Total consecration to Mary a vow?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Matthew91
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
M

Matthew91

Guest
A long time ago as I was returning to the faith and becoming more interested in devotions and other forms of prayer I came across the act of total consecration to Mary, by St. Louis De Montfort. And at the time, I thought it was just a nice prayer and it had been recommended to me, so I recited it without having done any of the perquisites for this consecration, thinking that it laid no responsibility or obligation on me, and that it was just a good devotional prayer.

However today I came across this website:

newjerusalem.com/conditions.htm

And this site says, and I quote:
DeMontfort’s Total Consecration is different. This consecration has the characters of a vow: because it is a most solemn and eternal dedication. It is more than an ordinary promise - which is not binding under penalty of sin; but it is less demanding that the solemn vows, which one would make to become a professed religious. Still, the effect of this consecration, properly made, is irrevocable. Once a person understands the nature of this consecration, he understands that he is entirely abrogating any of his natural spiritual rights to dictate where the merits of his good actions might be applied.
Now I had no clue about any of this when I prayed the act of consecration, I had no clue that this was a vow, and certainly did not know of any obligations placed on me by reciting that prayer.

So my question is, am I obligated anyway? and am I bound by this vow? when I didn’t know about any of this when I recited that prayer and certainly would not have if I knew I would be obligating myself to do certain things under pain of sin. I didn’t know it was a vow, and certainly wouldn’t have done it if I knew this beforehand.

In addition, I didn’t follow the process at all, much less know about it.

Step 1 is to read St. Louis De Montfort’s “True Devotion to Mary” I didn’t read this at the time, and have never read it, just read a few snippets here and there on the internet.

Step 2 is to pick a Marian feast day on which to make your consecration. I didn’t do this either, I don’t even remember what day or specific year I recited that consecration to be honest.

Step 3 is to begin a 33 day preparation period prior to the feast day on which you make the actual consecration. I didn’t do this 33 day period at all or know about it.

Step 4 is to make the act of consecration, the only thing here I actually did without understanding the gravity of what I was doing or know about the preceding steps.

And Step 5 if a bunch of other requirements that I had no clue about and haven’t done.

But in spite of all of this, all this is necessary is to recite the act of consecration according to what I’ve read and that is the only thing I actually did here.

So wrapping this all up, #1 I am not even sure if I did this consecration correctly, #2 I didn’t know that it is considered a vow to be kept under pain of sin #3 If I knew that it was a vow I wouldn’t have done it.

Essentially I’m looking for answers as to whether or not I am bound by a vow (that I didn’t know about) as a result of praying that consecration prayer in a spur of the moment thing one night? I certainly hope not 🤷
 
I am about to complete the 33-day preparation for the Total Consecration to Jesus Through Mary, and I was asking the same question. The Total Consecration is above all else “a perfect renewal of the baptismal vows”. However, it is a very special promise that can be thought of as a simple vow…check f. ex. this post of mine on this topic, which quotes (with no intent of advice whatsoever) the Code of Canon Law on these matters.

I apologize, but the following phrase is beyond my understanding:
thinking that it laid no responsibility or obligation on me
I have a hard time understanding how could you possibly think such a thing…because if you indeed prayed that “good devotional prayer”, you said with full knowledge and deliberate consent the following, among other things:
I, N., a faithless sinner, renew and ratify today in thy hands the vows of my Baptism and I give myself entirely to Jesus Christ, the Incarnate Wisdom, to carry my cross after Him all the days of my life, and to be more faithful to Him than I have ever been before.
In the presence of all the heavenly court I choose thee this day for my Mother and Mistress.
I deliver and consecrate to thee, as thy slave, my body and soul, my goods, both interior and exterior, and even the value of all my good actions, past, present and future; leaving to thee the entire and full right of disposing of me, and all that belongs to me, without exception, according to thy good pleasure, for the greater glory of God in time and in eternity.
Is this the prayer you prayed? If yes, what do you mean by “I had no clue and certainly did not know of any obligations placed on me”? Is it “I deliver and consecrate to you as your slave …] for the greater glory of God …] in time and in eternity” not clear enough? :confused:

