To end or not to end a relationship

  • Thread starter Thread starter runwaymodel
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Regarding the last of the above, men who have received an ubpringing which put emphasis on chivalry are likely to show much more esteem and deference than a modern woman is prepared to process. But this is similar to respecting e.g. an office holder (due to his office) even though he’s a fallible sinner like you are. The reverence and even deference that a woman will experience from a man in such a situation shouldn’t make her feel like she’s in a superior-subordinate type of dynamic. Not with a boyfriend, not with a friend, not with a stranger. That e.g. your every morally acceptable request would be complied with (or even the man would rush to comply with it) doesn’t mean that you could get away with an immoral request or even a dubious one, or an outright command if you tried to issue it. This kind of behaviour on the part of the man may seem, on the face, to invite a woman to behave like a spoiled brat, and there is such a risk, but a more proper reaction would be generosity, reciprocal kindness, something, let’s say, comparable to two friendly mediaeval lords going out of their skins to to host each other stately, in their respective turns. 😉 In other words: he pays for you? Don’t tell him not to, just pay for him some other day. Holds the door? Great, thank him and do the same for him when he seems to need it. Did he get up and walk around the table to pour your wine or coffee or tea? Nothing prevents you from doing the same for him (over his objections). Does he help you with your coat? Just accept it and thank him, there can be humility in that (it may be more humble to accept something embarrassing than to refuse it flat out; this is somewhat similar to a mediaeval king or bishop wearing a hear shirt under his rich robes). And so on and so forth. The same applies to less etiquettal situations that don’t fall under a manners cliché.

To sum up the previous two paragraphs (rather lengthy, I’m sorry for this), basically making him “your equal” for the purposes of manners, etiquette, kindness and so on may require you to start going out of your way for him rather than demanding him to stop doing that for you. This too would put you on a more equal footing. There’s a lot a woman can do in this regard but doesn’t have to and that’s where the beauty of it lies.

And don’t feel superior to him. That one is up to you. Rather recognise his kindness, humility, lack of pride, contentedness with where he is in life, this kind of thing. Unless he actually does cross the line into being a lap dog but that doesn’t seem likely to me from your descriptions of him as a man who hardly seems to be spineless. Now if he really treated you literally like his boss, that would be a different cup of tea. If that were true, you’d need to think long and hard before committing, and the outcome would likely be in the negative.

Finally, a man may be intimidated by a beautiful woman. It is a natural reflex to want to serve something which or someone who is beautiful, after all, God is the most beautiful and that is where beauty relates, or should do. I’ve occasionally been made speechless… I, the young lawyer wannabe who talked back to judges, scolded the Attorney General, made the court laugh at a law professor and the client and work up another veteran counsel, and more, I just couldn’t find enough energy to sustain a normal conversation due to being so moved by a woman who was so much of what I looked for, to the point I couldn’t believe it was happening (despite all the negatives that I actually saw clearly, and actually did address). She made the mistake of judging me to be weak and playable (she was very wrong about that one)… things weren’t pretty afterwards, with lots of suffering for both parties as I believe. This is probably part of the male side of falling in love. You, the big guy, are suddenly left speechless by a girl. I guess that’s how it works. (Whereafter you want to protect her and you’re inclined to see her as a better person than you are, since you’re big, ugly and hairy and, well, male, so not supposed to be pretty etc.)
Wow, there was so much about this post that hit home and made sense. Now I am just confused again–emotionally. Maybe I am just overthinking everything. Because yes, he is quite needy and affectionate but definitely not spineless (I’ve seen how he talks to business clients!). No, he is quite confident and secure in every other aspect of his life except when it comes to me.

Everything you said about opening doors, taking my coat, pouring the wine made me laugh because he completely goes out of his way to do all that, and yes, sometimes it bugs me because to me its like “I can put on my own coat”, yet when I think about it, why am I complaining about that? I guess the honeymoon phase was over and I am getting very nit-picky over every little detail. Girls always want a gentleman and when we get one its like we don’t appreciate it. Same goes for the women who want a nice guy, get one and then let him go.

I would never feel superior to him. I would never feel superior to anyone. That is beyond arrogant and a sin I am sure! :o
Maybe the intimidating thing has something to do with it. I can defintiely see how he would feel that way the first few months, but we’ve been together long enough for me to think that he would be comfortable with me.

Thank you so much, chevalier. Your posts always resognate with me. I very much appreciate all the advice here.
 
