Unity of faith?

  • Thread starter Thread starter jasev
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
J

jasev

Guest
So, I’ve been listening to Catholic radio for about a week and a half. I’ve been lurking on these forums for a few days. I’ve caught EWTN’s Coming Home a few times over the last year. I’ve noticed, because it seems to be said or written once every two minutes, that one of the chief arguments Catholic apologists like to throw out is a line that usually runs something like, “There are 30,000 something denominations out there all claiming to understand the Bible and the Bible alone, clearly they’re not all right! Therefore the Bible is not enough.”

Okay, I really have no interest in debating whether that is true or not. What I am curious in, is how then do Catholics understand all of the great diversity in the Church itself? The kind of diversity in mind is:
I heard Fr. John Corapi state this morning that only 65% of Catholics believe in the Real Presence. (I’m going by memory. If I’ve grossly mis-remembered that number please just call me on it. Not trying to mis-represent what he said if that’s wrong… just a faulty memory!).
I’ve witnessed a number of shots taken at charismatic Catholics (are these the Renewal Catholics?), Old School Catholics (who apparently believe Vatican II was a mistake), conservative modern Catholics (I’m guessing they could be called the Vatican II crowed just to distinguish them from liberals and the old school folks?), and liberal Catholics (both the theological and politically liberal). These are shots at each other, not from outside!
I don’t fully claim to understand the idea of religious orders within the church (e.g. Franciscans, Dominicans, Jesuits, etc.) but based on brief comments I get the impression they don’t all agree that the others are “doing spirituality right.” Have I totally misunderstood this one? The Jesuits in particular seem to be taking a lot of flak for being liberal. Is that right?
I have a book on my shelf from Fr. Gary Wills titled, “What Paul Meant.” I very highly doubt most conservative Catholics would agree with this man on his interpretation of Paul. It’s really not worth my going into his theories here. You can likely get a good enough sense of them from the book’s reviews on Amazon. In any case, there are apparently scores of not so conservative Catholics who agree with him. No? (Perhaps these are the ~75% who don’t show up for mass weekly? Another figure I think I heard from Corapi this morning.)
In a similar vein as Fr. Gary Wills above, there is John Dominic Crossan. I understand he is now a former Catholic Priest. He is still a Roman Catholic, right? He and Funk basically are the “Jesus Seminar.” I don’t think I’m going out on a limb to assume this isn’t inline with “official” church teaching, right?
It sure seems to me the Catholic church isn’t nearly the monolith of faith her apologists claim for her. Is it really that the Roman Catholic Church itself is “one, holy, catholic, and apostolic?” The unity just doesn’t seem to be there past the surface level. Have I misunderstood the claim?
 
Yes, its true that many Catholics have dissident beliefs.

But of course no one can deny that not everyone’s beliefs can be true. There is only one truth. That is why there is a logical necessity for an infallible interpreter of the bible (because there are sooo many different individual interpretations.)

If a particular Catholic holds beliefs that are not in agreement with the Catholic church, that does not mean the church is wrong, it means they are wrong. The Catholic church claims to be infallible, and does not change its teachings.

The apologists are making claims about the teachings of the magesterium, not the behavior and beliefs of individual people. There is only one truth no matter what individual people believe.

Does that answer your question? Or are you asking why there are so many Catholics that disagree with the church? I don’t know why that is. 🤷
 
Is there some kind of Magisterium body of knowledge… a dictionary or encyclopedia so you can easily look up the infallible interpretations indexed topically or by scripture reference? I’m assuming the Catechism somewhat plays this role, but is that it?

Speaking of the Catechism, I’ve seen Catholics claim the current Catechism is somehow not good or accurate and that the Baltimore Catechism is better. Does this mean that only what the currently reigning Magisterium believes is correct and overrules what prior bishops might have written?
 
Because the Catholic church is not contained within a body of people, as in the people being the end and the beginning of it, that’s the protestant church. With people, we all have our struggles, errors, and in general, will never fully get along, do not take human nature itself as being definitive of the church itself, otherwise you are going to always fall short with understanding, ie. trust not in the flesh, for the flesh will always let you down.
 
