VIRTUS training: some thoughts

  • Thread starter Thread starter nordskoven
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
So you wouldn’t want to potentially help other children that maybe victims of abuse in the programs at your parish or school? Just because the priest sexual abuse cases didn’t take place in your parish, doesn’t mean that there isn’t abuse occurring outside or inside the parish and it is our duty to protect the innocent as much and wherever we can. Why not go the extra mile to help those being abused, even if the cases in the media never occurred around you?
Patrice, I agree with you 100%. However, the training never mentions the priest abuse scandal at all. Frankly, that diminishes the impact of the training and reduces it’s credibility.

And, yes, one of the priests in the parish where I grew up was a molester.
 
In our diocese volunteers are obligated to report suspected abuse too. The only difference is that professionals are obligated to go straight to law enforcement while volunteers are required to report it to the principle, DRE or pastor.
There is a difference between reporting to a DRE and calling the police. The law in Texas requires any suspicion of abuse by a professional be reported to police or CPS. There is no such legal requirement for volunteers.

Peace

Tim
 
Patrice, I agree with you 100%. However, the training never mentions the priest abuse scandal at all. Frankly, that diminishes the impact of the training and reduces it’s credibility.

And, yes, one of the priests in the parish where I grew up was a molester.
No it doesn’t diminish anything. Sexual abuse occurs all around you on a daily basis, hate to tell you. Its EVERYWHERE. It could be within your own family and not know it if you haven’t been informed enough to see it. It could be happening right under your nose. If the one good thing that comes out of the priest abuse scandal is that the common day volunteer is a bit more informed to help those being abused, than we as Cathlics have a duty to inform ourselves.
 
Patrice, I agree with you 100%. However, the training never mentions the priest abuse scandal at all. Frankly, that diminishes the impact of the training and reduces it’s credibility.
Again, there must be a different version of Virtus out there than the one I attended in 2003 and have facilitated since 2005. One of the victims in the videos was molested by her parish priest. Both bishops in the videos address abuse by priests.

I don’t know what else to say about that.

Peace

Tim
 
Our archdiocese uses Called to Protect. My impression upon watching it was this: Why is the general public not being taught these things?

The instances of child sexual abuse I am aware of from my childhood (that is, aware of now; I didn’t remotely suspect it at the time) were some school friends who were sexuallly abused by an uncle and some much younger cousins who were sexually abused by teachers (female). Combine that with sexual abuse being perpetrated by at least two priests in our archdiocese at the time, and we have the whole gamut from male-on-female, female-on-female, female-on-male, and male-on-male.

Although it could be argued the priest was by far the worst, none of these crimes were really more worthy of prevention than the others, because all were instances of young victims being preyed upon by an adult they should have been able to trust. Our task is to keep the adults from preying without requiring the children to give up their ability to trust anyone. We will do that when the vast majority of adults who are trustworthy keep their eyes open and hold each other to rules that will deny opportunities to offend.

I saw no bias in our training with regards to the possible types of sexual abuse. If anything, the training opened my eyes concerning the possibility that children will sometimes sexually abuse other children–not as mutual sexual “exploration”, which I knew about, but aggressively. The assailants lure their victims into bathrooms or into secluded places, and the victims are often too humiliated to report the assaults. This happens from a very young age all the way through high school. When you realize that this isn’t just an issue of disordered sexual appetites, but also of cruelty or power struggles playing out in the sexual humilation of victims, it opens your eyes to a whole other class of possible offenders and victims.

What this training taught me was the equivalent of not leaving valuables in your car in plain sight, not leaving your windows open in hot weather, not giving your Social Security number or birthdate to someone who has no business having them, not being alone when you show your car to someone responding to a newspaper ad, and so on.

In other words, the Called to Protect training taught me common-sense ways to make our parish programs “target poor” environments. The goal is to make it hard, if not impossible, for a predator to “succeed.”

This is why we need to know the basics of the disorders that lead to this kind of a crime: It keeps us from thinking we know what a predator looks like. Rather, we learn what a predator wants–opportunities for victim selection, opportunities for victim grooming, opportunities for an assault that can be perpetrated without detection–and therefore how to keep any kind of predator from preying on anyone.

