T
tau_gamma_pi
Guest
I was thinking about this today…
Baptism is a transformation, yes? I can’t see how that works if we aren’t totally depraved. Look:
First, we have immaculate people.
Then, we have an incident with a snake and a tree. Bad things happen.
For the sake of this argument, assume that EITHER we are totally depraved OR we are deformed and diseased (i.e. the Catholic doctrine of original sin) but still ontologically good.
As an analogy for TOTAL DEPRAVITY, we have people turned into pigs.
As an analogy for the CATHOLIC DOCTRINE, we have people with their arms and legs cut off.
Either way, we have baptism, which is a transformation.
In the first analogy (people turning into pigs), the pigs are turned back into people. It is clearly a transformation.
In the second analogy (people with their arms and legs cut off), the arms and legs are sewn back on and healed. This isn’t so much a transformation - it was just a flesh wound, after all. You can’t be ontologically changed if you’re going from being a person to being a person.
Does that make sense? I’m confused.
Baptism is a transformation, yes? I can’t see how that works if we aren’t totally depraved. Look:
First, we have immaculate people.
Then, we have an incident with a snake and a tree. Bad things happen.
For the sake of this argument, assume that EITHER we are totally depraved OR we are deformed and diseased (i.e. the Catholic doctrine of original sin) but still ontologically good.
As an analogy for TOTAL DEPRAVITY, we have people turned into pigs.
As an analogy for the CATHOLIC DOCTRINE, we have people with their arms and legs cut off.
Either way, we have baptism, which is a transformation.
In the first analogy (people turning into pigs), the pigs are turned back into people. It is clearly a transformation.
In the second analogy (people with their arms and legs cut off), the arms and legs are sewn back on and healed. This isn’t so much a transformation - it was just a flesh wound, after all. You can’t be ontologically changed if you’re going from being a person to being a person.
Does that make sense? I’m confused.