venial

  • Thread starter Thread starter jesus4ever
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
J

jesus4ever

Guest
i saw a lady on the television and had a brief impure thought in which i found myself deeply dewling in for a couple of seconds and i think briefly took control of the thought. i calmly thought to my self this is a impure thought and sinful and started to shake my head to get rid of it and stop the thought.

when i relized what i was doing I stoped.

would this be venial
 
It’s certainly not a mortal sin, if that’s what you’re asking 🙂
 
Is it Venial because i said to my self oh no it’s a impure thought and i’m delwing in it and taking control of it so i must stop.

then what would make it a mortal sin…

so it ok to go to communion.

i felt my heart pumping hard after i got out of it. and for the next couple of hours my heart didn’t feel to good. it was as if it was going to stop.
 
Is it Venial because i said to my self oh no it’s a impure thought and i’m delwing in it and taking control of it so i must stop.

then what would make it a mortal sin…

so it ok to go to communion.

i felt my heart pumping hard after i got out of it. and for the next couple of hours my heart didn’t feel to good. it was as if it was going to stop.
 
don’t worry, it’s not mortal,
if you had realized what you were doing and kept doing it, then it would be mortal,
but you resisted and overcame, it was a temptation, and temptations are not bad,
they in fact can be good, because by resisting temptations we become stronger
against them,

you can actually mention the things you struggle most with in confession, even if
you don’t commit them, you can just tell the priest, like in your case for example,
“i have been tempted to impure thoughts” and by that you will receive special graces
for better resisting and overcoming those temptations, and possibly not be so
strongly tempted to it,

but i’d like to point out, even if you commit a sin, don’t let that stress you out,
of course we should have sorrow for our sins and truly wish to amend our lives,
but Jesus does not want you to worry or stress even over your sins, you simply
need to pray and trust that God will help you overcome them, and work diligently
and constantly in resisting them,
it is only when we do not ask for help from God that we fall, we get our strength
entirely from Him, and when we think we can do it on our own and not ask for
His help, that is a great insult to Him, and it is one of the biggest reasons why
we fall,
another big reason why we fall, is because we are to attached to the things and
comforts and creatures of this world, even our own selves,
we must detach from all things, and die to ourselves, in order to be filled completely
with God.

i’d like to recommend a book for you to read(if you don’t already have it.)
it’s both online to read, and available on tanbooks for a cheap price -
tanbooks.com/index.php/page/shop:flypage/product_id/147/keywords/imitation+christ/
2heartsnetwork.org/Imitation-of-Christ.pdf
i think that will help you alot.

ok hope this helps, tc.
 
how can i be sure it was a temtation and not me starting it. thats the problems i am having.

what would it be if i started the thought, completly forgeting that this is evil and contoling the thought and then i relized what i was doing was wrong and stoped. is it different if I started the thought.
 
how can i be sure it was a temtation and not me starting it. thats the problems i am having.

what would it be if i started the thought, completly forgeting that this is evil and contoling the thought and then i relized what i was doing was wrong and stoped. is it different if I started the thought.
You’re being scrupulous.

Don’t beat yourself up over such trivial details. We’re not Pharisees.
 
how can i be sure it was a temtation and not me starting it. thats the problems i am having.

what would it be if i started the thought, completly forgeting that this is evil and contoling the thought and then i relized what i was doing was wrong and stoped. is it different if I started the thought.
Regarding when one is tempted and one wonders if one gave compete consent…various theological works give some helpful signs of not having complete consent…such as:

being half asleep…distracted by another matter and hardly noticing the thought…after the act or thought one scarcely remembers what happened…one hesitates but does not want to offend God and so after the moments of hesitation one rejects the temptation…one resists thoughts but in a half hearted way or in a weak manner putting up half resistance (hence partial consent so perhaps a venial sin)…

For a mortal sin one needs: grave matter…the full knowledge and complete consent.

sometimes thoughts start…sometimes we can even start thoughts without realizing ‘what we are doing’…what matters is what one does when one realizes!

Of course there are some things that we need to avoid (do not scruple about this)…but then again…we are not obliged to avoid all possible temptations…we would have to leave this life.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top