To Kill A Mockingbird by Harper Lee

  • Thread starter Thread starter empther
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
E

empther

Guest
In post 4 of the thread “Life of Pi” pro-atheism? what do you think?

CatherineOH wrote:
It is a worse book than To Kill a Mocking Bird
I think To Kill a Mockingbird is a great book, good enough for its own thread.

I’ll give others a chance to start it off. 😃
 
In post 4 of the thread “Life of Pi” pro-atheism? what do you think?

CatherineOH wrote:

I think To Kill a Mockingbird is a great book, good enough for its own thread.

I’ll give others a chance to start it off. 😃
My favorite all-time book. I must have read it 100 times. Went through many copies over the years.
 
Most admit I have never read the book but loved them movie. I liked the way the kids didn’t call their dad, dad, but adacus. I thought it was great movie about the injustices that have gone on in this country.
 
:ehh: Hmmm, it’s hard for me to comprehend what anyone could find bad about TKAM! It’s my favorite novel of all time. It’s accessible, has a clear moral theme, colorful and memorable characters, and you can even read Atticus Finch as sort of a Christ figure, IMO, because of the way he was socially “crucified” by the town. Or perhaps Tom Robinson is the Christ figure and Atticus is St. Peter or something - but I’m telling you, the book has depth and every time I’ve reread it (countless times) I find something new to appreciate about it. :yup:
 
An American classic that has changed the lives of many people, mine included. And the movie, with Gregory Peck as Atticus Finch, is a masterpiece!
 
I’m not aware that Harper Lee has said what the book is about,
but here’s my interpretation.

Basically,
the main character is Scout, real name Jean Louise Finch. It’s not what she does, but rather what society tries to do to her. Nearly everybody in her small Southern town is racially prejudiced. The question is, will Scout succumb to this prejudice sentiment or can she resist it?
 
:ehh: Hmmm, it’s hard for me to comprehend what anyone could find bad about TKAM! It’s my favorite novel of all time. It’s accessible, has a clear moral theme, colorful and memorable characters, and you can even read Atticus Finch as sort of a Christ figure, IMO, because of the way he was socially “crucified” by the town. Or perhaps Tom Robinson is the Christ figure and Atticus is St. Peter or something - but I’m telling you, the book has depth and every time I’ve reread it (countless times) I find something new to appreciate about it. :yup:
Agreed, one of the best of all time. Truly American but also universal. Although I grew up in the era of Civil Rights, I still look at that kind of bigotry as if I were looking at another planet. It makes no sense at all.

Lisa
 
There are more than a few classics of 20th-century American literature that are not available for Kindle. Oddly enough, TKAM is not one of them :confused:
 
Great book, great movie. My 9th grader just finished reading it as well. Can’t see what’s wrong with it
 
I just finish reading the novel for school. Like others have said, I don’t know what anyone could find wrong with it. 🤷 It’s one if my favorites! And Atticus makes his faith clear when he says he couldn’t go to church and worship God if he didn’t give his all to defend Tom Robinson.
 
Dave, I heard Harper Lee is going through some legalities over copyright at present; that may have something to do with TKAM not being on Kindle yet, IDK.

In a way, to me, the book has several “main” characters - in different ways. Scout is the narrator who pulls it all together. Jem is transitioning from boy to man, and he and Scout successfully, thanks to Atticus’s teachings, manage to become a true gentleman and lady like Atticus and Miss Maudie Atkinson, rather than some of the other characters who are either evil (Bob Ewell), ignorant (some of the Cunninghams), or well-meaning but blind to their prejudices (some of the businessmen, the Missionary Society ladies, etc.).

Scout narrates from her grownup perspective filtered through her memories of her childhood perspective. Unlike Stephanie Crawford, Scout has worthwhile information to impart rather than silly gossip.

Boo Radley, like Tom Robinson, is the “mockingbird” whom it’s a sin to kill. Scout and Jem start out believing the legends about Boo, and don’t know as much about the racial issues a man like Tom must face on an everyday basis. But by the end of the book, there is the implicit promise that if the next generation is more like Jem and Scout, the innocents such as Boo and Tom won’t suffer needlessly.

