J
jasev
Guest
So, I’ve been listening to Catholic radio for about a week and a half. I’ve been lurking on these forums for a few days. I’ve caught EWTN’s Coming Home a few times over the last year. I’ve noticed, because it seems to be said or written once every two minutes, that one of the chief arguments Catholic apologists like to throw out is a line that usually runs something like, “There are 30,000 something denominations out there all claiming to understand the Bible and the Bible alone, clearly they’re not all right! Therefore the Bible is not enough.”
Okay, I really have no interest in debating whether that is true or not. What I am curious in, is how then do Catholics understand all of the great diversity in the Church itself? The kind of diversity in mind is:
Okay, I really have no interest in debating whether that is true or not. What I am curious in, is how then do Catholics understand all of the great diversity in the Church itself? The kind of diversity in mind is:
I heard Fr. John Corapi state this morning that only 65% of Catholics believe in the Real Presence. (I’m going by memory. If I’ve grossly mis-remembered that number please just call me on it. Not trying to mis-represent what he said if that’s wrong… just a faulty memory!).
I’ve witnessed a number of shots taken at charismatic Catholics (are these the Renewal Catholics?), Old School Catholics (who apparently believe Vatican II was a mistake), conservative modern Catholics (I’m guessing they could be called the Vatican II crowed just to distinguish them from liberals and the old school folks?), and liberal Catholics (both the theological and politically liberal). These are shots at each other, not from outside!
I don’t fully claim to understand the idea of religious orders within the church (e.g. Franciscans, Dominicans, Jesuits, etc.) but based on brief comments I get the impression they don’t all agree that the others are “doing spirituality right.” Have I totally misunderstood this one? The Jesuits in particular seem to be taking a lot of flak for being liberal. Is that right?
I have a book on my shelf from Fr. Gary Wills titled, “What Paul Meant.” I very highly doubt most conservative Catholics would agree with this man on his interpretation of Paul. It’s really not worth my going into his theories here. You can likely get a good enough sense of them from the book’s reviews on Amazon. In any case, there are apparently scores of not so conservative Catholics who agree with him. No? (Perhaps these are the ~75% who don’t show up for mass weekly? Another figure I think I heard from Corapi this morning.)
It sure seems to me the Catholic church isn’t nearly the monolith of faith her apologists claim for her. Is it really that the Roman Catholic Church itself is “one, holy, catholic, and apostolic?” The unity just doesn’t seem to be there past the surface level. Have I misunderstood the claim?In a similar vein as Fr. Gary Wills above, there is John Dominic Crossan. I understand he is now a former Catholic Priest. He is still a Roman Catholic, right? He and Funk basically are the “Jesus Seminar.” I don’t think I’m going out on a limb to assume this isn’t inline with “official” church teaching, right?