Since I took the Called to Protect training, I have read about many young people being preyed upon. Most incidents were in inadequately-supervised youth sports. The vast majority were athlete-on-athlete and private-coach-on-athlete crimes.

Every adult ought to have training in the facts taught by these programs. I think it ought to be in Parade Magazine and Newsweek and the Wall Street Journal. Knowing what predators need in order to offend helps us to remove opportunities by which our children and young people can become victims. Also importantly, it helps us to protect ourselves from accusation by giving us an awareness of how to keep ourselves out of situations where an unfair accusations could be leveled against us because we gave ourselves and opportunity to offend.

Furthermore, we have to remember that the predators have their own kind of training, via chat rooms on the internet. They are learning from each other and getting affirmation from each other in ways that were never possible in the past. They are going to get more cunning and more bold. It is not enough to apprehend them after the fact. By then, some child’s innocence has been shattered. We have to deny them opportunities to offend in the first place.
 
Our archdiocese uses Called to Protect. My impression upon watching it was this: Why is the general public not being taught these things?

(snip)

In other words, the Called to Protect training taught me common-sense ways to make our parish programs “target poor” environments. The goal is to make it hard, if not impossible, for a predator to “succeed.”

This is why we need to know the basics of the disorders that lead to this kind of a crime: It keeps us from thinking we know what a predator looks like. Rather, we learn what a predator wants–opportunities for victim selection, opportunities for victim grooming, opportunities for an assault that can be perpetrated without detection–and therefore how to keep any kind of predator from preying on anyone.
Good! You get it! 👍

Luckily, I think that you are in the large majority of people who take this type of training, whether it be Called to Protect or Virtus.

Peace

Tim
 
There is a difference between reporting to a DRE and calling the police. The law in Texas requires any suspicion of abuse by a professional be reported to police or CPS. There is no such legal requirement for volunteers.

Peace

Tim
Agreed. However, it seems the OP was left with the impression that volunteers did not have the obligation to report. They probably do have the obligation but it’s not a legal one but a policy one.
 
Agreed. However, it seems the OP was left with the impression that volunteers did not have the obligation to report. They probably do have the obligation but it’s not a legal one but a policy one.
We can add moral obligation to that list.

This is unfortunately why Joe Paterno is in trouble at Penn State. He got a report and he did what he was supposed to do: report it to the people whose job it was to contact police in matters pertaining to possible crimes committed on the campus. Because the allegation that got to him was vague, however, he did not follow up on the matter.

In retrospect, knowing what we know now about the mishandlings that can happen with these things, Mr. Paterno should have called the administrator later and asked what had been done. If nothing had been done or if there was a cover-up going on, then he had a *moral *duty to make a call to the authorities himself in defense of the possible victim, even though he might have gotten into trouble with his superiors for doing it.

The problem was that Mr. Paterno unconciously made the decision that the report probably didn’t have substance to it, so he was not concerned when he heard nothing more about it. With what we know about these matters now, in 2011, he ought to have made certain that the decision that the report had no substance was only made by someone who had actually done a real investigation into the matter. That didn’t happen.

I don’t know what Mr. Paterno knew about these kinds of crimes back in 1985, when he made the decisions he did, but I have always gotten the impression that he is an unusually decent and responsible man. There is a reason that Penn State has never been investigated by the NCAA for rules violations, and a reason his former players speak so highly of him. If he had known what I learned in Called to Protect training and what we have learned as a result of the difficult disclosures forced by the victims of abuse within the Catholic Church, I think he’d have followed up. By the accounts of prosecuters, some victims would almost certainly have been spared, if he had. If the athletic director at Penn State had had that training, the opportunity to abuse might never have taken place on the Penn State campus in the first place. When you know better, you can do better.

