Thoughts on 53% Divorce Rate?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Seagull
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
The Church has broadened it’s understanding of what constitutes marriage. Before, under the old Code of Canon law consent involved a contract to “consent to sexual intercourse.” If that never happened after marriage, which was rare, annulment was granted. Under the new Cod
I honestly believe that if King Henry VIII applied for an annulment today, it would be granted.

Honestly, I feel like annulments today are simply a Catholic loophole for divorce. How can you justify saying a married couple of 30 years with 7 children were never really married all that time? It’s absurd.

I’d rather if we were honest with ourselves and adopt the Eastern Orthodox custom of allowing remarriage after divorce, after a period of penance, and the marriage having a penitential instead of celebratory character.

The whole world knows Catholic annulment = Catholic divorce. It’s time we look at ourselves and admit the truth, and stop using silly loopholes which abide by the letter of the law yet totally violate the spirit of the law. It makes us look like legalistic hypocrites.
 
Last edited:
I honestly believe that if King Henry VIII applied for an annulment today, it would be granted.
It would be very likely if it could be proven his understanding of what he was was consenting to was flawed in some way.
How can you justify saying a married couple of 30 years with 7 children were never really married all that time? It’s absurd.
Is a cohabiting couple who have been together that many years with 7 seven children married? It’s not the evidence of how the marriage or life together was lived after the ceremony that’s in question. That’s why if a spouse cheats years into the marriage or develops a mental illness in which they become abusive, it’s not grounds for annulment. It’s about “what did the couple understand or not understand they were consenting to at the time of the ceremony” which is under investigation. If they weren’t able to give valid consent, then the marriage isn’t a valid one. If, for example, a wife finds out her husband had a woman on the side before marriage and kept at it a few years after, even if later he gave it up and stayed faithful and the wife finds out 30 years later, the marriage can be annulled because he obviously didn’t give valid consent to be faithful to her only or show proper judgement that marriage is for life by risking it right from the start. It’s the intention of the spouses when they exchanged vows that determines the marriage’s validity, not how they lived afterwards.

I don’t think the number of annulments is surprising at all given the secular culture’s strong messaging that if something is difficult or requires too much sacrifice, you have the right to be free. I think many people who marry in the Church have this understanding and perhaps are only doing a Church wedding because of family pressure or tradition rather being formed correctly in the understanding of what it means to consent to a partnership of the whole life.

When you look at the other thread that is discussing why so many Catholics fall away from the Church due to poor formation and poor example in their own families and culture, it’s not surprising at all that many marriages that have taken place over the last 50 years lacked valid consent. I think the number of annulments is sad but not because I think they are granted willy-nilly but because the Church, family and the culture has done such a poor job of educating and supporting what a valid marriage looks like and means.
 
I still feel the way I expressed…

I think annulments are way over used and have become a way for Catholics to legitimize divorce.

I think we’d be better off and be more honest with ourselves if we adopted the Eastern Orthodox custom of allowing remarriage in certain cases after a period of penance.
 
I think Pope Francis has a good understanding of the lunacy of the way the Church is currently doing things…

Which is part of the reason why I believe he revised the annulment process and promulgated Amoris Laetitia at pretty much the same time.
 
Yes. I’m watching with interest how things develop along these lines while reading positions from those who support and those who oppose. I’m on the fence about it all personally so I’ll trust the Holy Spirit to lead the Church the right way.
 
Last edited:
I’m on the fence about it all personally so I’ll trust the Holy Spirit to lead the Church the right way.
I’m in the same position.

Whether the Church stays the same or has a change in discipline, either way I’ll trust the Holy Spirit is guiding her.

I certainly won’t be crusading because remarried people can’t receive Communion…

And neither will I be proclaiming “all is lost! The end is nigh!” If they can receive Communion.
 
The Church has broadened it’s understanding of what constitutes marriage. Before, under the old Code of Canon law consent involved a contract to “consent to sexual intercourse.” If that never happened after marriage, which was rare, annulment was granted. Under the new Code, marriage is seen as a covenant rather than a contract and consent is understood as both partners having full understanding that marriage is both for the procreation of children and a partnership of their whole life. Things like mental capacity to consent, ability to judge matrimonial rights and obligations, not being under the influence of drugs or alcohol at the time, etc are all considered now as part of consent.
Well, the old Code said a lot more than that about what constituted marriage. What could be called the immediate object of marital consent, it is true, was said to be the giving/accepting the perpetual and exclusive “right to the body” for those acts which are ordered to the generation of offspring (old code, c. 1081). Nevertheless, since it is an act of consent which makes marriage (and this was stated in the old code and the new one), “mental capacity” for marriage has always been required.

That being said, the notion of an “incapacity to consent” (a la canon 1095 in the 1983 Code) is a lot more frequently used nowadays than it was before 1983.

Dan
 
I honestly believe that if King Henry VIII applied for an annulment today, it would be granted.
Not if he used the same argument that he actually used to attempt to justify his annulment. His argument was wrong then and wrong today.
 
How can you justify saying a married couple of 30 years with 7 children were never really married all that time?
Theoretically, I can imagine a justification. Practically, I don’t think I have ever seen such a case and concluded that I thought it was an invalid marriage.

Dan
 
Last edited:
using silly loopholes which abide by the letter of the law yet totally violate the spirit of the law.
Speaking personally, when I see an actual marriage case decided “in the affirmative” (i.e., the marriage is declared invalid), but I would never have come to that conclusion, I don’t consider the decision to be in accord with either the letter or the spirit of the law.

