Unhealthy relationship

  • Thread starter Thread starter canadiannurse
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
C

canadiannurse

Guest
Hello everyone,

I’ve posted a few times before and am hesitant about posting again but would like some (name removed by moderator)ut.

The last three years have seen a deepening in my faith, and I spent some time discerning becoming a sister early last year. Ultimately I felt God was calling me to marriage, so I pursued online dating which I had done before. I had one previous relationship from Catholic Match, so I thought I would try Catholic Match again. That relationship, he wasn’t as deep as a Catholic as I would have liked, and also a city boy and very material which did not work for either of us since I’m kind of a country bumpkin that just knows how to dress well once in awhile 🙂

I met a man who was 37, and who I believed him to be turned out to be different than who he was. He was not honest about some things that I really wish he had been. Things from his past kept coming up as the relationship evolved that made me uncomfortable. He claimed that God had forgiven him, and the past doesn’t matter, but when you are 37 and getting drunk at a rodeo and then taking a girl back to her hotel room two weeks before we met, I felt that showed me a lot about who he still was - not something he had done years before but only two weeks prior to us meeting.

He has MS, which I felt I could handle, but it turns out that only seemed to be one of many things he brought to the table. He was very insecure and seemed to need to make up for this by being very dominant, adding in his temper, and he would grab me a lot if I tried walking away when he wasn’t done talking to me. The day I noticed bruises on my forearms was a bit wakeup call to me. His moods were also very unstable, and I can’t diagnose him but he has every single symptom of bipolar disorder. I’m a nurse and I watched this very carefully, his grandiose ideas, flight of thoughts, elevated moods and personality, racing thoughts, unable to sleep, and then going back to periods of hopelessness and depression. His work stability has never been stable which for 37 worried me, especially since he thought he should be the primary bread winner.

I am going to seek counseling for having stayed in this relationship - obviously I have my own issues that led me to stay and be in this relationship. I have had one appointment so far, another one this week. I also saw my spiritual director last week and will see her again next week.

He said a lot of mean things to me, he could be very mean. I ended up losing almost 20 lbs over the span of this relationship and I don’t think I have much more room to lose weight. I hadn’t considered myself chubby. He was constantly bringing up how beautiful other women were and once said something along the lines of a beautiful tv star wouldn’t be interested in a man like him. Somewhere in there was supposed to be a compliment for me, I still haven’t figured it out. He broke up with me and changed his mind many times over the course of the relationship, the lack of stability was really hard on me. I can see now that after my first visit to see him when he broke up with me right after, that I should have said Adios and take care.

I ended up losing a lot in this relationship - it was long distance so I made some decisions to pursue it that I shouldn’t have. I can see now that God kept opening the doors until only so far, and in this is the biggest learning lesson of my life, the hardest and most painful.

This does give me a chance to start fresh - and maybe God has plans in that. I think the most confusing part for me is that we prayed together a lot, went to Mass when we were together, spent a lot of time with his family (siblings and their families). We made a lot of mistakes, one of them having slept together. We went to Confession and did not repeat it, but my heart sits very heavy as I wait to find out if I am pregnant.

Before this I felt like I had had my life together - my own house, full time job, had worked on myself and my relationship with my family. It all kind of came crashing apart, and all because I met a man who turned out to be someone very different than I thought.

This is still all very fresh and raw in my head and heart - things ended on Christmas Day. I had left so many of my things with him, as we are from different countries (he is american). I think I will call all those a loss.

I still feel called to marriage but this one will take me awhile to sort through. I will remain faithful to God especially in this time, especially because I am in a pretty vulnerable place right now.

Thanks for listening 🙂
 
God bless you, sister.
I’m sorry you have been through so much with this relationship, It sounds as if you have learned a lot from it, however.

I have a good friend who has confided in me over the past couple of years as she dated and prayed for a spouse. She met several nice fellows and always seemed to think it was “the one.” She wanted someone honest and sincerely Catholic, and wouldn’t settle for less.

Her first guy after several months turned out to be an alcoholic, and she broke up with him. The next was a professional who just didn’t have time for her, would make dates and then have to break them because of work emergencies. And he wanted to spend most of his free time with his children, which left little for her.

After meeting several guys, she is now engaged to an excellent Catholic who is kind and reliable. She has known him for quite awhile, and they’ve attended retreats and mass together.

I mention all this to explain that my friend went through all this without injury to her heart by sticking to her convictions. She never went to bed with any of them, She tries to follow God’s will in everything. If everyone approached dating as she did, there would be much less heartbreak. It was inspiring to talk with her.

