TV: "Family Guy"

  • Thread starter Thread starter edwest2
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
When I’m trying to discern whether or not I should watch something, I always imagine Jesus sitting right next to me watching the show with me. Would I be embarrassed? Would He look sad or angry because of the show? Would He ask me why I am watching it? (After all, He is with us always anyway.)
That’s kind of how I got to the point where I no longer really watch Futurama, Family Guy, or the Simpsons much anymore. I started thinking, would God approve of these shows I am watching? With the language and things in them, I pretty much deduced He wouldn’t, so I figured why should I then?
 
My introduction to Family Guy came when Peter fell into a lard factory and ate his way out—it was so absurdly hilarious I started watching the show.

But I can’t any more. There’s too much about it that is downright disgusting and morally objectionable.

I still watch Futurama now and then. How can you not like a show in which the cranky old scientist says, “The Bible is the REAL good news!”
 
I used to watch it when it came on (Sunday night), mainly feeling guilty because I was watching such hilarious trash on the Lord’s Day. But now our local FOX station is playing reruns on weekdays, so I’m OK with watching then…for now. That may change, of course. As for “The Simpsons,” I love them – and they even go to church!
 
My introduction to Family Guy came when Peter fell into a lard factory and ate his way out—it was so absurdly hilarious I started watching the show.

But I can’t any more. There’s too much about it that is downright disgusting and morally objectionable.

I still watch Futurama now and then. How can you not like a show in which the cranky old scientist says, “The Bible is the REAL good news!”
I see Futurama and Family Guy on two different levels. Family Guy is just so much more crass and explicit that often I don’t feel comfortable watching it. I class it in with South Park. Both are trash. Sometimes very funny trash, but still trash. Futurama seems cleaner and less crude, although it’s not a kids’ show. I put it more on the level of Farscape and Firefly (not in terms of quality or style, just acceptability).
 
If you’re feeling guilty, then may I suggest that might be an answer to your question.

Understandably, there are a lot of people out there who enjoy crass senses of humor, no matter who it offends. People are sinful in nature, and what might offend one would probably go along with another’s point-of-view. In time, you may no longer find the shows appealing. Continue to pray on this matter, and the Lord will provide you with the answers.

God Bless!
I thought likewise, that the guilt was my answer right there. What appeals to me is not necessarily the toilet humor, per se, but rather the references to many of the shows and music that I grew up with as a kid. They’ve done skits with the Electric Company, Great Space Coaster, Pac-Man, Kool-Aid Kid, He-Man, Transformers, GI-Joe, The Price is Right, Wheel of Fortune… and the list goes on and on.

Plus, the main character (Peter Griffin) keeps me laughing almost non-stop. For all of these reasons and more, I can’t get enough of Family Guy. And yes, they’ve occasionally poked fun at other groups, but so seldomly as compared to Christians.

I think they poked fun of the Taliban like ONE time and they had an episode that revolved around the Jewish faith, but if you were ever to count the amount of anti-Catholic/anti-Christian jabs compared to all of the others, you’d be amazed at just how much negative “humor” is directed there.

There was actually one joke involving church that I actually found kinda funny, only because they weren’t saying anything bad about Catholicism, but you be the judge. Peter is shouting upstairs to his wife because he can’t find his favorite pair of underwear:

Peter: Yo Lois!
**
Lois**: What?
**
Peter**: I’m packing for Kiss-Stock and I can’t find my favorite underwear.
**
Lois**: You mean the pair with the rip in the right butt check from when you stepped on them pulling them up in that airplane bathroom from when you had the trots?
**
Peter**: No, no. The pair with the hole in the left butt check from when I held it in for two hours cause it was an extra long Palm Sunday church sermon and I thought that blowing gas would offend Jesus so I let it go in the vestibule after mass and it sounded like Louie Armstrong.
**
Lois**: Oh! Bottom drawer.
 
“Abstain from all appearance of evil.” I like that.

Imagine a dial, and next to it are words. Like a volume control, the first words are: “irreverant,” “off color,” “risque.” Then you very slowly turn the dial up: “suggestive,” “sexual innuendo.” A little more: “tawdry,” “sexual references.” A little more: “occasional profanity,” “brief nudity.” And a little more: “some profanity,” “partial nudity,” and “sexual situations.”

I really object to the terms “Adult Language” and “Adult Entertainment.” Both say that it’s not OK for kids but it is OK for adults. Excuse me? Being raised a Catholic does not mean that as a kid, I’m somehow not allowed to say or or watch certain certain things, and then, as an adult, poof!, it’s suddenly OK. The Commandments I’ve been taught and the rules stay in place from childhood through adulthood. What, I’m going to go to Confession thinking, “Well, now I’m an adult and I can watch adult stuff because everybody else does.” I don’t think so.

