Venial and Mortal sins.

  • Thread starter Thread starter Gerrybhoy1888
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
G

Gerrybhoy1888

Guest
Hi, could any one tell me the diffirence between the 2 from the standpoint of which sins are classed as venial and which are classed as mortal.

Thanks

Gerry
 
Hi, could any one tell me the diffirence between the 2 from the standpoint of which sins are classed as venial and which are classed as mortal.

Thanks

Gerry
Since child, I was taught that, but I cannot figure it out either.
I was surprised by the certitude of certain priests saying from the menu whether this or that was a sin!
 
Hi Gerry. The main difference is that one sin (mortal) if left unrepented separates you from God’s grace, the source of life. This one sends a person to hell after death. The other one (venial) merely creates a loss of charity within the soul. This damages the relationship with God and others but not fatally. However, one must be careful because repeated venial sins may lead to mortal sins. Also, when you are in a mortal sin, this is called a state of sin. This is because a mortal sin creates a break from the grace of the Holy Spirit. In the state of sin, it is another serious sin to receive Holy Communion unless it is extremely grave. It is important to confess this sin through the Sacrament of Reconciliation. However, fear not! It’s hard to knowingly commit a mortal sin. These are the three conditions:
  1. Grave matter
    2.The person must know it is a mortal sin after a good amount of reflection
  2. The person must deliberately do it.
Number 3 is tricky. Things like severe psychological disturbance, addiction, threat under pain of death and the like would actually cancel it out.
 
So does that mean things like Murder, rape, theft , blasphemy, adultry etc would be classed as a mortal sin, with the likes of masturbation, birth control being venial, but possibly becoming Mortal if a regular occurance?:confused:
 
When I said that venial sins may lead to mortal sin, I meant that repeated exposure to sin weakens the will against temptations. But anyway, the way I see it, things like masturbation and contraception may be venial sins out of ignorance. And about masturbation, (it’s highly addicting) it’s very disputed about when it becomes mortal or venial. Just err on the side of caution. Try not to do it.
 
Hi, could any one tell me the diffirence between the 2 from the standpoint of which sins are classed as venial and which are classed as mortal.

Thanks

Gerry
___________________________________________________________________A venial sin would be arguing witgh your parents; being untruthful;
A mortal sin is a SERious SIN//*- AGAINST gOD.
nOT BELIEVING YOU R SINS ARE FORGIVEN IN cONFESSION; MAKING SACRELIGIOUS COMMUNIONS.

tHE NEXT TIME YOU GO TO CONFESSION, fATHER CAN EXPLAIN IT TO YOU’’

jesus I trust in you

jIM rOBERTS
 
So does that mean things like Murder, rape, theft , blasphemy, adultry etc would be classed as a mortal sin, with the likes of masturbation, birth control being venial, but possibly becoming Mortal if a regular occurance?:confused:
No. All of those sins you listed would be mortal if committed with full knowledge and consent.
 
Hi, could any one tell me the diffirence between the 2 from the standpoint of which sins are classed as venial and which are classed as mortal.

Thanks

Gerry
As John writes

16 If any one sees his brother committing what is not a mortal sin, he will ask, and God will give him life for those whose sin is not mortal. There is sin which is mortal; I do not say that one is to pray for that. 17 All wrongdoing is sin, but there is sin which is not mortal. . [1 Jn 5:16-17]

Okay, so what sin is mortal? You can bet that sins that prevent one from going to heaven if one dies with them on their soul, are mortal.

For example
  • Ephesians 5: 3-5 fornication, covetousness……5 Be sure of this, that no fornicator or impure man, or one who is covetous (that is, an idolater), has any inheritance in the kingdom of Christ and of God.
  • Hebrews 10:25-26 missing mass deliberately, no sacrifice for sin for THEM but a fiery judgement that consumes the adversaries of God.
  • Hebrews 12: 16 - 17 immoraliy, is selling your inheritance
  • Galatians 5: 19 - 21 sexual immorality, impurity and debauchery; 20idolatry and witchcraft; hatred, discord, jealousy, fits of rage, selfish ambition, dissensions, factions 21and envy; drunkenness, orgies, will not inherit heaven
  • Colossians 3: 5-6 immorality, impurity, lust, evil desires and greed, which is idolatry, …rath of God is coming
  • 1 Corinthians 6: 9 - 10 no sexually immoral, nor idolaters, nor adulterers, nor male prostitutes, nor homosexual offenders, 10 nor thieves, nor the greedy, nor drunkards, nor slanderers, nor swindlers, will inherit the kingdom of God.
  • Matthew 15: 19 - 20 murder, adultery, false witness, slander…defile a man
Venial sin by contrast are minor sins.
 
