Truly Catholic?

  • Thread starter Thread starter frail
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
F

frail

Guest
My first real experience with church and God in general was with the Catholic Church. As a teenager I had stayed the night at a friend’s house(he’s Catholic) and I went to Mass with him on Sunday morning. I thoroughly enjoyed it and started going with him every Sunday.

I was at an Easter Vigil Mass and had watched someone be received into the Church and I decided that night that I wanted to become Catholic. I was assigned a sponsor and started weekly RCIA classes with the parish Priest. Because of my young age he wanted me to be absolutely sure of my decision so he told me I would have attend RCIA for two years before he would receive me into the Church.

After about a year of RCIA, I had started going to a youth group sponsored by a local Non-denominational church. The pastor of that church was a former Catholic seminarian. Once he found that I was on the road to becoming Catholic, he immediately started pouring the proverbial poison into my ear about the Catholic Church and I started having doubts as to the validity of the Catholic faith.

One night at RCIA, I had a question that the parish Priest didn’t answer to my satisfaction it led to me abandoning RCIA and eventually the Catholic faith.

Somewhere down the road I eventually stopped believing in God because people had asked me questions I couldn’t answer and it stirred up some doubts, one of which to this day remains unresolved.

That was about 13 years ago and I am now 28. During the last 13 years I’ve read every apologetic work I could get my hands on, every book on miracles, apparitions, etc and I will say that my faith has increased, but it’s not where I’d like it to be.

Last year, around the time The Passion of the Christ came out in theaters, I had a desire to become Catholic again. Being in the military, I went to speak with the Catholic chaplain on base and informed him of my intentions and that I had completed a year of RCIA in the past. Though I did leave out that I was supposed to complete two years.

He received me into the Church, right there and then in his office. I made Confession, was Confirmed and received my first Holy Communion later that day. I was overjoyed, but the doubts and sins of my past started to catch up with me again and I’ve since stopped practicing.

I also regret that I wasn’t completely honest with the priest who received me about my doubts and that I hadn’t completed the full two years of RCIA. It makes me wonder if my Confession and Confirmation were truly valid and if I am indeed truly a Catholic at all.

I’ve also considered mentioning this at my next Confession, but another Priest advised me to let it go. He told to confess it if I felt the need to, but it wasn’t required. He said it’s more important that I live the the Catholic faith and not worry so much about how I actually became Catholic.

Any opinions, insights, suggestions and even criticisms are welcome and appreciated.
 
I guess what I would say to you is this. You are Catholic. Practice it. Even though your circumstances may have been a little different than usual you were still received into the Church. Do not worry how you got there - but just that you are there and it is time to live it.

Confession is a way to unburden our hearts and lift that heavy load we feel we must carry. In truth that suffering is already gone if only you would let it go. God forgave you before you even asked. So confess again if you must and let it be in the past.

Even though you may be an impressionable person - you cannot let others poison your thoughts. Resist these temptations that others may be right. Multiple times now you have been drawn back to the ONE TRUE CHURCH. You already know where you belong in your heart; it is time to convince your mind and get rid of the weakness holding you back from fully celebrating this joy in your life. Embrace your Catholic faith - make it who you are!! Your life will only multiply in blessings. Remember that you have the most patient teacher, forgiver, friend, love and oh so much more! He will walk you through it if you extend your hand.

God bless and good luck with this new chance to practice your faith!
 
40.png
frail:
My first real experience with church and God in general was with the Catholic Church. As a teenager I had stayed the night at a friend’s house(he’s Catholic) and I went to Mass with him on Sunday morning. I thoroughly enjoyed it and started going with him every Sunday.

I was at an Easter Vigil Mass and had watched someone be received into the Church and I decided that night that I wanted to become Catholic. I was assigned a sponsor and started weekly RCIA classes with the parish Priest. Because of my young age he wanted me to be absolutely sure of my decision so he told me I would have attend RCIA for two years before he would receive me into the Church.