The trend on TV, and even now with cartoons, once solely for kids, has been toward porn. David Duchovny goes from an FBI agent to failed writer-fornicator on Californication. A real step down. I tried watching a few minutes of Howard Stern once. Here’s a total Juvenile Delinquent in an adult body being paid to do all the perverted things his mom told him not to do.

To me, watching Family Guy has its funny moments but it’s like getting dinner and having to pick out all the garbage before you can enjoy what’s left. And anti-Christian bashing is a bad thing, especially for young and impressionable people who might think it’s OK. (Stewie said it and it was funny, right?)

God bless,
Ed
 
I think Family Guy has changed since the first two seasons.

My daughter was home from college for a few weeks in August, and we watched several episodes from the earlier seasons. They were great. The humor was still there, but not so crass and gross and anti-church.

After the show came back on after public demand brought it back, I think it lost a lot of the creativity that made the first two seasons so funny, and went for the gross, sick, racist humor.

E.g., in the first few seasons, Baby Stewie was definitely a wise-cracker plotting to take over the world, but it was funny. Every mom looks at her baby and wonders what he/she is really thinking, and Baby Stewie demonstrated that we are right, that our babies really are little geniuses!

But now Stewie is often foul-mouthed and many of the jokes have to do with his sexual orientation.

Also, in the first few seasons, Peter would have these crazy fantasy flashbacks that were hilairious. But now a lot of his flashbacks are perverted. E.g., I loved the snippet where a giant squid lives in the Griffin’s kitchen. That is just so off-the-wall and funny! And I loved the thing when Peter would fight to the death with that giant chicken–that was pointless and hilarious! But the scene where Peter is really a girl and has surgery to make him a man (hence the name, Peter)–that was gross.

I think was has been done with Meg is really bad. In the first few seasons, she was just kind of a loser teenager, pretty, but very self-depracating like so many kids are. But now, she is totally hopeless, but I don’t think she’s that homely, and I wonder why she is portrayed as such a loser. I just don’t get it.

Brian is actually Seth McFarlane, and I really like this character, although even he is becoming so sexual. I really don’t like the fact that he’s dating Jillian the Bimbo while lusting after Lois at the same time. He’s a dog! I liked it better when he was simply the intellectual liberal philosopher in the TV watching, overeating Griffin family. He used to be more like Snoopy the Beagle. Now he is quite perverted.

To me, this show is becoming more like Beevus and Butthead, which was just disgusting. I wish that the show would stay with Simpsons type writing, which is very touching and deep and “reverent” underneath all the humor. We really LIKE the Simpsons. But I don’t think I would like anyone in the Griffin family.

Anyway, I still watch the show if I’m home, but I won’t make an effort if I’m not home, and I’m not going to bother to tape the show to watch later. I think the writers are heading down a bad path, and I wish they would step back and take a second look and try to return to the fantasy-creative-approach that they used in the first few seasons. After all, that’s what made all of us demand the return of the show, the creativity.

As for never running into Seth–he was a guest speaker at my daughter’s college, St. Louis University, which is a Catholic college! So you might run into him–just keep an eye out on his public appearance schedule.
 
When I’m trying to discern whether or not I should watch something, I always imagine Jesus sitting right next to me watching the show with me. Would I be embarrassed? Would He look sad or angry because of the show? Would He ask me why I am watching it? (After all, He is with us always anyway.)
I must confess, I couldn’t begin to guess at our Saviour’s tastes in television entertainment. Certain aspects of Creation makes one suspect that the Lord has a ruder sense of humour than we’d think. I’d probably end up dodging the issue altogether, and hand Him the remote. I’m pretty darned sure what would happen, though, if you ever gave Satan the remote–“Golden Girls,” 24/7.

***“Bravo, Peter: you are the Spalding Gray of cr-p.”
–Brian Griffin, 2002

 
I’ve seen that show and honestly don’t think it’s appropriate. This is coming from someone who could quote the first 8 seasons of the Simpsons and found them hysterically funny (to the point of not being able to breathe sometimes - LOL). Of course, The Simpsons isn’t really any good anymore, though I suppose that’s for a different thread. 😛

Have you tried The Office? HILARIOUS show and not too much objectionable material. 😃
 
The best humor is dramatic and often tragic underneath all the laughs. It makes us cry inside while we laugh outside.

Probably the best example of this that I can think of is the brilliant Red Skelton. When he did Freddy the Freeloader, we all laughed, but inside a part of us was crying for this pathetic character who had so little and yet didn’t even realize his own poverty.

I personally think that it is not harmful for Christians to watch comedies like Family Guy or Knocked Up because we often get hidden in our own wonderful, redeemed world of the Church, and we forget that out there in the “world,” people are suffering in their sins and they don’t even realize it, and eventually they will die and go to hell.

