Understanding the Trinity

  • Thread starter Thread starter AustralianGuy
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
A

AustralianGuy

Guest
I’ve found the Trinity really hard to get my mind around. Is this the same for other Catholics? I’ve read that the Father, Son and Holy Spirit are all one but yet separate, or something along those lines, but I don’t fully understand how it works?

I’ve read some articles on the Catholic Answers site but still am a bit unsure if I understand it all fully… it just seems to be a really hard concept to grasp.

Can anyone explain it to me?

Thanks 🙂
 
I’ve found the Trinity really hard to get my mind around. Is this the same for other Catholics? I’ve read that the Father, Son and Holy Spirit are all one but yet separate, or something along those lines, but I don’t fully understand how it works?

I’ve read some articles on the Catholic Answers site but still am a bit unsure if I understand it all fully… it just seems to be a really hard concept to grasp.

Can anyone explain it to me?

Thanks 🙂
Hello Australian, from an Australian girl…Welcome. Will try and answer Trinity question but first welcome and enjoy being here with some really nice people.
GraceAngel.
 
Hello Australian, from an Australian girl…Welcome. Will try and answer Trinity question but first welcome and enjoy being here with some really nice people.
GraceAngel.
Thanks for the welcome GraceAngel 🙂 Happy to be here, I plan on becoming a pretty active member! It seems like a nice and interesting community.
 
Read the story of St. Patrick. He used a shamrock to explain the Trinity. In simple words the shamrock is one but it has three leaves. It’s the same with the Trinity - One God, but Three Persons. Hope this helps a bit.
 
This is how I understand trinity:

First there is this One perfect God. This one perfect God has a perfect knowledge of everything outside himself and of Himself.

Since this one perfect God has a perfect knowledge of Himself, this knowledge of Himself is so perfect that it is exactly like God Himself.
There is now way in which God can think of Himself except that " He is who He is". God is eternal, since this knowledge of Himself is exactly like God, it follows that this knowledge of Himself is also eternal. God can exist on his own, since this knowledge of Himself is exactly like God, it follows that this knowledge of himself exist on its own also, so that even if God will turn his thoughts on other things, this knowledge of Himself does not cease to exist. This knowledge of Himself is a living mirror image of God. God who produces the knowledge of himself is Father, while the knowledge of Himself produced is the Son. Two distinct entity yet one Divine Nature. This is one Divine Nature because the Son derives his nature from the Father, naturally thier nature is just one and the same.

God deserves God. God does not deserve anything less than Himself. Nobody can give due to what belongs to God except God Himself.

What does the Son deserve? the Son deserves no less than the Father Himself. And the Father can give nothing to the Son which is less than Himself. So, the Father gives Himself to the Son because the Son deserves it, and the Father in giving Himself is not consumed because He is eternal. This giving of Himself is always active since the source of it cannot end because the Father is infinite. Since this is a self giving it is therefore Love, because love is to give oneself. Since what is given by the Father to the Son is Himself, what is given therefore is a Divine Person. And this Divine Person that is given is the HolySpirit.

So there you are. Father has a perfect knowledge of Himself. This perfect knowledge of himself is the Son. The Father gives Himself eternally to Son as his love, and this Love that is given to the Son is also divine and it is the Holy Spirit.
 
I’ve found the Trinity really hard to get my mind around. Is this the same for other Catholics? I’ve read that the Father, Son and Holy Spirit are all one but yet separate, or something along those lines, but I don’t fully understand how it works?

I’ve read some articles on the Catholic Answers site but still am a bit unsure if I understand it all fully… it just seems to be a really hard concept to grasp.

Can anyone explain it to me?

Thanks 🙂
Read Theology for Beginners by F.J. Sheed. It has an excellent chapter on the trinity.
 
I’ve found the Trinity really hard to get my mind around. Is this the same for other Catholics?
Absolutely.