This is precisely why God gave us the (one) Church, pillar and foundation of (one) truth. We must be obedient to the truth and authority of it, even if we can’t or choose not to understand it. Jesus is the Truth and Authority and he gave it to His one Church. This is quite the hardship even for many Catholics. May we all be One, as the Father and Son are One. One spirit, mind and faith; one heart and soul.

Peace,
T
 
So, the Magisterium is the teaching authority in the church. It is composed of the Bishops in union with the Roman Pope. This is all bishops/popes across time, not just current. Right?

Are you telling me that there is nothing that is an authoritative body of work from these people… an encyclopedia, an anthology, something? How in the world does one know if their beliefs are inline with this then?

Surely I’m misunderstanding something here.
 
Is there some kind of Magisterium body of knowledge… a dictionary or encyclopedia so you can easily look up the infallible interpretations indexed topically or by scripture reference? I’m assuming the Catechism somewhat plays this role, but is that it?

Speaking of the Catechism, I’ve seen Catholics claim the current Catechism is somehow not good or accurate and that the Baltimore Catechism is better. Does this mean that only what the currently reigning Magisterium believes is correct and overrules what prior bishops might have written?
There is Fundamentals of Catholic Dogma which arranges teachings of the Church by their degree of certitude (there are a number of categories which a teaching can fall into depending on how certain it is: I think only the top two categories are for infallible teachings, but that Catholics are still more or less expected to believe the teachings in at least the next couple of categories, though with not as unwavering faith as for the infallible ones). If you are thinking of getting it, bear in mind that Ott’s compendium is not necessarily infallible itself. Also, it was originally in German, and I have heard the English translation criticized, though only on what seemed to me comparatively quite minor points.

As regards your second question, theological opinions can evolve, but infallible teachings cannot be changed. It is important to remember that any catechism, while it almost certainly will contain a number of infallible teachings, is not infallible itself. An example of theological opinion evolving would be concerning the Limbo of Infants: it was widely believed in for a long time, but, as far as I know, it was never Church teaching, and it is a far less popular idea now.

If, however, the Pope were to issue a statement tomorrow, dressed up in all the trappings of infallibility, which stated that Jesus of Nazareth was only divine and not also human, such a statement would be utterly void, as the existence of the two natures of Christ is an infallible teaching of the Church.
 
If, however, the Pope were to issue a statement tomorrow, dressed up in all the trappings of infallibility, which stated that Jesus of Nazareth was only divine and not also human, such a statement would be utterly void, as the existence of the two natures of Christ is an infallible teaching of the Church.
Fortunately for us, the gift of papal infallibility would guarantee us that he could not do that. Even the handful of really bad Popes we’ve had throughout our 2000 year history did not declare any erroneous doctrines for the Church universal. Maybe they were too busy being bad? 😃
 
Is there some kind of Magisterium body of knowledge… a dictionary or encyclopedia so you can easily look up the infallible interpretations indexed topically or by scripture reference? I’m assuming the Catechism somewhat plays this role, but is that it?

Speaking of the Catechism, I’ve seen Catholics claim the current Catechism is somehow not good or accurate and that the Baltimore Catechism is better. Does this mean that only what the currently reigning Magisterium believes is correct and overrules what prior bishops might have written?
You are assuming for the Church to be unified, all its members must agree on every topic. That is not the case, though of course some Catholics will not agree with my statement. See what I mean?

I believe, however, that Scipture supports my statement. I have taken the liberty of providing a bit of Scripture from the Amplified Bible (a Protestant translation): Galations 2:11-12:
“But when Cephas (Peter) came to Antioch, I protested and opposed him to his face [concerning his conduct there], for he was blameable and stood condemned.
For up to the time that certain persons came from James, he ate his meals with the Gentile [converts]; but when the men [from Jerusalem] arrived, he withdrew and held himself aloof from the Gentiles and [ate] separately for fear of those of the circumcision [party].”


In this passage the Apostle Paul openly disagrees and chastises the Apostle Peter and others of the Jewish faction in the early Church. Blind acquiescence or obedience is not always the proper course of action, unless it is a matter of infallible dogma or doctrine.

Even between a husband and wife (Their marriage defined as a lifelong unifying bond that God has sanctioned.), the man and woman may often disagree. That doesn’t mean they aren’t still husband and wife. That doesn’t mean that somehow the unifying bond is broken.

