Trying to Understand Old Testament History

  • Thread starter Thread starter SpeakKindly
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
S

SpeakKindly

Guest
So, I watch this video of Father Barron’s on Youtube recently: youtube.com/watch?v=1A65Wfr2is0

What he was talking about is the violence that we read about in the Old Testament. He said that if we read it in such a way that we think violence is okay, or that God is a violent being, then we’re reading the Scripture incorrectly. He goes on to say that we should read them more metaphorically, or as an allegory, to understand the spiritual meaning behind what those stories mean. He said that these would be very important for the Jewish people to understand their God as a God who isn’t weak, who fights for His people, and destroys His enemies, and destroys sin.

I asked my RCIA instructor if we are not necessarily meant to believe these events really happened, and she said that the events were from the Israelite’s perspective. I was confused by this, and asked if she was saying that everything the Bible says God did, is actually what God did, or if it was from a human perspective, and they just interpreted it.

She said that the two creation stories in Genesis shows that not everything in the Bible that God is said to do (two creations of humans, was her example), is accurate. So, I asked her if something like where God hides Himself from His people was real, or if they just stopped listening, and she said that we don’t know.

So, how ARE we supposed to view the history and God’s interaction with people - is it from a human perspective and interpretation and could not be accurate on God’s involvement at all (and they’re just worth reading for the spiritual understanding), or are they literal events where God DID interact (like “confusing the enemy”, or “hiding Himself from His people”)?

Are they just good stories with good meanings, but potentially from a fallible viewpoint, or real stories with good meanings for those who read it still? If they’re not real events, then that makes them sound like myths or legends.
 
This is a difficult stumbling block for many people in our society because we simply cannot understand the nature of society in OT times. It was so wholly and completely different from what we have today that there are really no analogous systems we can compare it to. The closest thing we have today is the tribal mentality of many of the African Tribe.

As for how to read the OT, it is important to understand that, although divinely inspired, it is still written so that humans can understand it, and therefore cannot fully express the nature of God (since we cannot fully comprehend his nature we cannot fully express it). The OT attempts to express the nature of God from a human perspective, and as such it frequently used concepts like anger to express God’s retribution when His people rejected him (happens a lot in the OT… happens a lot nowadays to… happened big time when they decided to, you know… kill his son…). However, anger is not really an appropriate term in discussing God, we just don’t have another way of describing it from our viewpoint.

There are portions of the OT which are allegorical, and there are portions which are quite literal. The creation accounts, for example, are probably allegory meant to express certain Truths. #1: All of creation is a result of God’s will. #2 God fashioned humanity for a purpose. Whether that occurred over time through evolution, or instantaneously through creation is up for debate, but the fact remains that God created us, and chose to give us rational souls (the first two truly human people were the first man and woman to whom God granted a rational soul). #3: Sometime after receiving our rational souls, our first parents (Adam and Eve, as we call them) made a decision to reject God in some way shape or form (Original Sin), and that stain has impeded our ability to fully know God ever since. All of this may have occurred, word for word as it happened in the OT, and you are free to believe that if you chose to; you are also free to believe that the creation account is allegorical, and express the Truth about our human nature in an easy to understand manner. (That existence of Adam and Eve as our first parents and as the progenitors of our race is not up for debate, and has long been expressed as Dogma. However, the nature of their sin is unknown, it could have been eating an apple, or it could have been something else entirely.)

In the end, there is no one way to label to OT. It is a highly, highly complex book developed over hundreds, if not thousands of years. It is the cumulative history of the original people of God, the Israelites. Many people have devoted their entire lives to studying it, and have still only scratched the surface. We believe that it is the divinely inspired word of God, but that it is also written so that humans could understand it and derive meaning from it. There are a number of people here who can do a much better job of explaining it than I can, but I do hope that my explanation has helped you in some way. Additionally, if you go to the Catholic Answers main site and search around, I’m pretty sure there are quite a few tracts discussing the reliability of the OT from both a theological and historical perspective.

Additionally, you make mention of the violence in the OT. It is quite true that we believe that most of those battles did occur as recorded; and it is also true that the Israelites did some violent things. This relates back to our being unable to understand the nature of their society at the time. This is an excellent series of articles, written by Jimmy Akin, which looks at a lot of the “dark passages” in depth. It helped me to understand them, and I know it has helped many others on these forums. I highly suggest you read them.

