Very Worried Husband

  • Thread starter Thread starter Jack_Hilling
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
The priest crossed several boundaries here: he should not be sleeping at your house; he should not be going out to eat alone with your wife, ever; and he should have been very careful in having frequent contact with your wife while you and she were having marital problems. Like others have said, it is so so common for women to form emotional attachments with priests when they don’t have them elsewhere. The burden was on him primarily, and not your wife, to maintain boundaries, because he has a moral authority and position of fatherhood towards her. The priest sounds like he enjoyed the companionship of your wife and family. But those types of consolations are what he gave up in becoming a priest, and he needs to reinforce the resolve of that sacrifice.
You have stated it very well. Clearly the burden is on the priest, because this is his job, and is expected to understand and regard boundaries whether or not the woman agrees to what he’s doing. And for that matter, whether or not the husband is OK with what he’s doing. I’m assuming we’re getting a least a part of the true picture here, and that part is enough to know from seeing it, that it is not good.

Even politicians understand this. When my wife one time went to lobby in Washington for a pro-life group, they were taught that the women lobbying should never be alone in the office with their rep or senator, and the door and curtains will always be fully open. Why? Because the politicians know that all it takes is the appearance of impropriety to ruin a career. To me that’s a big, “well, duhh.”

Teachers have the same problem. Try having a 45 year old college professor hanging out in a restaurant/bar every week, with an unmarried 18 year old female student from last semester, and see how well that goes over with the school and with the newspapers. How about if it were a high school student who just turned 18? Would it be OK because he was her teacher only in the previous semester and she was of age to give consent? Or because she was either married young or at least had a “steady boyfriend?” (What would the boyfriend do, for that matter?) You can say, “oh he’s helping her with her Geometry.” Yeah, I bet he is. I used to teach College Algebra (to both college kids and adults) and I know what it’s like to be hit on by women who never would have hit on my old and fat self, if I weren’t an authority figure in their lives … and if I had behaved the way this priest did toward a student I’d never have been hired back.

Priests should know how to behave at least as ethically and above reproach, as politicians, teachers, and anyone else who have power or influence over other people through their line of work. :tsktsk:
If you think his behavior is due more to lack of prudence than a deliberate inappropriate relationship, I would go talk to the priest alone and tell him honestly what specific points of his behavior upset you. In charity, you are doing him a favor because the next husband might not be so kind. These are the type of situations that can wreck a well-intentioned priest’s career.
This is good advice as well, and I see now why the OP should say anything at all. But IMO not about possible failure to counsel, but about hanging out alone with his wife all the time.

One poster has suggested that if the case goes to divorce, then it won’t matter how this priest had behaved. I see it just the opposite way. If I were in that situation and I were served with a divorce (I would never serve one myself) and there was the least bit of contention, you had better believe that I’m going to bring up this unusual behavior with the priest and make it a central issue in determining child custody.

If she does get a divorce, I wonder if Fred will still be there for her or if she will have become a “hot potato.” Maybe he’d do the decent thing and hang up his robes and marry this woman he “romanced” away from her own husband (getting annulment first) – of course not proven yet but to all appearances … and yes I used “romanced” as a loaded word because that’s basically what was likely happening at least in her mind based on what we know so far. He may have been too clueless to realize what he was doing, but like we’ve been over, it’s his job and he should have known better.

Alan
 
If she does get a divorce, I wonder if Fred will still be there for her or if she will have become a “hot potato.” Maybe he’d do the decent thing and hang up his robes and marry this woman he “romanced” away from her own husband (getting annulment first) – of course not proven yet but to all appearances … and yes I used “romanced” as a loaded word because that’s basically what was likely happening at least in her mind based on what we know so far. He may have been too clueless to realize what he was doing, but like we’ve been over, it’s his job and he should have known better.

Alan
Hang up his robes? What did I miss? Priests cannot stop being a priest after they have been ordained.