There’s a legend about Saint Augustine. He was sitting on a beach, pondering God, and a mysterious child digging a hole in the sand. Augustine asked the child what he was doing, and the kid said he wanted to put the whole ocean into the hole he made. Augustine said that’s impossible; the kid responded, it’s easier to do this than for you to fully understand God.

I think there is a point where we just have to acknowledge that we can’t answer everything, and this mystery of the Trinity is probably

I had a professor who said something to the effect that they are just different manifestations of one God. She made it sound as if God just existed in one person, and that’s just not right. She implied, for example, that Jesus was praying to Himself in Gethsemane. She wasn’t a theologian though, so frankly I know better than to believe that.

To make things even more confusing for you, I was reading a bit about Fatima. Some days before Mary appeared to the three kids, the Angel of Peace appeared to them and prayed this:

“Most Holy Trinity, Father, Son and Holy Spirit, I adore You profoundly. I offer You the Most Precious Body, Blood, Soul and Divinity of Our Lord Jesus Christ…”

Some people thought this was weird – essentially, the Angel was offering Jesus to Himself.

I know this isn’t immediately helpful to answer your questions, and it probably only confused you more (I know it confused me!), but it’s something that you might find helpful pondering while you study about the Trinity. I personally find it helpful to remember Genesis: it has God referring to Himself as “Us” and “We,” which some people put forth as Old Testament evidence of the Trinity.
 
I’ve found the Trinity really hard to get my mind around. Is this the same for other Catholics? I’ve read that the Father, Son and Holy Spirit are all one but yet separate, or something along those lines, but I don’t fully understand how it works?

I’ve read some articles on the Catholic Answers site but still am a bit unsure if I understand it all fully… it just seems to be a really hard concept to grasp.

Can anyone explain it to me?

Thanks 🙂
with all due respect to all those who try to “grap the concept of the Trinity” …its impossible for human reason to complelty comprehend a Divine Mystery as Awsome as the Trinity.
if someone claims to fully understand the nature of God/Trinity; then you know str8 away they’re on the wrong track…just be assured in the knowelge that God has reveled himself to us as a Trinity, beyond that some mysteries are better left unsolved.

Welcome to the Fourm Australian Guy, from another Australian dude.
 
Thanks for the welcome GraceAngel 🙂 Happy to be here, I plan on becoming a pretty active member! It seems like a nice and interesting community.
Thats great to hear Australian guy, lets show our gorgeous friends of this community that we are fair dinkum 😃
Fair guy, my young son came home from school one day and said “Mum in RE today the teacher said that God is three in one. how can that be?” “Darling said his wise mum Me:p come to the kitchen and lets see if I can help you a bit.” So off to the kitchen went this wise mum 🙂 and gets out an ice cube tray full of ice cubes, puts on the electric jug on with water to boil and pours a glass of water from the tap. Then waiting for the kettle to boil I said, "darling just wait till the water boils, then I can show you.
Boiling the kettle and we watch the steam shooting out quite strongly. Now I had my three things to show how something can be three things in one. Enough for a child to understand.
Look darling, here is a glass of water, here are the ice cubes, and look at the steam. Now tell me what is the same about all of them. Strangely he looks at his up to this stage perfect mother, and said “I dunno” Water, darling water. Look glass of water, ice cubes are water in a different way, and steam is water in a different way. OHHHHH mum you are clever. Yes I know said I.
Well the Trinity is a little bit like that. The Trinity is not water but you can see how one thing can be three totally different things doing very different things and even feeling different. When you are much older I will try and explain better.
IThis clver mummy is terrified of that day, but I hope that I will have learnt more about the Trinity for when that day comes.
Is this good explaination Aussie Guy?:clapping:
GraceAngel:angel1:
 
Read the story of St. Patrick. He used a shamrock to explain the Trinity. In simple words the shamrock is one but it has three leaves. It’s the same with the Trinity - One God, but Three Persons. Hope this helps a bit.
hmmm, that makes sense, thanks! 🙂
This is how I understand trinity:

First there is this One perfect God. This one perfect God has a perfect knowledge of everything outside himself and of Himself.

