S
SimmieKay
Guest
Was the American Revolution sinful? Was it a violation of Romans 13:1, 1 Peter 2:13-17, Titus 3:1? Does it fall under the condemnation of Pope Pius IX’s Syllabus of Errors, 63 (“It is lawful to refuse obedience to legitimate princes, and even to rebel against them”)?
Defenders of the American Revolution justify it as overthrowing tyranny. Yet, the government which St. Paul speaks of in Romans 13:1 is that of the Roman Emperor Nero, who literally fed Christians to the lions and burnt them alive and by whom St. Paul would go on to be martyred; if Christians are to obey the Emperor Nero, then surely they must also obey King George III, who never did anything even remotely comparable.
If the American Revolution was a sin, doesn’t it logically follow that July 4th celebrations are sinful too? Is not the public promotion and celebration of sin itself a sin?
Conversely, if the American revolution wasn’t a sin–well, then to be consistent wouldn’t you have to say that forcibly overthrowing the present-day US government need not be a sin either? Increasing numbers of people argue that the present-day US government is more tyrannical than King George III ever was, and maybe they are right.
Defenders of the American Revolution justify it as overthrowing tyranny. Yet, the government which St. Paul speaks of in Romans 13:1 is that of the Roman Emperor Nero, who literally fed Christians to the lions and burnt them alive and by whom St. Paul would go on to be martyred; if Christians are to obey the Emperor Nero, then surely they must also obey King George III, who never did anything even remotely comparable.
If the American Revolution was a sin, doesn’t it logically follow that July 4th celebrations are sinful too? Is not the public promotion and celebration of sin itself a sin?
Conversely, if the American revolution wasn’t a sin–well, then to be consistent wouldn’t you have to say that forcibly overthrowing the present-day US government need not be a sin either? Increasing numbers of people argue that the present-day US government is more tyrannical than King George III ever was, and maybe they are right.