Value of life

  • Thread starter Thread starter 1inICXC
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
1

1inICXC

Guest
Reading some of the posts about St. Catherine of Siena and the large families of back in the day ( in the Duggars thread) Made me wonder:

did Catholics, back the, value life the way we do now?

I mean I can’t imagine a Catholic family, nowadays, saying: we’ll have lots of children because many of them will die anyway.

I think today’s attitude is that we must do everything in our power to preserve and protect at all cost each of our children’s lives and if bringing another sibling into the world would endanger that, then, the responsible thing would be o not bring more children into the home. It seems to me like Children were viewed as “replaceable”…

I also wonder how a mother could have the strength to bury her own children, over and over…

Are we too attached to life today, were they too nonchalant about it back then?
 
Large families were necessary back then due to the agrarian culture of Western Europe. More children meant more hands to work the fields. That is also why the marriage rate was much higher because a man needed a wife to produce children. Since the Industrial Revolution, the need for many children decreased since most families moved to the cities where housing was very cramped and space was not available. Nowadays, the need for children decreases even more since one of the parents can sustain an income to support his family. Children now are seen as a luxury rather than a necessity.
 
Reading some of the posts about St. Catherine of Siena and the large families of back in the day ( in the Duggars thread) Made me wonder:

did Catholics, back the, value life the way we do now?

I mean I can’t imagine a Catholic family, nowadays, saying: we’ll have lots of children because many of them will die anyway.

I think today’s attitude is that we must do everything in our power to preserve and protect at all cost each of our children’s lives and if bringing another sibling into the world would endanger that, then, the responsible thing would be o not bring more children into the home. It seems to me like Children were viewed as “replaceable”…

I also wonder how a mother could have the strength to bury her own children, over and over…

Are we too attached to life today, were they too nonchalant about it back then?
I think in some ways you are right. People back then didn’t hold onto life the way they do now - disease killed more people, life was a heck of a lot harder (at least physically speaking). Because of that, it may have been easier to pay more attention to the life ahead. I think part of the reason atheism and pure secularism are on the rise is because with life as it is now, at least in much of the West, many lack the perspective that tells us that this life is just this life and it doesn’t matter much in the face of what comes next. So pursuit of everything that comes now is even more critical than ever.

I am not sure that either perspective is “better”…but they do present very different challenges.
 
Reading some of the posts about St. Catherine of Siena and the large families of back in the day ( in the Duggars thread) Made me wonder:

did Catholics, back the, value life the way we do now?

I mean I can’t imagine a Catholic family, nowadays, saying: we’ll have lots of children because many of them will die anyway.

I think today’s attitude is that we must do everything in our power to preserve and protect at all cost each of our children’s lives and if bringing another sibling into the world would endanger that, then, the responsible thing would be o not bring more children into the home. It seems to me like Children were viewed as “replaceable”…

I also wonder how a mother could have the strength to bury her own children, over and over…

Are we too attached to life today, were they too nonchalant about it back then?
I think women had more children back then not to insure that some grew up, I think they wanted all to grow up.

My great grandparents had 8 total, the first two died. I don’t think they were expecting the first two to die, and that the rest were replacemtnents.

St. catherine of Siena’s parents were not aiming for 26 in case some didn’t make it. Some didn’t make it, so they ended up with 26.
 
I think women had more children back then not to insure that some grew up, I think they wanted all to grow up.

My great grandparents had 8 total, the first two died. I don’t think they were expecting the first two to die, and that the rest were replacemtnents.

St. catherine of Siena’s parents were not aiming for 26 in case some didn’t make it. Some didn’t make it, so they ended up with 26.
I agree most with this.
 
How sad that anyone would think any child lost to a mother was “replaceable”.
It was no fault of the poor mothers, that medical knowledge and care was far less advanced than now. This also meant that there were fewer know cures for illnesses. It wasn’t a matter of caring less about the lives of loved ones. There was simply no real recourse in medicine for many illnesses.
And given the medical knowledge of earlier times, perhaps you could suggest how parents could limit the number of children. Abstinence and separation would have been the only way to limit the number of children? And that itself can be a callous suggestion, given the number of child-bearing years.