The same is true of the Catholic Church. Many members may disagree, but to remain within the Church, they agree to agree on certain basics: the infallible dogmas and doctrines, understanding that human comprehension of those dogmas and doctrines will evolve by the grace of the Holy Spirit.

The above Biblical passage demonstrates this clearly. The first Christians, which were led by the Jewish faction from Palestine, slowly came to realize that older Jewish traditions and observances were not necessary and in fact, many times superfluous or a hindrance to salvation.

The Apostle Paul concludes in Galations 2:15-16:
" Although we ourselves (you and I) are Jews by birth and not Gentile (heathen) sinners,
Yet we know that a man is justified or reckoned righteous and in right standing with God not by works of the Law, but [only] through faith and [absolute] reliance on and adherence to and trust in Jesus Christ (the Messiah, the Anointed One). [Therefore] even we [ourselves] have believed on Christ Jesus, in order to be justified by faith in Christ and not by works of the Law [for we cannot be justified by any observance of the ritual of the Law given by Moses], because by keeping legal rituals and by works no human being can ever be justified (declared righteous and put in right standing with God)."*

Did that mean that the Apostle Paul taught that salvation came from professing faith only? Of course not, the Church taught (and continues to teach) that true faith and love of the Lord was (and is) demonstrated by actions on the part of the believer. As Jesus said to his disciples in John 14:15 “If you [really] love Me, you will keep (obey) My commands.”

Although I have provided these passages from a Protestant translation for your benefit, even in the interpretation of Scripture, Catholics agree to be guided by the Church, and there are many Scriptural interpretations within the Church. Still, all the interpretations must ultimately conform to the basic dogmas and doctrines.

I hope this helps you understand the idea of unity within the Church.*
 
You are assuming for the Church to be unified, all its members must agree on every topic. That is not the case, though of course some Catholics will not agree with my statement. See what I mean?

I believe, however, that Scipture supports my statement. I have taken the liberty of providing a bit of Scripture from the Amplified Bible (a Protestant translation): Galations 2:11-12:
“But when Cephas (Peter) came to Antioch, I protested and opposed him to his face [concerning his conduct there], for he was blameable and stood condemned.
For up to the time that certain persons came from James, he ate his meals with the Gentile [converts]; but when the men [from Jerusalem] arrived, he withdrew and held himself aloof from the Gentiles and [ate] separately for fear of those of the circumcision [party].”


In this passage the Apostle Paul openly disagrees and chastises the Apostle Peter and others of the Jewish faction in the early Church. Blind acquiescence or obedience is not always the proper course of action, unless it is a matter of infallible dogma or doctrine.

Even between a husband and wife (Their marriage defined as a lifelong unifying bond that God has sanctioned.), the man and woman may often disagree. That doesn’t mean they aren’t still husband and wife. That doesn’t mean that somehow the unifying bond is broken.

The same is true of the Catholic Church. Many members may disagree, but to remain within the Church, they agree to agree on certain basics: the infallible dogmas and doctrines, understanding that human comprehension of those dogmas and doctrines will evolve by the grace of the Holy Spirit.

The above Biblical passage demonstrates this clearly. The first Christians, which were led by the Jewish faction from Palestine, slowly came to realize that older Jewish traditions and observances were not necessary and in fact, many times superfluous or a hindrance to salvation.

The Apostle Paul concludes in Galations 2:15-16:
" Although we ourselves (you and I) are Jews by birth and not Gentile (heathen) sinners,
Yet we know that a man is justified or reckoned righteous and in right standing with God not by works of the Law, but [only] through faith and [absolute] reliance on and adherence to and trust in Jesus Christ (the Messiah, the Anointed One). [Therefore] even we [ourselves] have believed on Christ Jesus, in order to be justified by faith in Christ and not by works of the Law [for we cannot be justified by any observance of the ritual of the Law given by Moses], because by keeping legal rituals and by works no human being can ever be justified (declared righteous and put in right standing with God)."**

Did that mean that the Apostle Paul taught that salvation came from professing faith only? Of course not, the Church taught (and continues to teach) that true faith and love of the Lord was (and is) demonstrated by actions on the part of the believer. As Jesus said to his disciples in John 14:15 “If you [really] love Me, you will keep (obey) My commands.”

