Unfortunately one of the reasons many evangelicals consider Catholics to be uninformed about the Gospel is that many people publicly identify themselves as Catholics who do not practice or have good understanding of their faith. My husband’s family is Italian Anerican and all are quick to identify themselves as Catholic, have their kids baptized, etc. but almost none of them have any understanding of their Faith and most of them only go to Church for baptisms, weddings, etc. I doubt any of them could name the apostles, tell you what John 3:16 says, tell you what books are in the old vs. New Testament, etc. Many of them are pro-choice. Let’s face it, the kind of knowledgeable, committed Catholics you find on CAF arent always the kind of Catholics you encounter in real life. So if you’ve mostly met Nancy Pelosi type Catholics or just the run of the mill poorly catechized type like many of my relatives, who couldn’t defend their beliefs if their life depended on it, is it hard to think you would believe that Catholics aren’t “saved” and haven’t really been exposed to the Gospel?