Tridentine mass vs Novus ordo mass

  • Thread starter Thread starter Tradcat1
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
OrbisNonSufficit said:
If there is no Sacrificial meaning, Mass isn’t valid. Meaning is that we understand our Lord Sacrificed Himself for us.
Click to expand...
That is exactly my point. If people do not understand the language of sacrifice, is there any sacrificial meaning? Most modern people have not sacrificed an animal to a god, or participated in sharing the remains of that animal with the god. They do not quite grasp the meaning of the unbloody sacrifice because they do not know about bloody ones. (There are still a few places in the world where bloody sacrifices persist)
OrbisNonSufficit said:
Pope after Council of Trent said that Tridentine Mass is Mass of All Ages IIRC (maybe it was mentioned later by another Pope). Are you questioning Wisdom of that Pope?
Click to expand...
Not at all. The Tridentine Mass is the Mass of All Ages. The post Vatican II is the Mass of All Ages. OF is the Mass of All Ages. EF is the Mass of All Ages. The Pope after the Council of Trent was not referring to the form of the Mass, but to the substance of it.
 
Dovekin said:
Most modern people have not sacrificed an animal to a god, or participated in sharing the remains of that animal with the god.
Click to expand...
Even as a kid when listening to Biblical stories about Sacrifice I understood the point. I wasn’t educated religiously by far, but this isn’t part that is hard to understand.
Dovekin said:
Not at all. The Tridentine Mass is the Mass of All Ages. The post Vatican II is the Mass of All Ages. OF is the Mass of All Ages. EF is the Mass of All Ages. The Pope after the Council of Trent was not referring to the form of the Mass, but to the substance of it.
Click to expand...
Well context was used for Tridentine Mass while discarding other local forms of Mass so I am not too sure about that. Anyway my points in this regard are two; firstly that past Magisterium holds as much value (if not more by logic of non-contradiction) as current one… and secondly that OF isn’t superior to EF in eyes of the Church.
 
Uhm I am pretty sure that he was joking. Chill out he just prefers the one over the other.
 
Uhm I am pretty sure that he was joking. Chill out he just prefers the one over the other.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top