Trouble finding my spirituality type

  • Thread starter Thread starter latingirl
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
L

latingirl

Guest
I am a person who is struggling to find out what my spirituality type is. I know there are several different types like Franciscan, Carmelite, Dominican… etc. But from the descriptions I was given I don’t seem to fit anywhere! I am passionate about evangelization, catechesis, study and Scripture but not completely intellectual and bookish- I like helping others but I could never work in some strange country with poor people. I love to contemplate but could not spend all day doing so. Right now I am in a period of spiritual dryness and I’d like to find some devotions that resonate with my spirituality type…if I can find out what it is.

Please help, thanks.
 
Pray the Rosary daily and I promise Our Lady will eventually show you:thumbsup:
 
I usually do pray the rosary daily and when I first converted I prayed it daily for two years. I still have no clue.
 
I don’t believe we are all called to “spirituality types”. Instead of trying to find a type to fit into, just live out your faith as a Catholic.
 
Hi there. I’m a Lay Carmelite, so maybe I can help. The various forms of Catholic spirituality are like flowers. All have similarities-prayer, work, study-like stems, leaves and petals. But to fully understand and appreciate them, one must experience them. All are beautiful and each exudes it’s own unique fragrance. Each is unique and comparing them isn’t really correct. After all, how can we compare a rose and an orchid, or a gardenia and a lily? We cannot a d ought not.
As for your spirituality, we just don’t know yet. Ask the Holy Spirit to reveal this to you. Then be prepared to wait patiently for the answer. Until then be of good cheer and practice a simple devotion, such as the Devotion to the Holy Face.😃
 
I agree that you continue to pray. I also thought of my niece who is a lay Cannossian (hope I spelled that right). Your description sounded like my niece who seems very dedicated to her lay group.

Some people seem to know where to go and stay there; others search and take and give a little along different paths. God made us so similar and so different.
 
Thank you for helping. The reason why I ask is because I need to find a devotion and prayer program that suits me and one I can do everyday. Due to my job, I cannot go to daily Mass. I do very well with the Chaplet of Divine Mercy and Rosary but after awhile I get very dry. I tried the Liturgy of the Hours and experienced the same problem. Not that I am giving up these devotions but I wish to find a spirituality that speaks to me and one that can nourish me. The only thing I can keep up is weekly adoration.

Basically I thought this would help my unbearable dryness.
 
Since you’ve mentioned dryness a couple of times, I have to ask: do you have a spiritual director? I, too, am in a period of dryness. In my case it’s severe. My SD described it as “spiritual desolation so acute it borders on a dark night of the soul.” :bigyikes: I would have given up ages ago if it weren’t for the assistance I get from him.

An SD might also be able to help you develop a suitable prayer routine—mine did. I will warn you that it didn’t happen overnight. In fact, it remains a “work in progress” to a certain extent. In any event, I’m praying for you as I know how exasperating dryness can be. :console:

I absolutely love Adoration, and it’s good that you go weekly. Do you look forward to going, or is it difficult for you to stay committed to it?

God bless! :signofcross:
 
About missionary??? A group that do this.

There is also Mother Teresa sister of charity but this is about helping others not necessary evangelize.

You can become a pastoral teacher until you figure this out.

All the best
 
Father Thomas Green, a very good writer on prayer, has a book called When the Well Runs Dry. I haven’t read it, but from the title, I assume that it deals - at least in part - with the issue of dryness in prayer.

For some people, dryness is just something that God chooses for them - because it is the best way for them to attain holiness. Rather than trying to escape from it, one has to learn how to make it fruitful. I don’t know of course, whether you are in that category. But I suggest you get the book and see if it helps. Although the author is a Jesuit, his approach to prayer draws heavily from John of the Cross and Theresa of Avila.

God bless.
 
An SD might also be able to help you develop a suitable prayer routine—mine did. I will warn you that it didn’t happen overnight. In fact, it remains a “work in progress” to a certain extent. In any event, I’m praying for you as I know how exasperating dryness can be. :console:
I totally agree with this.

I don’t think it matters if you’re more Benedictine or more Carmelite or some combination of things. What matters is your relationship with God and a spiritual director can help you deepen that. Being able to talk with someone understanding about the ups and downs of your prayer life and develop routines that work for you is a tremendous thing. The prayerful support of a spiritual director makes a huge difference.
 