I honestly think that Jesus would watch pretty much anything on TV or movies, and He would see beyond the laughs to the REALITY of the human condition that the writers and actors are attempting to portray though comedy.

After all, He watches US, doesn’t He? And we’re much more filthy and sinful than TV can ever be.

And what’s even more important, after watching the show, Jesus would get off the couch and go out into the world to help the pathetic characters that were portrayed in the “comedy.”

Don’t you know someone who has Peter Griffin’s traits–silliness, addiction to alcohol and food (and sex), foul-mouthed, inconsiderate, etc.? Peter Griffin has ALL these traits and more, and we laugh when we see him bumble through life.

But doesn’t a part of you think of the “Peter Griffin” you know and want to reach out to that person? Perhaps the comedy helps you to understand your friend better and come up with some ways to love him better.

That’s what Jesus would do.

When we watch Family Guy, it is a picture of our culture today–pretty wretched, isn’t it? No wonder we all want to hide out in the Church and forget about everything and everyone outside of Christianity.

**If the Griffin family epic were portrayed as a DRAMA, it would be unbearable. No one would watch because it would hurt to confront that much reality, to realize that our culture really is so selfish and filthy and evil.

So McFarlane is presenting our tragic culture as a “comedy.” ** Perhaps he is crying out, “DO SOMETHING! Help Meg to not hate herself! Help Chris to overcome his fear of the Evil Monkey! Help Stewie to find an outlet for all his brilliance. Help Brian to conquer alcoholism. Help Peter to become an unselfish caring man. Help Lois to grow a spine and stand up for what’s right instead of constantly changing her mind.”

Not everyone can discern this. Many people can’t get past the foul language and irreverent jokes. But hopefully many Christians can watch popular comedies and understand what is REALLY happening behind all the laughs.
 
I personally think that it is not harmful for Christians to watch comedies like Family Guy or Knocked Up because we often get hidden in our own wonderful, redeemed world of the Church, and we forget that out there in the “world,” people are suffering in their sins and they don’t even realize it, and eventually they will die and go to hell.
Anyone who visits CAF clearly realizes that Catholics do not live in a bubble, as you insinuate. We start with the premise that we are sinners ourselves and observe sin among our family members and friends every single day. You honestly think a dopey comedy that glorifies sin and debauchery and dysfunction is going to expand a Christian mind in some illuminating way? It sounds like justification to me.
I honestly think that Jesus would watch pretty much anything on TV or movies, and He would see beyond the laughs to the REALITY of the human condition that the writers and actors are attempting to portray though comedy.
Right. Christ would get a real kick out of watching Himself mocked with regularity on sitcoms and comedies. Christ would find this edifying in some way because it enlarges his view of the “human condition.” Again, would you watch programs that repeatedly mocked a family member that you loved? Would you consider this a useful tool in uncovering the deeper meaning of sin?
After all, He watches US, doesn’t He? And we’re much more filthy and sinful than TV can ever be.
I doubt he finds our sins funny or entertaining at all. I doubt he would laugh at our shennanigans at the expense of our souls.
And what’s even more important, after watching the show, Jesus would get off the couch and go out into the world to help the pathetic characters that were portrayed in the “comedy.”
Is that what watching The Family Guy motivates you to do? Do you take to the streets after it’s aired and minister to sexual deviants, alcoholics, and Christian haters?
Christ was perfectly capable of identifying sin on His own, without any help. As Catholics, we should not need the putrid and fetid media to help expose sin for us.
Don’t you know someone who has Peter Griffin’s traits–silliness, addiction to alcohol and food (and sex), foul-mouthed, inconsiderate, etc.?
Yes. It breaks my heart. It does not move me to giggles.
But doesn’t a part of you think of the “Peter Griffin” you know and want to reach out to that person? Perhaps the comedy helps you to understand your friend better and come up with some ways to love him better.
:rolleyes:
That’s what Jesus would do.
Cat, I’ve seen you defend other TV programs with the same passion as you’ve done here. Personally, it’s up to each Catholic to decide which shows and movies they want to watch and enjoy. Just please don’t try and equate watching The Family Guy with what Christ would do or how He would respond. You want to watch these shows? Fine. You enjoy them, you watch them, you’re ok with them. Just leave it at that.
Not everyone can discern this. Many people can’t get past the foul language and irreverent jokes. But hopefully many Christians can watch popular comedies and understand what is REALLY happening behind all the laughs.
Clearly we are not as evolved and don’t get the “deeper meaning.” But don’t kid yourself. The only thing happening is ratings, money, fame, celebrity, and pushing the limits.
 
blessedtoo, I didn’t say Jesus would laugh.

I said that comedy often makes us cry inside. I think that’s what Jesus would do, and I think that’s what Christians often do when they watch comedy.