  1. Grave matter
    2.The person must know it is a mortal sin after a good amount of reflection
  2. The person must deliberately do it.
Number 3 is tricky. Things like severe psychological disturbance, addiction, threat under pain of death and the like would actually cancel it out.
It would be "Grave matter, full knowledge and deliberate consent (completed consent).

I would not put number 2 and 3 like that…nor the note there.

Yes there can be things that “may” mitigate full consent but I would not say it that way.

Here is the Catechism:

vatican.va/archive/ENG0015/__P6C.HTM
 
So does that mean things like Murder, rape, theft , blasphemy, adultry etc would be classed as a mortal sin, with the likes of masturbation, birth control being venial, but possibly becoming Mortal if a regular occurance?:confused:
All the above there are grave matter…(though theft can be venial matter…there is a difference between stealing a pencil and a car) and when done with the full knowledge and complete consent…are mortal sins (with them happening even only one time…)

(see CCC quoted above for more info…and also read the section on the 6th commandment for more details)
 
I think a big problem today is that people think they can decide what is a “grave matter”. To some, masturbation is no big deal. It doesnt seem like a grave matter. You’re not hurting anyone, no one knows about it. Whats the harm? If the person doesnt know its a grave matter then he has not sinned. But if he comes to know the laws of God he will very quickly find that it is. On the flip side of the coin…CHOOSING to remain ignorant is really not a way out! True ignorance is true ignorance and God knows your heart. It may be a more grave sin to choose to remain ignorant and continue what you’re doing. That is up to God’s determination, knowing your heart.
 
I think a big problem today is that people think they can decide what is a “grave matter”. To some, masturbation is no big deal. It doesnt seem like a grave matter. You’re not hurting anyone, no one knows about it. Whats the harm? If the person doesnt know its a grave matter then he has not sinned. But if he comes to know the laws of God he will very quickly find that it is. On the flip side of the coin…CHOOSING to remain ignorant is really not a way out! True ignorance is true ignorance and God knows your heart. It may be a more grave sin to choose to remain ignorant and continue what you’re doing. That is up to God’s determination, knowing your heart.
…and also up to you (us), actually, to know our hearts. 🙂 That’s what the sacrament of reconciliation is for: to examine our hearts, own up to our sins, and reveal those, in order to obtain healing graces against them. I do not mean to contradict you! 🙂 I’m not signing on to the subjective determinism which you accurately define as “a big problem today,” I agree with you.

That is, in line with your remarks about ignorance, indeed, you have hit the nail on the head: We have all the resources at our disposable to become informed (non-ignorant!).

For me, to answer the OP directly, I combine my knowledge of Church teaching, with prayer, and with my “gut.” Thus, there’s another thread in Moral Theology asking about copying student work for an exam. To me, this is a no-brainer: definitely grave matter. My immediate reaction is to feel seriously ashamed of the triple offense of:

(a) lying (misrepresenting what is and is not one’s own work)
(b) using that lie for illicit gainful purposes (a grade not honestly earned), which violates justice
(c) involving another person in one’s own sin :eek:

When my ‘internal barometer’ reacts quickly to something I’ve done (or failed to do), and “haunts” me, then that, to me, has risen to the level of grave (mortal). No intellectualizing it away works for me, such as parsing of words, doing some math by which “only 10%” of the grade was affected. Etc. It was a fundamentally dishonest thing to do, and it’s the ‘root,’ or fundamental aspect of something, which is the violation.

I’m quite aware that the proportion of an act, or an omission, does figure into the gravity. Thus, stealing a piece of candy from a store is clearly venial, vs. stealing someone’s essential rent money or food money, or stealing a large item or sum of money, would rise to grave. However, I’m just saying that when one gets into multiple aspects of sin (such as above), and/or if one’s conscience is eating away (not referring to scrupulosity here), then I think the Holy Spirit is moving us to acknowledge and confess. Generally, if I’m not really clear on fine lines of distinction between my venial and mortal sins, I simply confess the sin & its circumstances, along with the level of my regret (briefly), and possibly admission of some selfish or toxic motivation, and simply wait for the priest to respond to how he sees the gravity, which invariably he does.

For example, suppose I stole a piece of candy, and especially in a cruel manner, from a little child on his or her birthday, and that child was really looking forward to that piece of candy and for some reason that was not immediatley replaceable. In that case, I have crushed the child’s feelings, destroyed a special birthday moment, perhaps, and done it with cruel intent. The candy represented something joyful to him. The graver sin is the malice, not the petty theft. I would feel that was essential to bring to confession. So I try to distinguish between ‘essential’ offenses and nonessential, vs. ‘venial’ and ‘mortal.’
🙂

It’s just my way. Hope that helps.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top