I suggest that you mention this to your confessor, and mention that you made such a great promise lightly and without any intention whatsoever of keeping it. Let him, to be on the safe side, release you from what may or may not have been a simple private vow.
If I knew that it was a vow I wouldn’t have done it.
I have a hard time understanding this one. :sad_yes:

A vow is “a deliberate and free promise made to God about a possible and better good” which “must be fulfilled by reason of the virtue of religion”. Baptismal promises to renounce to Satan and all his works and pomps (which we should renew often) are vows. When you confess and do your act of contrition and say “I firmly resolve, with the help of Your grace, to sin no more and to avoid the near occasion of sin” that’s also a vow, which you (and me, and all of us) break every time we sin. There is nothing terrifying about simple vows.

I’d rather not promise anything to God, unless I am doing it with the intention of keeping it (thus making it a simple vow). And anyways if we find ourselves unable to fulfill them, we can commute them into an equal or better good (or speak to a confessor who can commute them into a lesser good).

Public solemn vows of poverty, chastity, and obedience are a different matter.

Thus I invite you to meditate on these matters, and to mention this to your confessor and let him determine what’s the right course of action. And do read “Treatise on the True Devotion” by St.Louis Marie Grignon de Montfort…you will understand better than many others the Catholic love for the Blessed Virgin 😉
 
I have a hard time understanding how could you possibly think such a thing…because if you indeed prayed that “good devotional prayer”, you said with full knowledge and deliberate consent the following, among other things:
Well at the time I didn’t know who St. Louis de Montfort was, I didn’t know about this specific devotion in that there were weeks of preparation supposed to be taken beforehand, which I didn’t do. I saw the consecration recommended on some Catholic website, but I didn’t know it referred to this extensive devotion, I thought it was just a simple devotional prayer akin to the rosary, that would be a pious practice to pray. And I certainly didn’t know that it would place extra obligations on me, such as praying the consecration prayer at least once per year, that I should pray the little crown of the blessed virgin once a day if not inconvenient, among whatever else the devotion obligates one to. These are the extra obligations I am referring to, the things you have to do as a result of the consecration, I wasn’t aware of them at all.
Is this the prayer you prayed? If yes, what do you mean by “I had no clue and certainly did not know of any obligations placed on me”? Is it “I deliver and consecrate to you as your slave …] for the greater glory of God …] in time and in eternity” not clear enough? :confused:

I suggest that you mention this to your confessor, and mention that you made such a great promise lightly and without any intention whatsoever of keeping it. Let him, to be on the safe side, release you from what may or may not have been a simple private vow.
I’ll mention it next time I go to confession, but I should note, does the consecration count if you didn’t do any of the other aspects of it? I didn’t do the 33 days of preparation, I didn’t go to confession the week preceding or after, I didn’t receive communion or go to mass on the final day when you are supposed to recite the consecration (which is supposed to be a Marian feast day) and I didn’t sign a printed or copied version of the consecration, all of which you are supposed to do. I didn’t read “True devotion to Mary” much less know about it or St. Louis De Montfort. I didn’t know you were supposed to do any of this until today, It was literally a spur of the moment looking at the prayer online, and reciting it because it was recommended without the understanding that there was any extra responsibility laid on me from simply reciting it.

For what it’s worth, I read the following on the wikipedia article on this devotion:
In order for the consecration to be complete, the consecrator must attend Mass on the final day, partake in confession either the week before or after, and do a personal penance for Mary.
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Preparation_for_Total_Consecration_according_to_Saint_Louis_de_Montfort

And if this is true, what I did wasn’t complete at all since I did none of this except recite the prayer, didn’t go to confession, or mass, or do a penance. Would this be correct?
A vow is “a deliberate and free promise made to God about a possible and better good” which “must be fulfilled by reason of the virtue of religion”. Baptismal promises to renounce to Satan and all his works and pomps (which we should renew often) are vows. When you confess and do your act of contrition and say “I firmly resolve, with the help of Your grace, to sin no more and to avoid the near occasion of sin” that’s also a vow, which you (and me, and all of us) break every time we sin. There is nothing terrifying about simple vows.

