Ultimatum: Vasectomy or else

  • Thread starter Thread starter fm1982
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
F

fm1982

Guest
This is quite a long story, so I’ll summarize the best I can.

Married relatively young in the Church, first child 9 months after wedding, 4th child due soon 7 years later. In between that time, all family has turned their back on us to the point that there are lawyers involved between one set of our parents and us after they stole an inheritance. Some very nasty things have been said about us by that set of parents, even nastier in the last little while.

My wife has taken all of this, plus having 3 going on 4 young kids very hard. I think that we are doing the best job we can as parents, the kids are very good kids and we do have some support from friends who are very supportive and giving.

Unfortunately, depression has hit my wife very hard and she has completely lost “it” over the past 4 or 5 months. Over that time she has tossed a bunch of friends away over what most people would consider minor issues, has accused me of cheating, has absolutely no patience for me or our children to the point that our oldest always mentions how her mom is always screaming, we’ve had child services in because of things she told the doctor, she’s under a doctor and counsellor’s care, and she has told me numerous times she wants to leave and/or commit suicide (the doctors know this).

Part of the reason she wants to leave is that I will not commit to a vasectomy. Putting aside the moral aspect of it, I am relatively young (still under 30) and if things settle down over the next few years I would love to have more children if that is in God’s plan. To “shut it down” now would leave me with a feeling of “emptiness” for many years, at least that is how I think of it now.

She has also said that if I don’t get it and we get pregnant, she will have an abortion. Legally at that point there would be nothing I could do to stop her, which causes me great distress as well. She is upset that if she left me or died, that I would still be open to having more children.

Add to this her constant questioning of what I would do in terms of custody arrangements for the kids if she did get a divorce. My first response was that I was not even thinking about that option, that I was here to work things out (to which she responds I’m a donkey hole and she hates me, but I know that’s depression talking). After she goes and goes, I say that I will do what is best for the kids and that they are not pawns in a game, but with her history of mental instability over the past couple of years, the only option in my opinion for the good of the kids would be for me to have full custody with her getting a weekend here or there. She knows this and then goes off on the suicide rant again. The facts are that she cannot handle the kids for more than 20 or 30 minutes at a time without finding something to freak out about. I do get concerned about their mental well being listening to her yelling at them so often.

I really don’t know what to do in this situation and how to deal with it. I’m praying that after the baby is born things will settle down significantly, but the stats show that postpartum depression has a very high probably of hitting like a ton of bricks.

At first I thought that maybe a vasectomy would be the best solution to this problem. After months of careful reflection, I know that it is not, that “giving” her that would just lead to other similar demands and that it is not what is intended by God. My conscience won’t allow it. However, it does put the marriage on incredibly shaky ground, although there are many other issues there as well. I feel that if things improve over the next few years that we should be open to more children. On the flip side, me being open to more children means that if she follows through on her threats, I will likely never have any more children, unless I could get an annulment. I do have age of marriage (honestly at 23 never having lived on my own I had no idea what I was getting into) and my family history (professionals I have gone to have called it abuse even without me using that word - and I got married to get out of that situation), but that is my absolute last resort.

I want this to work, but I don’t know what to do. She is not herself at all right now, everything is bad, I’m an awful person (even though I take on 95% of all household tasks - my colleagues who are women are shocked by the amount of housework I do - work full time while she is at home 5 out of 7 days with no responsibility - I take care of weekends, we are paying a babysitter we can’t really afford (but I tell her we will be ok) 3 days a week to take the stress off her, yet she is always angry and freaking out. It has taken a toll on our relationship, there are many days I’m quite happy to not have her around the house at all. There are days when I really don’t care if she left, it’s almost as if it would be easier to manage 4 kids on my own than to have to manage 4 kids + her emotions.

Maybe someone out there has some words of wisdom for me. I know this is a bit of an incoherent rant, but this whole situation has been very difficult for me. Thank you for any support or ideas you can provide.
 
Dear fm, your situation is so complex and serious that may I suggest that you make an appointment to speak with your priest?
Remember by the way that leaving your wife means, most likely, leaving your children and from what you have indicated, it isn’t a healthy situation for them as things stand. I’m sure you do realize, but they need protecting or that’s another four lives damaged. If you cannot cope with all you are enduring, how can they as little ones?

