Was This A Sin?

  • Thread starter Thread starter DonJamieson
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
D

DonJamieson

Guest
Last night I was watching That '70s Show, and for some reason I thought, “Is Jackie flat-chested?” so I looked for a brief moment to find out. It wasn’t out of lust, I’m always just terribly curious about weird things. Was this a sin? Or, more importantly, a Mortal Sin? I need to know so I may know whether or not I should receive the Eucharist.
 
Last night I was watching That '70s Show, and for some reason I thought, “Is Jackie flat-chested?” so I looked for a brief moment to find out. It wasn’t out of lust, I’m always just terribly curious about weird things. Was this a sin? Or, more importantly, a Mortal Sin? I need to know so I may know whether or not I should receive the Eucharist.
See the Ten Commandments. 🙂

bluelake
 
Why do all the “Is this a sin” threads leave me rolling on the floor?

OP, I don’t think it is a sin to notice whether someone is flat chested or not. We as humans notice things like that. Now if you start thinking, “I wonder if I could…” then you are lusting. :tsktsk:
 
Last night I was watching That '70s Show, and for some reason I thought, “Is Jackie flat-chested?” so I looked for a brief moment to find out. It wasn’t out of lust, I’m always just terribly curious about weird things. Was this a sin? Or, more importantly, a Mortal Sin? I need to know so I may know whether or not I should receive the Eucharist.
Code:
I beleive that ,for it to be a sin, the preson  watching the
show,and looking at Jackie flat chest, must keep looking at it,and have lust in their mines,
for it to became a sin. I usally turn away, when they show to much,so that my mine does
get Imoral thought,which leads to a lustful mine.
:gopray:
 
The three conditions for a sin to be mortal are: Grave matter, full consent, full knowledge that the matter is serious.

Check out the Catechism of the Catholic Church 1858, 1859 - available online.

YouCat questions 315 and 316.
 
The three conditions for a sin to be mortal are: Grave matter, full consent, full knowledge that the matter is serious.

Check out the Catechism of the Catholic Church 1858, 1859 - available online.

YouCat questions 315 and 316.
It wasn’t out of lust, really. At the time Jackie was in a sweater and covered up all the way to her neck, so you definitely couldn’t see anything. I was just curious. I know that these sorts of curious thoughts should be ignored, but it was late at night and I really wasn’t thinking. If you think I should I’ll confess it this week in confession, simply stating it as “Looking at women lustfully”, but I really don’t think lust had anything to do with it. I’m just terribly scrupulous and I’m always worried about it.
 
The specific events you describe don’t sound like anything sinful is going on.

However, I’m curious why you are watching “That 70’s show”, especially as you describe yourself as a highly scrupulous person. Scrupulous or not, that program celebrates adultery, fornication, and drug use among other things. So, while the particular circumstances you describe may not be sinful, I most certainly can see occassions of sin, and thus possible falling into sin coming from watching that show.

Pax and God bless.
 
The specific events you describe don’t sound like anything sinful is going on.

However, I’m curious why you are watching “That 70’s show”, especially as you describe yourself as a highly scrupulous person. Scrupulous or not, that program celebrates adultery, fornication, and drug use among other things. So, while the particular circumstances you describe may not be sinful, I most certainly can see occassions of sin, and thus possible falling into sin coming from watching that show.

Pax and God bless.
It doesn’t “celebrate” these things, nor does it endorse these things. If anything, it makes a lot of jokes about idiots who indulge themselves in drug abuse and such. I’ve never once had a near-occasion of sin when watching the show. In fact, when compared to the stuff shown on MTV, That '70s Show seems almost worthy of being on EWTN. It doesn’t, of course, but the show is actually quite mild when compared to many other shows. I would still cry tears of disappointment if it was shown on EWTN though. 😃
 
Last night I was watching That '70s Show, and for some reason I thought, “Is Jackie flat-chested?” so I looked for a brief moment to find out. It wasn’t out of lust, I’m always just terribly curious about weird things. Was this a sin? Or, more importantly, a Mortal Sin? I need to know so I may know whether or not I should receive the Eucharist.

I do not think it was a mortal sin or even a venial sin–you were just curious and nothen happened, so let it be.

JESUS I TRUST IN YOU

jr
 
The three conditions for a sin to be mortal are: Grave matter, full consent, full knowledge that the matter is serious.
So you’re saying that if I commit a sin that I know is a sin but committed anyway, and then later found out it was Mortal, it’s not a Mortal sin?
 
So you’re saying that if I commit a sin that I know is a sin but committed anyway, and then later found out it was Mortal, it’s not a Mortal sin?
That doesn’t make sense. If you later found out it was Mortal, the obviously it is Mortal…
 
That doesn’t make sense. If you later found out it was Mortal, the obviously it is Mortal…
Well, I meant that if I committed a sin that I knew was a sin, but then later found out it was a Grave sin, did it still count as a Grave sin?
 
Well, I meant that if I committed a sin that I knew was a sin, but then later found out it was a Grave sin, did it still count as a Grave sin?
My prayer for you is that you can be a happy young person who can have fun and laugh at an old sitcom and not be worried constantly about sinning every second of the day. Have you talked with any of your buddies about feeling guilty all of the time? Sometimes a good friend or school chum your same age can talk you through the hard times. :rolleyes:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top