Trouble in my faith

  • Thread starter Thread starter doke
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
D

doke

Guest
Sometimes i just think christianity was made up by the roman government to try to control its people. And there were religons as far back as we can date. Once people became smarter they started asking themselves who created the earth. The old testimant says that first god created Adam and Eve. But the Jewish God of Abraham, who supposivly communicated with adam and eve. If they were the first people created, and they belived in the bible’s God, then they would have passed it on to everybody. Yet, there were religons very far predating anything in the bible.

This has just been troubling me as i want to believe in christ very much but can’t kick my logic out of my head.

Please give me some advice
 
Sometimes i just think christianity was made up by the roman government to try to control its people. And there were religons as far back as we can date. Once people became smarter they started asking themselves who created the earth. The old testimant says that first god created Adam and Eve. But the Jewish God of Abraham, who supposivly communicated with adam and eve. If they were the first people created, and they belived in the bible’s God, then they would have passed it on to everybody. Yet, there were religons very far predating anything in the bible.

This has just been troubling me as i want to believe in christ very much but can’t kick my logic out of my head.

Please give me some advice
I can certainly understand a doubter’s proclivities towards unbelief, as my life has been a roller coaster of faith (Christian to a dark 10-year atheism to Catholic). I now have certitude in my faith. Other religions that predate do not explain everything. To their credit, they do explain a lot with myths and legends. But seriously, if somebody made up the Bible, what crazy mind would have thought that up? God’s people being led through many places and being the slaves to sin. God (the Creator of Life) takes the gift of life to those who refuse to cherish it. God comes down from eternity into our temporal realm (the only religion that God or a god does this) to redeem His own people by destroying death and sin on the cross with an unimaginable suffering, gives His people new life by “putting on Christ” in the Resurrection and giving His people hope into attaining everlasting joy with their Source of the Life, Truth and Love that created them and the world they live in.

Know that there is a different between difficulties and doubts. A difficulty is just that. If we jump to conclusions we lead to anxiety and depression. A healthy doubt would lead one looking for answers which is kind of what you are doing. An unhealthy doubt would lead one to almost despair in life which is also kind of what you are doing.

Reason, logic and rationalities are not the ony sources of knowledge. Please understand that. Sometimes those make it more complex. Can I demonstrate with any of those 3 that my mom loves me? Perhaps to an extent but that in itself will not suffice. I have certitude in that. Can you reasonably, logically or rationally demonstrate or prove the existence of Berlin as a city in German? Can I prove that I exist? I have certitude with all of these things beyond a reasonable doubt even though I cannot conclusively prove through my mind. I have more reasons why God does not exist than any atheist book or person I have every come across. But if I deny God, I would have to bring something else to the table and nobody can do that. I do have 1 irrefutable reason why He does exist. That is all I need.

Read the book “Faith and Certitude” by Thomas Dubay… That is if you can find it. Try to observe your thoughts rather then let them control you and your emotions because they will affect your body.

Calm down, my friend. There is no need to panic. We all go through doubts and difficulties. Trust me that I have faith in Christ although I am bad sometimes. Mary is helping me with my spiritual side. Anyway, I hope this helps and just breathe. Calm down. Just observe your thoughts until they pass and make simple prayers. The Our Father, Hail Mary and a little personal prayer for yourself. This will go away. I promise.

Your friend in Christ,
Gregg
 
Sometimes i just think christianity was made up by the roman government to try to control its people.
Faith issues aside, history does not support this view. For the first several hundred years of Christian history the roman government spent considerable effort trying to purge Christianity from existence.

And there were religons as far back as we can date. Once people became smarter they started asking themselves who created the earth. The old testimant says that first god created Adam and Eve. But the Jewish God of Abraham, who supposivly communicated with adam and eve. If they were the first people created, and they belived in the bible’s God, then they would have passed it on to everybody. Yet, there were religons very far predating anything in the bible.

Though they are one and the same God [the God of Adam and Eve and the God of the Bible] our first parents precede the bible by thousands of years. i.e. plenty of time for multiple tribes and religions to form.

We don’t get any of the Old Testament scripture until the time of Moses.

For reasons know only to God, He chose to reveal himself to mankind gradually, first through the decedents of Abraham and eventually to all mankind in Jesus Christ.
This has just been troubling me as i want to believe in christ very much but can’t kick my logic out of my head.

Please give me some advice
Pray, then study, then pray some more.

Many of the greatest thinkers the world has ever known found no logical conflicts with belief in God in general or Christianity and Catholicism in particular.

You might try reading some of their works.

Chuck
 
Sometimes i just think christianity was made up by the roman government to try to control its people. And there were religons as far back as we can date. Once people became smarter they started asking themselves who created the earth. The old testimant says that first god created Adam and Eve. But the Jewish God of Abraham, who supposivly communicated with adam and eve. If they were the first people created, and they belived in the bible’s God, then they would have passed it on to everybody. Yet, there were religons very far predating anything in the bible.