Wow, there was so much about this post that hit home and made sense. Now I am just confused again–emotionally. Maybe I am just overthinking everything. Because yes, he is quite needy and affectionate but definitely not spineless (I’ve seen how he talks to business clients!). No, he is quite confident and secure in every other aspect of his life except when it comes to me.
There is nothing more common than having one attitude when it comes to confrontations in business or athletics and another when it comes to romance or family. For instance, you cannot see a man in a boardroom and extrapolate that to how he’s going to act when his parents try to run his life. They are two totally separate spheres, and people will often have different confidence levels and boundaries in their various separate spheres.

There is also nothing more common than going through some angst when it seems a relationship is not working very well. That is OK. Give yourself time, do not beat yourself up about it. Be kind, but be willing to take the time you need to decide.
 
Many times it seems that it was far smarter for one’s family to choose a spouse. You learned to love and did not let all these what ifs muddle the waters.
 
Wow, there was so much about this post that hit home and made sense. Now I am just confused again–emotionally. Maybe I am just overthinking everything. Because yes, he is quite needy and affectionate but definitely not spineless (I’ve seen how he talks to business clients!). No, he is quite confident and secure in every other aspect of his life except when it comes to me.
Touché. 😉

(While at it please note that confidence with women comes from experience and experience comes with the obvious and is typically acquired in the obvious way.)
Everything you said about opening doors, taking my coat, pouring the wine made me laugh because he completely goes out of his way to do all that, and yes, sometimes it bugs me because to me its like “I can put on my own coat”, yet when I think about it, why am I complaining about that? I guess the honeymoon phase was over and I am getting very nit-picky over every little detail. Girls always want a gentleman and when we get one its like we don’t appreciate it. Same goes for the women who want a nice guy, get one and then let him go.
Exactly. 😉 I am honestly inclined to see that as a case of not knowing what one wants. Either that or having some kind of contradictory needs. Not like men are incapable of having such (e.g. wanting both a lady and a beer pal but feeling bad about the one when the other seems to be more desired at the moment). There’s no reason for nitpicking here because he does nothing wrong. 😉 As I said, take up the challenge and try to do chivalrous things for him in turn. Ladies can be chivalrous too. 😉
I would never feel superior to him. I would never feel superior to anyone. That is beyond arrogant and a sin I am sure! :o
Yup, but from your earlier complaints it would seem that his behaviour is clearly pushing you in that direction. So, in this context, just remember what you said now, i.e. that you’d never feel superior to anyone. So just don’t, and problem over. 😉 Unless you’re dealing with a person who behaves pathologically (i.e. like a doormat) in which case you need to take stronger measures.
Maybe the intimidating thing has something to do with it. I can defintiely see how he would feel that way the first few months, but we’ve been together long enough for me to think that he would be comfortable with me.
This is a far guess but with all your independence you may be distanced and that’s something to slow down the normal gradual dissipation of intimidation due to increasing familiarity. It is also possible that he’s more taken with you than has ever been with any other woman, which may simply be due to the fact that you’re more to his liking than anybody has ever been. That was the case with the last woman I told you that I was similarly intimidated around. This doesn’t mean I’d never come around. Not sure why it’s taking your guy so long, though. You don’t sound like a person with anger issues, I presume you’ve never hung up on the phone or burst out of the room due to hearing something you don’t like? That’s the typical behaviour by a girlfriend that would make me hesitant to bring up potentially negative subjects, from my experience. I’m sure you already understand this but just to make sure: I’m no way implying anything, just trying to cross out any typical explanations (I occasionally interrupt unwelcome conversations myself anyway, so I wouldn’t look down on you for that).

Anyway, please understand that he may be a case of oldschool gentleman, who’s not only well-mannered but conditioned in such a way that he’s practically physically incapable of being overly direct or overtly unpleasant with a woman. I had to overcome a lot of inhibitions myself to arrive at the stage where I’m ready to tell a woman I don’t like something she says or does and I’m still not on a firm ground there. If you can recall him ever firmly making a stand when you were clearly in the wrong (logically but especially morally) unlike the typical situation of a mere difference of subjective opinion, then you’d have your answer there.

Re: money, status etc.: that stuff comes and goes overnight sometimes. Joseph was prince if not actual de iure king of Israel and still worked hard with his hands as a carpenter as did Our Lord up to age 30. Some saints who were secular kings or dukes practiced extreme forms of mortification. There are also plenty of people who don’t have that much of money or status but seem happy anyway. As you correctly point out, money or status is not the end of the story. It is also not guaranteed to be permanent or bring any happiness or prevent happiness when it’s not there.
 
