Was this a grave sin? Should I confess this?

  • Thread starter Thread starter s.cono
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
S

s.cono

Guest
Hi brothers and sisters:

I am a new member struggling to get back into my faith. I was literally away from the church from the very beginning, however, I was Baptized, received Holy Communion, and Confirmation at the appropriate ages, and attended Catholic school. I was an altar boy as a child. It was all an illusion, though, as I don’t think at the time I ever practiced my faith correctly, or truthfully. Fast forward 50 years. I recently felt a strong urge to return to the church, to basically fall to my knees and beg for forgiveness. I was carrying around a titanic load of sins I committed over the years, especially in my alcoholic and drug-fueled young adult days. In other words many heinous sins against pretty much everyone and everything.

I basically showed up at a parish, rang the bell, and asked if I could talk to a priest. He allowed me to make a general confession the following morning. I made a list of sins that I remember committing from early childhood, then through the decades until the present. It was lengthy and took quite some time. It was weird because it was face to face and I was literally terrified, but this blessed man put me at peace and I got through it.

I have been to confession weekly, confessing the sins I forgot to confess and remembered afterwards. I’m probably still not done with the past ones, but the flow is only a trickle now.

I recently remembered something that I did not that long ago, and I am wondering if it is a bad sin. It was just this past Ash Wednesday. I went to check on my elderly parents, as I do a couple of times a day. They were sitting around watching television, and made me notice that they drew crosses on their heads with a sharpie marker. The reason is because they missed Ash Wednesday. If I had known it was Ash Wednesday I would have taken them, but it was now early evening and too late. I got an idea. There was some palm in the house left over from the previous palm Sunday. I got the idea in my head that I could burn some of it, say a prayer while doing it, and make the sign of the cross on their forehead with the ashes. I did exactly that. They were happy, I was happy, but in retrospect I don’t think I should have been doing this. Did I commit a grave sin? I’m going to confess this on Saturday, but until I am worried about what I did. I certainly was not in any state of grace or purity, because when I did this it was way before my general confession.

Thanks for taking the time to read this.

S.Cono
 
Welcome home indeed! May God bless you and keep you close to him!
 
I don’t think that was a mortal sin, especially because even if it is grave matter (doesn’t sound like you did anything gravely wrong to me, although I’m not an expert on this sort of thing), it definitely seems like you were not aware so as to be culpable of mortal sin.

Also, you shouldn’t be worried, as whatever mortal sins you forgot to mention were forgiven when you went to confession, i.e. you do not leave the state of grace by remembering. Just do what you’ve been doing and mention them whenever your next confession is if you remember some.

Thanks for sharing your story, it’s great to read. Welcome home.
 
Last edited:
Just tell that to the priest next confession. I don’t think you had any intent to commit a grave sin, but rather to give comfort to your aged parents. Like someone else said, don’t beat yourself up over it.

Shalom.
 
S,
You confessed everything you remembered and when the priest absolved your sins, all your sins those confessed and those not mentioned, were forgiven. As long as you did not deliberately withhold a grave sin you are a clean slate. Move forward. Remember what happened to Lott’s wife when she looked back. Welcome home!
 
Welcome back my friend! It is good that you are back!

I wouldn’t worry too much about this being a mortal sin. If you aren’t sure, then it probably wasn’t a mortal sin. It might be good just to confess it anyway (as you said you were going to do) but say that you are doubtful that this is a mortal sin.
 
Wait…your parents drew crosses on their foreheads with a Sharpie?!
 
God bless them. I do hope perhaps they were washable. I think it’s very sweet 😊
 
Sharpies’ advertise as being permanent.

Washability aside, I’d be a lot more concerned about elderly parents drawing on each other with markers than whether a sin was committed. Or, I’d be very seriously concerned, to say the least
 
Last edited:
I understand, for some reason I assume some folks say sharpie when they mean any kind of marker.
 
I should have just said “marker”. It was semi-permanent. My mother is 92 and my dad is 87. They do require I drop in on them a few times a day, but can see to most of their own needs, so long as I pick up food and their other necessities, and take them to their appointments. The marker stain did come off. The lines were drawn very thin, and the marker was nearly spent.
 
Thanks for all who replied. I feel better, and will stick to the plan of mentioning it at my next confession.

S.Cono
 
The ashes received in church on that day are blessed, but otherwise, they are no different than what you had. I don’t see how there could be any sin at all in being prayerful and penitent.
 
Based on the information provided we can have a moral certainty it was not a mortal sin.
 
Yes, father confirmed on Saturday that it was not a mortal sin, and that it was done with good intention. Thanks to everyone who opined.

S.Cono
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top