This has just been troubling me as i want to believe in christ very much but can’t kick my logic out of my head.

Please give me some advice
First of all, the reasons there were religions as far back as history takes us is because God placed a yearning in each one of us to seek him. But God revealed himself to us in stages.

Your issue seems to be that if God spoke to Adam and Eve, why didn’t they pass that information on . Well, they did, right? It was passed on by word of mouth for generation upon generation until it was finally written down. No one can date that.
 
Sometimes i just think christianity was made up by the roman government to try to control its people. And there were religons as far back as we can date. Once people became smarter they started asking themselves who created the earth. The old testimant says that first god created Adam and Eve. But the Jewish God of Abraham, who supposivly communicated with adam and eve. If they were the first people created, and they belived in the bible’s God, then they would have passed it on to everybody. Yet, there were religons very far predating anything in the bible.

This has just been troubling me as i want to believe in christ very much but can’t kick my logic out of my head.

Please give me some advice
Adam & Eve didn’t have a religion-they simply had direct knowledge of God-a knowledge that religion-at least Judaism and Christianity seeks to restore. But “faith died in mans heart” due to the original sin according to the Catechism, so Adam & Eve had nothing to pass along-they forfeited the knowledge of God by rebelling against Him, i.e. He was no longer their God.

And reconciling this separation is the entire purpose of Gods plan of salvation, walking with man through history via the Jews until man was ready for God to come in a more direct and profound manner-when He walked and lived and then died among us, revealing His true self-the God who is love-the God we need in a direct manner in order to live and have life abundantly.

BTW, the Romans didn’t invent Christianity; history tells us many blamed Christianity for the fall of the empire.
 
Sometimes i just think christianity was made up by the roman government to try to control its people. And there were religons as far back as we can date. Once people became smarter they started asking themselves who created the earth. The old testimant says that first god created Adam and Eve. But the Jewish God of Abraham, who supposivly communicated with adam and eve. If they were the first people created, and they belived in the bible’s God, then they would have passed it on to everybody. Yet, there were religons very far predating anything in the bible.

This has just been troubling me as i want to believe in christ very much but can’t kick my logic out of my head.

Please give me some advice
I wish you could explain to me just how a pagan nation that believed in no God could invented Christianity. it just doesnt make any sense. it seems to me the same argument is made by non Catholics that constantine converted and invented the Catholic Church. how can someone convert and then invent another church? if he converted to whatever these people say he did, how can a convert invent the CC? your argument is that you think you know more than God. God has a way of doing things, and it is not our way, that is for sure. submit yourself to the will of God and things starts to fall into place. none of us is perfect and we tend to fall into temptation. one of these temptations is to stop believing that God is One Living God. He is to all people. but many back then, just like today rejects Him. if one rejects Him, you cannot blame Him for it.

I think you are giving to much credit to a pagan nation instead of giving God the credit for converting a pagan like Roma into believing in One Holy God. history tells us that the roman empire fell while the Kingdom of God took over. what better history could we have than seeing the pagan empire falling and the Kingdom of God rise in its place? just think about that.
 
Sometimes i just think christianity was made up by the roman government to try to control its people.
Yes, exactly. If you want to control people create a religion they all want to be a part of. It should have these attributes:
  • make it illegal to join
  • put to death those you catch practicing it
  • make it attractive to others by spreading propaganda that includes baby killing sacrifices and cannibalism
For those who do join, make it really exciting by:
  • requiring adherents to buck all the social norms of the day including types of jobs they can hold
  • make it a religion completely at odds with the permissive sexual culture of the day, make it a sin to do all the fun things
  • require aspirants to study, pray, and fast for 3 years just to join
  • give severe penances lasting upwards of 7 years to those who sin
  • require all these hard things so it will be really attractive to the broadest spectrum of people and very popular
Yes, that’s exactly what I would do if I were a government trying to control people
And there were religons as far back as we can date.
And this has *what *to do with anything?
Once people became smarter they started asking themselves who created the earth. The old testimant says that first god created Adam and Eve. But the Jewish God of Abraham, who supposivly communicated with adam and eve. If they were the first people created, and they belived in the bible’s God, then they would have passed it on to everybody. Yet, there were religons very far predating anything in the bible.
Some flawed logic there. There were not religions “predating” anything in the bible, because the bible tells us of our origins.

Various religions predate the calling out of the Jewish people as a nation in the time of Abraham.

Yes, Adam and Eve walked with God. They also sinned. This darkened their intellect. Over time, many people moved farther and farther away from the truth-- never denying the existence of God but distorting it in numerous ways including polytheism, worship of nature, etc.
This has just been troubling me as i want to believe in christ very much but can’t kick my logic out of my head.

Please give me some advice
Frankly I don’t think your argument is logical at all.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top