Dan
 
Speaking personally, when I see an actual marriage case decided “in the affirmative” (i.e., the marriage is declared invalid), but I would never have come to that conclusion, I don’t consider the decision to be in accord with either the letter or the spirit of the law.
Most of us don’t ever get to ask a canon lawyer their opinion about this so now is our chance. Although you have seen decisions that you wouldn’t agree with, in your opinion, is that happening way too much in that most annulments are being handed out like candy with questionable reasons for those decisions?
 
I think annulments are way over used and have become a way for Catholics to legitimize divorce.

I think we’d be better off and be more honest with ourselves if we adopted the Eastern Orthodox custom of allowing remarriage in certain cases after a period of penance.
Concerning the first statement, I understand your point of view. I wouldn’t say there is an over use of the nullity process, though, but a misuse of it by those who are charged with directing it. Concerning the second, I don’t think we’d be better off. My preference would be for a more faithful, honest and realistic application of Catholic theology and law, not a Mosaic-style mitigation of both.

Dan
 
Most of us don’t ever get to ask a canon lawyer their opinion about this so now is our chance. Although you have seen decisions that you wouldn’t agree with, in your opinion, is that happening way too much in that most annulments are being handed out like candy with questionable reasons for those decisions?
I’d not use the “handed out like candy” phrase but, yes, when I disagree with a decision I might think the rationale is woefully insufficient. At the same time, there are times when I may have come to a different conclusion but can at least say “ok, I can see why the Judge(s) came to this decision.” Does this happen “way too much”? With certain Judges, yes, I would say it does. But, as Jeffrey Lebowski would say “yeah, well, that’s just … like … your opinion, man.” It’s just that, my opinion. It’s an educated one … but I’m not the smartest canon lawyer around.

Dan
 
I haven’t read all of the posts, but I don’t think it’s fair to blame one sex over the other or one single cause. First consider that most of society doesn’t share the Catholic view on marriage. Then combine that with all of the challenges that modern marriage face - high expectations (e.g. materialism, work-life balance, etc.), me-first culture, ubiquitous access to porn, etc. It’s a complicated issue with no one single factor.
 
Honestly, I feel like annulments today are simply a Catholic loophole for divorce. …

I’d rather if we were honest with ourselves and adopt the Eastern Orthodox custom of allowing remarriage after divorce, after a period of penance, and the marriage having a penitential instead of celebratory character.
… It’s time we look at ourselves and admit the truth, and stop using silly loopholes which abide by the letter of the law yet totally violate the spirit of the law. It makes us look like legalistic hypocrites.
I think annulments are way over used and have become a way for Catholics to legitimize divorce.
I think you are making some good points here. I wonder if it is possible for any marriage to be annulled because of some defect or another that supposedly occurred long ago. Of course, this supposed defect is not brought up until one or both of the spouses wants out of the marriage.
 
Thank you. Your opinion is still a good one to hear because you are a lot more “in the know” than the rest of us.
 
I wonder if it is possible for any marriage to be annulled because of some defect or another that supposedly occurred long ago. Of course, this supposed defect is not brought up until one or both of the spouses wants out of the marriage.
“Some defect or another” might or might not be such that it made a person’s marital consent insufficient to form a marriage. The defect cannot only “supposedly” be present but has to be proven. When it comes to light (brought up) doesn’t matter, as long as it actually did exist and make the consent absent/defective at the time of the wedding.

Dan
 
In the case of my marriage, my husband was gay. He knew he was gay. He had a male lover before we were married whom he kept as a lover after we were married. He kept it secret from me. I didn’t know. He needed to marry me because he was in danger of losing his military career because it was “don’t ask, don’t tell.” So he used me as a beard and then left me as soon as they dropped “don’t ask, don’t tell” and he could be openly gay and in the military (and he is). And he comes across as a manly, military man (not the stereotype of a gay man you see in the media). Plus, it was his plan all along to leave me as soon as he retired (it’s just that being able to come out and stay in the military happened before he retired). He basically used me for extra military benefits and as a cover.

I never knew and I certainly never would have married him had I known. I only learned he planned to leave me after he left too.

So that’s one marriage that had a defect long ago, that I didn’t even know about until he left. He certainly knew, but I didn’t.

That’s why my marriage was annulled.

Ending the marriage was his choice. He left. The divorce was my choice, I filed (I needed to to protect myself legally and financially). And I went though the annulment process to find peace. It’s took more than a year, I kept having to be questioned and interviewed, and it wasn’t easy. But it had a sort of healing effect on my soul in a way that I can’t explain. Like I said earlier, I didn’t to it to remarry and I don’t plan on ever marrying again. I am not saying I am not open to marriage again, but I just don’t see it happening and it’s not a “goal” of mine if you will.

Edited to add: We were married 12 years and had a child too. After a year of marriage, I knew things were wrong, but I tried my best to make it work because “you don’t get divorced.”
 
Last edited:
When it comes to light (brought up) doesn’t matter, as long as it actually did exist and make the consent absent/defective at the time of the wedding.
And if it is never brought up? Why is it being brought up except that the couple wants to divorce and have the right to remarry in the Catholic Church? Speaking about a case of a couple who are married ten years and have children, but now want to divorce, Cardinal Kasper says: “This marriage was a reality, and to say it was canonically null and void does not make sense to me. This is an abstract canonical construction. It’s divorce in a Catholic way, in a dishonest way.”
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top