Furthermore, I think you are jumping to WAY too many conclusions. To say that this has been a “romance” is an assumption which is unfounded, and you are detracting from this priest without having enough information to know if what you are saying is even true!
 
Hang up his robes? What did I miss? Priests cannot stop being a priest after they have been ordained.
Oh yeah? Who is an authority on this matter? Is it impossible for a priest to disavow his priesthood – like an annulment maybe – upon the realization that he was not intended to be a priest in the first place? Should I have said, “becomes laicized,” rather than “hang up his robes?” Potayto, potahto. Either way he loses his power to act as a priest.
Furthermore, I think you are jumping to WAY too many conclusions. To say that this has been a “romance” is an assumption which is unfounded, and you are detracting from this priest without having enough information to know if what you are saying is even true!
I’m saying that spending date after date with a woman who loves you and does things for you and is with you instead of with her husband – with whom she feels no marital commitment toward – is a formula for her to develop emotional attachment to him, which is clearly greater than that to her husband. How does that materially differ from adulterous behavior?

I didn’t say his intention was to romance her, but I don’t think anyone who knows human nature and a thing or two about love, can say that this is not effectively what has taken place. He doesn’t have to buy her flowers and candy, or make professions of love to her, to capture her heart. ❤️

Alan
 
Oh yeah? Who is an authority on this matter? Is it impossible for a priest to disavow his priesthood – like an annulment maybe – upon the realization that he was not intended to be a priest in the first place? Should I have said, “becomes laicized,” rather than “hang up his robes?” Potayto, potahto. Either way he loses his power to act as a priest.
…

I am rather surprised that you don’t already know that once a person is a priest, they are always a priest.

Holy Orders is not like Marriage, it is like Baptism and Confirmation. Just as you cannot get an “annulment” for Baptism or Confirmation, so you cannot for Holy Orders. The reason for this is because these three sacraments imprint a permanent character on your soul which is absolutely irremovable, alive or dead, Heaven or Hell.

To be laicized as a priest doesn’t mean you are no longer a priest, it just means that you have lost the permission to give the Sacraments. In fact, a laicized priest can still consecrate the Eucharist validly, but it is a MASSIVE sacrilege and mortal sin on his part.
I’m saying that spending date after date with a woman who loves you and does things for you and is with you instead of with her husband – with whom she feels no marital commitment toward – is a formula for her to develop emotional attachment to him, which is clearly greater than that to her husband. How does that materially differ from adulterous behavior?

I didn’t say his intention was to romance her, but I don’t think anyone who knows human nature and a thing or two about love, can say that this is not effectively what has taken place. He doesn’t have to buy her flowers and candy, or make professions of love to her, to capture her heart. ❤️

Alan
You said these words:

“Maybe he’d do the decent thing and hang up his robes and marry this woman he “romanced” away from her own husband…”

This statement is declaring your believe that the priest “romanced” the woman away from her husband. Although it may seem likely to you, it is not at all fair to make such a statement without more information.
 
To be laicized as a priest doesn’t mean you are no longer a priest, it just means that you have lost the permission to give the Sacraments. In fact, a laicized priest can still consecrate the Eucharist validly, but it is a MASSIVE sacrilege and mortal sin on his part.
So his power to administer sacraments would be taken away. Still a priest but not able to perform as one. Like I said, potayto, potahto.
This statement is declaring your believe that the priest “romanced” the woman away from her husband. Although it may seem likely to you, it is not at all fair to make such a statement without more information.
There is certainly enough information to raise a logical suspicion. And from what we have, it’s clear this woman was emotionally tied to the priest in preference to her husband. And he doesn’t have to have the intent to romance, to behave in such a way that it happens anyway. And under any measure, his behavior was suspicious at best, and unethical for a person in his position of authority to behave in such a way as to give this impression.

