Watchfulness when recieving Holy Communion

  • Thread starter Thread starter Arturo_Ortiz
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
A

Arturo_Ortiz

Guest
I thought I should post this as a reminder

Lately I have been studying books dealing with the Eucharist and the Mass in general. I have also been studying about the Eucharist itself.

Something that just came to me that it has not done so much in the past is the fact that many times we don’t examine our conscience before receiving Holy Communion. There are many quotes from saints and Scripture passages that describe this very thing. Some of the most profound ones include

From Saint Thomas Aquinas on being a false person

" We are false when the inmost self does not correspond to what is expressed externally. The sacrament of the Eucharist is an external sign that Christ is incorporated into the one who receives him and he into Christ. One is false if in his heart he does not desire this union and does not even try to remove every obstacle to it. Christ therefore does not remain in him, neither does he in Christ.

" As Christ’s Passion does not produce its effect on those who do not hold him as they should, so also those do not attain heaven through this sacrament who receive him unworthily". Accordingly Augustine writes, " The sacrament is one thing, its virtue another. Many receive from the altar and, receiving it, are dead. Eat therefore heavenly bread, carry innocence to the altar." S it is not surprising that those who do not keep a pure heart fail to gain the effect of the sacrament.

(1Corinthians 11:27-29)

Whoever eats the bread or drinks the cup of the Lord unworthily will have to answer for the body and blood of the Lord. A person should examine himself, and so eat the bread and drink the cup. For anyone who eats and drinks without discerning the body, eats and drinks judgement on himself.

St. John Chrysostom

I beseech, beg, and implore that no one draw near to this sacred table with a sullied and corrupt conscience. Such an act, in fact, can never be called “communion” not even were we to touch the Lord’s body a thousand times over, but “condemnation” torment", and increase of punishment"

This does not mean we should be scared about receiving Holy Communion, but we should be cautious about our state of grace. Just today at Sunday Mass I felt tempted sexually with a lot of intrusive thoughts, but I still ended up taking the Eucharist. I did so because I honestly felt that I did not want these thoughts. The point though is simply that we should be prepared.

The above people for that matter are reminded us that when we ought to receive the Eucharist we need to evaluate whether we have commited mortal sin, or if we really believe in the True Presence.
 
I thought I should post this as a reminder

Lately I have been studying books dealing with the Eucharist and the Mass in general. I have also been studying about the Eucharist itself.

Something that just came to me that it has not done so much in the past is the fact that many times we don’t examine our conscience before receiving Holy Communion. There are many quotes from saints and Scripture passages that describe this very thing. Some of the most profound ones include

From Saint Thomas Aquinas on being a false person

" We are false when the inmost self does not correspond to what is expressed externally. The sacrament of the Eucharist is an external sign that Christ is incorporated into the one who receives him and he into Christ. One is false if in his heart he does not desire this union and does not even try to remove every obstacle to it. Christ therefore does not remain in him, neither does he in Christ.

" As Christ’s Passion does not produce its effect on those who do not hold him as they should, so also those do not attain heaven through this sacrament who receive him unworthily". Accordingly Augustine writes, " The sacrament is one thing, its virtue another. Many receive from the altar and, receiving it, are dead. Eat therefore heavenly bread, carry innocence to the altar." S it is not surprising that those who do not keep a pure heart fail to gain the effect of the sacrament.

(1Corinthians 11:27-29)

Whoever eats the bread or drinks the cup of the Lord unworthily will have to answer for the body and blood of the Lord. A person should examine himself, and so eat the bread and drink the cup. For anyone who eats and drinks without discerning the body, eats and drinks judgement on himself.

St. John Chrysostom

I beseech, beg, and implore that no one draw near to this sacred table with a sullied and corrupt conscience. Such an act, in fact, can never be called “communion” not even were we to touch the Lord’s body a thousand times over, but “condemnation” torment", and increase of punishment"

This does not mean we should be scared about receiving Holy Communion, but we should be cautious about our state of grace. Just today I Sunday Mass I felt tempted sexually with a lot of intrusive thoughts, but I still ended up taking the Eucharist. I did so because I honestly felt that I did not want these thoughts. The point though is simply that we should be prepared.
Its not simply a case of being in a state of grace to be able to receive. You have to be properly disposed to receive even though you are in a state of grace.
 
I thought you meant another kind of watchfulness… but, yes.

Father told me recently that it makes him sad to see so many people who receive in a matter-of-fact way. To put his words (he’s not a native English speaker) into American slang, receiving as if it’s no big deal.

