A
AlanFromWichita
Guest
You have stated it very well. Clearly the burden is on the priest, because this is his job, and is expected to understand and regard boundaries whether or not the woman agrees to what he’s doing. And for that matter, whether or not the husband is OK with what he’s doing. I’m assuming we’re getting a least a part of the true picture here, and that part is enough to know from seeing it, that it is not good.The priest crossed several boundaries here: he should not be sleeping at your house; he should not be going out to eat alone with your wife, ever; and he should have been very careful in having frequent contact with your wife while you and she were having marital problems. Like others have said, it is so so common for women to form emotional attachments with priests when they don’t have them elsewhere. The burden was on him primarily, and not your wife, to maintain boundaries, because he has a moral authority and position of fatherhood towards her. The priest sounds like he enjoyed the companionship of your wife and family. But those types of consolations are what he gave up in becoming a priest, and he needs to reinforce the resolve of that sacrifice.
Even politicians understand this. When my wife one time went to lobby in Washington for a pro-life group, they were taught that the women lobbying should never be alone in the office with their rep or senator, and the door and curtains will always be fully open. Why? Because the politicians know that all it takes is the appearance of impropriety to ruin a career. To me that’s a big, “well, duhh.”
Teachers have the same problem. Try having a 45 year old college professor hanging out in a restaurant/bar every week, with an unmarried 18 year old female student from last semester, and see how well that goes over with the school and with the newspapers. How about if it were a high school student who just turned 18? Would it be OK because he was her teacher only in the previous semester and she was of age to give consent? Or because she was either married young or at least had a “steady boyfriend?” (What would the boyfriend do, for that matter?) You can say, “oh he’s helping her with her Geometry.” Yeah, I bet he is. I used to teach College Algebra (to both college kids and adults) and I know what it’s like to be hit on by women who never would have hit on my old and fat self, if I weren’t an authority figure in their lives … and if I had behaved the way this priest did toward a student I’d never have been hired back.
Priests should know how to behave at least as ethically and above reproach, as politicians, teachers, and anyone else who have power or influence over other people through their line of work. :tsktsk:
This is good advice as well, and I see now why the OP should say anything at all. But IMO not about possible failure to counsel, but about hanging out alone with his wife all the time.If you think his behavior is due more to lack of prudence than a deliberate inappropriate relationship, I would go talk to the priest alone and tell him honestly what specific points of his behavior upset you. In charity, you are doing him a favor because the next husband might not be so kind. These are the type of situations that can wreck a well-intentioned priest’s career.
One poster has suggested that if the case goes to divorce, then it won’t matter how this priest had behaved. I see it just the opposite way. If I were in that situation and I were served with a divorce (I would never serve one myself) and there was the least bit of contention, you had better believe that I’m going to bring up this unusual behavior with the priest and make it a central issue in determining child custody.
If she does get a divorce, I wonder if Fred will still be there for her or if she will have become a “hot potato.” Maybe he’d do the decent thing and hang up his robes and marry this woman he “romanced” away from her own husband (getting annulment first) – of course not proven yet but to all appearances … and yes I used “romanced” as a loaded word because that’s basically what was likely happening at least in her mind based on what we know so far. He may have been too clueless to realize what he was doing, but like we’ve been over, it’s his job and he should have known better.
Alan