Let this priest speak to me directly about not having enough information to raise such suspicion and I’ll counter every excuse he has. He may not have intended to romance the woman, but in fact it does appear that’s what he did. He may not even have any feelings for her; just being awesome in her eyes and having the private meetings is enough to get it done.

Look, I’m not trying to make something out of nothing here. This is wrong behavior for a priest any way you slice it. Just like if he regularly met with young boys privately for undisclosed reasons, that would be stupid and would raise suspicion, even if there was no ill intent and in fact nothing bad actually happened. Perceptions are critical to priests, and cannot be brushed aside as unreasonable, simply on the basis that there may not be enough evidence to convict him in a court of law. They are representatives of God, so they must be held to a higher behavioral standard than the rest of us and MUST avoid scandal in the performance of their jobs.

Alan
 
So his power to administer sacraments would be taken away. Still a priest but not able to perform as one. Like I said, potayto, potahto.
What do you mean, “Like you said?” Just a few posts ago you were saying that a priest could lay down his robes and get married!
**There is certainly enough information to raise a logical suspicion. ** And from what we have, it’s clear this woman was emotionally tied to the priest in preference to her husband. And he doesn’t have to have the intent to romance, to behave in such a way that it happens anyway. And under any measure, his behavior was suspicious at best, and unethical for a person in his position of authority to behave in such a way as to give this impression.
No it is not.
Let this priest speak to me directly about not having enough information to raise such suspicion and I’ll counter every excuse he has. He may not have intended to romance the woman, but in fact it does appear that’s what he did. He may not even have any feelings for her; just being awesome in her eyes and having the private meetings is enough to get it done.
If you were actually able to speak to this priest, then you would be able to delve into the situation and find out what the real situation is. In this case, you would be able to reach a conclusion.
Look, I’m not trying to make something out of nothing here. This is wrong behavior for a priest any way you slice it. Just like if he regularly met with young boys privately for undisclosed reasons, that would be stupid and would raise suspicion, even if there was no ill intent and in fact nothing bad actually happened. Perceptions are important to priests, and cannot be brushed aside as unreasonable, simply on the basis that there may not be enough evidence to convict him in a court of law.
I didn’t say you were trying to make something out of nothing. What I am saying is that you are taking one side of the situation, one point of view, and are jumping to very large conclusions forming opinions based on it. You are not giving any benefit of the doubt, and are taking the point of view of the OP as proof.

To clarify, I actually think that you are right in that the priest should not be spending so much time with the woman. I was on the side of the OP from the beginning. However, you are taking it WAY too far and going on to make declarations which have no foundation.
 
Like others have said, it is so so common for women to form emotional attachments with priests when they don’t have them elsewhere.
Exactly! The problem lies in that the wife does not have the appropriate emotional attachment to the husband. Now why is that? This is the real problem.

I think the priest should not be scapegoated. Focusing on him is not going to fix the problem in the marriage. The question should be, why does the wife NOT have a proper attachment to her husband? Were they not making time for each other? Did one of them stop taking emotional risks in the relationship? Are either of them harboring resentment toward the other? Do they need to forgive each other? Do they need to take a look at their priorities?

Focusing on the priest is going to get this couple NOWHERE!

When people are hurt they often want to blame someone else when there is no one to blame but themselves. It is hard to look at yourself and take responsibility for your choices but no change will come until you do. Focusing on someone else’s responsibility (even the spouse’s) is going to do nothing but make matters worse!
 
I didn’t say you were trying to make something out of nothing. What I am saying is that you are taking one side of the situation, one point of view, and are jumping to very large conclusions forming opinions based on it. You are not giving any benefit of the doubt, and are taking the point of view of the OP as proof.
I’m not jumping to any conclusions at all; I’m scoping out the possibilities, based on what information we have.