Although I have provided these passages from a Protestant translation for your benefit, even in the interpretation of Scripture, Catholics agree to be guided by the Church, and there are many Scriptural interpretations within the Church. Still, all the interpretations must ultimately conform to the basic dogmas and doctrines.

I hope this helps you understand the idea of unity within the Church.

I’m sure you’ll get an earful from the traditionalists but I for one support your position here.

One Question: do you consider the ban on barrier method birth control, same unions, females in the priesthood, married males in the priesthood, universal excommunication for women who wilingly abort (even in the case of life-threatening pregnancy or rape), to be part of the protected infallible dogma/doctrine that must be dissented from?
 
I’m sure you’ll get an earful from the traditionalists but I for one support your position here.

One Question: do you consider the ban on barrier method birth control, same unions, females in the priesthood, married males in the priesthood, universal excommunication for women who wilingly abort (even in the case of life-threatening pregnancy or rape), to be part of the protected infallible dogma/doctrine that must be dissented from?
Before he responds, I just want to clarify that not having married priests is not an infallible doctrine, it is only a discipline and can be changed at any time.
 
I’m sure you’ll get an earful from the traditionalists but I for one support your position here.

One Question: do you consider the ban on barrier method birth control, same unions, females in the priesthood, married males in the priesthood, universal excommunication for women who wilingly abort (even in the case of life-threatening pregnancy or rape), to be part of the protected infallible dogma/doctrine that must be dissented from?
One question? Whoa! That’s a lot of questions, and each one is probably worth a thread on its own. And I don’t believe that Catholics can dissent from the infallible dogma and doctrine of the Church. They can dissent on teachings, but may have to leave the Church or face excommunication if they practice that dissent.

Abortion is willful taking of another human life. That life may still be within the mother’s womb, but at the moment of conception, a new, individual life has been created. I believe that the Church’s position on abortion is infallible and I believe that Scripture supports that position. John the Baptist jumped within the womb of Elizabeth when Mary, already carrying the Lord Jesus, spoke to Elizabeth (Luke 1:41)

In Jeremiah 1:5, God speaks to the prophet: *“Before I formed thee in the bowels of thy mother, I knew thee: and before thou camest forth out of the womb, I sanctified thee, and made thee a prophet unto the nations. *” (Douay Rheims)

Whether the taking of human life is always a violation of the New Covenant commandments, obviously, is open to interpretation, since even religious Catholics willingly kill other people in war.

I assume that you mean same-sex unions. Homosexuality is both an Old and New Covenant sin, just like adultery, fornication, drunkeness, gluttony, sloth, etc. To knowingly and willingly persist in such a sin separates a person from God, violates the temple of the Holy Spirit, and literally opens a highway to hell.

I don’t believe that the Church teaches the conditions of priesthood as infallible dogma or doctrine. The Apostle Peter, the first Pope, was married. We know that from Scripture. The conditions of ordination are simply that: conditions. If a man does not want to meet those condtions, he should not become a priest. I believe that women are barred from the priesthood, based on the writings of the Apostle Paul and early Church practices, which were carryovers from the Jewish roots of Christianity.

Barrier birth control is opposed by the Church and to use that method is a sin. To willingly continue to use such a method exposes that person to punishment from the Church including excommunication. In the United States, however, we all know that such punishment is rarely applied.
 
One question? Whoa! That’s a lot of questions, and each one is probably worth a thread on its own. And I don’t believe that Catholics can dissent from the infallible dogma and doctrine of the Church. They can dissent on teachings, but may have to leave the Church or face excommunication if they practice that dissent.

Abortion is willful taking of another human life. That life may still be within the mother’s womb, but at the moment of conception, a new, individual life has been created. I believe that the Church’s position on abortion is infallible and I believe that Scripture supports that position. John the Baptist jumped within the womb of Elizabeth when Mary, already carrying the Lord Jesus, spoke to Elizabeth (Luke 1:41)

In Jeremiah 1:5, God speaks to the prophet: *“Before I formed thee in the bowels of thy mother, I knew thee: and before thou camest forth out of the womb, I sanctified thee, and made thee a prophet unto the nations. *” (Douay Rheims)

Whether the taking of human life is always a violation of the New Covenant commandments, obviously, is open to interpretation, since even religious Catholics willingly kill other people in war.

