Tolkien 2019 movie

Status
Not open for further replies.
The difficulty always is with the more academic types that their brilliance isn’t a showy kind of genius. Yes, there were flamboyant geniuses; Newton was one of those (and also a pretty awful person), but Tolkien was a pretty normal, almost unbelievably normal academic. His faith was important to him, but he wasn’t a proselytizer (although he was disappointed Lewis rejoined the CofE, and didn’t convert to Catholicism). He was a family man, and about the most you can say about his marriage is that Edith at times felt a little lonely because Tolkien, in classic English tradition, loved to have a pint with his mates. He was a thorough first-half-of-the-20th century Englishman.

The brilliance came out in his writing and lectures, and that was who he was, a man who didn’t like to travel, who had felt at home in the halls of Oxford since his youth, raised a decent-sized family, and in the middle of it, wrote a couple of extraordinary books (and spent most of his life trying to finish the backstory) that give us a glimpse of the great mind, but he had no need or desire to flaunt it, and indeed found the fame a little befuddling (until his publisher finally hired him a secretary).
 
But how the devil are you going to punch up being an Oxford professor and a member of the Inklings. At least with the Lewis docudrama, there was a late-life romance that ended sadly, which you could tell a story around. But after WWI, when Tolkien went back to Oxford, the last half century of his life was about as exciting, from the exterior, as watching paint dry. I love the man and his writing dearly, but he did not live a magnificent exterior life. It was a good life and he took good care of his family, and the fortune he produced, and continues to produce, has created a legacy for his descendants, but other than that, not the stuff of high drama.
 
The screenwriters could have accessed his letters which have been published.

This could give a glimpse of his thoughts and his interior life.

However, I am just speculating.

In the trailer, I saw him having discussions with the Inklings about the ideas for the books he will write.
 
Last edited:
Actually it looks really good. You can put inspiring music and camaraderie onscreen and create a good movie about anybody’s life, I guess.
I’d like to see one about me. But I’d gloss over my early sins and the last 20 or so years might be pretty boring.
 
The working title, ‘There Will Be Tweed,’ reveals a little of the flavor we can expect from this.
 
Last edited:
Actually it looks really good. You can put inspiring music and camaraderie onscreen and create a good movie about anybody’s life, I guess.
I’d like to see one about me. But I’d gloss over my early sins and the last 20 or so years might be pretty boring.
Speak for yourself. Some of us oldsters have kept up with the sins part.
 
A lovely shot of the Tolkiens, JC. I’d not seen it before, so thank you. I terribly miss English people of that type.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top