Since this one perfect God has a perfect knowledge of Himself, this knowledge of Himself is so perfect that it is exactly like God Himself…
That was a little confusing I must admit, I’ll have to have another read through later on I think. Thanks for sharing though, it’s much appreciated 🙂
Read Theology for Beginners by F.J. Sheed. It has an excellent chapter on the trinity.
I’ll see if I can find the book or see if its in any libraries in my area, thanks!
Absolutely.

There’s a legend about Saint Augustine. He was sitting on a beach, pondering God, and a mysterious child digging a hole in the sand. Augustine asked the child what he was doing, and the kid said he wanted to put the whole ocean into the hole he made. Augustine said that’s impossible; the kid responded, it’s easier to do this than for you to fully understand God.
That was a great legend and story to read thanks! It does get to a point which I’ve started to think whilst trying to understand the trinity. I agree with you, that as humans its hard to understand it fully. I’ve had that feeling that maybe because it is God, it’s like ants trying to understand how a plane works. It’s just so far advanced from us that we just can’t comprehend it fully?

Your answer didn’t confuse me more, it kinda matched what I already had started to think. The only thing is, I’ve heard about those in the Catholic church coming together and deciding on this all (I forget the name of their meeting or where it was published, sorry to be so vague but i’m sure you know what i’m talking about), so I thought, if they understood it enough to be able to decide on it, surely I should be able to understand it as well? At least close to the point they were able to? I doubt anyone can understand it fully, but i’d like to be able to understand it enough to comprehend it a bit better without getting so confused.
with all due respect to all those who try to “grap the concept of the Trinity” …its impossible for human reason to complelty comprehend a Divine Mystery as Awsome as the Trinity.
if someone claims to fully understand the nature of God/Trinity; then you know str8 away they’re on the wrong track…just be assured in the knowelge that God has reveled himself to us as a Trinity, beyond that some mysteries are better left unsolved.

Welcome to the Fourm Australian Guy, from another Australian dude.
Firstly, thanks for the welcome 🙂 Secondly, as I said above, I agree with you on that one. I’m mostly looking to understand it at least a little better than I currently do. I doubt I’ll ever fully understand but I’d like to be able to at least comprehend it a bit better when thinking about everything, discussing it with others and praying… etc.
Is this good explaination Aussie Guy?:clapping:
I was going to quote the whole thing but I thought it would probably be a bit much! I thought your example was quite good. It’s helped me get a bit better of a grasp on the whole thing. I’ll admit i’m still not completely sure about it all but I’m at least a tiny bit better off in my understanding than before!

Thank you all so much for your thoughts and help so far! They were greatly appreciated and I will really take them all into account in furthering my understanding of the Trinity. Any further examples or thoughts are welcome of course 🙂
 
only thing is, I’ve heard about those in the Catholic church coming together and deciding on this all (I forget the name of their meeting or where it was published, sorry to be so vague but i’m sure you know what i’m talking about), so I thought, if they understood it enough to be able to decide on it, surely I should be able to understand it as well? At least close to the point they were able to? I doubt anyone can understand it fully, but i’d like to be able to understand it enough to comprehend it a bit better without getting so confused.
It sounds like you’re thinking of the Ecumenical Councils of the Church that defined these doctrines.

The first one was the Council of Nicaea that was held in 325 and it wanted to define whether or not Christ was Divine or not. From the beginning, the Church had thought that Jesus was God (it’s most clearly laid out in the beginning of the Gospel of Saint John: “In the beginning, the Word was with God and the Word was God.” But the Church never formally defined that Christ was Divine, probably because up until that time the Church was underground and persecuted; numbers were small, Christianity was essentially a cult in the eyes of the world, and I’d guess it would be hard for the leaders to get together and formally pronounce something.

In 312, the Roman Emperor Constantine the Great (whom we recognise as a saint) began to open up to Christianity and he made it legal in 313. It no longer had to be underground. Christianity became vogue and people wanted in, and it became the dominant religion.