Yes, Family Guy helps me to relate to those who are outside of the faith. Since my family is faith-filled (although not Catholic), I really have no concept of faithlessness and sinful lifestyles other than through artistic media.

My daughter heard Seth McFarlane speak in person. There is more to Family Guy. I agree, the money is probably top priority for him, and that in itself is something that we as Christians need to realize and understand about the rest of the world. We are not like this. We don’t fit in. As the Gospel said this week, we should “hate” our parents. (I know that the passage means that we should place God at the very center of lives.) So you see, a lesson from Family Guy. There are many more for those who watch the show and discern.

BTW, I want to make it clear that I don’t believe children should ever watch this show, and young teens should watch it only with parents, and it should be discussed afterward.
 
Yes, Family Guy helps me to relate to those who are outside of the faith. Since my family is faith-filled (although not Catholic), I really have no concept of faithlessness and sinful lifestyles other than through artistic media.
Wow. You have no friends who engage in questionable behavior? Everyone at work squeaky clean? Extended family members are all living righteous lives?

Do you do any volunteer work which would put you in contact with sinful behaviors? Do you watch the news? Read the newspapaer?

I work for a “Christian” company yet I am surrounded by sinful behavior. You can’t be in the world without being constantly bombarded with it. I guess I don’t understand why anyone would invite entertainment that celebrates, mocks, uses, or misrepresents such behavior into their home.

BTW: Nancy Miller, the creator of the piece of filth that is “Saving Grace” is a “practicing Catholic” who “believes” her show is a gritty portrayal of the struggle to find faith. What a load. It’s a tool she is using to attempt to reach a wider audience for her anti-Catholic, anti-Christian, soft porn propaganda.
 
Wow. You have no friends who engage in questionable behavior? Everyone at work squeaky clean? Extended family members are all living righteous lives?

Do you do any volunteer work which would put you in contact with sinful behaviors? Do you watch the news? Read the newspapaer?

I work for a “Christian” company yet I am surrounded by sinful behavior. You can’t be in the world without being constantly bombarded with it. I guess I don’t understand why anyone would invite entertainment that celebrates, mocks, uses, or misrepresents such behavior into their home.

BTW: Nancy Miller, the creator of the piece of filth that is “Saving Grace” is a “practicing Catholic” who “believes” her show is a gritty portrayal of the struggle to find faith. What a load. It’s a tool she is using to attempt to reach a wider audience for her anti-Catholic, anti-Christian, soft porn propaganda.
Of course I have acquaintances who live badly. My kids were ice skaters, and we saw some trashy living at the rink, but a lot more clean, decent living!

I repeat, a show like Family Guy helps me understand why people live the way they do. There’s a lot of pain hidden under those “jokes.”

It may make you feel better about me personally to know that I have no idea what you’re talking about when you say “Saving Grace.” I assume it’s a TV show? I remember a book by Eerdman’s press, but I think it was called Amazing Grace, and it’s a very touching story about a little girl and her father.

You see, I really don’t watch a lot of TV. The Unit without fail. *The Simpsons * and Family Guy when I’m home. Football and figure skating when they’re on network (we don’t have cable and never will unless channels are sold ala-carte.)

And as I said in my post above, Family Guy has changed quite a bit from its first few seasons. I hope that the *Star Wars Family Guy * will put the show back on its original creative tract again, or I will seriously consider taking it off my list. I agree that it is no longer as funny as it was the first two seasons, and the family doesn’t seem to be depicting any good positive lessons, as the Simpsons do.
 
I once enjoyed Family Guy, but lost interest in it when it did cross a line in my mind between hilarity and being crass just for its own sake.

I have often wondered (and this is my only speculation) if Seth McFarlane has somehow been affected by what happened to him on September 11, 2001. This day happened between the time the show was first on and the time the show came back.

On that day, he was supposed to be one of the flights that flew into the World Trade Center, but he missed the flight (his travel agent put the wrong time on his ticket, or something like that). Could he be angry at God, like so many people who have close brushes with death have? Like, why did I miss the plane, but others didn’t? A survivor’s guilt of sorts? I am not trying to psychoanalyze him (at least not on purpose), but I do wonder if his “crassness” and the show’s descent into it has increased because of his possible anger at God.

And yes, I know that I could be wrong and making something out of nothing. If I’ve offended, then I apologize.
 
When I’m trying to discern whether or not I should watch something, I always imagine Jesus sitting right next to me watching the show with me. Would I be embarrassed? Would He look sad or angry because of the show? Would He ask me why I am watching it? (After all, He is with us always anyway.)
I honestly don’t think Jesus would have time for any forms of entertainment.

(Not with all there is to do in this broken world of ours.)
 
You know, Jesus did attend a 3-day wedding feast, had dinner at many people’s homes, engaged in lively banter with his opposers, and watched the apostles flounder along the way. Better than any night’s entertainment on the TV!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top