And it still happens that a mother grieves over losing one child after another through miscarriage.

Do you believe, then, that a mother of a large family loves her children the less because there are many. Or a father? If you do, as a member of large family of large families, I know differently.
 
Reading some of the posts about St. Catherine of Siena and the large families of back in the day ( in the Duggars thread) Made me wonder:

did Catholics, back the, value life the way we do now?

I mean I can’t imagine a Catholic family, nowadays, saying: we’ll have lots of children because many of them will die anyway.

I think today’s attitude is that we must do everything in our power to preserve and protect at all cost each of our children’s lives and if bringing another sibling into the world would endanger that, then, the responsible thing would be o not bring more children into the home. It seems to me like Children were viewed as “replaceable”…

I also wonder how a mother could have the strength to bury her own children, over and over…

Are we too attached to life today, were they too nonchalant about it back then?
A little of both, really. We cling to natural life because it is better than anything most of us can imagine ahead. They held loosely to it because they saw how hard and unstable it really was.

ICXC NIKA
 
A little of both, really. We cling to natural life because it is better than anything most of us can imagine ahead. They held loosely to it because they saw how hard and unstable it really was.

ICXC NIKA
However, can anyone support the statement that they hung on to life more loosely?
It was no fault of earlier generations that they did not have all the medical knowledge and skills and facilities that have been developed. Even antibiotics, the first effective anti-biotic Penicillin was discovered by mistake in 1928, and prior to that many people were lost throughout the ages through infection alone. And from diseases, which were little understood and for which there was no cure.They didn’t know of the benefits we have so could only long for better medical care when they were ill and dying or their lovesd ones were.

And life is very hard and unstable now, and worsening.
They had the reality they knew, just as we have our present reality.
They had fewer threats, their very planet was safe, today, we know we are destroying the environment, we have terrible weapons that can wipe out nations, that can destroy civilization, the Church is under more attack than ever, from without and from within. Several countries are on the brink of financial collapse…I could go on and on as to why our world is under grave threat on many levels.
 
However, can anyone support the statement that they hung on to life more loosely?
It was no fault of earlier generations that they did not have all the medical knowledge and skills and facilities that have been developed. Even antibiotics, the first anti-biotic was discovered by mistake, and many people were lost through infection alone. And disease, which was little understood and for which there was no cure.
I don’t mean that.

Obviously, every time period accepts that there are human conditions for which nothing can be done. Our 2100s descendants will likely say we “hold our minds loosely” because we accept there is nothing to be done for Alzheimer disease or massive head trauma.

What I meant was that death was more “accepted” in those times. They didn’t say, as far as I know, in so many words: “We hold life loosely.” But saints of the period kept skulls on their desk, to keep them reminded of their impending death. The poetry of the age dwelt upon human death. Even today, the Mexican “Day of the Dead” reflects the even celebratory view of death that existed in that country at the end of the period. It was never far away, so the average mind was adjusted to it.

Consider now when in the western world, the thought of an end to life is so hideous that we try desperately to hide it.

ICXC NIKA
 
Perhaps to many. It’s not something I mind. An exciting prospect, actually, when I’m done here and it’s time to go home! I just would feel sorry for my sons, and my husband would be lonely. Those things bother me, not dying. There are probably a lot who feel like that too.

Anyway, the questions we’ve been discussing are all academic. We can only speculate regarding others now and in earlier times, and we can only generalize regarding people, but all people in every age, are individual persons.
Anyway, such is life! my husband will be awake in a while. It’s a rainy Saturday morning, welcome rain. It’s early summer here.

God bless you! 🙂
 
I mean I can’t imagine a Catholic family, nowadays, saying: we’ll have lots of children because many of them will die anyway.
Just curious but it that what they said back then? I think that when you live in a time where people have a lot of children, you just think that is life and leave it at that. Also, I doubt anyone replaced anyone. I think in a way, mom’s had it easier because since so many children died, they had a lot of peer support. I can’t help but think today, the worst thing a grieving mom faces is she knows deep down other moms are thinking better you than me.
Are we too attached to life today, were they too nonchalant about it back then?
With all the birth control being used today, I don’t think society is too attached to life. Again, I don’t think people were non-chalant just very accustomed to early death. The option to go to a doctor and be cured was non-existent in their minds

CM
 
My grandmother-in-law was one of 11 kids. The oldest 6 died of diptheria, leaving one surviving child, and then her parents went on to have 5 more children.