It makes me sad to see the difference in length between the lines to receive, and the lines waiting for Confession. And it makes me wonder if some of them think the Eucharist is “just a symbol,” not the real Body and Blood, Soul and Divinity of Jesus!

Let’s all pray for them… :crossrc:
 
Watch the Greatest Miracle for the best idea of what really goes on in mass.
 
I agree with you Ruthie. I was hoping that because Pope Benedict XI would only give Communion to recipients on their knees, this practice would be universally returned to the Church. I think we went wrong when we started to receive Communion standing and in the hand. I also feel that bowing before Communion isn’t quite sufficient (I’ve started genuflecting.)

I also agree with the OP. We need to hear more homilies regarding the sacred nature of our Communion with Jesus and how to prepare ourselves. .
 
Let the The Holy Spirit move us, to kneel and never touch~

but receive Eucharist in mouth…by simply doing it:)

I returned to Catholic Church in Jan. The priest told me things were different than before

( when I attended, which was a Latin Mass) He instructed me on how to receive in my hand.

So the first time, I received in my hand. and maybe couple more times… Then, I returned

to how I knew and began receiving on my tongue. People see this and they start doing

it too. I saw a man kneel to receive….now I think I will also do this.

If we all keep kneeling, they will bring the altar rail back! :signofcross:
 
Let the The Holy Spirit move us, to kneel and never touch~

but receive Eucharist in mouth…by simply doing it:)
How about

Let the The Holy Spirit move us to receive only when in a state of grace and let us receive in a manner approved by the Church. Let us trust Her wisdom.
 
Well only God can judge a person, but these things are good to keep in mind - but dont let the obstacles become so big, that the Eucharist becomes a source of stress instead of Love. When i was at mass on Sunday & i saw the many lines of people walking up to receive Our Lord, i couldnt help but feel extremely grateful that they were all here to receive Him, & how extremely happy it would make Our Lord that they had all come in their various capacities to see & receive Him.
 
We should avoid either extreme of presumption or scrupulosity. Unfortunately, the people most likely to read the above quotes with attentiveness are the scrupulous, who need rather to be told that apart from knowledge of mortal sin, they should receive. Others, who make no preparation at all, would do well to reflect on admonitions to receive worthily.
 
I think we went wrong when we started to receive Communion standing and in the hand.
Well, I have never known any other way, since I was confirmed in 2006. I did choose to receive on my tongue, though. So far, no minister has objected.

My husband receives kneeling. But he is fit enough so that it takes no longer than anyone else. For anyone lining up behind me, it would be rude of me to kneel. I’m obese. 😊 It would take a long time for me to get onto my knees, and then I could not rise again without help. (I don’t even kneel in the “pews” when they aren’t pews but chairs with kneelers. It would be disruptive when, in pulling myself up, I make the chair go over backwards. ;))

I do wish they’d bring back altar rails - but only if they’re sturdy!

Back on topic: I agree with Joy2day and Ad Orientam. Also, don’t worry about the other people. Concentrate on just Who you are receiving under the roof of your mouth - it’s the most joyful thing in this world!
 
In the beginning of Mass, we have the “I confess to…” which is to remind us of our sins and to ask God’s pardon and our neighbor’s prayers for us. This is preparation. The bible readings are also thoughts to prepare our hearts. Holy Communion actually removes venial sins if we are adequately alive in our love for Jesus.

From my knowledge it seems to me that our depth of belief in the real presence is a big item to the beneficial reception of Communion. Faith is the foundation to love.

Just a thought.​

“Pardon for the sinner, a shepherd for the sheep, a drink of living water for all who thirst and seek, and feasting at your table, the lowly and the least.” (hymn)
 
Well, I have never known any other way, since I was confirmed in 2006. I did choose to receive on my tongue, though. So far, no minister has objected.

My husband receives kneeling. But he is fit enough so that it takes no longer than anyone else. For anyone lining up behind me, it would be rude of me to kneel. I’m obese. 😊 It would take a long time for me to get onto my knees, and then I could not rise again without help. (I don’t even kneel in the “pews” when they aren’t pews but chairs with kneelers. It would be disruptive when, in pulling myself up, I make the chair go over backwards. ;))

I do wish they’d bring back altar rails - but only if they’re sturdy!

Back on topic: I agree with Joy2day and Ad Orientam. Also, don’t worry about the other people. Concentrate on just Who you are receiving under the roof of your mouth - it’s the most joyful thing in this world!
I always say this: If you can kneel you should, if you can’t then you should at least receive in the mouth.

God Bless
Arturo
 
Why is it that when a person has such deep faith in the Most Blessed Sacrament that they decide receiving on the tongue while kneeling is best and state such, they are looked upon as scrupulous, “holier than thou”, or judgemental of those who receive in the hand ? Every thread where this topic comes up, this will happen.