This is all just scratching the surface of such a rich, layered work. :coffeeread:
 
This is all just scratching the surface of such a rich, layered work. :coffeeread:
You’re absolutely right there.

On my recent third reading of the book I noticed things whose significance I hadn’t seen before.

And I still don’t understand everything. For example: what was the purpose of including the Dill character in the book? Why was sheriff Tate out of town when the gang showed up at the jail to get Tom? Why did Atticus take in his sister Alexandria who was an irritation to the kids?
 
You’re absolutely right there.

On my recent third reading of the book I noticed things whose significance I hadn’t seen before.

And I still don’t understand everything. For example: what was the purpose of including the Dill character in the book? Why was sheriff Tate out of town when the gang showed up at the jail to get Tom? Why did Atticus take in his sister Alexandria who was an irritation to the kids?
Did you know Dill was modeled on Truman Capote, who was a cousin of Harper Lee? Just a trivia tidbit, that. I think Dill served several purposes in the narrative. For one, he was a sort-of outsider to the town during 3 seasons of each year, but he was on-scene when the big action took place. He functioned as a sort of catalyst, ramping up the drama for Jem and Scout. They knew the legends about Boo Radley, but may not have thought to actually attempt to interact with Boo had it not been for Dill’s urgings. This brings them to lonely Boo’s attention and in the end of the book is what saves their lives when Boo defends them against Bob Ewell’s attack.

Dill is also a tiny satirical commentator on the ways of the people of Maycomb, from his closet-alcoholic Aunt Rachel to everyone at Tom Robinson’s trial. Aunt Alexandra even chides him for being cynical and Dill responds “Telling the truth’s not cynical,” to which Aunty says, “The way you tell it, it is.” Dill is also the one who says when he grows up he is going to be a different kind of circus clown and laugh at the audience.

Dill provides a “romantic” interest for Scout that balances a little of her tomboyishness as well.

Sheriff Tate was out of town when the gang tries to lynch Tom because some of the mob “called him off on a snipe hunt,” i.e. lured him away deliberately with some scheme so he would not be there and the lynchers would have an easier time of it.

I think Atticus, strong as he was in the ways of the law, might have had a little weakness when it came to his sister, who had an iron will. 😛 I find it interesting that Alexandra like every character is multi-dimensional. She fits in well enough with the gossipy Missionary Society ladies and she seems reluctant to embrace the same views about justice for Tom Robinson as Atticus does, at least not wholeheartedly.

She tries to change Scout into her version of what Scout should be as an about-to-be budding Southern lady (with mixed success) but at the end of the book we see her handing Scout the overalls to put on instead of a dress. I think she balances the book with another strong female character, and also she’s a work-in-progress - she has come from the background of how things were in the Old South, yet she is capable of opening her mind to different ways of thinking.
 
Great observations, 3DOCTORS ! :bowdown: :bowdown2:

You should write a book. 👍 🙂
 
Did you know Dill was modeled on Truman Capote, who was a cousin of Harper Lee? Just a trivia tidbit, that. I think Dill served several purposes in the narrative. For one, he was a sort-of outsider to the town during 3 seasons of each year, but he was on-scene when the big action took place. He functioned as a sort of catalyst, ramping up the drama for Jem and Scout. They knew the legends about Boo Radley, but may not have thought to actually attempt to interact with Boo had it not been for Dill’s urgings. This brings them to lonely Boo’s attention and in the end of the book is what saves their lives when Boo defends them against Bob Ewell’s attack.

Dill is also a tiny satirical commentator on the ways of the people of Maycomb, from his closet-alcoholic Aunt Rachel to everyone at Tom Robinson’s trial. Aunt Alexandra even chides him for being cynical and Dill responds “Telling the truth’s not cynical,” to which Aunty says, “The way you tell it, it is.” Dill is also the one who says when he grows up he is going to be a different kind of circus clown and laugh at the audience.

Dill provides a “romantic” interest for Scout that balances a little of her tomboyishness as well.