The Dark Passages of Scripture

One last thing. Congratulations on taking the first step towards becoming Catholic and joining RCIA. It is a difficult journey, but one that is well worth travelling. God bless you, and I pray that you find the answers you are looking for ^^
 
So, I watch this video of Father Barron’s on Youtube recently: youtube.com/watch?v=1A65Wfr2is0

What he was talking about is the violence that we read about in the Old Testament. He said that if we read it in such a way that we think violence is okay, or that God is a violent being, then we’re reading the Scripture incorrectly. He goes on to say that we should read them more metaphorically, or as an allegory, to understand the spiritual meaning behind what those stories mean. He said that these would be very important for the Jewish people to understand their God as a God who isn’t weak, who fights for His people, and destroys His enemies, and destroys sin.

I asked my RCIA instructor if we are not necessarily meant to believe these events really happened, and she said that the events were from the Israelite’s perspective. I was confused by this, and asked if she was saying that everything the Bible says God did, is actually what God did, or if it was from a human perspective, and they just interpreted it.

She said that the two creation stories in Genesis shows that not everything in the Bible that God is said to do (two creations of humans, was her example), is accurate. So, I asked her if something like where God hides Himself from His people was real, or if they just stopped listening, and she said that we don’t know.

So, how ARE we supposed to view the history and God’s interaction with people - is it from a human perspective and interpretation and could not be accurate on God’s involvement at all (and they’re just worth reading for the spiritual understanding), or are they literal events where God DID interact (like “confusing the enemy”, or “hiding Himself from His people”)?

Are they just good stories with good meanings, but potentially from a fallible viewpoint, or real stories with good meanings for those who read it still? If they’re not real events, then that makes them sound like myths or legends.
I do not think that interpreting those passages metaphorically rules out the possibility that the events actually happened.

I have not seen the video in question, but I would imagine Fr. Barron’s point is simply that we cannot take the events described in the Old Testament as somehow indicative that God approves violence and bloodshed. The allegorical meaning of those passages is the lesson to be learned rather than learning that smiting our enemies is a God-approved pasttime. And this is the case whether or not we interpret those passages as depicting actual historical events.

God is the Master Storyteller who can weave the story of salvation even with uncooperative, imperfect sinners. So even though the people depicted in Scripture often get far more wrong than they get right, it all comes together to show us who God is and who He has revealed Himself to be.
 
This is a difficult stumbling block for many people in our society because we simply cannot understand the nature of society in OT times. It was so wholly and completely different from what we have today that there are really no analogous systems we can compare it to. The closest thing we have today is the tribal mentality of many of the African Tribe.

As for how to read the OT, it is important to understand that, although divinely inspired, it is still written so that humans can understand it, and therefore cannot fully express the nature of God (since we cannot fully comprehend his nature we cannot fully express it). The OT attempts to express the nature of God from a human perspective, and as such it frequently used concepts like anger to express God’s retribution when His people rejected him (happens a lot in the OT… happens a lot nowadays to… happened big time when they decided to, you know… kill his son…). However, anger is not really an appropriate term in discussing God, we just don’t have another way of describing it from our viewpoint.

There are portions of the OT which are allegorical, and there are portions which are quite literal. The creation accounts, for example, are probably allegory meant to express certain Truths. #1: All of creation is a result of God’s will. #2 God fashioned humanity for a purpose. Whether that occurred over time through evolution, or instantaneously through creation is up for debate, but the fact remains that God created us, and chose to give us rational souls (the first two truly human people were the first man and woman to whom God granted a rational soul). #3: Sometime after receiving our rational souls, our first parents (Adam and Eve, as we call them) made a decision to reject God in some way shape or form (Original Sin), and that stain has impeded our ability to fully know God ever since. All of this may have occurred, word for word as it happened in the OT, and you are free to believe that if you chose to; you are also free to believe that the creation account is allegorical, and express the Truth about our human nature in an easy to understand manner. (That existence of Adam and Eve as our first parents and as the progenitors of our race is not up for debate, and has long been expressed as Dogma. However, the nature of their sin is unknown, it could have been eating an apple, or it could have been something else entirely.)

In the end, there is no one way to label to OT. It is a highly, highly complex book developed over hundreds, if not thousands of years. It is the cumulative history of the original people of God, the Israelites. Many people have devoted their entire lives to studying it, and have still only scratched the surface. We believe that it is the divinely inspired word of God, but that it is also written so that humans could understand it and derive meaning from it. There are a number of people here who can do a much better job of explaining it than I can, but I do hope that my explanation has helped you in some way. Additionally, if you go to the Catholic Answers main site and search around, I’m pretty sure there are quite a few tracts discussing the reliability of the OT from both a theological and historical perspective.