I’d rather not promise anything to God, unless I am doing it with the intention of keeping it (thus making it a simple vow). And anyways if we find ourselves unable to fulfill them, we can commute them into an equal or better good (or speak to a confessor who can commute them into a lesser good).

Public solemn vows of poverty, chastity, and obedience are a different matter.
Well, to be perfectly honest, today is the first time I’m hearing that such things are considered vows. I always understood vows to be reserved for extremely serious public occasions such as wedding vows, or vows of celibacy for the religious life and so on. And that to break any vow is a mortal sin. I never even considered that simple promises to God would be considered vows, I just saw this prayer as statement of sentiment that we often give in prayer. And I certainly did not think reciting that consecration prayer was a vow at the time. I’ve recited more prayers written by saints than I can remember, and they each use certain language that might seem strong or declaratory towards a specific end but I did not see this prayer as adding an extra responsibility beyond what I normally would do as a practicing Catholic. Keep in mind I was a teenager at the time, and I was ignorant on many points of the faith.
 
Do mention it in confession anyways 😉

The act of consecration may have been invalid indeed. However, if you checked out those quotes from the Code of Canon Law you know now that any promise to God is a vow, though in your case it may be a simple private vow. If you did not intend to make any promise to God, it may not even have been a vow, and anyways your lack of full knowledge on the matter does hint to absence of mortal sin 🤷 But this stuff only a confessor can discern :o

I do understand your point perfectly, however no matter what, you did say to Our Lady that you delivered and consecrated to her, as her slave, your body and soul, your goods, et cetera. Did you mean this?

I mean: you did not know about all other requirements, etc. and did not fulfill the characteristics of the consecration etc. but did you intend to consecrate yourself fully to Christ through Our Lady?

In that case, I do not think that you voluntarily broke the vow (again, presuming there actually was such a thing).

Are you still willing to maintain that promise, perhaps by going through the 33-day preparation and considering, during those 33 days, to do a valid consecration? I do suggest you read the “Treatise on True Devotion” and follow the 33 days of prayer. It may be a worthy experience and you may learn a lot about how extraordinary it is to reach the third level of devotion to Our Lady, even if in the end you chose not to go through with the consecration just yet.

So again, don’t be exceedingly worried 😉 Any promise to God is a vow, though we only hear the word “vow” as referring to public solemn vows (like the ones you mention) 😉 And there’s a big difference between those and a simple private vow 😉 I leave the matter totally up to your confessor and invite you to take this great chance to discern the third and highest level of devotion to Our Lady. This actually does not add extra responsibilities, but takes a lot of them away, for you give up and do everything (works, prayers, benefits) to and through Our Lady, who does God’s will perfectly and certainly better than you and me ever will 😉
 
Do mention it in confession anyways 😉

The act of consecration may have been invalid indeed. However, if you checked out those quotes from the Code of Canon Law you know now that any promise to God is a vow, though in your case it may be a simple private vow. If you did not intend to make any promise to God, it may not even have been a vow, and anyways your lack of full knowledge on the matter does hint to absence of mortal sin 🤷 But this stuff only a confessor can discern :o
Yes, thank you for those quotes, today is the first time I am reading those. Well, I don’t think I intended to make a promise of any sort either to God or our Lady. I’m quite scrupulous as you can probably see, and I don’t make promises at all let alone promises to God. And This dilemma here didn’t even register in my mind as a potential issue until I saw in another thread someone referring to praying this consecration is equivalent to a vow, and it shocked me, so I did further research and made this thread for answers. I simply saw it as a prayer, nothing more, not any sort of promise to do anything extra out of the ordinary for a Catholic, or anything that would alter my spiritual life.
I do understand your point perfectly, however no matter what, you did say to Our Lady that you delivered and consecrated to her, as her slave, your body and soul, your goods, et cetera. Did you mean this?
Honestly, I am not sure, it depends on the context. In the isolation in which I prayed this prayer, unfamiliar with St. Louis De Montfort or the accompanying devotion, I simply saw it as a sentimental act of piety similar to the rosary where we pray to Mary who intercedes for us while recognizing her as Queen of Heaven. I didn’t see it as a lifetime binding “deal” so to speak, after all, as I said I was seeing this prayer isolated from the context of its devotion and author who had an expansive spiritual tradition which elaborated on what was in the consecration.

