Traditional Confessional Booths

  • Thread starter Thread starter Dempsey1919
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Our regular parish uses a variation of a traditional confessional. We have 3 doors. One side is a screen. The other side has a wall about half-way up with a chair instead of a kneeler.

I prefer face-to-face - because I feel funny talking through a wall. I haven’t found many (any?) priests who maintain eye contact while you are confessing your sins. Which is fine.
 
I have seen several churches though that have “confession rooms” which have a screened kneeler in addition to face to face. These places seem to be more open, airy and more well lit than typical closet confessionals.
My parish has one of those.
 
😉
I prefer face-to-face - because I feel funny talking through a wall. I haven’t found many (any?) priests who maintain eye contact while you are confessing your sins. Which is fine.
You are lucky, my confessor usually stares at me. I don’t mind that much because he happens to be a friend of mine and can usually tell if I am holding anything back. He scares me sometimes.
 
if the bishops ever ask my advice (which I do not anticipate) I would advise that it is obvious esp in the wake of the scandals where the new design of confessional “rooms” seems to have facilitated the abuse of some of the offending priests, that the solution is to introduce carrels seen in so many European cathedrals, where both priest and penitent are full visible, but separated from each other by a screen (have also seen these in older churches in Mexico. they are located far enough away from pews so that the confession cannot be overheard, and seem to be designed architecturally with “baffles” at the top to prevent sound from carrying.

or the practice in so many Eastern rite and Orthodox churches, where the penitent simply approaches the priest at the foot of the altar, and before the screen that is a feature of those churches, and stands facing him to confess.
 
I went into a confessional booth once…it was a traditional confessional, but some idiot decide that shutters would be nice, which Fr promptly opened as soon as I said bless me Fr…it was the worst confession I ever made, not on purpose, but I was so flustered I figured if I forgot something God would understand
 
The oddest confession I ever made was in a parking lot, obviously face-to-face. What made it really strange, in retrospect, was the fact my best friend was with me…communal reconciliation to the max. It was a long time ago, in the wake of V2, and a lot of fairly strange things were going on, especially with order priests.🙂
 
My parish was rebuilt in 1972, and is way modern(it’s hexagonal…yeah), but it has a traditional confessional, sort of. It’s not a free-standing thing, but there are two doors in the wall, with a big space between them. The priest has a door on the other side of the wall(in the vestibule…sort of…it’s a strangely-shaped church). There’s a little screen above each kneeler that opens and closes-for sound, he can’t see you either way. That way, two people can be in the confessional at once, and the priest hears one, dismisses them, and goes to the next, while another person goes into the other side, and can prepare and gather themselves for a moment in the ‘scary booth’. I like it that way…

And yeah, you have to whisper, which is pretty good because it helps mask your voice unless you have a really distinctive one :o

We also have a ‘reconciliation room’, but I don’t know if our current priest has ever used it.
 
Several posters have mentioned (or implied) “anonymous” confession.

NB that while Canon Law does call for confessionals to have a fixed grille, no indication is made that privacy/anonymity must be maintained.

tee
 
We have a traditional confessional with three rooms. One of them is currently used for storage. The one we use has a kneeler in it and a small grill with a screen in the wall. No way to see through it.
 
Since the church I go to was built around the 1900, we still have the what can be considered traditional type confessionals. Each one has 3 doors. One for open confessions (I think that part may of been refurbished), one with the screen, and the middle one for the priests.

The only person I see using the open side is one of the other priests when he goes to confession before Mass on Saturday.

There are six confessionals and usually four or five of them are being used each Saturday when I go to Mass.
 
Hello all
Some years ago, my first confession was done face-to-face, although there were and still are confessionals at that Church. I prefer confession in the booth, the old-school way. Most of the Churches I go to, even if they are relatively new or have been “renovated” have retained the booths. However, most parishes never have confession, its always by calling in for an appointment. I have also gone to confession and was the old form was used; ie. “Ego te absolve a peccatis tuis in nomine Patris…” When I go to the EF, it is done the old school way. An interesting thing is that by the parish near my house, the new priest from the Philippines is using the old form in latin. This is in an ordinary parish. {The funny thing about this church, my honarary parish since it is closest to my home, is that it was built during the council. Big large circle auditorium style building. The altar was obviously built for versus populum masses. However, it was built with altar rails, and the choir loft is above in the back with the organ. Candles and shrines, but around the top are “mosaic” stain glass windows. I guess this church was built during the transition, with elements from before and after. I couldvbe better, but other churches are a lot worse. The thing that keeps me going there is the same priest absolving in latin. If I do not go to the EF, which is far away and across the Golden Gate Bridge( with a $6 TOLL:eek: ) I go there on saturday at 4:30 for the vigil. Its not as loud and rambunctious as it would be on sunday. This new priest does not use altar girls, and he tried to stop EMHC’s, but apparently someone snitched or complained and he used them the following week.} The weirdest confessions are at my high school. Twice a year, during Advent and Lent, students in religion classes are taken out of class and there is a “Reconciliation” in the auditorium. We all take our seats, then some readings are read, and a few prayers prayed. Then everyone says the act of contrition. In each corner of the auditorium, there are priests sitting in chairs. So those who want to go sit down. I did not like it, and I felt very uncomfortable, because the priest was just like tell me your sins. He did not use the old way Sign of the cross then Bless me father… When was your lat confession etc. I believe last year the priest did not even give me absolution. He just gave me advice, and said bye. I have also experienced those large rooms with the priest sitting down. One could either choose the chair beside him or kneel behind a screen. I choose the latter. Face to face confession is better than no confession at all, but I prefer the box.👍
 