I want to get a spiritual director and I used to have one a year ago. He was kind of on the liberal side and I couldn’t relate to him much. He still does spiritual direction at our church but I have stayed away for reasons I’ll keep to myself (nothing sexual or creepy). Besides this guy, there is really no one else but the priest. He is a new priest. I’m having some small troubles with him as well but I suppose I can ask him. I would really like a female spiritual director.

I firmly believe that part of my dryness comes from the fact my parish is so dry. The person who teaches religious ed and RCIA while very nice knows less about official doctrines than I do. The parish in general doesn’t know much. I caught our old priest telling people that confession was more of a comfort thing than a necessity :eek: Our new priest has wonderful enthusiasm but he is very focused on making us feel welcome and happy- to the expense of a reverent liturgyy (which is the small problem I stated above). No one seems to care about improving anything but appearances. Devastatingly, at least in my opinion, is the utter lack of persons my age. I don’t feel like there is anyone I can relate to (and I don’t believe there is) I just can’t live in that environment LOL but it is the only place I can go to Mass so I force myself to go.

Eucharistic adoration. I love going. Very rarely I have had to force myself to go but more lately, it has been harder. I just ignore how tired and depressed I am and keep going- like I keep going to Mass.
 
For some people, dryness is just something that God chooses for them - because it is the best way for them to attain holiness. Rather than trying to escape from it, one has to learn how to make it fruitful.
I agree with this, and have found spiritual direction vital in figuring out how to do exactly that—not just helpful, but vital. Direction may also reveal the cause of the dryness (gift from God, result of not persevering in spiritual practice, something else), which potentially makes it easier to react appropriately to it.
I want to get a spiritual director and I used to have one a year ago. …] I would really like a female spiritual director.
If that is your preference I can think of no reason why you can’t have one. (Our parochial vicar had a female SD in high school. Eventually it got to a point where they were no longer making any progress, but she wisely knew it was time to let go and referred him to a priest.) Your priest and/or former SD (if the reasons you’re keeping your distance from him would not prevent you from asking the question) should be able to recommend someone, or at least give you suggestions for where you might find an suitable female SD.
I firmly believe that part of my dryness comes from the fact my parish is so dry. …] but it is the only place I can go to Mass so I force myself to go.

Eucharistic adoration. I love going. Very rarely I have had to force myself to go but more lately, it has been harder. I just ignore how tired and depressed I am and keep going- like I keep going to Mass.
In dryness/desolation, it’s important to keep up our spiritual practices even when we don’t feel like it, even if it seems hollow/fruitless/pointless/etc. I’ve found that can be very, very hard without appropriate guidance, support and accompaniment provided by…an SD. I really encourage you to find an SD promptly. It may the be the best way to find the answer to your initial question as well, and since you’re seeking that answer at least partly because of your dryness I truly believe your best option is to have the assistance of a good SD.

Disclaimer: as I am not you and everyone is different, YMMV.

As I said previously, I’ll be praying for you. And in light of my SD appointment in eleven hours, I’d appreciate it if you (and any other willing soul :)) could keep both my SD and me in your prayers as well. Many thanks in advance, and God bless you! :hug3:
 
Mother Teresa was strong on being faithful and short on emotion. Obedience to what we should do pleases God more than being emotionally on fire. The first we do, the second He does.

So I wouldn’t worry too much about how dry you feel. In fact this will make your prayer even more acceptable if you offer your dryness to him as well.

It is hard to accept this since we don’t think we are praying unless our emotions are involved, and we blame ourselves for not being more enthused, almost indifferent to God.
But that isn’t the case at all.

Being faithful to prayer, especially the same prayer, day after day, gets monotonous and routine because we don’t have to think any more, the prayers become automatic. And so more effort is required and even then the mind wonders. And then the thought comes that we don’t care and are indifferent and to give them up.

He expects faithfulness and our willingness to try. Distractions do not bother him only us.

One prayer you may try is spontaneous prayer. Just talking with the Holy Spirit about anything. Maybe your day, your faults or one of them, a friend you know, your job or someone at work, or just plain telling him how much you appreciate him for every blessing he has given to you. You might also open up the new testiment and read a passage and then talk about it and think on it. This requires maybe 15 minutes out of your day when you can dedicate yourself to it. This is more refreshing prayer. Just remember that he is dwelling with in you when you start and it will go better. That way you talk to him present within you.

May Mary give you her love.
 