I can only speak from my own experience but I love being married to my DH and love growing up with him and so much look forward to grow old with him. There was no question in my mind - I have never second guessed or had a bad feeling in my stomach. Don’t ignore your intuition. In my marriage there is a year or two year (depending on what month it is) gap between us and it is perfect for me. We have spent well over a decade together already; I cannot imagine missing out on all those years together and him being decades older than me and at a different stage in life for the rest of life. For whatever it is worth money didn’t even factor into my decision and honestly sometimes money costs too much. You can always make more money or find money somehow by being dedicated to doing so, but real deep love where there are no questions is something that you cannot buy. It is also something that feels much better than anything money can buy and is more meaningful on a deeper level.
 
Because I choose to end relationships in the past does not make me a heart breaker…

Of course I realize men don’t grow on trees. But I cannot visualize spending the rest of my life with him anymore. Sometimes I think if I try really hard and we work on things that maybe it can change, but there’s this weird feeling in the pit of my stomach that doesn’t think so.
Oh, goodness, no it does not make you a heartbreaker because you are willing to break off relationships once you realize a marriage would not be appropriate. Heaven forbid!

If you ever have “a weird feeling in the pit of your stomach,” take some time off from this relationship. If doing so makes you feel as if a steel band encircling your chest has been removed, do not go back. He may be the best man on the planet without being the man you ought to marry. God may have someone more flawed in mind for you!
 
Oh, goodness, no it does not make you a heartbreaker because you are willing to break off relationships once you realize a marriage would not be appropriate. Heaven forbid!

If you ever have “a weird feeling in the pit of your stomach,” take some time off from this relationship. If doing so makes you feel as if a steel band encircling your chest has been removed, do not go back. He may be the best man on the planet without being the man you ought to marry. God may have someone more flawed in mind for you!
How can something as simple as this, make the most logical sense? 👍
 
OP, it kind of seems you came here to get validation that it’s OK to break up with him. You really don’t have to get our permission. I think you know in your heart of hearts that it’s time to let go. If he’s as good of a man as you describe him then he will find someone else who is on the same page as he is.

After more than a year of dating you two should be on the verge of engagement (in my opinion), not having tons of nagging doubts. It’s not fair when one person’s heart is all the way in it and the other person’s is not. At the very least you need to have a totally open discussion with him about all the doubts you’re having and why. It seems like a make it or break it point for the relationship.
 
You have your answer. Don’t marry someone or stay with someone based on you having to try really hard to work on things so they can change.
You must have missed my earlier response to your “gut feeling.”
 
How can something as simple as this, make the most logical sense? 👍
Still, I understand why she’s finding this so hard. If you wake up and realize that your boyfriend is a rude, self-satisfied dimwit or a cad or that he’s been using you or deceiving you, that is one thing. You dust off your dignity and you leave, and good riddance to him. If the fellow is the exceptional kind of guy that you have dreamed of and may never have the chance to marry otherwise, though, if he is someone you feel tremendous affection and respect for, that is another kettle of fish. That makes it really hard to say, “You’re definitely someone’s Mr. Right, but you’re also definitely not my Mr. Right”, and not just a little bit scary.

Having said that, once honest communication has been tried and found wanting, there is not much else to do. That band of stainless steel is highly unlikely to go away by the mere passage of time. You can’t expect there to be some magic that takes your anxiety away. That usually doesn’t happen. If anything, the weight and the tightness will only grow as time goes by. You profit no one by signing on to live out the plot of a tragic Victorian novel because you think highly of someone on paper. He doesn’t have to be perfect, but he does have to be someone you can commit to without reservation.
 
OP, it kind of seems you came here to get validation that it’s OK to break up with him. You really don’t have to get our permission. I think you know in your heart of hearts that it’s time to let go. If he’s as good of a man as you describe him then he will find someone else who is on the same page as he is.

After more than a year of dating you two should be on the verge of engagement (in my opinion), not having tons of nagging doubts. It’s not fair when one person’s heart is all the way in it and the other person’s is not. At the very least you need to have a totally open discussion with him about all the doubts you’re having and why. It seems like a make it or break it point for the relationship.
Excellent advice!! Discussion time! A real deep discussion to clarify your next moves is required.
 
I too was handsome, buff, charming, athletic, English accent, a lawyer when I was young. Women (and men:o) would pursue me.

It sickened me, and I left my life and joined a religious order for 6 years. Then I worked in prison ministry and then education. I finally found a woman with the same morals, goals and ideals as me (as well as being 5’10 and blonde!) We married. She is my life companion.

You will know when you meet that person.

I was poor, an had thrown away my career when I met my wife. We have struggled, have a child with serious disabilities, but we have a family - the most wonderful thing in the world. We have 3 kids and are trying for one more. My daughter is gorgeous, intelligent, gifted and most importantly caring and prayerful. My 6 year old is the best little boy in the world. My son with down syndrome continues to be a gift and a source of grace.

What a beautiful story!
 
Simple: year and half into dating; fish or cut bait, get married or break it off.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top