Receiving on the tongue while kneeling is the universal norm in the Church. Receiving in the hand is allowed via indult.

So why should the one who states he/she prefers COTT be subject to correction or finger pointing ? Sure, if I were to state I prefer COTT and proceed to acuse those who receive CITH as irreverent or lacking in the faith somehow, then I would certainly expect such comments about my attitude. But so many times, members are subject to that which they don’t desreve.

Anyhow, good thread. on another recent thread a member noted she didn’t receive at every mass she attended and someone jumped on her as if she were doing something wrong. Hopefully, that person will see this thread.
 
Why is it that when a person has such deep faith in the Most Blessed Sacrament that they decide receiving on the tongue while kneeling is best and state such, they are looked upon as scrupulous, “holier than thou”, or judgemental of those who receive in the hand ? Every thread where this topic comes up, this will happen.

Receiving on the tongue while kneeling is the universal norm in the Church. Receiving in the hand is allowed via indult.

So why should the one who states he/she prefers COTT be subject to correction or finger pointing ? Sure, if I were to state I prefer COTT and proceed to acuse those who receive CITH as irreverent or lacking in the faith somehow, then I would certainly expect such comments about my attitude. But so many times, members are subject to that which they don’t desreve.

Anyhow, good thread. on another recent thread a member noted she didn’t receive at every mass she attended and someone jumped on her as if she were doing something wrong. Hopefully, that person will see this thread.
I have not heard anyone criticize, in this forum, those who kneel or receive on the tongue (I receive on the tongue). I think the problem arises when we “should” each other. Yes, kneeling and on the tongue is the norm, but in procession and in the hand is permitted (by indult, as you say, but a very, very wide indult).

It “should” be sufficient that people avail themselves of a liberty given them by the Church (either way) and the only other “should” ought to be that they not receive as they should NOT: in a state of mortal sin, not properly disposed, etc.
 
Why is it that when a person has such deep faith in the Most Blessed Sacrament that they decide receiving on the tongue while kneeling is best and state such, they are looked upon as scrupulous, “holier than thou”, or judgemental of those who receive in the hand ? Every thread where this topic comes up, this will happen.
They aren’t looked upon as judgemental for receiving on the tongue. They’re looked upon as judgemental if they start telling everyone that receiving in the hand is wrong.
 
Well, I won’t say ROTT is best, just that it is right for me. (I have enough sins of pride to confess, without that.) I don’t see anyone react to my DH kneeling, either; by then I am totally focused on the Eucharist. Early on, though, I did see a few parishioners make big eyes* at him, but they relaxed as soon as they realized he wasn’t slowing down the line.

The only time I got big eyes for ROTT was when we were out of town, and went to Mass. The church had a “risen cross” instead of the big Crucifix; the Tabernacle was in its own little chapel, off to one side; and everybody held hands during the Our Father. So I wasn’t surprised at the minister’s shock.

*That’s an idiom for the eyes widening, because the person is shocked. Like this: :eek:
 
They aren’t looked upon as judgemental for receiving on the tongue. They’re looked upon as judgemental if they start telling everyone that receiving in the hand is wrong.
Well, your second sentence just repeated/agreed with what I said. (the part of my post you left out for whatever reason)

As far as the first sentence, I have to disagree. I’ve seen it a lot over the last few years, There was a subtle swipe directed at LoveMercyGrace in this thread. That’s why I posted what I did.
 
Well, your second sentence just repeated/agreed with what I said. (the part of my post you left out for whatever reason)

As far as the first sentence, I have to disagree. I’ve seen it a lot over the last few years, There was a subtle swipe directed at LoveMercyGrace in this thread. That’s why I posted what I did.
Since I am the only one that quoted LoveMercyGrace, maybe you could quote my subtle swipe? 👍

Because I have no idea what you are talking about. 🤷
 
(the part of my post you left out for whatever reason)
Reason: I often only quote the statement (or part of a statement) to which I’m directly responding. See, I just did it again.

It’s a very common practice on this forum, and elsewhere on the internet, and generally doesn’t require comment.
 
Before I receive my Lord in Holy Communion I make sure that if I,ve sinned that I go to confession,so that I,am in the state of Grace,because I know in my heart when I feel it,s not OK to go and recceive Jesus,than after I go to confession,my heart now tells me now I can go up to receive Jesus,I also talk to Jesus when I go up to receive Jesus,and when I return to my pew,I say to Jesus, Thank you,for allowing me to receive you again in my body,the temple were you dwell. Amen
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top