I assume that you mean same-sex unions. Homosexuality is both an Old and New Covenant sin, just like adultery, fornication, drunkeness, gluttony, sloth, etc. To knowingly and willingly persist in such a sin separates a person from God, violates the temple of the Holy Spirit, and literally opens a highway to hell.

I don’t believe that the Church teaches the conditions of priesthood as infallible dogma or doctrine. The Apostle Peter, the first Pope, was married. We know that from Scripture. The conditions of ordination are simply that: conditions. If a man does not want to meet those condtions, he should not become a priest. I believe that women are barred from the priesthood, based on the writings of the Apostle Paul and early Church practices, which were carryovers from the Jewish roots of Christianity.

Barrier birth control is opposed by the Church and to use that method is a sin. To willingly continue to use such a method exposes that person to punishment from the Church including excommunication. In the United States, however, we all know that such punishment is rarely applied.
So then, you don’t dissent from any Papal teaching? Correct?
 
The Church is one in the sense that there is only one Mystical Body of Christ, i.e. all its members with Christ as its head. The second aspect is that these members are in union with the Pope and recognize and accept his authority. Rituals, practices, language may be various, but all are under the authority of Peter and his successors.
 
So then, you don’t dissent from any Papal teaching? Correct?
Not all Papal teachings fall under the umbrella of infallibility. The First Vatican Council in1870 defined the dogma of Papal infallibility: the Pope “… is, by reason of the Divine assistance promised to him in blessed Peter, possessed of that infallibility with which the Divine Redeemer wished His Church to be endowed in defining doctrines of faith and morals…”

So solemn and strict is the dogma of Papal infallibility that it has only been invoked once, ex cathedra, since the First Vatican Council to promulgate the Assumption of the Virgin Mary as a basic tenet of the Catholic faith.

More or less, I am not required, even as a good Catholic, to accept every teaching of the Pope as infallible, though of course in most cases I would accede to his learning and piety.
 
Not all Papal teachings fall under the umbrella of infallibility. The First Vatican Council in1870 defined the dogma of Papal infallibility: the Pope “… is, by reason of the Divine assistance promised to him in blessed Peter, possessed of that infallibility with which the Divine Redeemer wished His Church to be endowed in defining doctrines of faith and morals…”

So solemn and strict is the dogma of Papal infallibility that it has only been invoked once, ex cathedra, since the First Vatican Council to promulgate the Assumption of the Virgin Mary as a basic tenet of the Catholic faith.

More or less, I am not required, even as a good Catholic, to accept every teaching of the Pope as infallible, though of course in most cases I would accede to his learning and piety.
I don’t understand richardacombs. You raised the issue of the Petro-Pauline Controversy and correctly pointed that the matter shows us that Papal supremacy had not really been established in Peter’s own lifetime. In the early church dissent was quite possible even over matters of doctrine and morals as any clearheaded reading of the book of Galatians will make clear.

So if you assent to everything the Pope teaches (whether infallible or no) why did you bring this up at all? Is there an issue where you think the Pope is just plainly wrong?
 
I don’t understand richardacombs. You raised the issue of the Petro-Pauline Controversy and correctly pointed that the matter shows us that Papal supremacy had not really been established in Peter’s own lifetime. In the early church dissent was quite possible even over matters of doctrine and morals as any clearheaded reading of the book of Galatians will make clear.

So if you assent to everything the Pope teaches (whether infallible or no) why did you bring this up at all? Is there an issue where you think the Pope is just plainly wrong?
The truth that many poorly catechized Catholics do not sometimes know is that ALL that the Pope teaches in matters of faith and morals, irrespective if it is broadcast as ex-cathedra (“from the chair” using the well established formula/language) is to be considered as true.

It may help you to know that anytime the pope issues an encyclical, or bull or official statement etc. it has allready been well vetted and thoroughly reviewed by his most trusted theologians and papal advisors.

Do you know of any papal teachings that seems to you to be in error to you? If so, what do you base your personal opinion on?
 