A priest from Alexandria, Egypt, named Arius began to theorise that Jesus wasn’t God. Since nothing had formally been declared by the Church about this yet, Arius’ belief gained some growing acceptance. It was opposed by Arius’ own Bishop, Saint Athanasius, who held that Christ is Divine. Debate about this spread through the Empire, and by the 320s, it actually became a topic of major contention in the Empire and Saint Constantine feared that they would start to riot about this.

Constantine called a Council in 325 for the Bishops to define whether or not Christ was God (I like using the word “define” rather than “decide”; some people will use the word “decide” but the Bishops didn’t *choose *anything – their job was just to figure out what the truth was). This Council was the first “Ecumenical” Council, meaning it was for the entire Church. The Bishops got together and overwhelmingly agreed that Jesus is God.

The issue wasn’t totally settled, though. While the Church had already defined it and the Bishops already agreed, there were some pockets of people who still believed in Arius around the Empire. So, another Ecumenical Council was held at Constantinople in 381. It reaffirmed that Christ is Divine, but it also wanted to affirm that the Holy Spirit is God.

There were 21 Ecumenical Councils all together, the last one (Vatican II, popularly named that way because it was the Second Council held at the Vatican) finished in 1965, though it didn’t deal with dogma.

You can read the texts of the documents these Councils made. You can find it online as PDF files, but if you have trouble, let me know and I can send them to you through e-mail or through messenger.

A lot of the stuff in there is pretty arcane and don’t apply anymore; only a handful of the topics they covered were dogmatic. Most of it was disciplinary rules for Church governance. If I remember right, Nicaea also declared that a Bishop was married to his diocese, and transferring to another diocese would be tantamount to adultery. This is one of the things that don’t apply anymore and wasn’t dogmatic; if it still applied, then the current Pope would be an adulterer too (now he is Bishop of Rome, but before that, he was Archbishop of Munich and later the Bishop of Ostia). So, when reading these things, keep in mind that they were in a different mindset back then, and a lot of these things were customs and disciplinary rules that can change and indeed have changed.

But anyway, are those the meetings you were thinking of that tried to talk about the Trinity? Or was it something more recent?

The basics of the Trinity are this:
We believe in One God.
God exists in Three Persons,
*but *, we do not believe in three gods
and each Person is not 1/3 God.
Each is fully God. Each is Eternal.
Each is Equal,
however the Father comes first in precedence, then the Son, then the Holy Spirit.
 
It might be helpful to go here vatican.va/archive/catechism/p1s2c1p2.htm

Scroll down about halfway to where it says “The formation of the Trinitarian Dogma” in bold.

There’s also this thing called the Trinity Shield. Wikipedia has this image of one: http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/e/ec/Shield-Trinity-Scutum-Fidei-basic.png
upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/e/ec/Shield-Trinity-Scutum-Fidei-basic.png

The words translate:

Pater = Father
Filius = Son
Spiritus Sanctus = Holy Spirit
Deus = God
Est = Is
Non Est = Is Not

Basically it says in Latin that the Father is not the Son, the Son is not the Holy Spirit, and the Holy Spirit is not the Father, but the Father is God, the Son is God and the Holy Spirit is God.
 
But anyway, are those the meetings you were thinking of that tried to talk about the Trinity? Or was it something more recent?

The basics of the Trinity are this:
We believe in One God.
God exists in Three Persons,
*but *, we do not believe in three gods
and each Person is not 1/3 God.
Each is fully God. Each is Eternal.
Each is Equal,
however the Father comes first in precedence, then the Son, then the Holy Spirit.
Yes, thank you so much, that’s exactly what I was thinking of, I just didn’t know about it all in that much detail (I’d only heard about the general discussions being made). That was a great post, it’s helped my understanding of how the church came to define it all.

The trinity shield is also really helpful, it’s good to get a visual representation like that 🙂

I’ll have a look at the link you provided as well.

Thanks so much, your answers have been really helpful!
 