I was 21 when married, a cradle snatcher, as my husband was 18, by the way. I left home because my Dad had married again after my Mum died, and my step-mum went through a period of criticizing everything I did, including to help around the house. I couldn’t take it after a while. She got over it and became a good step-mother, by the time all we older ones left home and married too soon.
My own mother had a major breakdown after three children, and spent some months in a nursing home and we girls went into an orphanage as Dad had to work and there was no other recourse if family weren’t near. The orphanage did harm, broke my ability to trust for many years. So I do know how hard things can be.

My Mum did recover, and went on to have other children and coped well.
We’ve made it through! Not without hiccups along the way. I pray your family will.

I pray you folk will make it through,
but you wife mightn’t be in a nursing home recovering because she foresaw an endless stream of children, (died with the miscarriage of the 11th at age 43, my darling mother.) Your wife is scared stiff and hasn’t had a breakdown where like my Mum she ‘saw the curtains on fire’ when they weren’t, but your wife is having some sort of breakdown.

My Mum did recover fully, the lovely lady, yet in those early days my Dad must have wondered if things would turn out all right.

Don’t give up hope,
and I hope and pray that your priest can guide you well and your wife get the help she needs…and my Mum used to cop her mother’s criticism for all the babies, but Dad’s family couldn’t as they were big families.

I do feel for you,
and I do feel for you wife
…and I feel for your children too.
I’ll pray for you all, so will others I’m sure

You sound a good young man and a big help, and I hope you manage little acts of cherishing even if your wife doesn’t at this time feel capable of welcoming them. I pray she comes to appreciate you more too.

A hug
 
Fm, you are in a rough situation but you are absolutely correct that you should never give in to a demand to mutilate yourself - because that’s what vasectomy is. God did not create us in order for us to harm and mutilate our healthy bodies. Our bodies are temples of the Holy Spirit and we should treat them as such. Vasectomies and any other forms of self-harm and self-mutilation are just flatly inconsistent with the dignity God gave to our bodies by making them temples of the Holy Spirit. So, that option must be taken off the table, no matter what - even if your wife truly follows up on her threats and divorces you.

You still have another option: long-term abstinence. If these pregnancies have such a harsh effect on your wife that they push her into depression (which often is a very real chemical imbalance in the body, and causes unbelievable amounts of suffering, so much so that suicide may start to appear as a way out to the depressed patient), you should consider relieving her of the fear of yet another pregnancy. That would mean total abstinence for as long as it takes, for as long as your wife gets better.

Also, did your wife see a good psychiatrist, someone who would prescribe her medication and other forms of therapy as needed?
 
Ouch!

First I’d like to say that I can empathise somewhat - my husband is in the process of deciding whether to get a vasectomy. We have five children and my sixth is due in January. I do not have the major stressful issues that you have described, however. In my case I will ask my husband to wait until the baby is born before making the decision, because now there is too much going on for him to think clearly.

I think you are right that if you did get the vasectomy it would not fix things. The operation is just a manifestation of your wife’s struggle. If you did that, something else would surface to take its place. I think.

She has a lot to figure out, and I don’t know what she needs most. Depression is a terrible disease that makes good people into horrible people (my family is rife with it, my brother took his own life because of it, I don’t know how to deal with it). She seems to be looking for reasons to be angry at you. I have done this to my husband in the past and I’m not proud of it. What it came down to for me was that I was angry with myself or scared about something, and I’d focus that anger/fear on my husband instead. Not fair for him and he had no way of fighting back because I didn’t want reassurance, I wanted to be angry. I think what I’m saying is that if she doesn’t want to be helped, there’s not much you can do to help her. Depression makes a person resist help.

You sound like you’re doing your best for her and your family. Take my advice, though, don’t compromise your integrity to try and fix things. If it really did come down to the vasectomy or the marriage, then it would still be the better thing for you to refuse to do it.

Our first obligation is to get ourselves to Heaven, and then after that, to get others to Heaven. Not the reverse. By doing something that is wrong, you can’t hope to save someone else, or even save your marriage. As I said before, something else will come up.