To answer the original poster:

Q1: Catholics are human beings. Human beings are individuals are falliable beings. The gospel of Jesus Christ that has been handed down generation to generation through the Church founded by His Apostles is not an easy gospel to follow. As such we human beings through our pride and arrogance refuses to accept the teaching we find as hard such as the gospel’s teach on divorce, fornication, birth control, abortion, etc. fall into the prideful sin of not accepting that teaching. We try to justify our refusal by saying to ourselves that the Church is ran by a bunch of old men who are out of touch or use one or more of any other excuse to justify our unbelief. The problem with human beings is that we have the tendency of trying to mold God into our image instead of molding ourselves into God’s. That is the reason why it takes us a lifetime to break away from our pride and find humility. It is also the reason why humility is the beginning of living a virtuous life.

This human flaw is the reason why you have 30000 christian denominations. This is the reason why you have so many differing views within the Church. This is the reason why God established the Church and its Bishops. The Bishops keep each other in line through the help of the Holy Spirit.

Q2: The Catechism of the Catholic Church is difinitive authority on the teachings of the Catholic Church. If you want to know what the Church teaches it is in this Catechism. The thing to remember about this Catechism is that it is the “general” writing. It may not go into as much detail as is needed if you are studing a certain teaching of the Church such as the Trinity. There are many writings that you can refer to get more detailed information.

Hopefully this helps.
 
I don’t understand richardacombs. You raised the issue of the Petro-Pauline Controversy and correctly pointed that the matter shows us that Papal supremacy had not really been established in Peter’s own lifetime. In the early church dissent was quite possible even over matters of doctrine and morals as any clearheaded reading of the book of Galatians will make clear.

So if you assent to everything the Pope teaches (whether infallible or no) why did you bring this up at all? Is there an issue where you think the Pope is just plainly wrong?
Actually, the quotation I cited from Galations clearly supports the dogma of Papal infallibility as defined by the First Vatican Council. Conditions of infallibility are set forth in the dogma: the teaching from the Apostolic chair must agree with Scripture, must agree with previous dogma and doctrine, and must agree with established tradition.

When Paul rebukes Peter, he gives the exact reason. Peter has gone against the personal revelation that Jesus gave to each man of salvation through grace. Obviously, those revelations were in complete agreement, since Peter accepted Paul’s chastisement without argument.

Although modern practice is that when a Pope speaks on faith and morals, his teachings have been thoroughly reviewed, that–as we all know from history–has not always been the case. Popes are human and subject to all human failings. That is why the conditions of infallibility were clearly defined by the First Vatican Council.

As to whether, I agree with all Papal teachings. If those teachings meet the conditions of infallibility, I may not agree with them, but as a practicing Catholic I will obey them. Faith is ongoing action (John 14:15). The Church teaching on forgiveness is a good example. If I believe that someone has somehow wronged me, I am instructed by the Church, in line with Scripture, that I must forgive that person. I may not agree that they should be forgiven. I may not want to forgive them, but I must practice forgiveness. From my physical action in faith, the mental and spiritual forgiveness will follow.

Papal “supremacy” was established by Jesus, Matthew 16:18-19: *“And I tell you, you are Peter [Greek, Petros–a large piece of rock], and on this rock [Greek, petra–a huge rock like Gibraltar] I will build My church, and the gates of Hades (the powers of the infernal region) shall not overpower it [or be strong to its detriment or hold out against it].
I will give you the keys of the kingdom of heaven; and whatever you bind (declare to be improper and unlawful) on earth must be what is already bound in heaven; and whatever you loose (declare lawful) on earth must be what is already loosed in heaven.” *(Amplified Bible)

The “supremacy,” however, is as a servant of the Church following the examples in the ministry of Jesus. I don’t believe that I need to provide Scriptural references, but will on request.

When you ask the question of whether I believe a Pope could ever be wrong, I would have to respond that if his teachings, even ex cathedra, contradicted Scripture (in the generally accepted interpretation of the Catholic Church), or the accepted dogmas and doctrines of the Catholic Church, or the established tradition of the Catholic Church, I would believe that he was wrong. I have never been put in that position.

Incidentally, one of the reasons that I often cite Protestant translations of the Bible is so I will not stand accused of using a translation biased toward the teachings of the Catholic Church.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top