Was Early Christianity Corrupted by 'Hellenism'?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Big_Dummy
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I don’t buy it, at least the claim that the Hellenistic corruptions seeped in starting in the third century, because - regardless of how you interpret it - Jesus’ divinity is pretty clearly a view of the author of the Gospel of John, which was probably written/finished around the end of the first century. A little early for Hellenistic corruption, especially since the Apostles were still alive.

Also, check out the conversation on the last couple pages - 30 and 31 - of this thread between posters Contarini and Sufjon to see some implications of how orthodox Christianity is strikingly unHellenistic in many ways.

Furthermore, some strains of Hellenistic philosophy are, intellectually speaking, partially compatible and often helpful in combination with the traditional Jewish world in the context of which Jesus carried out His teachings and ministry.
 
Also, check out the conversation on the last couple pages - 30 and 31 - of this thread between posters Contarini and Sufjon to see some implications of how orthodox Christianity is strikingly unHellenistic in many ways.
My profile is set to display 100 posts per page and the whole thread is only 5 pages long. What is the range of *post-by-post *serial numbers that corresponds to the segment of that conversation you had in mind?
 
I did read the article and the author concludes in the negative . This is not a new question .
Why did you think the question should be addressed again ? Certainly the author you site doesn’t argue the affirmative . Are you asserting it was ?

I think this question would puzzle the 1st and 2nd century Christian Church . I’m sure you know that the early Christian Church was considered by some/many as a " Jewish Cult ".
Should we also ask if 1st and 2nd cetury AD Judaism was corrupted by Hellenism ?
 
My profile is set to display 100 posts per page and the whole thread is only 5 pages long. What is the range of *post-by-post *serial numbers that corresponds to the segment of that conversation you had in mind?
Sorry, I was referring to replies #433-#457, but particularly the posts in that range from Sufjon and Contarini. Note how difficult Sufjon, as a Hindu seeker, is finding assimilating Christianity as it has existed ever since St. Paul. That speaks volumes about whether Christianity is more Jewish or more Greek.

In any case, I agree with the assessments of the article the OP linked to. The claims of groups like Mormons about Church history constitute conspicuous anti-intellectualism. The influence of Hellenistic thought on the early Christian worldview certainly didn’t dominate Christianity, which stood out quite distinctly in the ancient world.

In the words of the article, “the claims of those like the Mormons and Jehovah’s Witnesses that New Testament Christianity was corrupted by later Hellenistic influence fail to account for the fact that it is the New Testament data itself which led the early Christian fathers to confess the deity of Christ and the Trinity of God.”
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top