And again, I’m not taking anything as proof. I’m just saying that there is enough circumstantial evidence to raise some eyebrows, and I think it is naive at best. And by “naive” I’m not saying “willfully ignorant.” I wouldn’t even be surprised if he had some mild mental illness that affected his judgment; after my experience of living for 11 years with severe psychosis, I can definitely see how he could fully believe he was serving God by meeting with her. So I’m neither assuming guilt nor condemning him. But although 2+2 doesn’t always add up to 4, it does for the vast majority of us, almost all of the time.

Currently my signature is: “It is the mark of an educated mind to be able to entertain a thought without accepting it. – Aristotle” I’m just examining some possibilities without claiming to know the Actual Truth. I’m emphasizing one “side” of the story because it seems there are posters that are in denial that it is even worth considering. If the priest didn’t at least realize this was a possibility even while it was going on, than I absolutely think he’s a fool, or extremely naive and ill-trained at best. (If there is mental illness involved these comments don’t apply.) Am I claiming that he is a fool or a scoundrel based on what we know? No. I’m saying we shouldn’t rule it out as a possibility just because there are other explanations – explanations we would prefer to think about because we love our priests and want to take their side in any given matter. That said, the most generous explanation I can come up with for the way the priest behaved was that he was extraordinarily naive – if you prefer that term to “fool.”

So am I saying the priest did something morally wrong? We can’t say.

Did the priest do something reckless or otherwise foolish? Yes, unless the OP is just plain lying about the meetings. And the birthdays, etc. If it’s mental illness then I wouldn’t necessarily say “foolish” but it’s still reckless.
To clarify, I actually think that you are right in that the priest should not be spending so much time with the woman. I was on the side of the OP from the beginning. However, you are taking it WAY too far and going on to make declarations which have no foundation.
I respect that viewpoint. I guess I’m incredulous that there are those who actually do defend Fred’s behavior as not only OK but helpful, so maybe I gave my story a shot of steroids to try to build it up some. But I will not back off of my use of the term, “romancing.” I believe the priest knew or should have known, that behaving this way with a troubled married woman was playing with fire, and risking making this woman’s moral and emotional condition worse. This behavior was nearly certainly toying with her feelings, so no I can’t conclusively claim that she “fell for” Fred, but that’s the most likely explanation I have thus far that fits the data. I may be wrong, but I’d bet you $200 that if the bishop found out about this, Fred would at least be coached not to meeting like that in the future.

Alan
 
Exactly! The problem lies in that the wife does not have the appropriate emotional attachment to the husband. Now why is that? This is the real problem.

I think the priest should not be scapegoated. Focusing on him is not going to fix the problem in the marriage. The question should be, why does the wife NOT have a proper attachment to her husband? Were they not making time for each other? Did one of them stop taking emotional risks in the relationship? Are either of them harboring resentment toward the other? Do they need to forgive each other? Do they need to take a look at their priorities?

Focusing on the priest is going to get this couple NOWHERE!

When people are hurt they often want to blame someone else when there is no one to blame but themselves. It is hard to look at yourself and take responsibility for your choices but no change will come until you do. Focusing on someone else’s responsibility (even the spouse’s) is going to do nothing but make matters worse!
Well, the fact that the marriage was in trouble was already pre-existing. But regardless, I have seen marriages where the parish priest is sort of the third party (in a non-sexual way). I have seen this over and over again: you have a charismatic, enthusiastic priest who has trouble with boundaries. And you have women seeking to deepen their faith, and thinking that spending time with Father can only be good. Every marriage has dry spells, every couple has serious disagreements. Women are more likely to seek the advice of their parish priest, and that can become a slippery slope to Father’s influence becoming a growing wedge in a relatively healthy functioning marriage. Priests are human too, and while most of them wouldn’t commit the type of sins we read about in the newspaper, all of them are prone to sliding down that path of well-intentions + personal weakness just like the rest of us. This priest really just sounds like he has boundary issues, lacks prudence, is lonely, and really feels the sacrifice of not having his own family, and all of those things have lead him to live vicariously through this inappropriate relationship, what he is missing in the priesthood.
 
