Let me preface this post by saying that I’ve been up all night studying and I tend to get “chatty” and my spelling goes out the window when I’m sleepy. So I’m sorry if it takes me a while to get to my point.
I can feel your pain. After being away from the Church for about 10 years, I had racked up a long list of sins. Including numerous ones against chastity that didn’t involve anyone but myself. When I had finally worked up the courage to go to confession, I seriously thought I would either pass out or throw up in the confessional (or both!). But I cannot express the relief that I felt afterwards. To know Jesus loves YOU personally and that you personally have been forgiven for your sins is a powerful feeling.
Even though we are really talking to Jesus, as humans we still think of it as telling the human priest and we are afraid of the priest’s judgements. But you need to remember that you are talking to Jesus, not the priest who is sitting there. So try your best to forget that the priest is even there.
I would absolutely go to another parish where the priest won’t recognize you and where they use some form of privacy (screens/booths/etc). That will help alleviate some of the shame and thoughts that the priest will be able to recognize your voice and know what you have been up to. I live in a small town and unless we get a visiting priest that is not an option. I actually teach with my priest at the Catholic school, and I know he knows my voice, so going to confession always requires lots of prayers for courage. I have been known to seek out a confessional on my vacations just so I feel more comfortable about the anonimity of being from out of town.
Do as was suggested and TALK to the priest. Take a deep breath and explain it to him the same way you explained it to us. He will ask whatever questions he needs. Unless this priest is different from any of the priests I have ever confessed to, he won’t try to embarass you. He’ll just ask whatever questions are necessary to draw out just what the sin was, without going too much into specifics. He may not even ask very much. But try to avoid misleading him. You don’t want to give so few specifics that he thinks you are talking about ABC when you are really talking about XYZ.
And don’t worry. He has heard it all. I was wracked with guilt about a particular sin and it took me a few rounds of showing up during confession hours but not actually going in for a confession to finally admit it. When I finally confessed my sin and told the priest how I was stressing about it, he actually chuckled a little and asked if that was it. So in other words, lots of times we build it up and make it seem like the end of the world when it really isn’t.
Remember that no matter how horrible and ill you might feel in the moments leading up to and during the confession, just think about how free and unburdened you will feel afterwards. And if you ever face that temptation again, think about the tortue you’ve been going through with the guilt you’ve been feeling now. That (and God’s Grace) will help you get through it.
We are all praying for you. It won’t be easy, but you can do it!