Even if she aborted her baby because you didn’t have the operation, you are not culpable. It’s horrible to think about, but you really must follow your conscience and take each occurrence as it happens, not think of all the different possibilities.

Sorry my post is a bit rambling, but I hope it helps in some way.
 
Maybe someone out there has some words of wisdom for me. I know this is a bit of an incoherent rant, but this whole situation has been very difficult for me. Thank you for any support or ideas you can provide.
Your wife is in the midst of a very serious breakdown. She needs more than a counsellor, she needs competent psychiatric care. Possibly her pregnancy will keep her from drug therapy. These things can turn quite tragic quite quickly,.

Stop having sex with her. Period. Just tell her that there won’t be a problem to deal with until you both have come to a mutually acceptable solution.

Yeah, I know, you’re under 30. You can also be divorced under 30. Or a widower. Or worse. These aren’t good options. Take the issue off the table until everyone has a better handle on what’s going on. Protect your children and care for your sick wife. Get her as much help as she needs and remember: it’s not her fault.
 
This situation is more than can be properly handled, or even advice given, over the internet. You must needs involve a priest and a therapist, and it is likely advisable to contact a psychiatrist (i.e. an MD that provides medical therapy, not talk therapy). I’ve seen medications work wonders in myself and others. I am surprised your wife has not been committed yet; usually, if someone threatens suicide, they are committed until they are stabilized and judged to be competent and in no danger of suicide or violence by a team of clinicians. I am loathe beyond all to suggest the idea, but, if she is threatening suicide, it may be wise to speak with someone about (name removed by moderator)atient psychiatric treatment. In an (name removed by moderator)atient center, the doctors can monitor patients more closely and figure out the right course and dosage of medications and regimen of therapy more effectively and much more quickly, but it is expensive (over $1000 a day) if insurance doesn’t cover it, and can take anywhere between five days and a month.
 
I can’t say anything on this topic, but yrs, I am trying to understand all the matter.
 
If she were my sister, I would do everything in my power to get her good (name removed by moderator)atient treatment for her illness.

Prayers, stay close to Jesus.

Have you checked catholictherapists.com/
 
What a terrible situation.

Odd that she insists you be sterilized. I would think she would be threatening to have her tubes tied.

God Bless you!
 
my only words of wisdom are this: I have been pregnant 7 times, this is my 8th pregnancy. In all but 2 of the pgs I suffer from severe depression. PPl talk about Postpartum depression but it is often overlooked that depression can occur during pregnancy too. I get very depressed every time and say irrational things. I think hers is very severe and requires medication and/or hospitalization possibly. As far as possibly having more children after this one I am not sure that would be in her best interest if this is how she becomes while pregnant. You have to think of what is better for everyone. I am not saying vasectomy but I wouldn’t actively try for more. I would try to abstain.

right now as far as the vascetomy I would say, we are not going to talk about it until at least 6 months after this baby is born. Hopefully then she will be able to reason better.

meanwhile I second others advice that you both need counselling
 
Sir, get your poor wife help immediately. If she is working, please get her to quit. And get a teenage girl from your parish to come in ASAP to take over the housework, and pay her to help out. Your wife needs all the help she can get right now, she is under massive stress. I have been where she is and thought I’d lose my mind. I understand exactly how she feels. 😦
Sterilization is not an option, but total abstinence for right now is imperative. Her mental health depends upon it.
I will pray for your family.
 
Your wife needs a full time job outside the home.

I personally feel that your children might be in danger from her mental inability to adjust to their growing needs.

Abstinence, counseling for her, and your marriage, and work away from the children.
 
Thank you for all the responses.

She is seeing an MD (psychiatry) , she did go to the hospital after talking to the doctor over the phone about her suicidal thoughts, but they let her go that day with follow up appointments. The immediate threat is not now, she has said she wouldn’t do anything to harm the baby, but she has talked about suicide and number of times and has openly wished to die during childbirth. I know the doctor knows all of this because I heard her saying it to the doctor on the phone (I made the call and got through to the doctor, so I know it wasn’t a “fake” call).