I firmly believe that part of my dryness comes from the fact my parish is so dry. The person who teaches religious ed and RCIA while very nice knows less about official doctrines than I do. The parish in general doesn’t know much. I caught our old priest telling people that confession was more of a comfort thing than a necessity :eek: Our new priest has wonderful enthusiasm but he is very focused on making us feel welcome and happy- to the expense of a reverent liturgyy (which is the small problem I stated above). No one seems to care about improving anything but appearances. Devastatingly, at least in my opinion, is the utter lack of persons my age. I don’t feel like there is anyone I can relate to (and I don’t believe there is) I just can’t live in that environment LOL but it is the only place I can go to Mass so I force myself to go.
.
Wow! I understand your spiritual desert now. I’ve been there. So here’s what happened: I found a few reverent rogues hiding in my parish, as well as finding some inspiring, and reverent Catholics, 3 hours from home, at a Latin Mass conference. That kept my spirits up and opened up the “locks” for me. Good luck. You sound amazing.
 
I am a person who is struggling to find out what my spirituality type is. I know there are several different types like Franciscan, Carmelite, Dominican… etc. But from the descriptions I was given I don’t seem to fit anywhere! I am passionate about evangelization, catechesis, study and Scripture but not completely intellectual and bookish- I like helping others but I could never work in some strange country with poor people. I love to contemplate but could not spend all day doing so. Right now I am in a period of spiritual dryness and I’d like to find some devotions that resonate with my spirituality type…if I can find out what it is.

Please help, thanks.
LG can detail what you mean/experience by “I am in a period of spiritual dryness” and
“I love to conetmplate.” How old are you and what is your ethnic/religious background and history?

Apologies for the 20 questions but its hard to be helpful without understanding your context.

One one thing I would say for the moment is that any number of things could be going on but in the normal course of events the no-mans land of dryness must be faced head on. With very very few exceptions noone has ever got anywhere in prayer without facing this brick wall without demur - sometimes for many years. Finding a technique to short-cut this necessary deeping of prayer may well be the opposite of what God asks of you.
However there are exceptions to this and there are good and bad ways of handling this experience.

No point analysing this reality further until we understand your context more fully.
 
Wow! I understand your spiritual desert now. I’ve been there. So here’s what happened: I found a few reverent rogues hiding in my parish, as well as finding some inspiring, and reverent Catholics, 3 hours from home, at a Latin Mass conference. That kept my spirits up and opened up the “locks” for me. Good luck. You sound amazing.
I have actually thought about attending a Latin Mass parish but they are all about 2 hours away. I know I would find younger people there- and ones who value tradition. I have certain alienated myself at my church for expressing traditional views. Funny thing is, today our priest was bemoaning a lack of vocations. I don’t know why they complain about this and then do things that just push the next generation away. We want the tradition back!..sigh, I’ve said too much.

for more on it, you can see my article:
catholicwvengeance.wordpress.com/2012/11/28/what-young-catholics-truly-want/
 
To Blue Horizon:

//LG can detail what you mean/experience by “I am in a period of spiritual dryness” and
“I love to conetmplate.” How old are you and what is your ethnic/religious background and history?//

By dryness I mean I don’t feel motivated to pray. I still do my spiritual reading but that’s about it. I don’t even want to go to Mass because of something new our church is doing that is really irreverent and making me sad. I feel alienated from the people at my church and alone. I dropped out of some church-related activities due to my new job and because I don’t feel like doing them anymore. I often think, what’s the point. I just don’t want to do anything!

I love to think about the mysteries of Christ, the incarnation, the eucharist. Alot of things bring my mind back to this, in movies and in art. Sometimes I just sit and think- I can’t explain it well. Just today, before Mass, I sat and stared at the altar, thinking of what it meant and how important it was…

I am 28 years old.

I grew up Evangelical Protestant. I read alot of the Bible and memorized it. Now as a Catholic I understand it! This is part of why I love Scriptures so much. All the stuff I used to read I can understand now. Been Catholic for 5 years,

No more questions! lol
 
I am a person who is struggling to find out what my spirituality type is. I know there are several different types like Franciscan, Carmelite, Dominican… etc. But from the descriptions I was given I don’t seem to fit anywhere! I am passionate about evangelization, catechesis, study and Scripture but not completely intellectual and bookish- I like helping others but I could never work in some strange country with poor people. I love to contemplate but could not spend all day doing so. Right now I am in a period of spiritual dryness and I’d like to find some devotions that resonate with my spirituality type…if I can find out what it is.