Additionally, you make mention of the violence in the OT. It is quite true that we believe that most of those battles did occur as recorded; and it is also true that the Israelites did some violent things. This relates back to our being unable to understand the nature of their society at the time. This is an excellent series of articles, written by Jimmy Akin, which looks at a lot of the “dark passages” in depth. It helped me to understand them, and I know it has helped many others on these forums. I highly suggest you read them.

The Dark Passages of Scripture

One last thing. Congratulations on taking the first step towards becoming Catholic and joining RCIA. It is a difficult journey, but one that is well worth travelling. God bless you, and I pray that you find the answers you are looking for ^^
Thank you (both of the people who have posted already), so would it be incorrect to assume that when the Old Testament says something like, God broke chariots, and confused the hoses of the Phillistines, or when He hide His face from them, or broke down the walls of Jericho, does that mean that God really did those things - or is it a human perspective that “Hey we won because we prayed!”, or “God’s not listening to me”, but in reality it’s us not listening to God? :confused:
 
Thank you (both of the people who have posted already), so would it be incorrect to assume that when the Old Testament says something like, God broke chariots, and confused the hoses of the Phillistines, or when He hide His face from them, or broke down the walls of Jericho, does that mean that God really did those things - or is it a human perspective that “Hey we won because we prayed!”, or “God’s not listening to me”, but in reality it’s us not listening to God? :confused:
There are many passages in the Old Testament that use anthropomorphic language about God. Even back with Adam and Eve, it talks of God “walking in the garden”. Some passages speak of God being “angry” or otherwise attributing human emotions to God.

Not to speak too generally (as I’m sure it varies based on the passage) but I think much of that is simply descriptive of the perception of the Old Testament people rather than being descriptive in a literalistic way.
 
There are many passages in the Old Testament that use anthropomorphic language about God. Even back with Adam and Eve, it talks of God “walking in the garden”. Some passages speak of God being “angry” or otherwise attributing human emotions to God.

Not to speak too generally (as I’m sure it varies based on the passage) but I think much of that is simply descriptive of the perception of the Old Testament people rather than being descriptive in a literalistic way.
Okay, that make sense. 🙂

So, when the Bible says (I can’t remember the exact spot), that God interacts during a war the Israelites were fighting, and broke the wheels of the chariots, and confused their horses, that we can assume that it wasn’t just the perspective of the Israelites, but that God actually was at work there?

I guess I’m confused because I’m not sure what to think about the Old Testament mentioning God involving Himself in wars, and other thing, because I was told that was possibly just the Israelite’s interpretation (like them winning a war might have been because they were protected by God, or perhaps they just happened to be faithfully praying at the time, and won, but it wasn’t the praying that won). 🤷
 
So, I watch this video of Father Barron’s on Youtube recently: youtube.com/watch?v=1A65Wfr2is0

What he was talking about is the violence that we read about in the Old Testament. He said that if we read it in such a way that we think violence is okay, or that God is a violent being, then we’re reading the Scripture incorrectly. He goes on to say that we should read them more metaphorically, or as an allegory, to understand the spiritual meaning behind what those stories mean. He said that these would be very important for the Jewish people to understand their God as a God who isn’t weak, who fights for His people, and destroys His enemies, and destroys sin.

I asked my RCIA instructor if we are not necessarily meant to believe these events really happened, and she said that the events were from the Israelite’s perspective. I was confused by this, and asked if she was saying that everything the Bible says God did, is actually what God did, or if it was from a human perspective, and they just interpreted it.

She said that the two creation stories in Genesis shows that not everything in the Bible that God is said to do (two creations of humans, was her example), is accurate. So, I asked her if something like where God hides Himself from His people was real, or if they just stopped listening, and she said that we don’t know.

So, how ARE we supposed to view the history and God’s interaction with people - is it from a human perspective and interpretation and could not be accurate on God’s involvement at all (and they’re just worth reading for the spiritual understanding), or are they literal events where God DID interact (like “confusing the enemy”, or “hiding Himself from His people”)?

Are they just good stories with good meanings, but potentially from a fallible viewpoint, or real stories with good meanings for those who read it still? If they’re not real events, then that makes them sound like myths or legends.
This article explains quite well why some places are historical and not metaphorical.
unamsanctamcatholicam.blogspot.com/2009/02/genocide-of-joshua-part-1.html
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top