human being was elevated beyond all that mankind ever knew. The age of concubines and prostitutes was replaced by one in which the dignity of the virgin and of the spouse was sacred: “love your wife as Christ loves the Church”. All sorts of abuses and trades were made with children, too, and it was perfectly legal. That changed. The Church made it such that children were protected.

There was, however, a problem. See, in the days of Christ, and up to about 100 years ago, there was no such thing as democracy. That was nonsense. What we had in place was the power of one. He could be a tribe chief, a warrior ruler, a king, an emperor. These people went around slaughtering and conquering. The Church knew, just as Paul knew, that it was necessary to become omnia omnibus, all things to all men, so that all may be saved. The bishop of Rome, then, successor of the chief of the Apostles Peter, assumed a role of leadership recognized not only by his brothers in the episcopal rank, but also, in time, by the temporal power. Some argue that the Pope was sort of the UN of the day. In fact, as vicar of Christ the Lord, the Pope at some point had the authority to crown and depose kings and emperors. Gifts came, and wealth accumulated. It was bound to happen. Wealth was used for good, though some did abuse their position through history.

Is the Church truly wealthy today? That may be the biggest prejudice the world has against us. The Church is not poor, of course. We would not want our family to be poor. Holy poverty is poverty in spirit, but money is needed to feed our family, feed our kids, take care of our parents. The Church spends today in average over 100 billion dollars in works of mercy all over the world, has over one million consecrated priests, religious, and nuns that go all over the world, amidst the wealthy as well as amidst the poorest, and gives work to about one other million lay faithful who have to take care of their families. The parishes and dioceses work in a very transparent way, publishing their expenses, and all referring back to the Holy See. If a deficit occurs, often parishes will be merged, or even closed. The Holy See itself had a few years ago a massive deficit of $19 million dollars (2011, to be exact) and had to employ part of its patrimony to cover it. Yes, the Church has a patrimony that it can use. The patrimony totals about $770 million according to some experts. A lot of money. But in comparison, the patrimony of Harvard University is about 40 times larger - we talk of one university compared to the Catholic Church.

What about the buildings, the artwork? Will you consider that the Church can sell a basilica or a work of art? Can the Republic of France sell the Monna Lisa, or the US sell the Capitol?
 
Was there corruption? Is there? No doubt. But sins could never be forgiven by giving money to priests. We speak of indulgences, meaning remission of temporal punishment (from Purgatory) in exchange of a sacrifice, an offering made for a good cause. Money was even harder to get yesterday than it is today. Even wealthy people were not born such, they became such through great efforts, and when a war was to be fought, they were the army.

Luther did not form a new Christianity. He rebelled. His rebellion had political reasons, as well. His first letter was not addressed to the poor, but to the princes. He did not hesitate to push the princes to slaughter (try reading his letter called “Against the Murderous, Thieving Hordes of Peasants”, see if you still “respect” him afterwards). He removed books from the Bible that had been used for a thousand years, added words into some, and developed gravely erroneous teachings unheard of, such as “sola fide” and “sola scriptura”, that ultimately led to over forty thousand denominations to come into existence in the next 500 years, while in the previous 1500 years the apostolic Church was respectably intact (exclusion made for the Great Schism with the Orthodox Church, though it is a complex topic, and certainly they did not reason like Luther did, not at all).

What about the scandals? Sure, even one case of abuse is too much for the Church, but there are evildoers everywhere. In fact, it has been shown that the physical sexual abuse of students in public schools is likely more than 100 times the abuse by Catholic priests, yet I don’t see people outraged at the government or at society. Some accuse the Church about covering up things. Sure, there has been such thing. But don’t forget that just because today we have laws and jails, it doesn’t mean we had them yesterday. These monstruosities did not just come into existence today. The Church has been dealing with this for centuries - hundreds of years. It is thanks to the Church that many things are now considered abuses when once they were almost normal. Thus the Church has to adapt to the modern time, collaborate with the legal system. And great attempts are being done. People have been judged and ended in jail. This is also true for corruption. Less than a week ago, an archbishop was arrested by the police of Rome and escorted to the local jail, with no special privilege and no protection given by the Church. Times are changing.
 