My greatgrandmother had 8 children. All survived to adulthood, with one being shot as a young married woman via domestic violence (in the 1930s), another had a heart attack as a young adult.

My own father grew up in the country and slept in an unheated bedroom from about age 2 in Minnesota. There was often frost on the roof rafters of the house, and he could see his breath in the cold inside his bedroom.

Life was vastly different and far more uncomfortable than it is today.
 
Just curious but it that what they said back then? I think that when you live in a time where people have a lot of children, you just think that is life and leave it at that. Also, I doubt anyone replaced anyone. I think in a way, mom’s had it easier because since so many children died, they had a lot of peer support. I can’t help but think today, the worst thing a grieving mom faces is she knows deep down other moms are thinking better you than me.

With all the birth control being used today, I don’t think society is too attached to life. Again, I don’t think people were non-chalant just very accustomed to early death. The option to go to a doctor and be cured was non-existent in their minds

CM
I know this is going to draw angry response; but… I think we can distinguish " openness to procreation" from “attachment to one’s own life, or to human beings already alive”. IMNAAHO, although contraception is wrong, using it does not imply that one is not attached to human life already in being.

ICXC NIKA
 
Reading some of the posts about St. Catherine of Siena and the large families of back in the day ( in the Duggars thread) Made me wonder:

did Catholics, back the, value life the way we do now?

I mean I can’t imagine a Catholic family, nowadays, saying: we’ll have lots of children because many of them will die anyway.

I think today’s attitude is that we must do everything in our power to preserve and protect at all cost each of our children’s lives and if bringing another sibling into the world would endanger that, then, the responsible thing would be o not bring more children into the home. It seems to me like Children were viewed as “replaceable”…

I also wonder how a mother could have the strength to bury her own children, over and over…

Are we too attached to life today, were they too nonchalant about it back then?
I think the decline in family size, has much to do with “wanting to provide our children and ourselves with everything we and they deserve”. I don’t believe that mothers saw their children as replaceable, nor do I believe we view life as more valuable.

Back then, there was not much in the way of higher education to prepare and save for, there was no need to have many family vehicles, there was no need for designer clothes and occasional meals out. There was no need to buy expensive car seats and orthodontics etc.

I"m not in anyway suggesting we shouldn’t provide these things for our children. We should do our very best to provide them. But I’m just saying, that back then, you really just worried about providing some hand me down clothes, and food.

I do think that seeing death all around you, may have detached you a bit more than we are today from it. We have the ability to prevent and cure many things that took children at a young age back then. However, I’m sure if you asked a mother today who had a baby die if her next child was a replacement she would be no more insulted than a mother back then would have been. I don’t believe they saw their children as replaceable. I know I read a diary of a young mother from the early 20s and it included all of her fears and worries as she spent many a night by one of her 6 sick children’s beds.
 
Large families were necessary back then due to the agrarian culture of Western Europe. More children meant more hands to work the fields. That is also why the marriage rate was much higher because a man needed a wife to produce children. Since the Industrial Revolution, the need for many children decreased since most families moved to the cities where housing was very cramped and space was not available. Nowadays, the need for children decreases even more since one of the parents can sustain an income to support his family. Children now are seen as a luxury rather than a necessity.
Well, I don’t think it was so much of a necessity. If you only had one child, than you didn’t need as many resources. I think it was rather a given, that you would have a large family (given the lack of contraception and NFP knowledge) so you needed the land, the cattle, etc.

Come to think of it, most of life was a given: you’d have a large family, some of the children would die, you’d suffer from all kinds of disease etc. They probably didn’t feel like there was much they could do about.

Today we live on whims, we feel like doing this or that, we want to be superstars, to have 3 kids, no kids or just a boy and a girl. We want careers, vacations etc. Providence has ceased to exist as a concept. But, the wisdom the church imparts to us equips us with the ability to value the essence of life on a deeper theological and physical level.