I hope that you also will not give up, but keep your heart to yourself. Don’t give away either heart or body before you are sure you’ve found a good man. Anyone who asks you to sleep with him before marriage has ruled himself out right then.
As a nurse, you know what advice you would give your patients. We are reluctant to take our own advice, but think about what you would tell a patient in your situation, and follow your own advice.

.
 
I know you must be feeling a whole host of emotions (fragile, hurt, vulnerable etc)…and it may not seem like it now, but it was probably a blessing from God that you broke up with this man before it went on any longer…

If you want to try dating why not ask family, friends etc if they know any nice, single catholic gentleman to set you up with on. Blind date…if your family and friends know the men they are likely to be decent as I doubt they would set you up with a creep.

If you haven’t done so already then please do find out if you are pregnant so that you can start receiving any medical care you need for you and your baby…and you need to know if you are pregnant so that you have plenty of time to prepare and buy all that you need…

I know it must hurt to have had to leave your belongings with the man and to know you probably wont get them back…but it may not seem like it now but you have been blessed with being able to make a clean break from him…if you had been married to him and wanted to leave him it would have been messy with divorce,an annullment, dividing assets, joint finances etc…
 
Sorry the relationship turned out so badly for you. I certainly hope you aren’t pregnant, but as the poster above stated, you need to find out so you can prepare for your son or daughter. You might want to get checked for STDs as well. As a nurse, you know they don’t all have symptoms.

I think it’s wonderful you’re going to counseling. I hope you continue. You might want to see a priest as well. Deepening your prayer life will make you stronger next time and hopefully you don’t make the mistake of sleeping with a man outside of marriage or staying in an abusive relationship. God is not calling you to that.

I’ve never known anyone who had success with online dating. Why not make an effort to find a nice Catholic man in your community? And to make sure you aren’t being called to the religious life why not go stay with some sisters for a time? Many orders welcome guests, and even if you aren’t going to become one of them being with them will bring you some peace and tranquility in this stressful time.

Good luck and God bless.
 
Many of us here on CAF met their husbands or wives online.
The problem is not internet dating.
The problem is continuing in a situation that is not healthy or uplifting. This can happen even if the guy lives next door.

OP sounds like you are handling this in the proper way, seeking outside help, and realizing that this is an unhealthy match.
God bless you, and I pray that you meet someone who will value you as Christ Himself does.
Peace.
 
OP,

You need to stick to your beliefs. Be firm in your position.

Don’t start changing your beliefs to please a date. All of the changes you did were red flags. Also, the fact that your date did not care about your beliefs is a red flag. Also, keep yours eyes open for those that like playing with your feelings. If he is playing games then just drop him. It is not worth the hassle.

It helps not to put yourself in those situations. Don’t be alone with him at his place or your place. Meet in public places for your dates. Invite another couple if you want to see him at your place. Don’t let him overstay after the other couple leaves.

I’ve read several threads so far, and the OPs were good Catholic women like you with the best of intentions, but just met the wrong dates.
 
Holding you up in prayer this morning.

So glad you got away from him and have recognized that something was not right, and also recognized something going on within you that you put up with and ignored all these signs. I am so sorry that this took such a heavy toll on you emotionally, physically, financially. I’m sure it feels like the darkest hour. But, you have a very mature and positive approach to the whole thing, so I am sure God will work things out for you and better things are on the horizon.

Take care of yourself, and don’t beat yourself up over this. We all want to be loved and to love in return. Sometimes we let that need get ahead of our common sense. Don’t be afraid to love in the future, just make sure you have a more firm grasp on discerning signs in the relationship before you start a new one.
 
Thank you for your responses so far. It will take me time and help to unpack it. I don’t have a problem with online dating, I feel as though I approached it safely. Although I did learn a lot of things I would do differently to have a support system.

I feel an incredible amount of shame for my actions - I know God has forgiven me but I haven’t forgiven myself yet.

I will be speaking my priest - he had met this fellow. The only problem is that I hadn’t been honest with anyone about some of the dynamics of the relationship… not my family or his family or any of my friends up until these past few days. When he met my family and priest, I felt like he could be very charming and what I saw of him was very different. Depending on his mood. I’m terribly embarassed about all of this - I’m a RN, I’m not sure how I allowed myself to get so deep into what I can now admit was an abusive relationship.

Someday when I have worked through all of this and with the okay of my spiritual director, I hope I can try dating again. I also hope that whoever it is I end up marrying will be okay with this - it’s a terribly messy part of my past.
 
Many of us here on CAF met their husbands or wives online.
The problem is not internet dating.
The problem is continuing in a situation that is not healthy or uplifting. This can happen even if the guy lives next door.