Frankly, the OP has a lot of legitimate concerns that are stumbling blocks for a lot of today’s Catholics. Even if he was drunk when he wrote the message, he will be sober when he reads the responses. I hope he’s not put off from staying in the Church because a few Catholics decided not to listen to his concerns.
Maybe some of us would be more likely to listen if he had not been as drunk as he seemed to be. My first reaction was that he needed our prayers and possible more of God and maybe AA and less beer. 🤷 :gopray2 :hug1:
 
I’m sorry you feel this way. Some of the other members have disregarded your argument because you were drinking when posted this, the way you write your post is evident of drunkenness. However, despite being drunk, I imagine your feelings are no different drunk or sober.

Your arguments against church teachings are evident to the fact that there is a lot of misunderstandings towards why the church teaches what it does. I suspect that you have a lot of personal issues that warrant attention before you argue theological doctrines.

The weight of a personality disorder/ mental health issues is a very very heavy cross to carry. I would know a little of this since I bet yours and my life are not all that different. Don’t let that be a stop you from having a fulfilling life.

This world is a seemingly cruel place especially for people with mental health issues. If you can’t make the cut in this fast paced society then they leave us to rot on the side of the road. We are the modern day lepers of today’s society.

I have found great peace in the church. That peace helped me to get myself on a track that eventually lead to a good marriage and great children. I also find great peace in praying the rosary. It gives me a chance to quiet my mind.

Don’t worry yourself with the theological pillars of church teaching right now, open yourself up to the Holy Spirit and let him guide you to true peace. The church has saints of all walks of life even ones with mental health issues. They can help you on your journey. Seek out a devotion to our Holy Mother Mary. She helped to set me right and she will not abandon you if you open your heart to her.

I was raised catholic but I was floored when my atheist shrink told me (without knowing I was catholic) that the Catholic Church is the best Christian church for helping people with these kinds of issues. We have an out for our wrongdoings called confession. There is great grace that comes from it. When I established at a catholic church the priest took over as my psychologist and it was the best thing that ever happened to me. I suspect it can be the same with you.

This does not mean that Christ is going to heal you (to make you “normal”), he did not in a medical sense heal me, but He will help you to carry this heavy burden. Then we both can lead a good example to society of Jesus’ love for us, even though we are sick and tormented we are still witness to the fact the Christ loves each and every one of us even if society doesn’t.

Don’t give up brother, Christ never said it was going to be easy.
 
Yes, we can blame people taking their own life. Nobody takes it away from fun, but from illness. Suicide is the culmination of a process that makes our mind ill, very ill. So it is wrong. Very wrong. Do we blame people? Never. We blame the sin. Your statement on the jews comes out very, very selfish. I wish you had spoken to some concentration camp survivors. They had no reason to keep moving forward, no reason to embrace life. Yet they did. And many today live with very, very difficult situations, and yet they embrace the God-given gift of life no matter what. To take our life is an act of cowardice, a running away from problems. Running away is what children do, not what adults do, because it is irresponsible.

You say something prevents you from marriage. Do you think your illness allows you to hurt others? Because wanting sex is no excuse for anything. We all want stuff in life. In fact, some people want things they cannot have, others want things they should not have. Sex is something great, but sex with strangers is no good. It is bad for you - for your psychological and emotional health, and despite usage of condoms, it can be even for your physical health - and it is bad for the woman whose body you are using to please your fancies and your desire to possess and control, because she is not living a pleasant life (surely you would do all you can to prevent your daughter from ending there) and because she may belong to a system of sexual exploitation in which girls are often kidnapped very young, raped, and then forced into prostitution. And the system is kept running because there are customers willing to pay, no matter what. Because they want to have sex.