Can you imagine religious services for miscarried babies 100 years ago?!

On a personal note, my grandma used to talk quite nonchalantly about her 3 siblings who died in the 30s and when she had my uncle ( she lived in a very remote area) he contracted a disease as an infant and she just told herself that if he ends up dying, she’ll have another one… Unfortunately, I do think that during those hard times, even mourning life was a luxury…
 
On a personal note, my grandma used to talk quite nonchalantly about her 3 siblings who died in the 30s and when she had my uncle ( she lived in a very remote area) he contracted a disease as an infant and she just told herself that if he ends up dying, she’ll have another one… Unfortunately, I do think that during those hard times, even mourning life was a luxury…
1in1CXIX, I think that perhaps you are generalizing from the case of your own grandmother to everybody in her generation. When you make statements like this in your OP, you seem to be painting every single person who lived in the same era as having the exact same outlook on life and death.
Are we too attached to life today, were they too nonchalant about it back then?
Who is this “they” you are referring to?

I find this to be as unfair, as if someone a hundred years from now were to say “my grandmother was a fervent supporter of abortion rights” and generalize that to say that every single woman living now must have supported abortion. Let’s say that this person lives in a culture that is very pro-life, anti-abortion. That person could ask the very same question.
Are we too attached to life today, were they too nonchalant about it back then?
Wouldn’t this be unfair to the many men and women who did NOT support abortion, who did value life?

I see this same kind of glib judgment made about people who live in Third World countries, or just different cultures than the White Bread American one. I’ve heard all these whoppers from people who saw themselves as Liberal and Tolerant:

(A nurse talking about a Chinese woman who lost her premature baby): “I’m not too worried about her. Chinese women don’t bond with their babies until they’re much older. It’s a cultural thing.”

(An anti-child-porn crusader reporting from a South Asian village): “I guarantee, people are so poor here, you could buy any given child off the street, no questions asked.”

(A teacher I knew in high school): “In modern urban Black Culture, men just aren’t expected to stay around to raise their children.”

All of these generalizations might indeed apply to a large number, or even a majority, of the population being discussed. But don’t you agree that it’s very unfair to the people who don’t fit the generalization, to make statements like this? I’m sure there are many Chinese women who grieve the losses of their babies as much as Western women, many poor South Asians who wouldn’t dream of selling their children into prostitution, and of course there are many Black men who do indeed stay around for their children, even actually marry the children’s mothers.

So, while many women of a certain era may indeed have been more accepting of their children’s deaths than women of this era, I think it’s very unfair to use the word “they” as if you can glibly make generalizations about everyone in the era.
 
Reading some of the posts about St. Catherine of Siena and the large families of back in the day ( in the Duggars thread) Made me wonder:

did Catholics, back the, value life the way we do now?

I mean I can’t imagine a Catholic family, nowadays, saying: we’ll have lots of children because many of them will die anyway.

I think today’s attitude is that we must do everything in our power to preserve and protect at all cost each of our children’s lives and if bringing another sibling into the world would endanger that, then, the responsible thing would be o not bring more children into the home. It seems to me like Children were viewed as “replaceable”…

I also wonder how a mother could have the strength to bury her own children, over and over…

Are we too attached to life today, were they too nonchalant about it back then?
I think families are smaller now in general more because of not appreciating life, the culture of death, where, like you mentioned, a new life is seen as a threat instead of the actual blessing it is. (Obvisously there are wonderful generous couples that may end up with small families, including no children at all, because of God’s will, but I’m talking in general.)
 
My mother is the sixth of eleven children. The child born before her died within a few hours of birth, and my grandparents were told that they should not have any more children. However, they went on to have six more children. If they hadn’t, my mother wouldn’t be alive and neither would I.

I think life is an exceptionally precious gift, and it should be highly valued. It should not be taken for granted or seen as replaceable - instead, life should be understood for what it truly is - fleeting and beautiful. Each child is a glorious creation sent by God, and to be blessed with any number of children is, to me, a wonderful thing.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top