Originally Posted by Malleus 01
when the Our Father is prayed in a Latin Mass - the Congregation is kneeling …
Keep in mind that the liturgical paradigm has always been Solemn Mass (missa solemnis), and note that there (and in a missa cantata) the congregational posture for the Pater has always been to stand.
Mal: Thats correct - I was referring to Low Mass not Solemn High Mass. But keep in mind - at the Latin Solemn High Mass we arent holding hands either. And how many Solemn High Masses do we have a year where we hold hands? The answer is zero.
I don’t follow the logic.
Our focus should be on God at all times.
Therefore, when the Our Father is prayed, the Congregation is kneeling.
Conclusions …
- When we’re kneeling, we’re focusing on God. When we’re not, we’re not focusing on God.
Mal: When we are looking for our Neighbors Hand we are distracted whether Standing or Kneeling.
- Since we should focus on God “at all times” during Mass – then we should kneel through the entire Mass.
Mal: Thats not what I said. Now you can intimate that this is what I said - But in Latin Mass our attention is on GOD and not in Holding Hands with the Person next to us and whether kneeling or standing both we and our neighbor should be concentrating on that IMO.
- Since the traditional Latin Mass calls for standing and sitting – these postures are wrong since we cannot focus on God during those times.
Mal: Actually the reverse is true since the People are interacting with the Priest and through the Priest GOD according to the Rubrics and the People are both Standing Genuflecting and Kneeling as one depending on the Rubrics instead of Interacting with one another by offering the Sign of Peace or Holding Hands or recieving in the Hand or having to receive under both species and all the shenaigans put in by the Modernists.
- Therefore, the Tridentine Mass is a false form of worship and should be avoided.
Mal: Not worthy of comment. A ridiculous conclusion.
Or perhaps this …
- Kneeling is the most important posture
Mal: Well when it comes to receiving Holy Communion thats true - but then without communion rails you just go up there and stick out your hand - and then you wonder why the reverance for the Real Presence is down with many so called Catholics no longer believing in this dogma.
- Since there are parts of Mass where we don’t kneel, that just means those parts of Mass (like the Offertory and Gospel) are not very important.
Mal: Well when the changes under Paul the VI came along - the offertory was completely revised - so instead of the Body and Blood being offered for Propitiation its the fruit of the vine and the work of human hands.And the fact that most modern Churches use the NAB which was compiled with the Imput of Protestant theologians instead of the Latin Vulgate of St Jerome circa 380 AD under Pope Damasus so I believe you probably do feel that way.
Here’s another one …
- In the earliest Catholic liturgies, there was no kneeling on Sunday. This remains true today in Eastern Rites.
Mal: And how many of the Eastern Rites in the Earliest Catholic liturgies Hold Hands during the Our Father and offer each other the sign of Peace? Just wondering.
- Since we kneel at the Our Father and Sanctus, and that means we are focusing entirely on God – those Early Liturgies (from the Apostolic era) were wrong.
Mal: Once again , you have missed the point. Whether you Kneel or Stand isnt at issue - what is at issue is the Interaction of the Laity in the Pews with each other takes away from the attention that should always be directed to GOD. What part of that seems confusing to you?
We can prove this because we have kneelers in true, traditional Catholic chapels, and the Early Catholic churches did not (for over 1,000 years). Kneelers were introduced after the Protestant Reformation (Protestants innovated benches which Catholic parishes copied).
Mal: Perhaps you should visit the Catholic Encyclopedia under Genuflexion which totally debunks this idiocy. Example: But when the occasion was one of special solemnity, or the petition very urgent, or the prayer made with exceptional fervour, the Jewish suppliant knelt. Besides the many pictorial representations of kneeling prisoners, and the like, left us by ancient art, Genesis 41:43 and Esth., iii, 2 may be quoted to show how universally in the East kneeling was accepted as the proper attitude of suppliants and dependents. Thus Solomon dedicating his temple “kneeling down in the presence of all the multitude of Israel, and lifting up his hands towards Heaven”, etc. (2 Chronicles 6:13; cf. 1 Kings 8:54). Esdras too: “I fell upon my knees, and spread out my hands to the Lord my God” (Ezra 9:5); and Daniel: “opening the windows in his upper chamber towards Jerusalem, he knelt down three times a day, and adored, and gave thanks before his God, as he had been accustomed to do before” (Daniel 6:10), illustrate this practice. Of Christ’s great prayer for His disciples and for His Church we are only told that “lifting up his eyes to heaven, he said”, etc. (John 17:1); but of His Agony in the Garden of Gethsemani: “kneeling down, he prayed” (Luke 22:41). The lepers, beseeching the Saviour to have mercy on them, kneel (Mark 1:40; cf. 10:17).
Therefore Protestants are correct???
Mal: The Catholic encyclopedia speaks of things existing for 1500 Years prior to the First Protestant. Wanna try again?