The issue is not condoms, the issue is life. We have genitals in a certain way because they come together for procreation. Pleasure is there in order to make the union between a husband and a wife more tight and their coming together pleasant. When we transform this into something selfish, where we become one another’s sex tool, we are committing the worst sin we can: we are committing a sin of sacrilege against the single most sacred temple of God, the human body. We take something pure and transforming into something that belongs to the realm of animals. Sex for the sake of it, with whoever we can manage to find, whenever we feel like it. Do you think this is what Christ wants us to do?

Abortion of raped women, that ridiculous argument. Ever since abortion is legal in this country, there are about 1.2 million abortions performed every year. Do you know how many are abortions after a pregnancy resulting from rape? About 1%. The majority of the rest are performed by unmarried women or girls, and the pregnancy was the result of pre-marital sex - and guess what, often times protection was used, and it did not prevent pregnancy.

Again you speak selfishly. Have you ever spoken to the mother of a child conceived by rape? To one such child? Do it. Or find their testimonies online. Tell me if we don’t know *** or if it is you who don’t know *** and should be ashamed.

If you still have sex with prostitutes, or in any manner close to conception, you are not a heretic, but a sinner. Like me. Like everyone else. You won’t be special. You won’t get the rebel award. As for excommunication, that means absolutely nothing: it just means you are not supposed to receive Communion until you repent of your mistakes. I would be more concerned about the death of my soul than about whatever penance I may receive on earth. Because there can be no doubt: if we reject Christ and His teachings, we reject God, we reject life, we reject love. And that’s not a place where you’d ever want to be.

The Church has helped many to get out of such a place. They live great lives. The Church judges nobody and is ready to forgive everyone. But people have to understand that some things are wrong, they hurt people, and they cannot be tolerated. We are all welcome and nobody is expected to be a saint, for the Church is a gathering of sinners who realize that they are made for more, that God wants more of them and wants to give them more.

Instead of falling deeper down such a sad spiral, start climbing back. Talk to a priest, get involved in community life. Step into the light, feel the love of the Church and of its members. Your life can change, as mine and that of many of my friends and that of countless other peoples through the ages have. The choice is yours.

May Christ bless you now and forever.
 
A disclaimer I have had quite a lot of beers and am rather drunkish, though let that not withold you from reading this. Unless your a radical fundamentalist your going to hate me but I do hate fundamentalism with a passion! So we would have to hate each other. let’s start since even if I’m drunk heavily (Yes I’m an beginning alcoholic) I am not addicted but I need it to get trough my life. But my intellect is 100% alright so I am not going to say weird things.
ok really? that was weird right there.

i actually read it. go back to your doctor and get some help. i am sorry.
 
Dear Wulfgar, thanks and I might check it out! If I can claim a copy somewhere.

Dear Polytropos,

I am fully aware it’s reasonable but I think they should leave the gold rings and go back to being humble. Martin Luther surely held that as a mistake, but I can understand his frustration and can understand why he wanted to form something else.

I have told them but medical professionals don’t do much for you, I am on a waiting list for therapy I am already waiting two months, and after calling them multiple times they told me they cannot place me for now and they wouldn’t want to give a date on which they could place me. In the meantime my life look gloom and I don’t think I want to live very long. I told myself to at least make it to 24 before suiciding but I don’t think I will last that long. Either alcohol or suicide will kill me.

Well medical staff says that condoms when not being ripped and aplied the right way, hiv will be prevented! However even in areas where condoms are used hiv might infect others trough blood or other things. Also you can use a condom but when you start licking parts or doing other things you can indeed get hiv. And well even with chastity you could someday have the blood of hiv patient on you and get it. Just my two cents.
Homosexuality actually exists in animals also. So how come animals can do it and humans can’t? This is something I wondered a lot.