Ignorance is dangerous, especially ignorance that thinks that it knows. The victims of past crimes have insisted we look at some ugly truths about how these matters were handled in the Church. They have taken attacks for that. The least we can do is to learn from what they’ve insisted be brought into the light, so that we will have the knowledge to keep that light where it will do some good. Otherwise, the pain that the whole Church went through because of these disclosures will have been for nothing.

The disclosures will only do some good if we act differently in the future because of them.
 
I’m in our good Bishop Finn’s diocese. I have attended the VIRTUS training. And, yes, to volunteer you have to accept to be a mandated reporter here. I can understand the hurt expressed in the OP, even if the facts aren’t exactly correct.
 
And here’s the two-page confession in genuine Church-speak by an area pederast-priest, Fr. Bede Parry, ordained after caught preying on boys.
Fr. Bede Parry was ordained an Episcopalian priest. Please do not rely on SNAP or the Star for the facts. Same goes for the Ratigan/Finn case.
Millstones all around.
Jesus never once said that those accused of offending the children will get millstones. Jesus DID say that for those who actually DO offend the children, a millstone is the better option. Read your scriptures with a little more attention to detail.

From a fellow MoKan, member of St. Therese in Parkville
 
You didn’t see the two actual molesters in either of the two videos?
I’m not sure what you mean. Are all the VIRTUS videos the same across the country? It’s been 4 years so I don’t remember all the details of the video, except that dh and I were certain after watching it that the dangerous person being depicted was the creepy guy behind the Fence. Dh has encountered many, many cases of abuse in his job (investigating these cases is a large part of what he does for a living), and it is much more likely to be the baseball coach who capitalizes on the family that is too busy to drive their child everywhere they go, and who is grateful for the person who offers junior a ride. THIS was not the gist of the film.
I must be facilitating a completely different version of Virtus than people are discussing. We discuss parental supervision in every single session I have facilitated since 2005. We ALWAYS emphasize that parents are the primary protectors of their children.

Peace

Tim
But if parents are truly taking responsibility for their children’s safety, then their children wouldn’t be in most of the situations where safe-guidelines are needed. Our son is an altar boy. Guess what - we don’t NEED any safe-environment guidelines to protect him, because we don’t leave him in the sacristy alone. We are with him when he is with other adults. But you know what - the VIRTUS program that we watched didn’t tell parents to do that. In fact, it wasn’t offered to parents. It is offered to volunteers/teachers/etc. because it assumes that parents won’t be there with their kids, and it tells the teachers how to protect children that aren’t theirs from other predators. It may SAY that parents are primary protectors, but unless it advocates and expects parents to actually be the ones watching and protecting, then it is only lip service.

Another example was that they discussed sleep overs, admitting that this is an area of risk for abuse. The solution? Get to know the family, ask questions, blah blah blah. Was there a mention of “maybe sleepovers aren’t a good idea, because you the parent are not capable of protecting your child in the middle of the night at someone elses house” ? No there wasn’t, because that is considered too radical. Well, I believe that it is not only not radical, but it is necessary, and the only way to truly protect our children.

In my experience, and very opinionated opinion, we can liken safe environment programs to sex ed. Instead of getting to the root of the problem which is the break down of the family (which is a problem even in intact families), and lack of true parental supervision, the program says, “well we know that the parents are going to turn over the safety of their children to other people, so this is the next best thing we can do.” It is very much like the argument of “well, we know the kids are going to have sex anyway, so let’s teach them that condoms are what will keep them safe/un-pregnant.”
 
I’m not sure what you mean. Are all the VIRTUS videos the same across the country? It’s been 4 years so I don’t remember all the details of the video, except that dh and I were certain after watching it that the dangerous person being depicted was the creepy guy behind the Fence. Dh has encountered many, many cases of abuse in his job (investigating these cases is a large part of what he does for a living), and it is much **more likely to be the baseball coach **who capitalizes on the family that is too busy to drive their child everywhere they go, and who is grateful for the person who offers junior a ride. THIS was not the gist of the film.
Are you sure that the program you attended was Virtus and not something else? One of the two molesters who are interviewed in the videos was a softball coach. It sounds to me that you did not attend Virtus but perhaps another program. In fact, if you weren’t attending a program about child sex abuse, you wouldn’t know either of the molesters were what they are.
But if parents are truly taking responsibility for their children’s safety, then their children wouldn’t be in most of the situations where safe-guidelines are needed. Our son is an altar boy. Guess what - we don’t NEED any safe-environment guidelines to protect him, because we don’t leave him in the sacristy alone. We are with him when he is with other adults.
Just because you never, ever let your son out of your sight doesn’t change the fact that there are children potentially at risk. Are you only responsible for your own son? If you saw warning signs of a sexual predator, would you keep quiet if your son wasn’t the one at risk?