After about a year of RCIA, I had started going to a youth group sponsored by a local Non-denominational church. The pastor of that church was a former Catholic seminarian. Once he found that I was on the road to becoming Catholic, he immediately started pouring the proverbial poison into my ear about the Catholic Church and I started having doubts as to the validity of the Catholic faith.

One night at RCIA, I had a question that the parish Priest didn’t answer to my satisfaction it led to me abandoning RCIA and eventually the Catholic faith.

Somewhere down the road I eventually stopped believing in God because people had asked me questions I couldn’t answer and it stirred up some doubts, one of which to this day remains unresolved.

That was about 13 years ago and I am now 28. During the last 13 years I’ve read every apologetic work I could get my hands on, every book on miracles, apparitions, etc and I will say that my faith has increased, but it’s not where I’d like it to be.

Last year, around the time The Passion of the Christ came out in theaters, I had a desire to become Catholic again. Being in the military, I went to speak with the Catholic chaplain on base and informed him of my intentions and that I had completed a year of RCIA in the past. Though I did leave out that I was supposed to complete two years.

He received me into the Church, right there and then in his office. I made Confession, was Confirmed and received my first Holy Communion later that day. I was overjoyed, but the doubts and sins of my past started to catch up with me again and I’ve since stopped practicing.

I also regret that I wasn’t completely honest with the priest who received me about my doubts and that I hadn’t completed the full two years of RCIA. It makes me wonder if my Confession and Confirmation were truly valid and if I am indeed truly a Catholic at all.

I’ve also considered mentioning this at my next Confession, but another Priest advised me to let it go. He told to confess it if I felt the need to, but it wasn’t required. He said it’s more important that I live the the Catholic faith and not worry so much about how I actually became Catholic.

Any opinions, insights, suggestions and even criticisms are welcome and appreciated.
What prompted you to leave the non-denominational Church with the former Catholic seminarian pastor? Did they give you simplistic answers? I know that many former Catholics who are now evangelicals have an axe to grind with the Catholic church.
You’ve, no doubt, heard the spiel…Jesus has siblings, there are only 66 books in the Bible, not 72, Mary was not “sinless,” nor is she “co-Mediatrix,” Purgatory is man’s invention, infant baptism is invalid, communion is only symbolic, blah, blah, blah.

It’s just as bad as Catholics that constantly insist that evangelicals are ignoring the facts or else they would become Catholics. People don’t become Catholics for a variety of reasons, even after they have carefully examined all the facts.

Holding to orthodox Christian theology is fine and good, but being a Christian is much more than that. Give me a happy Mormon or Seventh-Day Adventist any day over a miserable, but theologically sound, Catholic.
 
40.png
Tibbar:
What prompted you to leave the non-denominational Church with the former Catholic seminarian pastor? Did they give you simplistic answers? I know that many former Catholics who are now evangelicals have an axe to grind with the Catholic church.
You’ve, no doubt, heard the spiel…Jesus has siblings, there are only 66 books in the Bible, not 72, Mary was not “sinless,” nor is she “co-Mediatrix,” Purgatory is man’s invention, infant baptism is invalid, communion is only symbolic, blah, blah, blah.
I felt more spiritually fulfilled in the Catholic Church. “Something” was always missing that I could only find in the Catholic faith. It’s such a rich faith. In my opinion, non-Catholics miss out on so much.
 
40.png
frail:
I felt more spiritually fulfilled in the Catholic Church. “Something” was always missing that I could only find in the Catholic faith. It’s such a rich faith. In my opinion, non-Catholics miss out on so much.
Welcome to the CAF! 👍

You sound like me only half-a-year ago, when I, too, started looking into a non-denominational church. After only a couple of services, and luckily, no Catholic-bashing, I, too, felt that somthing was missing in their worship, and I dove right back in to my Catholic faith.

You are truly blessed - the Holy Spirit has filled your heart and lead you to where you needed to be. Be thankful that you were recieved in the Church, that you are a full Catholic, and live your life through your faith in the Risen Saviour, Jesus Christ, as part of His Church, and in union with all those who believe in Him through the Sacrament of the Eucharist.