Please help, thanks.
There is a quiz I have used that determined one’s spirituality type but the only ones I could find online are Meyers-Briggs based and I don’t recall that the one I used was. But you could try it.

I would also look into the book “What Does God Want? A Practical Guide to Making Decisions” by Fr. Michael Scanlon. He describes how discerned his vocation to the Franciscan life. It’s a good book even if it might not be what will help you right now.
 
To Blue Horizon:

//LG can detail what you mean/experience by “I am in a period of spiritual dryness” and
“I love to conetmplate.” How old are you and what is your ethnic/religious background and history?//

By dryness I mean I don’t feel motivated to pray. I still do my spiritual reading but that’s about it. I don’t even want to go to Mass because of something new our church is doing that is really irreverent and making me sad. I feel alienated from the people at my church and alone. I dropped out of some church-related activities due to my new job and because I don’t feel like doing them anymore. I often think, what’s the point. I just don’t want to do anything!

I love to think about the mysteries of Christ, the incarnation, the eucharist. Alot of things bring my mind back to this, in movies and in art. Sometimes I just sit and think- I can’t explain it well. Just today, before Mass, I sat and stared at the altar, thinking of what it meant and how important it was…

I am 28 years old.

I grew up Evangelical Protestant. I read alot of the Bible and memorized it. Now as a Catholic I understand it! This is part of why I love Scriptures so much. All the stuff I used to read I can understand now. Been Catholic for 5 years,

No more questions! lol
Thanks LG
I have to be honest and say I do not have much experience re converts from Evangelical Protestantism.

What I can observe though is that Evangelical modes of worship well cater for use of imagination and human affective (not effective) needs in the journey to God. Catholicism (if you get the good stuff) tends to better address the needs of the mind both rational (by a very metaphysical and tight theology) and intuitive (through out modes of mystical devotion).

That you pursued Catholicism despite your background suggests you are a more rational/intuitive sort of personality … yet now the lack of affective, communally-connected experience (Catholics are a bit passive in that area) may be starting to kick in. That you are not a “cradle Catholic” may contribute to a feeling of not really being fully part of your present parish despite the social activity you mention. Catholics can be a bit “old boys/girls club” that way sometimes. (Or maybe you are not having this experience at all - hard to say from your comments).

I suppose I am saying that maybe you have strong affective needs (despite your announced rationality) that were answered in your old church (but you weren’t aware of that) and now they may not be. It appears that your more private, interior “mystical” experience, which I see you love, may have been compensating for the lack of external communal affectivity/connection. Possibly you are realising your interior life is not adequately compensating for the lack of exterior emotional support that we all need (some more than others).

It is very difficult to discern, in the spiritual life, whether dryness indicates we need to mature and let go of the sweets of immaturity (this is the usual Catholic advice) OR we have somehow gotten ourselves into a situation where somehow our very real and valid personal needs are seriously (and even dangerously at times) not being met. I cannot remember who said, “great pain is God’s megaphone that we’ve gone the wrong way!” its not always true, but it is good balancing advice.

Sometimes the answer is both.

What do you think re your present situation?
Obviously it is not “great pain”, but it could be a symptom that you are somehow unwisely or clumsily ignoring valid emotional needs. (If this is the case there is often an embarrassing, barely conscious “taperecorder” or a daydream that keeps playing in our head which we keep ignoring pushing into the dark.). If it increases in intensity as our pain increases … this is significant.

Does this mean anything to you?

If not just forget my advice. Your dryness is no more than the usual spiritual maturation process. Attend to the usual suspects … the Sacraments, the Commandments, love of neighbour, personal prayer (it needs to become less imaginative, emotional and exploratory and become more simple, a letting-go of your will and of active thinking - more about being passively attentive without much interior visual content)…and all will be well.

As the Cure of Ars once said to someone who asked him how he spent his hours daily sitting in the quiet pews of his own church, “Well, I just look at Jesus and he looks at me.” He was speaking of a “sensed” presence deeper than that of the visible, plaster crucifix above the altar. Whatever happens in your life don’t give up “chasing” (or rather “being chased”) by that prayerful presence. And when it abides with you in Church, then try and take it with you outside into daily life.

Re the spiritual reading - look up “lectio divina” - it should lead, for beginners, into meditation (look that up also). A time comes when meditation has to be dropped (which can become torture if you hold onto it too long) and go into “contemplation”. I am not sure you understand these words in the traditional Catholic sense, everybody means just about everything by them. Online Catholic Encyclopedia may be helpful,
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top