We are primarily responsible for our own children, but we are also responsible for keeping ALL children safe. We are seeing a very tragic scene play out in Pennsylvania because no one was willing to protect someone else’s child.
But you know what - the VIRTUS program that we watched didn’t tell parents to do that. In fact, it wasn’t offered to parents. It is offered to volunteers/teachers/etc. because it assumes that parents won’t be there with their kids, and it tells the teachers how to protect children that aren’t theirs from other predators. It may SAY that parents are primary protectors, but unless it advocates and expects parents to actually be the ones watching and protecting, then it is only lip service.
Virtus is offered to every single adult. Not all adults are required to attend, but it is offered to them. So, again, perhaps you attended a different program.
In my experience, and very opinionated opinion, we can liken safe environment programs to sex ed. Instead of getting to the root of the problem which is the break down of the family (which is a problem even in intact families), and lack of true parental supervision, the program says, “well we know that the parents are going to turn over the safety of their children to other people, so this is the next best thing we can do.” It is very much like the argument of “well, we know the kids are going to have sex anyway, so let’s teach them that condoms are what will keep them safe/un-pregnant.”
Wow.

Peace

Tim
 
Sorry for the tone of my last post. I am writing fast and furious, because I really should be doing something else right now, and I got caught up in the reply without realizing I probably sounded hostile to you.

I should start out by saying that I appreciate your efforts with VIRTUS, and that while I think the church response is inadequate and flawed, I do appreciate that there is at least a response, and that there are people willing to devote their time to making an effort to protect kids.

That said,
Are you sure that the program you attended was Virtus and not something else? One of the two molesters who are interviewed in the videos was a softball coach. It sounds to me that you did not attend Virtus but perhaps another program. In fact, if you weren’t attending a program about child sex abuse, you wouldn’t know either of the molesters were what they are.
No I am certain it was VIRTUS, and now that you mention it more specifically, I do remember there being interviews of molesters. But there was either another video, or another part of the video that was a re-enactment, not an interview, and this was the part that went back to the old stereotypes of the creepy guy by the fence. Maybe my dh and I over-reacted, but we left the class feeling like that portion of the video undid much of the message of “it could be anyone” that might have been stated before hand.
Just because you never, ever let your son out of your sight doesn’t change the fact that there are children potentially at risk. Are you only responsible for your own son? If you saw warning signs of a sexual predator, would you keep quiet if your son wasn’t the one at risk?
Now I do let my children out of my sight. And I do appreciate that other parents are being made aware of the problem and risks. Why on earth would I keep quiet if I saw a child at risk? Why would you think I would do that?

But I do think that it is very important that parents start getting the message that leaving it to other adults is not enough. Knowing that the catholic school soccer coach took a VIRTUS class is not enough. Knowing that he passed a background check is not enough. I know of specific situations in which this has not deterred children from being abused.

And here’s the thing. People hear that we go in the sacristy with our son and we don’t let our daughter go to sleepovers and think that we are extreme. I challenge every adult to reconsider that judgment. It is fully reasonable for parents to be in the sacristy with their children. Every parent should do that. It may be counter-cultural, but it is a very smart decision not to send your child to sleepovers. I know - people think it’s extreme. Why? Because everyone else is doing it. It is not convenient to buck that trend. Because their kids feel different and left out when they don’t get to do the same things the other kids do. The fact is, children are often left in situations that are not the safest, not because there is no other choice, but because parents feel pressure to go along with the crowd.

