S
SpeakKindly
Guest
So, I watch this video of Father Barron’s on Youtube recently: youtube.com/watch?v=1A65Wfr2is0
What he was talking about is the violence that we read about in the Old Testament. He said that if we read it in such a way that we think violence is okay, or that God is a violent being, then we’re reading the Scripture incorrectly. He goes on to say that we should read them more metaphorically, or as an allegory, to understand the spiritual meaning behind what those stories mean. He said that these would be very important for the Jewish people to understand their God as a God who isn’t weak, who fights for His people, and destroys His enemies, and destroys sin.
I asked my RCIA instructor if we are not necessarily meant to believe these events really happened, and she said that the events were from the Israelite’s perspective. I was confused by this, and asked if she was saying that everything the Bible says God did, is actually what God did, or if it was from a human perspective, and they just interpreted it.
She said that the two creation stories in Genesis shows that not everything in the Bible that God is said to do (two creations of humans, was her example), is accurate. So, I asked her if something like where God hides Himself from His people was real, or if they just stopped listening, and she said that we don’t know.
So, how ARE we supposed to view the history and God’s interaction with people - is it from a human perspective and interpretation and could not be accurate on God’s involvement at all (and they’re just worth reading for the spiritual understanding), or are they literal events where God DID interact (like “confusing the enemy”, or “hiding Himself from His people”)?
Are they just good stories with good meanings, but potentially from a fallible viewpoint, or real stories with good meanings for those who read it still? If they’re not real events, then that makes them sound like myths or legends.
What he was talking about is the violence that we read about in the Old Testament. He said that if we read it in such a way that we think violence is okay, or that God is a violent being, then we’re reading the Scripture incorrectly. He goes on to say that we should read them more metaphorically, or as an allegory, to understand the spiritual meaning behind what those stories mean. He said that these would be very important for the Jewish people to understand their God as a God who isn’t weak, who fights for His people, and destroys His enemies, and destroys sin.
I asked my RCIA instructor if we are not necessarily meant to believe these events really happened, and she said that the events were from the Israelite’s perspective. I was confused by this, and asked if she was saying that everything the Bible says God did, is actually what God did, or if it was from a human perspective, and they just interpreted it.
She said that the two creation stories in Genesis shows that not everything in the Bible that God is said to do (two creations of humans, was her example), is accurate. So, I asked her if something like where God hides Himself from His people was real, or if they just stopped listening, and she said that we don’t know.
So, how ARE we supposed to view the history and God’s interaction with people - is it from a human perspective and interpretation and could not be accurate on God’s involvement at all (and they’re just worth reading for the spiritual understanding), or are they literal events where God DID interact (like “confusing the enemy”, or “hiding Himself from His people”)?
Are they just good stories with good meanings, but potentially from a fallible viewpoint, or real stories with good meanings for those who read it still? If they’re not real events, then that makes them sound like myths or legends.