Not for fun? Well you might be right there are a lot of cases where people are stupid party hard make a kid and then abort it. But then again if such a person had the child would she be a good mom? I do not think so. My mom and dad kept me even though I was an accident or well not planned… And I can tell you I’d rather not have lived. Sometimes I think most catholics and then also the ones that just said ‘we do not read this topic’ have been grown up in a protected envirement? I am a contempary humanist because of my past. As for consequence-free sex we got condoms for that. Which are then not allowed to use… So it’s kind of a though spot.

I don’t know if a girl that’s 16 gets raped wants to labor and give life to a child to give it away. I think when the child is born it gives a lot more emotional impact then to ‘take it away’ when it is not much. I do not say it’s not life but at least when the belly hasn’t grown and such you do not really know any better. It might be eaisier. And yes an abortion might be regret later. But it’s a choice people make and I do not feel like I should judge. I myself will never put any childeren on the world becaue I don’t believe in this world.

Well if the church did really teach that why did they employ crusades? Surely a crusade was intentional unustified killing, or was it justified because they where muslims? You see this is where I have a problem with… But even if you are killing intentional a feutus I think we are not the ones to judge, not we, not the church but Jesus he should judge about it! And I wish the church would also leave more judging to God/Jesus

And I see why we think different you embrace life and are glad with it, while I feel the opposite which is fair enough and makes me respect and understand your point of view.
And yes a human must be ensouled at some point, but when it is not conscience is it really murder? When the act of sex has been done you could say it’s ensouled but let’s say I do not want to have childeren. While I could make some, am I then not a murderer also? Of course I havn’t done abortion or used a condom. But I have not made a child which I could have done. I had the potential but did not do it. So that would make me a murderer. Because I could do it and have the potential but I don’t. At least if you understand what I mean? Sadly my English language is not good enought to explain it fully. But I think you get the gist.

Well that’s why I leave things to Jesus I want to rely on him and not on the fellow believers… We can of course help each other at times, but when we ask for it. I am the kind of person that would not want any help. Or that wold just want to do his own thing even if it is wrong I wanna be the captain of my own ship, and even if that means I end up sailing myself towards the cliffs and dieing I still would be happy like that.
I see so they do forgive it that’s a good thing I think.

Well you have shown kindness in answering me. And I will remember that. I just have a lot of things I cannot really understand or agree with church based. And I wanted to use this topic to get it clear or try to understand a bit at least.

I must say I do feel like my favourite author and he said to a priest once:

‘‘I shall not, as far as I am concerned, try to pass myself off as a Christian in your presence. I share with you the same revulsion from evil. But I do not share your hope, and I continue to struggle against this universe in which children suffer and die.’’

I feel hopeless just like that author.
 
Was there corruption? Is there? .
Hello R_C
I would like to relax but I have met to many fundamentalist, a really bad one at that.
I know addictions are bad, but it keeps me kicking. I mean without alcohol I don’t feel well, I get sad and stuff. Alcohol gives me the strength to keep going on. And I know that is bad but the therapy I am enlisted for cannot take me in.

Though if we are all connected trough each other, why do people seems so uptight and unfriendly towards each other? I have seen a catholic protesting at a store and scaring little childeren saying it’s bad to shop at sunday. I do respect the sunday laws, but what if someone gets sick, what if we need a doctor on sunday? Luckily Jesus knew all about this and did heal on sunday. So I am happy with that. Though I wonder what that man’s problem was maybe he was a protestant I do not know. But I would like it if we got allong nicer. But like in a topic like this, I get reactions that do not take me serious, or I get reactions like search help get a doctor. I even got acused of having heretic thoughts because I thought a bit different. I don’t like that. The catholic persons I like are those that do not judge. But where I live there’s almost no catholics here. Not even a youthgroup so I am in a group with older people.

Yes I am also heavy against the roman empire rule. Watching man fight in a arena, people that do this can never be good. But I do not think the church really helped the weak and was generous, in a matter of fact you had the time in which you had to pay for being absolved for sins. I do not know an awful lot about this but I wonder how did they do this with the poor that had no money? I would like to see a more humble church.