God Bless You! 👍
 
40.png
frail:
My first real experience with church and God in general was with the Catholic Church. As a teenager I had stayed the night at a friend’s house(he’s Catholic) and I went to Mass with him on Sunday morning. I thoroughly enjoyed it and started going with him every Sunday.

I was at an Easter Vigil Mass and had watched someone be received into the Church and I decided that night that I wanted to become Catholic. I was assigned a sponsor and started weekly RCIA classes with the parish Priest. Because of my young age he wanted me to be absolutely sure of my decision so he told me I would have attend RCIA for two years before he would receive me into the Church.

After about a year of RCIA, I had started going to a youth group sponsored by a local Non-denominational church. The pastor of that church was a former Catholic seminarian. Once he found that I was on the road to becoming Catholic, he immediately started pouring the proverbial poison into my ear about the Catholic Church and I started having doubts as to the validity of the Catholic faith.

One night at RCIA, I had a question that the parish Priest didn’t answer to my satisfaction it led to me abandoning RCIA and eventually the Catholic faith.

Somewhere down the road I eventually stopped believing in God because people had asked me questions I couldn’t answer and it stirred up some doubts, one of which to this day remains unresolved.

That was about 13 years ago and I am now 28. During the last 13 years I’ve read every apologetic work I could get my hands on, every book on miracles, apparitions, etc and I will say that my faith has increased, but it’s not where I’d like it to be.

Last year, around the time The Passion of the Christ came out in theaters, I had a desire to become Catholic again. Being in the military, I went to speak with the Catholic chaplain on base and informed him of my intentions and that I had completed a year of RCIA in the past. Though I did leave out that I was supposed to complete two years.

He received me into the Church, right there and then in his office. I made Confession, was Confirmed and received my first Holy Communion later that day. I was overjoyed, but the doubts and sins of my past started to catch up with me again and I’ve since stopped practicing.

I also regret that I wasn’t completely honest with the priest who received me about my doubts and that I hadn’t completed the full two years of RCIA. It makes me wonder if my Confession and Confirmation were truly valid and if I am indeed truly a Catholic at all.

I’ve also considered mentioning this at my next Confession, but another Priest advised me to let it go. He told to confess it if I felt the need to, but it wasn’t required. He said it’s more important that I live the the Catholic faith and not worry so much about how I actually became Catholic.

Any opinions, insights, suggestions and even criticisms are welcome and appreciated.
I cannot find anything in your post that would lead me to believe that there would be even a possibility that your confirmation and confession were invalid.
 
If your intentions were sincere at the time then I see no validity issues. If you have questions then practice your faith while seeking answers. Don’t allow questions to stop you from practicing your faith. Ask God to guide you as to how to proceed. My advice.
 
40.png
frail:
He received me into the Church, right there and then in his office.
Welcome home.

If you still feel you have something to learn I suggest you begin a course of apologetics, either books or using the many tapes that are available, by such wonderful converts as Scott Hahn.

I am currently listening to Scott’s set of talks on The Lamb’s Supper: The Mass and the Apocalypse and there are so many more. The link is
ewtn.com/vondemand/audio/file_index.asp?SeriesId=6607&pgnu=
👍
 
40.png
frail:
He said it’s more important that I live the the Catholic faith and not worry so much about how I actually became Catholic.
.
The priest has spoken. Words of wisdom. Quit worrying about your faith and start LIVING your faith. We all have “pasts”… why worry about them? Live your faith NOW. Presevere.
 
Eileen T:
Welcome home.

If you still feel you have something to learn I suggest you begin a course of apologetics, either books or using the many tapes that are available, by such wonderful converts as Scott Hahn.

I am currently listening to Scott’s set of talks on The Lamb’s Supper: The Mass and the Apocalypse and there are so many more. The link is
ewtn.com/vondemand/audio/file_index.asp?SeriesId=6607&pgnu=
👍
Thanks Eileen. Scott Hahn’s “Rome Sweet Home” is what helped put alot of my doubts to rest.

And to all:

I appreciate your responses. The advice given is sound so I guess I just need to act on it. Thank you all.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top