It’s like when we pray the Hail Holy Queen in the Rosary, we address Mary as “our life, our sweetness, our hope” Not at the exclusion of Jesus obviously, but it is a statement of sentiment and recognition of Mary’s special place in salvation history, but we don’t mean it literally word for word at the exclusion of Christ Himself of course, I interpreted the words of the consecration not as a binding contract for lack of a better term, but as a pious sentiment.

Also, I don’t think I knew what consecrate meant really, and maybe I still don’t know :o at least in this context. I simply saw it as a good intercessory prayer invoking the Blessed Mother in a special way, similar to how we make the sign of the cross to bless ourselves, I saw this consecration in a similar light but in regards to Our Lady. I didn’t understand that it would alter my spirituality completely and place on me certain extra obligations that I mentioned before.
Are you still willing to maintain that promise, perhaps by going through the 33-day preparation and considering, during those 33 days, to do a valid consecration? I do suggest you read the “Treatise on True Devotion” and follow the 33 days of prayer. It may be a worthy experience and you may learn a lot about how extraordinary it is to reach the third level of devotion to Our Lady, even if in the end you chose not to go through with the consecration just yet.
Well, I certainly have nothing against it, but in my special case I think it would be better for me to refrain from any sort of consecrations or binding devotions in the future. As a scrupulous person, these sort of things tend to cause me more grief than the joy that should be experienced, I would constantly be questioning myself as to whether I’ve lived up to the added standards and obligations, it’s just something that is admirable, but I sincerely think it would cause me more anxiety than I’m ready to deal with in my spiritual life.
So again, don’t be exceedingly worried 😉 Any promise to God is a vow, though we only hear the word “vow” as referring to public solemn vows (like the ones you mention) 😉 And there’s a big difference between those and a simple private vow 😉 I leave the matter totally up to your confessor and invite you to take this great chance to discern the third and highest level of devotion to Our Lady. This actually does not add extra responsibilities, but takes a lot of them away, for you give up and do everything (works, prayers, benefits) to and through Our Lady, who does God’s will perfectly and certainly better than you and me ever will 😉
Thanks, and I will address this with my pastor.
 
And This dilemma here didn’t even register in my mind as a potential issue until I saw in another thread someone referring to praying this consecration is equivalent to a vow, and it shocked me, so I did further research and made this thread for answers.
I apologize, for I believe it was me who posted that.

Since we will be doing our Total Consecration before a priest, it will be a simple public vow (or, at least, I think 🤷), and I was struggling with some temptations. Turns out many of my fellow brothers were in the same situation. So we keep moving forward on this wonderful path.

I do thank you for your kindness and understanding. Your phrase “not at the exclusion of Christ, of course” urges me to recommend that reading again…nothing in the devotion of Mary is to the exclusion of Christ…it is God’s will that, just as Christ came to us through Mary, we come to Christ through Mary…she is the Mediatrix before the Mediator, whose sole command to us is: “do whatever He tells you”. There are, however, seven false devotions to the Blessed Virgin. St Louis Marie covers them in the Treatise, and he shows that you can never love Mary enough, and that this love will always, always lead to Christ. The third level of devotion to Mary, which is our consecration to her in the manner of a servant, is in truth a consecration to Jesus, for necessarily the queen’s servants are also the king’s servants, and anyone who is a servant of Christ the King by virtue of Baptism is necessarily a servant of Mary, Queen of Heaven and Earth. It is a deep truth. That text is the mere beginning of a very profound theological truth, one engraved in the Sacred Tradition.

Once you read the booklet, you may find yourself changing your mind. If not, at least you’ll know more about Our Lady and the way the Holy Church loves her more than many, Catholic and non-Catholic 😉
 
I have done the consecration myself and never regret it.

It says it’s the character of a vow, but don’t get scared off by that.

No , I don’t think you did anything too bad if you didn’t understand it all, though you should have sensed the importance of it when reading the prayer.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top