What REALLY needs to keep kids safe is for parents to learn that they TRULY are the ones responsible for the safety of their children. To TRULY learn that it is not their obligation to give their children over to the state (ie. school) to do their job for them, or to give their children over to the culture (ie. sleepovers and other cultural trends). VIRTUS isn’t doing this. The church isn’t doing this (mostly). And parents ourselves, are dragging each other down as we forget our REAL roles in our childrens’ lives.
We are primarily responsible for our own children, but we are also responsible for keeping ALL children safe. We are seeing a very tragic scene play out in Pennsylvania because no one was willing to protect someone else’s child.Virtus is offered to every single adult. Not all adults are required to attend, but it is offered to them.
Very true. The church is doing better than a lot of organizations. But the Church has a long way to go before it can really claim that it is fixing the problem of abuse of children. After all, even though it was the priestly scandal that brought it on, abuse of children is much larger and more pervasive than that. Perhaps it is unfair to claim that VIRTUS is equivalent to advocating condom use in sex ed. After all their suggestions to the people who take the course are for the most part, not inherently wrong. But my point is that the program itself is missing the most important component of keeping kids safe - which is a truly family-centered culture. We need to not say, “oh well, parents will give their kids over to everyone else,” We need to be saying, “PARENTS! DON’T GIVE YOUR KIDS OVER. STAY WITH THEM! HOLD THEM CLOSE! BUCK THE CULTURE!” and we need to be saying it loud and strong.
 
Patrice, I agree with you 100%. However, the training never mentions the priest abuse scandal at all. Frankly, that diminishes the impact of the training and reduces it’s credibility.

And, yes, one of the priests in the parish where I grew up was a molester.
It could be because if all we do is protect from the danger that the priest might be a molester, the other molesters will still have carte blanche. Innocent people also need to know how to be safe from accusation. The people who accuse falsely are the minority, but they cause devastating damage, too! If you drag the priests into this and then bring up the topic of saving adults from false accusation, though, it will seem as if you’re just doing more protection of the “brand name.”

Again, I left the parish training wishing that all the parents with their kids in any sort of after school activity got this information. It would have saved some children and young people in our area in the time since I took the training.

For instance, our kids go for sports camps at a facility that offers private lessons. Those lessons are never offered with just one single adult in the facility. There are always at least two unrelated staff members on site, and the instructors are never given one-on-one closed-door privacy with a student. The touching, conversations, and relationships between staff and students are appropriate: that is, friendly but still professional. Likewise, I know what sort of conditions to look for at the local swim centers and community centers, what sort of behaviors to notice in swim instructors or volunteer coaches, and so on. I know how to keep my kids safe from predators, and also how to keep the people who volunteer on their behalf from unfounded accusations, as well. If I stay around with the coach when a child hasn’t been picked up from practice, everyone is safer. The child can’t be abused and the coach can’t be accused. Maybe some day I’ll be the parent who was held up in traffic; it is good to know other parents would look out for the whole team, too.

That’s the kind of thing I have learned to look for in a program that caters to children and youth: that is, that they go to the trouble and expense of denying opportunities for molesters. That wouldn’t happen if the parish had a program that was seemed to be about preventing priests from causing problems instead of the broader goal of preventing all sexual abuse and all untruthful accusations.
 
No I am certain it was VIRTUS, and now that you mention it more specifically, I do remember there being interviews of molesters. But there was either another video, or another part of the video that was a re-enactment, not an interview, and this was the part that went back to the old stereotypes of the creepy guy by the fence. Maybe my dh and I over-reacted, but we left the class feeling like that portion of the video undid much of the message of “it could be anyone” that might have been stated before hand.
I’m sorry, but I am truly amazed at this. There are almost 60 minutes of video between the two videos in Virtus. The guy you are referring to is on the video for, at most, 2 minutes and the two molesters that you had forgotten are almost half of the video. The two real molesters fit exactly what you described in your earlier post about what a molester is likely to be and yet you didn’t even remember that they were in the video. But you do remember the actor.