Wow, the first thing that strikes me is that the priest has crossed boundaries…not just crossed them, he’s like 10 miles past the fence he should have stayed behind! I know that nobody wants to entertain the idea that a priest could be acting inappropriately but he is a human, he is a sinner like all of us so you can’t just dismiss it because he is a priest. I’m not suggesting that there is a romantic (or sexual) relationship going on there, but he should know that to someone on the outside it just looks really bad. And I feel like the priest should be considering the wife’s reputation and the potential consequences for her of how this looks, even if it is 100% innocent and well-intentioned, that these kind of inappropriate “date” nights are just going to make her marital issues worse, not better. If my priest did that the bishop would be HORRIFIED.

Listen, I’m really sorry about your marital issues and the pain both you and your wife are experiencing. But considering the boundaries that have been crossed I don’t know that talking to the priest about your marriage is going to be very helpful, considering he will have a very biased perspective. Have you been receiving marriage counseling from this priest or someone else? It might be worth having a completely unbiased, objective perspective on everything from someone who doesn’t know either of you.
 
Contact the bishop’s office as soon as possible. They will not want to hear your story, but you have to be persistent. As well, if you have another priest you can talk to about this, one who is very mature and trustworthy (I would recommend a younger priest, one in his 30s or 40s at the oldest) then discuss it with that priest as well.

Women who get emotionally involved with priests is a well known phenomenon and most parish priests can relate multiple cases of it. The priest becomes for lonely women a kind of father/husband stand-in. Get on to the bishop immediately.
Is there a Saint Fred? Just wondering cause i’ve never heard of a father fred - but then maybe an alias name.:eek:

Further, should we be concerned if a female parishioner is in the confessional for longer than 10 mins? if so, will our parishes become a boys club - or maybe the men should sit on one side of the main aisle and the women on the other side of the main aisle, and in all events, keep the women away from the priest! unfortunately priests in their 30s and 40s are NOT always mature and trustworthy. Unless of course they are St Padre Pio who had MANY spiritual daughters. 👍

I will agree though that some women in parishes can become possessive/controlling of the priest, if only to ensure things run as they should…
 
Is there a Saint Fred? Just wondering cause i’ve never heard of a father fred - but then maybe an alias name.:eek:
I don’t know if there is a Saint Fred, but yes it is an alias. The OP introduced him with, “My question pertains to the actions/inactions of Father Fred (not is real name).”
Further, should we be concerned if a female parishioner is in the confessional for longer than 10 mins? if so, will our parishes become a boys club - or maybe the men should sit on one side of the main aisle and the women on the other side of the main aisle, and in all events, keep the women away from the priest! unfortunately priests in their 30s and 40s are NOT always mature and trustworthy. Unless of course they are St Padre Pio who had MANY spiritual daughters. 👍
I take it you endorse private weekly meetings at a restaurant/bar between a priest and a trouble married woman?

I don’t suspect you’re married – happily or otherwise – and saying this, are you? Or are you a married woman with a troubled marriage, having private meetings with a priest even while going to marriage counseling, and you find it to be a Good Thing?
Unless of course they are St Padre Pio who had MANY spiritual daughters.
Do we have any records of St. Pio, while he was a priest, having weekly meetings in a restaurant/bar with a woman in a troubled marriage? Instead I can imagine him telling her the first time he met her, in no uncertain terms, to go home and honor her vows. And about these “spiritual daughters” – did he have regular private meeting with them, excluding their husbands if they had any?
I will agree though that some women in parishes can become possessive/controlling of the priest, if only to ensure things run as they should…
Possessive or controlling to ensure things are run as they think they should be run, that is. :okpeople:

I’ve seen that. The altar society out-guessing the priest. :sad_yes:

But this comment doesn’t really apply because we are talking about emotional attachment which may not have been the intent of either party. 🤷

That’s OK though, since you missed the detail about Fred being a pseudonym I suppose you could have missed all the other pertinent details. :rolleyes:

Alan
 
I find this whole discussion rather “drama” oriented, full of suspicion and dis-compassionate. If this priest were Jesus, would anyone have a problem with him having fellowship over a meal and talking about a troubled relationship? Does anyone trust the Holy Spirit? Everyone wants to jump to the conclusion that they are sinning. Do you know what this tells me? That you are judging the situation based on your own corruption, seeing the situation through the filter of your own weakness and sinfulness.
 