Sheriff Tate was out of town when the gang tries to lynch Tom because some of the mob “called him off on a snipe hunt,” i.e. lured him away deliberately with some scheme so he would not be there and the lynchers would have an easier time of it.

I think Atticus, strong as he was in the ways of the law, might have had a little weakness when it came to his sister, who had an iron will. 😛 I find it interesting that Alexandra like every character is multi-dimensional. She fits in well enough with the gossipy Missionary Society ladies and she seems reluctant to embrace the same views about justice for Tom Robinson as Atticus does, at least not wholeheartedly.

She tries to change Scout into her version of what Scout should be as an about-to-be budding Southern lady (with mixed success) but at the end of the book we see her handing Scout the overalls to put on instead of a dress. I think she balances the book with another strong female character, and also she’s a work-in-progress - she has come from the background of how things were in the Old South, yet she is capable of opening her mind to different ways of thinking.
Marvelous! Makes me want to read the book again! Thank you
Lisa
 
Sheriff Tate was out of town when the gang tries to lynch Tom because some of the mob “called him off on a snipe hunt,” i.e. lured him away deliberately with some scheme so he would not be there and the lynchers would have an easier time of it.
I remember the lynchers saying that, but it seems Tate would realize that’s what they were doing.

I also remember that after Boo Radley saved Scout and Jem by killing Bob Ewell,
Tate told Atticus, “I may not be much, Mr. Finch, but I am the sheriff. Bob Ewell fell on his knife.”

Now why did Tate say, “I may not be much” ?
Maybe because he had chickened out the night the lynchers went to the jail to get Tom,
*and he knows Atticus knows this !!! * :bigyikes:
Now, Tate is trying to redeem himself by risking his reputation making up this Ewell fell on his knife baloney to keep Boo’s secret.
 
Did you know Dill was modeled on Truman Capote, who was a cousin of Harper Lee? Just a trivia tidbit, that.
Capote (birth name was actually Truman Streckfus Persons; Capote was his step-father’s name) actually came to stay with relatives who lived next door to Harper Lee in Monroeville, but was not her cousin.

The town of Monroeville actually stages a truly wonderful production (by amateurs) of the play each year over multiple weekends. The second act actually takes place inside the Monroe County Courthouse, with white male members of the audience sitting in the place of the jury. There are also other bit parts occasionally filled by local celebrities (my husband, who is a local news anchor, got to don overalls and ride in a donkey cart when we went to see the play a few years ago!!!)

This is likely the most exciting thing that happens in Monroeville, and they do a fantastic job of it. If you ever have a chance to see the play, do so, as you will enjoy it thoroughly.

Harper Lee herself is, of course, quite elderly and reclusive. A number of years back, however, a family who is friends of ours got to spend time with her on her front porch, having tea or lemonade and talking (the dad is a wonderful Catholic doctor with a big family of incredibly bright children; I forget how they received the invitation, but I would have loved to have been a fly on the wall!)

How anyone could object to anything in TKAM is completely beyond me!!!
 
She Alexandria ] tries to change Scout into her version of what Scout should be as an about-to-be budding Southern lady (with mixed success) but at the end of the book we see her handing Scout the overalls to put on instead of a dress. I think she balances the book with another strong female character, and also she’s a work-in-progress - she has come from the background of how things were in the Old South, yet she is capable of opening her mind to different ways of thinking.
Alexandria failed to accompany Scout and Jem to the play. She didn’t have being tired after a hard day’s work as an excuse like Atticus. She didn’t work.
As it turns out, it’s 13 year old boy Jem who struggles with Bob Ewell and it’s another male, Boo Radley, who defeats Bob Ewell.
Alexandria now realizes there’s a limit to her ability to help raise Scout and Jem safely. In fact, she is powerless. She has to eat humble pie.
The book ends there, but we can speculate that she will be less strict with Scout, who is doing fine, thank you. Jem went after a man twice his size. Nobody taught him that. It was in him. So are the right things in Scout without a dictatorial aunt nagging her all day.

On the last page, it is Atticus who puts Scout to bed and stays by Jem all night,
not Alexandria who has gone off to enter a nunnery or something. 😃
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top