And yes it’s the last thing I have a problem with the pope being a sort UN of the day. It is then also no surprise that his was an time of anti-popes. I always have to chuckle at the word anti-pope. It kinda would explain that religion in that time was a sort of tool, and a anti-pope was just a tool in the shed you could use. Else there would be no need for an anti-pope.

And I see the wealth may then not be that big. That does clarify things for me thanks. and well I guess you cannot really sell a basilisc so I can understand it somehow. As I with wealth was also really pointing at the earlier times.

I see the undulgences though where only for the rich and what of the poor?
I see so Luther actually is the only succesful anti-pope? Or well from what you write I could see him as a anti-pope.

I see the scandals are then taking care off. Though I am sometimes annoyed at people that take the churchs word for truth even when there has been proven that the church is not perfect. Would it be wrong to think yourself first and then see what the church has to say, and ponder it yourself? I do this a lot and this is seen as heresy a lot on this forum which I do not understand.
 
Dear Rc part two.

How can you blame someone taking his own life, yes it leaves his loved ones sad and bewildered. And surely a lot of songs that go about a lost friend/family member are really sad. I am listning one none stop though. I think some people get pushed to suicide, and do not even think of they’re family and loved ones. To be honest your bound to think that they never helped you the way you wanted to anyway. A selfish act but then again suicide means denying yourself and everything along with it. Well I know many Jewish people pulled trough and surived. But I know for a fact that many tried to escape and some even suicided. I have read a book where a jewish family send they’re son to the states but when they went to sleep the parents, the dad started up the gas in the kitchen and they died in they’re sleeps. I have read many things like this. Suicide is not so much running away but it is something you have to go trough. Surely we do not know how it is to be a poor African and in the same way no one knows what suicide really is, it is hell on earth. To do suicide, it’s not a funny nor a trival matter.

My personality disorder makes my abilities to socialize and be with someone impossible. Or well near possible it’s to hard. And yes I sometimes want sex. But I can’t really get me a wife I am to messed up for that, and would end up hurting her. It’s not easy to know your never going to get a wife and never will know what a girlfriend really is. But I accepted it. I would never rape or do anything of that. But there’s a lot of women that feel like me and just want to do it for a night and leave of. And there’s prostitues. You see when both parties want it? How can it be bad. I will always respect the other and the other will respect me and we will do what we both want. That it is not without faults I agree. It has a very large recoil damage on your psychological being I do not deny that. But for people like me that physchological recoil does not matter anymore. We can’t sink lower.

I don’t know if Christ wants us to do that I would say no and I can agree with you on that. But what for people like me that have such a disorder that a wife or girlfriend is really hard to get? I don’t want to be celibate all my life…

I think protection is used either wrongly, or well. I do agree abortion is being abused a lot. A lot of kids go out party hard take some pills do it yolo style or what is it called by the youths? And end up with a kid. Though such a person would never be a good parent. And you don’t want to be born in a family that has no money dosen’t give a **** about you and all that stuff. Tupac made a really nice song about it called Brenda got a baby. The gist of it is everyone leaves Brenda but Brenda is keeping the baby but to finance it all she becomes a prostitute and sells her body. This is also not what we want…

I do know my stuff. And I do know people make a choice and I will never judge that choice. And I think others that do should be ashamed. For I judge not over it. But my anger in that is basicly because I have seen a very scary old catholic woman going to someone that did abortion and called her a murderer. Not a nice thing to see at a family party somewhere. So maybe I overdid it a bit but it’s due the anger I have had of that moment.

I never felt love. I tried to go to Jesus and get the love but didn;'t get it and now I am makign this topic and not liking the church anymore. At first I did not even care about the churchs teachings but not having received Jesus love, maybe I’m in an act of rebellion. Though I think I am not the only one that finds obstacles like these in church.

Here the catholic faith is not that big. Church is empty so there’s no community life to get involved in to be honest.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top