Thank you, LL. I just wanted to point out that there are, in fact, other possibilities than the harmful ones I’ve suggested.

I am concerned about brushing off the behavior as unimportant, but beyond that it was all speculation on my part. I would have to know the personalities involved to venture an educated guess; this was just what hit me upon first reading.

My apologies to the OP, Fred, and the wife if I have posted something destructive.

Alan
 
Thank you, LL. I just wanted to point out that there are, in fact, other possibilities than the harmful ones I’ve suggested.

I am concerned about brushing off the behavior as unimportant, but beyond that it was all speculation on my part. I would have to know the personalities involved to venture an educated guess; this was just what hit me upon first reading.

My apologies to the OP, Fred, and the wife if I have posted something destructive.

Alan
Alan, I love how you took responsibility, even though I was not addressing you in particular. I appreciate your humility.
 
Hi all. Unfortunately St Padre Pio was accused of exactly the same thing that this priest is being accused of - of having relations with his spiritual daughters in the confessional or in his cell or where ever… and yes, he did meet regularly with women who were single and married by themselves - without their husbands or a chaperone! Really it doesn’t matter what you do, you could even be a great saint, and people will still accuse you. Its a shame to let behaviour that would lead to God, be stifled by the rumour mongers, which is what St Padre Pio refused to do. And further, the townsfolk where St Padre Pio lived in Italy became so emotionally attached to him that they barricaded his front door and yard and street, refusing to let the Vatican officials remove him out of their town! Turns out those poor emotionally attached ‘fools’ were quite right.

As for the rest of the story, I am not going to speculate.
 
Hi all. Unfortunately St Padre Pio was accused of exactly the same thing that this priest is being accused of - of having relations with his spiritual daughters in the confessional or in his cell or where ever… and yes, he did meet regularly with women who were single and married by themselves - without their husbands or a chaperone! Really it doesn’t matter what you do, you could even be a great saint, and people will still accuse you. Its a shame to let behaviour that would lead to God, be stifled by the rumour mongers, which is what St Padre Pio refused to do. And further, the townsfolk where St Padre Pio lived in Italy became so emotionally attached to him that they barricaded his front door and yard and street, refusing to let the Vatican officials remove him out of their town! Turns out those poor emotionally attached ‘fools’ were quite right.

As for the rest of the story, I am not going to speculate.
I guess it boils down to whether we have a moral obligation to avoid doing things in public that could generate scandalous rumors. When people see things done in public, that involve mystery and somebody with even a bit of celebrity (such as a priest), there will be rumors to fill in the missing parts. Anybody who doesn’t understand that needs to take VIRTUS training.

So the meetings were nothing? What if he were meeting her every night? Can a priest and a troubled married woman go on an all day “retreat” to a beach together – out of state, just the two of them, because he wanted a spiritual daughter to experience praying near an actual ocean? How far is it they can go, until they have to take responsibility for the rumors?

Now I’m not blowing anything up at all. I said I have no information about what happened. But I do have information about the appearances. Aren’t we all taught that it is our responsibility to avoid the appearance of impropriety? Why do we have to watch what we do in public for fear of creating scandal, but a priest does not? Because he’s a priest should we a) expect him to hold a higher behavioral standard when in public, or b) give him license to behave in any manner because he’s above reproach?

Alan
 
St. John of the Cross and Teresa of Avila had a very affectionate relationship, is that scandalous?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top