I’ve found the Trinity really hard to get my mind around. Is this the same for other Catholics? I’ve read that the Father, Son and Holy Spirit are all one but yet separate, or something along those lines, but I don’t fully understand how it works?

I’ve read some articles on the Catholic Answers site but still am a bit unsure if I understand it all fully… it just seems to be a really hard concept to grasp.

Can anyone explain it to me?

Thanks 🙂
God is the Trinity. The end.
 
Catholic Christians believe that God is a Trinity - that is, God is one nature in three Persons.

Concerning the meaning of the word nature, when someone asks “What is God?” we tell them His nature - like Jews and Muslims, we believe that God’s nature is eternal, indivisible, and infinite.

Concerning the meaning of person, when someone asks “Who is God?” we tell them that God is “the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit”. Yet these three Persons are not three Gods, but one God.

Since God is infinite, there cannot be three infinite Gods, for there can only be one infinite thing. In other words, 3 x infinity = infinity, not 3 infinities.

Here are a few analogies by which you may better understand the Catholic Christian belief that God is a Trinity:

Hold your hand in front of your mouth and say “God”: the thought that generated the word can be compared to the Father, the word itself can be compared to the Son, and the breath that you felt on your hand can be compared to the Holy Spirit. Yet, the thought, the word, and the breath are one.

Another example: light three candles - the three flames can be compared to the three Persons of the Holy Trinity; the nature of all three flames is fire, just as the nature of all three Persons is God. Now hold the three flames of the candles together – the three flames are now one; the three Persons of the Holy Trinity are eternally one.

We Catholic Christians look upon the creation of God as an expression of His nature. Notice that the universe is a trinity of time, space, and matter. Yet there are not three universes - the universe is one.

Notice that time is a trinity of past, present, and future. Yet there are not three times - time is one.

Notice that space is a trinity of height, width, and depth. Yet there are not three spaces - space is one.

Notice that matter is a trinity of solid, gas, and liquid. Yet there are not three matters - matter is one.

So, we believe that Jesus Christ is the incarnation of God, yet when Jesus prayed He was not talking to Himself. He prayed to God (that is, the Father). But Jesus and the Father are not two Gods – God is one. As Jesus says, I and the Father are one (John 10:30), and whoever has seen Me has seen the Father (John 14:9).

And we believe that the Holy Spirit is the Spirit of God, Who was given to the apostles of Christ at Pentecost, and Whose presence is still with us today. The Holy Spirit is the Spirit of Christ and the Father, and He dwells in us. This is why we are told to treat our bodies and the bodies of others with respect, since the human body is a temple of the Holy Spirit.

In our Holy Scriptures, the Father is often referred to simply as God, Jesus as Christ or Lord, and the Holy Spirit as the Spirit. Yet all three are equally God and all three have existed as one God in eternity. There was never a time when the Father existed without the Son or the Spirit, just as there is never a time when a flame is without light or heat.

Thus, God is like a flame (the Father) that generates light (the Son) and heat (the Spirit). The light generated by the flame strikes our eyes, and this is how we see the flame - in the same way, the Son entered our world by becoming flesh and this is how we see and know God. The heat proceeds from the flame through the light and warms our skin, and this is how we feel the flame – in the same way the Spirit of God dwells in our body and soul, and this is how we feel the presence of God.

This is what we believe about God. These things could not have been figured out by human reason alone – they have been revealed to us by the Holy Spirit speaking through the mouths of the prophets and Jesus Christ, Whom we believe is the ultimate revelation of God.

Peace.
 
Catholic Christians believe that God is a Trinity - that is, God is one nature in three Persons.

Concerning the meaning of the word nature, when someone asks “What is God?” we tell them His nature - like Jews and Muslims, we believe that God’s nature is eternal, indivisible, and infinite.

Concerning the meaning of person, when someone asks “Who is God?” we tell them that God is “the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit”. Yet these three Persons are not three Gods, but one God.