OP sounds like you are handling this in the proper way, seeking outside help, and realizing that this is an unhealthy match.
God bless you, and I pray that you meet someone who will value you as Christ Himself does.
Peace.
Yeah, this has nothing to do with online dating. There have been terrible men and women in existence long before the internet. This is an issue of self-respect for the OP, which I can tell she realizes. We can’t control whether or not the people we encounter have issues; we can only ensure we deal with our own.

Coincidentally, I met my wife on Catholic Match, am around their age (40) and have MS (though you can’t tell, and I haven’t had a symptom in years…), but have never been to a rodeo, it can’t be me.
 
Sorry the relationship turned out so badly for you. I certainly hope you aren’t pregnant, but as the poster above stated, you need to find out so you can prepare for your son or daughter. You might want to get checked for STDs as well. As a nurse, you know they don’t all have symptoms.

I think it’s wonderful you’re going to counseling. I hope you continue. You might want to see a priest as well. Deepening your prayer life will make you stronger next time and hopefully you don’t make the mistake of sleeping with a man outside of marriage or staying in an abusive relationship. God is not calling you to that.

I’ve never known anyone who had success with online dating. Why not make an effort to find a nice Catholic man in your community? And to make sure you aren’t being called to the religious life why not go stay with some sisters for a time? Many orders welcome guests, and even if you aren’t going to become one of them being with them will bring you some peace and tranquility in this stressful time.

Good luck and God bless.
I met my husband through online dating. We have been civilly married for almost 5 years, and sacramentally married for just over 3. (He had to have his first marriage declared invalid before we could be married in the Church.) My sister also met her husband online and they have been married for almost 7 years.

As regards the OP - I think the approach you’re taking is fantastic. I am very reassured that you discovered these facts about your partner before you took the step of marrying him. You don’t marry a project.

I recommend that you take this time to pray and watch for God’s will before you consider a new relationship. The LAST thing you need is to get into a rebound relationship.
 
I met my husband through online dating. We have been civilly married for almost 5 years, and sacramentally married for just over 3. (He had to have his first marriage declared invalid before we could be married in the Church.) My sister also met her husband online and they have been married for almost 7 years.

As regards the OP - I think the approach you’re taking is fantastic. I am very reassured that you discovered these facts about your partner before you took the step of marrying him. You don’t marry a project.

I recommend that you take this time to pray and watch for God’s will before you consider a new relationship. The LAST thing you need is to get into a rebound relationship.
I believe a small percentage of people have success with online dating, but personally, the ones I’ve known have found it a nightmare.

Glad your experience was different.
 
Thanks again for the replies. I just spoke with a counselor again and she helped me unpack it some more. It felt really good to be honest with her, and she also turned out to be Catholic and understood my faith background. Ultimately the relationship was abusive, which was hard for me to accept because I obviously thought the world of this guy, and he was a praying Catholic, and from a good catholic home. Whether he will ever have any insight to this, I’m not sure, but I guess all I can do for him now is pray for him.
 
I believe a small percentage of people have success with online dating, but personally, the ones I’ve known have found it a nightmare.

Glad your experience was different.
DH and I have been married 10 years and met on Ave Maria. Anecdotal, yes. But, there are many of us on CAF and elsewhere. It is quite common these days.

It takes a cautious approach, approaching online dating no differently than you would any other dating.
 
DH and I have been married 10 years and met on Ave Maria. Anecdotal, yes. But, there are many of us on CAF and elsewhere. It is quite common these days.

It takes a cautious approach, approaching online dating no differently than you would any other dating.
I’m glad you had a positive experience, but I do think online dating is significantly different from “real life” dating. When you meet someone in “real life” you usually get to know them prior to dating. You know what to expect from them. When you meet online, you develop expectations that can be unrealistic and you can feel tremendously letdown when you actually meet the person even if both people have been completely truthful.

I mean “you” in general, not you, personally.

At any rate, I’m glad it worked out for you.
 
I’m glad you had a positive experience, but I do think online dating is significantly different from “real life” dating. When you meet someone in “real life” you usually get to know them prior to dating. You know what to expect from them. When you meet online, you develop expectations that can be unrealistic and you can feel tremendously letdown when you actually meet the person even if both people have been completely truthful.

I mean “you” in general, not you, personally.

At any rate, I’m glad it worked out for you.
Online Datings works by moving the dating offline AS SOON AS POSSIBLE.
 
What is it that makes it so hard for people to meet in “real life,” i.e. not online, now? They seemed to do fine before the Internet, and I know I get asked out often by lots of men who aren’t aware I don’t date.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top