Vocational Dilemma

  • Thread starter Thread starter SamTheNewfie
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
S

SamTheNewfie

Guest
I’m graduating from college in May, and I think I want to try to become a weathercaster. For my TV Performance 2 final I did presented the weather and enjoyed it more than any other type of broadcast I’ve done. I feel like my reasons for wanting this are shallow and selfish. It’s a comfortable work environment. It’s not backbreaking labor. They tend to get a lot of free perks and are generally well-liked. Also, those who end up being really successful(such as Sam Champion, Al Roker, Jillian Reynolds, etc.) get very generous salaries and all the benefits of celebrity. Even though there is nothing objectively immoral involved, I’d wonder if I’d feel like I was wasting my life and talents doing something meaningless.

Are my goals sinful? Would I not be honoring God? Am I overthinking this?
 
I’m going to assume that you are not aware of another call from God that you are ignoring. That is always a bad idea.

Weather broadcasters provide a useful service. Weather reports and forecasts may even be the most practical offerings in all of broadcasting. Furthermore, finding a job that does the world some good and that you would do for free if you could afford it is not a sin, it is an ideal. After all, there are people who would rather do backbreaking labor than be caught dead having to speak in front of a camera. There are far more who don’t have the talent to point at a green screen as if it were a real map or to deliver the weather news in a competent manner.

Your compensation is not selfish unless you use the benefits that the Lord gives you in a selfish manner. You have to consider yourself the steward of your wealth and talents, and not an owner who pays a “charity tax” to God, no matter what you do, but that doesn’t mean you have to go looking for work that you won’t enjoy.

Have a “parachute”–that is, alternative plans for how you’ll support yourself if the broadcasting thing does not work out–pursue your goals in a moral way, continually look (and listen to Heaven) to use your talents for the Kingdom of God, and there should not be a moral problem with your plan.
 
I’m graduating from college in May, and I think I want to try to become a weathercaster. For my TV Performance 2 final I did presented the weather and enjoyed it more than any other type of broadcast I’ve done. I feel like my reasons for wanting this are shallow and selfish. It’s a comfortable work environment. It’s not backbreaking labor. They tend to get a lot of free perks and are generally well-liked. Also, those who end up being really successful(such as Sam Champion, Al Roker, Jillian Reynolds, etc.) get very generous salaries and all the benefits of celebrity. Even though there is nothing objectively immoral involved, I’d wonder if I’d feel like I was wasting my life and talents doing something meaningless.

Are my goals sinful? Would I not be honoring God? Am I overthinking this?
I cannot see anything sinful about wanting to be a weather forecaster. Someone has to do it! And once you proceed, you may find another area you want to move into. Also, one cannot do a single job any more. You must always be looking for the next opportunity, so don’t think “I will waste my life doing this one job,” because you won’t have that opportunity, especially in broadcasting which is notoriously fickle.

You can always do service work when you aren’t working. But I agree with the previous poster who said if you are ignoring some other calling, then it will be a problem.
 
If you are worried about anything, go talk with a priest. Now, we want God to be everywhere, and that includes in News stations. Any job can be holy (as long as it is not immoral in itself) if done the best we can and offered to Him. You might be in a position to influence others (especially if you become a celebrity) in a positive manner. All honest occupations can be a source of holiness, and if you do end up making a lot of money, then great, you can also be generous helping others!
 
I’m going to assume that you are not aware of another call from God that you are ignoring. That is always a bad idea.
This is where I’m conflicted. Ever since I was a child people have told me I’d make a great lawyer. I’ve done extremely well in English, history, and political science classes. I also have thought about studying accupuncture to help treat infertility, PMS, and menstrual problems. I’m having trouble knowing differentiating God’s calling and random advice from people and my own instincts. The fact that I beat out 50 other girls at ten years old to be the moderator for a major school presentation and happen to live so close to one of top schools for broadcast journalism tells me that maybe I’m on the right path. It seemed like the natural decision for me after high school.
 
IMHO there’s nothing shameful about pursuing a career that reflects your talents and interests. The most successful people feel passionate about their daily tasks. Besides, if you’re still in High School, you’re likely to change your mind about a zillion more times before you settle on one direction. Nothing wrong with that!

However, if you are evaluating your potential career track with comparisons to Al Roker and other celebrities, then you’re likely going to be quickly disappointed. For every celebrity weather person, there’s probably a thousand or more hard working but unglamorous and low paid workers. Its like saying I want to build computers because Bill Gates has done well for himself, and being a zillionaire sounds like a good lifestyle. Odds are totally unrealistic and you’re stuck with an unfulfilling career that drains the soul. The cheezy saying is “find a career that you’d do for free.” Lots of careers require brains and skill in public speaking – you’ve got the whole world in front of you. Stay off the crack, and you’ll be fine 🙂
 
This is where I’m conflicted. Ever since I was a child people have told me I’d make a great lawyer. I’ve done extremely well in English, history, and political science classes. I also have thought about studying accupuncture to help treat infertility, PMS, and menstrual problems. I’m having trouble knowing differentiating God’s calling and random advice from people and my own instincts. The fact that I beat out 50 other girls at ten years old to be the moderator for a major school presentation and happen to live so close to one of top schools for broadcast journalism tells me that maybe I’m on the right path. It seemed like the natural decision for me after high school.
Well, just because someone on the outside thinks you would make a great lawyer does not mean you have to go into law school!!! If YOU don’t have any inclination to do that, then pay no attention - you can probably use the same traits they might see in you, such as confidence in public speaking, in your broadcasting career.

Try spending a little more time in front of the Blessed Sacrament. I find that my mind clears and I hear from God in quiet adoration…

🙂
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top