Ukrainian Famine, one of the worst tragedies of the last century of which the world is just beginning to learn

  • Thread starter Thread starter Athanasiy
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
It strikes me as interesting – and a bit unnerving – to hear the old and tired trope that American education fails to discuss central historical topics because it’s weak and/or run by those who favor socialism/communism/totalitarianism (all three seem to be one in the same in some posts here). I don’t know any professors (or college administrators, for that matter) who don’t “want to report it or teach about it to this very day lest people realize just how vicious and totalitarian leftism has been historically, and how base are the motivations of so many of its leaders.” :confused: At my institution, there are at least thirty faculty members who regularly teach about the Holocaust, the Holodomor, Armenia, Cambodia, Bosnia, Rwanda, and on and on (plus at least twenty more who engage with these topics every 1-3 years in rotation with other human rights abuses). Our efforts have been institutionalized and given primacy in the college’s strategic plans. And we’re not alone – I can think of at least thirty other post-secondary institutions in the U.S. which have a formal endowment and/or program for this kind of work, and *dozens *more that engage with these topics in various courses and co-curricular programming. I can’t say that we’re the majority, but if we exist, best not to paint with too broad a brush by claiming that those lefty educators won’t ever confront totalitarianism.

I’d like to interject that we know far more about the atrocities of the USSR post-its collapse. There were certainly public attempts prior to this period to draw attention to the Holodomor, which were roundly quashed. But the extent of western knowledge is certainly impacted by increased access to this region.

Some other recommended reading, if anyone’s interested:

Execution by Hunger, by Miron Dolot
Bloodlands: Europe Between Hitler and Stalin, by Timothy Snyder
I congratulate you for having a university that’s different. But your experience is not reflective of most.

It may be noted in passing that both “One Day in the Life of Ivan Denisovich” and the “Gulag” series were all published BEFORE the Soviet Union collapsed. Possibly, due to Solhenitsyn’s stature in the literary world (Nobel Prize) and his experiential credentials, his works had a great deal to do with that collapse and with the disenchantment with leftism generally.
 
I congratulate you for having a university that’s different. But your experience is not reflective of most.
As I said…
I can’t say that we’re the majority, but if we exist, best not to paint with too broad a brush by claiming that those lefty educators won’t ever confront totalitarianism.
I’d like to interject that we know far more about the atrocities of the USSR post-its collapse. There were certainly public attempts prior to this period to draw attention to the Holodomor, which were roundly quashed. But the extent of western knowledge is certainly impacted by increased access to this region.
It may be noted in passing that both “One Day in the Life of Ivan Denisovich” and the “Gulag” series were all published BEFORE the Soviet Union collapsed. Possibly, due to Solhenitsyn’s stature in the literary world (Nobel Prize) and his experiential credentials, his works had a great deal to do with that collapse and with the disenchantment with leftism generally.
I was speaking of Ukraine, specifically, since that’s what this thread’s focus is. Check out Timothy Snyder’s Bloodlands, or even Fr. Patrick Desbois’ The Holocaust by Bullets, to see what I mean about increased access to information after the USSR’s collapse.
 
Here is the testimony of Tatiana Pawlichka about the famine in Ukraine.

In 1932, I was 10 years old, and I remember well what happened in my native village in the Kiev region. In the spring of that year, we had virtually no seed. The Communists had taken all the grain, and although they saw that we were weak and hungry, they came and searched for more grain. My mother had stashed away some corn that had already sprouted, but they found that, too, and took it. What we did manage to sow, the starving people pulled up out of the ground and ate.

In the villages and on the collective farms (our village had two collectives), a lot of land lay fallow, because people had nothing to sow, and there wasn’t enough manpower to do the sowing. Most people couldn’t walk, and those few who could had no strength. When, at harvest time, there weren’t enough local people to harvest the grain, others were sent in to help on the collectives. These people spoke Russian, and they were given provisions.

After the harvest, the villagers tried to go out in the field to look for gleanings, and the Communists would arrest them and shoot at them, and send them to Siberia. My aunt, Tatiana Rudenko, was taken away. They said she had stolen the property of the collective farm.

That summer, the vegetables couldn’t even ripen - people pulled them out of the ground - still green - and ate them. People ate leaves, nettles, milkweed, sedges. By autumn, no one had any chickens or cattle. Here and there, someone had a few potatoes or beets. People coming in from other villages told the very same story. They would travel all over trying to get food. They would fall by the roadside, and none of us could do anything to help. When the ground froze, they were just left lying there dead, in the snow; or, if they died in the house, they were dragged out to the cattle-shed, and they would lie there frozen until spring. There was no one to dig graves.

All the train stations were overflowing with starving, dying people. Everyone wanted to go to Russia [the Russian SFSR] because it was said that there was no famine there. Very few [of those who left] returned. They all perished on the way. They weren’t allowed into Russia and were turned back at the border. Those who somehow managed to get into Russia could save themselves.

In February of 1933, there were so few children left that the schools were closed. By this time, there wasn’t a cat, dog or sparrow in the village. In that month, my cousin Mykhailo Rudenko died; a month later my aunt Nastia Klymenko and her son, my cousin Ivan, died, as well as my classmate, Dokia Klymenko.

There was cannibalism in our village. On my farmstead, an 18-year-old boy, Danylo Hukhlib, died, and his mother and younger sisters and brothers cut him up and ate him. The Communists came and took them away, and we never saw them again. People said they took them a little ways off and shot them right away - the little ones and the older ones together.

At that time, I remember, I had heavy, swollen legs. My sister, Tamara, had a large, swollen stomach, and her neck was long and thin like a bird’s neck. People didn’t look like people - they were more like starving ghosts.

The ground thawed, and they began to take the dead to the ravine in ox carts. The air was filled with the ubiquitous odor of decomposing bodies. The wind carried this odor far and wide. It was thus over all of Ukraine.
 
This thread has been dormant for a considerable period. With rare exceptions, reviving threads after a protracted period of inactivity is discouraged because:
  • the issues that spurred them are often no longer “hot” or current topics, explaining why thread activity ceased originally.
  • posters originally involved in the discussion are sometimes no longer active on the forum and, therefore, unavailable to reply to comments added to the thread.
Our experience suggests that, when a topic merits revival, it is best accomplished by initiating a new thread that draws on recent events and can be posted to contemporaneously. This eliminates the baggage of folks being frustrated by asking and not receiving responses to issues raised in early posts (because the new poster didn’t notice that the post he was responding to was made a long time ago).

Posters are very welcome to open a new thread on the subject or any other topic, as well as to actively participate in the myriad active threads in the fora.
**
Thank you to all those who have participated in this discussion. This thread is now closed. **
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top