I’m sorry, but I believe that you went to the training with your mind made up that Virtus is nothing other than a CYA for the Church or some other waste of time and nothing was going to change your mind. I think that you latched onto something that validated your pre-concieved notion that the training is nothing but an excuse to be a bad parent.

I really, really wish you would re-take the training and do so with an open heart and open mind. I’m telling you for a fact that if people at Penn State had followed the training given in Virtus, at least some of those boys would not have been molested.

Peace

Tim
 
I’m telling you for a fact that if people at Penn State had followed the training given in Virtus, at least some of those boys would not have been molested.

Peace

Tim
I think you’re right. If Penn State had Called to Protect rules, the abuse that took place in the campus football compex would have been prevented, especially considering how scrupulous Joe Paterno was about following every rule. You know that a guy who runs a program that successful and never has an NCAA investigation runs a tight ship. They just had to lay those rules down, and it would have been done.

Those kinds of rules also don’t require the same level of courage from people who have to confront evidence that their friend or colleague is a molester. When the guidelines are in place and it is made clear that they are non-negotiable, it isn’t so personal when you have to do the right thing. Compliance is far higher than when you teach the same information, but expect people to apply it using their own judgment, because personal judgment has this way of letting personal feelings get in the way.
 
I’m sorry, but I am truly amazed at this. There are almost 60 minutes of video between the two videos in Virtus. The guy you are referring to is on the video for, at most, 2 minutes and the two molesters that you had forgotten are almost half of the video. The two real molesters fit exactly what you described in your earlier post about what a molester is likely to be and yet you didn’t even remember that they were in the video. But you do remember the actor.
I’m sorry, but I believe that you went to the training with your mind made up that Virtus is nothing other than a CYA for the Church or some other waste of time and nothing was going to change your mind.
Don’t be sorry. I love amazing people. 😃

Well, like I said it was 4 years ago, but now that you jarred my memory, I did remember the interview. I would have to watch it again to argue further details. But I remember that I DID go into it with an open mind. And after the fact, I was really disappointed. I felt like it could’ve done so much more. I wanted my dh to volunteer to get up and give the presentation instead, because he could’ve given so much more helpful information than what we got in the training.
I think that you latched onto something that validated your pre-concieved notion that the training is nothing but an excuse to be a bad parent.
Actually I didn’t think it was an excuse for bad parenting then, and I don’t think it now. I certainly didn’t go into the training with that notion.
I really, really wish you would re-take the training and do so with an open heart and open mind. I’m telling you for a fact that if people at Penn State had followed the training given in Virtus, at least some of those boys would not have been molested.
That may be true. And for the sake of those SOME boys, I wish that people had known about or followed that training. But I’d rather go for ALL (or even MOST) than SOME. And that can’t happen without a major shift in how parenting and care of children is viewed.
 
It could be because if all we do is protect from the danger that the priest might be a molester, the other molesters will still have carte blanche. Innocent people also need to know how to be safe from accusation.
I’m not saying that the training is bad, or that we should not protect against child molesters. The training is useful.

I am saying that an institution such as the Church does not institute anything as sweeping as this without outside forces acting upon it. Those outside forces are the abuse scandal, lawsuits, and public opinion. However, there’s nary a mention of it when VIRTUS is discussed or presented.
 
That may be true. And for the sake of those SOME boys, I wish that people had known about or followed that training. But I’d rather go for ALL (or even MOST) than SOME. And that can’t happen without a major shift in how parenting and care of children is viewed.
I agree with you. I actively publicize the training to any adult that will listen.

Peace

Tim
 
I’m not saying that the training is bad, or that we should not protect against child molesters. The training is useful.

I am saying that an institution such as the Church does not institute anything as sweeping as this without outside forces acting upon it. Those outside forces are the abuse scandal, lawsuits, and public opinion. However, there’s nary a mention of it when VIRTUS is discussed or presented.
Once again, unless you attended a different training than Virtus, it WAS discussed in the videos by one of the victims and her family AND both bishops and I know I specifically address it during the discussion period.

Peace

Tim
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top