Since God is infinite, there cannot be three infinite Gods, for there can only be one infinite thing. In other words, 3 x infinity = infinity, not 3 infinities.

Here are a few analogies by which you may better understand the Catholic Christian belief that God is a Trinity:

Hold your hand in front of your mouth and say “God”: the thought that generated the word can be compared to the Father, the word itself can be compared to the Son, and the breath that you felt on your hand can be compared to the Holy Spirit. Yet, the thought, the word, and the breath are one.

Another example: light three candles - the three flames can be compared to the three Persons of the Holy Trinity; the nature of all three flames is fire, just as the nature of all three Persons is God. Now hold the three flames of the candles together – the three flames are now one; the three Persons of the Holy Trinity are eternally one.

We Catholic Christians look upon the creation of God as an expression of His nature. Notice that the universe is a trinity of time, space, and matter. Yet there are not three universes - the universe is one.

Notice that time is a trinity of past, present, and future. Yet there are not three times - time is one.

Notice that space is a trinity of height, width, and depth. Yet there are not three spaces - space is one.

Notice that matter is a trinity of solid, gas, and liquid. Yet there are not three matters - matter is one.

So, we believe that Jesus Christ is the incarnation of God, yet when Jesus prayed He was not talking to Himself. He prayed to God (that is, the Father). But Jesus and the Father are not two Gods – God is one. As Jesus says, I and the Father are one (John 10:30), and whoever has seen Me has seen the Father (John 14:9).

And we believe that the Holy Spirit is the Spirit of God, Who was given to the apostles of Christ at Pentecost, and Whose presence is still with us today. The Holy Spirit is the Spirit of Christ and the Father, and He dwells in us. This is why we are told to treat our bodies and the bodies of others with respect, since the human body is a temple of the Holy Spirit.

In our Holy Scriptures, the Father is often referred to simply as God, Jesus as Christ or Lord, and the Holy Spirit as the Spirit. Yet all three are equally God and all three have existed as one God in eternity. There was never a time when the Father existed without the Son or the Spirit, just as there is never a time when a flame is without light or heat.

Thus, God is like a flame (the Father) that generates light (the Son) and heat (the Spirit). The light generated by the flame strikes our eyes, and this is how we see the flame - in the same way, the Son entered our world by becoming flesh and this is how we see and know God. The heat proceeds from the flame through the light and warms our skin, and this is how we feel the flame – in the same way the Spirit of God dwells in our body and soul, and this is how we feel the presence of God.

This is what we believe about God. These things could not have been figured out by human reason alone – they have been revealed to us by the Holy Spirit speaking through the mouths of the prophets and Jesus Christ, Whom we believe is the ultimate revelation of God.

Peace.
Thank you so much, those examples were brilliant! You explained it really really well 🙂
 
The Shield conveys some truths about the Trinity well, but it does not convey the relationships among the Perons very well. Instead of an inverted triangle, it should be a regular triangle, with the Father at the top and the Son and Holy Spirit the two corners at the bottom. That preserves the very important idea of the monarchy of the Father.
 
Why is God a trinity of Persons? Because God is love, and was love even before He created anything to love. That means that, before there was creation, there was some thing (or some one) for God to love.

Does God love Himself? That is, in the sense that God is only one Person who loves Himself? That does not seem to be the case, since that is not the model of love He gives to us follow. Rather, the model of love He gives us to follow is love for another (selfless love). That means that God did not “love Himself” in the sense that God is one Person who loves Himself (selfish love).

So perhaps God is two Persons, who love one another. These two Persons (the Father and the Son) have always existed (or else the one would not have been always loving the other) and both are equally God (since God was love before anything else was created).

But then, where does this “love” come from? It too must have always existed, or else love is simply a creation of God’s, and not a trait of God at all, and that means God wasn’t love until He had created it.

So love has always existed as well, along with these two Persons of God. This love is distinct from the two Persons of Father and Son, because it is something given from the one to the other. Thus, this “love” is a third Person of God, the Holy Spirit.

If God is not a trinity, then He is not love.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top