Hello all
Some years ago, my first confession was done face-to-face, although there were and still are confessionals at that Church. I prefer confession in the booth, the old-school way. Most of the Churches I go to, even if they are relatively new or have been “renovated” have retained the booths. However, most parishes never have confession, its always by calling in for an appointment. I have also gone to confession and was the old form was used; ie. “Ego te absolve a peccatis tuis in nomine Patris…” When I go to the EF, it is done the old school way. An interesting thing is that by the parish near my house, the new priest from the Philippines is using the old form in latin. This is in an ordinary parish. {The funny thing about this church, my honarary parish since it is closest to my home, is that it was built during the council. Big large circle auditorium style building. The altar was obviously built for versus populum masses. However, it was built with altar rails, and the choir loft is above in the back with the organ. Candles and shrines, but around the top are “mosaic” stain glass windows. I guess this church was built during the transition, with elements from before and after. I couldvbe better, but other churches are a lot worse. The thing that keeps me going there is the same priest absolving in latin. If I do not go to the EF, which is far away and across the Golden Gate Bridge( with a $6 TOLL:eek: ) I go there on saturday at 4:30 for the vigil. Its not as loud and rambunctious as it would be on sunday. This new priest does not use altar girls, and he tried to stop EMHC’s, but apparently someone snitched or complained and he used them the following week.} The weirdest confessions are at my high school. Twice a year, during Advent and Lent, students in religion classes are taken out of class and there is a “Reconciliation” in the auditorium. We all take our seats, then some readings are read, and a few prayers prayed. Then everyone says the act of contrition. In each corner of the auditorium, there are priests sitting in chairs. So those who want to go sit down. I did not like it, and I felt very uncomfortable, because the priest was just like tell me your sins. He did not use the old way Sign of the cross then Bless me father… When was your lat confession etc. I believe last year the priest did not even give me absolution. He just gave me advice, and said bye. I have also experienced those large rooms with the priest sitting down. One could either choose the chair beside him or kneel behind a screen. I choose the latter. Face to face confession is better than no confession at all, but I prefer the box.👍
Another missionary, come to save the West, thank God!!!

I love our missionary priests, they seem so untouched by the secularism many of our own fall prey to (off topic, I apologize, I just love missionary priests, especially from the Philippines, India and Africa)
 
Another missionary, come to save the West, thank God!!!

I love our missionary priests, they seem so untouched by the secularism many of our own fall prey to (off topic, I apologize, I just love missionary priests, especially from the Philippines, India and Africa)
Yes, I do love those who come fro the Philippines, given the fact I am 1/2 Filipino! Seriously, the Filipino priests who come here are solidly orthodox and they are very pious. They take the Faith seriously and do not play around. Also, the Dominican nuns that taught me were from the Philippines. They wear full habit, and they were very kind and loving. I miss them, as most were transfered to Hawaii. They were the Dominican Sisters of the Most Holy Rosary of the Philippines. The former principal at my School, Sr. Celestine Bancal, OP, is now the Mother Superior of the Order. Nearly ten years ago, when I went to the Philippines, we stayed at their retreat house in Iloilo, as it was their 75th anniversary. It was awesome. The novitiates were the preparatory habit, and the Churches were beautiful. No communion in the hand. Good music. They just do not play around. They are a young, vibrant, thriving order. One can liken them to the Nashville Dominicans, an excellent example of an American order that is young and flourishing.
 
Maybe I should preceed this by explaining that I live in a very Catholic region with many churches in a 40 mile or so radius. So that explains all of “my” churches 😃

One area chuch does have the old-fashioned confessional booths. (The church was built in the 1800s and still has the original pipe organ shipped from Germany.) It has a light-bulb on the outside that indicates that the booth is ocupied.

My current church has what I suppose you could call a confessional room. You step in and have the option of either going around the 1/2-wall to sit in a chair and face the priest, or going straight forward to kneel behind the wall (which has a window covered with a curtain).

My “home” parish…you know, I’m not sure if it even HAS a confessional. If it does, I have no idea where.

The parish in which I went to CCD, they also have a confessional room. Their’s, though, has no wall, just this, I guess you’d call it a movable wall with a built in kneeler. Very strange, now that I think back. You could either go behind the “wall” or face-to-face. At least, in theory you had a choice. They MADE us go face-to-face. I made what I am sure qualify as the world’s worst confessions. Absolutely awful. Honestly, that is part of what kept me away from confession for so long–I was horrified that I’d have to go face-to-face again. I was never so relieved as I was when I stepped into the confessional and realized that I had a CHOICE.
 
Maybe I should preceed this by explaining that I live in a very Catholic region with many churches in a 40 mile or so radius. So that explains all of “my” churches 😃
I grew up in a similar area. Within two blocks of my house where I grew up there were three Catholic churches and one Byzantine Catholic If you extended that radius by three more blocks the number went up to four Catholic churches and an Orthodox Church.

Imagine all that grace being poured from heaven each and every Sunday in such a small area and I didn’t realize what I treasure there was so close to my home.

ChadS
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top