I have suggested taking the issue off the table for the time being because we are not thinking clearly (I’ve phrased it as we), and that we can come back to it sometime in the near future. I am well aware of the fact that there will be no more children anytime soon and if I was a betting man, I would put my money on no more kids ever.

Abstinence is a good option, however that raises body image issues with her, that I don’t want to have sex because she is not attractive enough. We can talk about abstinence until I am blue in the face, but she will always come back to the “I’m not good enough” argument.

She has said she’ll get her tubes tied, but I need to get the vasectomy as well and that if I don’t, she’ll hate me forever. She argues that a tubal is much more invasive than a vasectomy and that every man gets one so I should too. By not getting it, I “don’t respect (her)” and she can’t live with that. She gets very angry about it.

I have been doing pretty close to 100% of all the house work for the past number of months, on top of everything else, but she still gets anxious when anyone offers help. Only a few weeks ago a friend of ours was over to take our daughter for a sleepover. My daughter, 5, said she didn’t want to go, and this friend offered to pick up her kids, drop them off with her mom and come back and help, but my wife would have nothing of it. She said, “no, I’m fine”, then proceeded to melt down shortly after this friend left. I told her that we have people who want to help, but she still said no.

As for working out of the home, when I suggested that to her, she told me there is no way she would go back to working and if I “made” her, she would commit suicide, that’s how strongly she feels about it.

I do know that I need to speak to someone about this in person, the biggest challenge I have is that I have to be on 100% of the time at home. I cannot even leave for a few minutes, I can’t even go to the bathroom for a few minutes without a high probably of yelling and screaming ensuing. She doesn’t want people in to help and is insulted if I say I’ll leave the kids someone else for a while. She has told me that I need to have no feelings, that only she matters. She tells me I cannot speak to anyone other than a professional about this, but when I ask when I can go, she cannot give me any answers.

Anyways, I appreciate all your suggestions, support and certainly your prayers. Right now my faith and my love for my family are what keep me going. I am hoping to see progress when the baby is born, and as some of you have mentioned, there is hope that things can get better with medication and treatment.
 
Even if you got the vasectomy that won’t magically solve all problems, it will create more. It is a difficult situation any way you look at it. Speaking with someone in person would be beneficial, in particular, a priest. I know you said it is extremely difficult to get away to do so. Prayers for you and your family.
 
There is a website where you can get some more support and more information about depression. dbsalliance.org/site/PageServer?pagename=home
They have a very good forum. Not that it would replace actual help with people who are psychiatrists or therapists. There are local support groups…see if they have one in your area, for you or your wife. sometimes they have online support chats.

I live with depression, not as bad as your wife’s but I have dysthymia and it can turn major…and I have had those thoughts maybe not as violent as she is having them.

Have you studied the book “Love and Responsibility”? by JP2 It might help you help your wife understand that sex is not about your attraction to her but a prayer to God. That you love her for her…and want her to become who God created her to be. If that means showing affection and intimacy in other ways then so be it.

I will advise that you need support too or you won’t be able to keep up with this forever. But at the same time, keep up with the sacraments and you will grow in love toward your wife and also the side benefit is compassion toward others. We are capable of handling more than we ever dream it is part of our sanctification and this, sir is part of that for you. To learn to love even when a person is acting unlovable. Jesus died on the cross in the midst of unlovable people. He overcame death and sent his Holy Spirit to teach us.

What a journey you are on! (((hug)))
 
Thank you for all the responses.
…
She has said she’ll get her tubes tied, but I need to get the vasectomy as well and that if I don’t, she’ll hate me forever. She argues that a tubal is much more invasive than a vasectomy and that every man gets one so I should too. By not getting it, I “don’t respect (her)” and she can’t live with that. She gets very angry about it.
Sorry that your having to go through this. Mental health issues in a loved one are very difficult.

Hope you realize that, even if we put aside the moral issues, the vasectomy won’t solve any issues in your marriage. Attempting to appease her this way will only contribute to your unhappiness, and you’ll have no one to blame for it but yourself. I think for the moment, deferring the discussion to a later time while trying to get help for her is a good approach.

In my prayers.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top