"We Believe Scripture, Except When It Supports Catholic Dogma"

  • Thread starter Thread starter Teflon93
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
If that were so, I would not be here. I am seeking information and being honest about what I have had or do have an issue.

The verse I quoted is one of the ones that pointed me towards the Catholic faith since I do not see anywhere that it is to be understood metaphorically.
Greetings all,

On vacation but the hotel had online service so thought I’d read up here a bit.

Hi Ellan,

Actually if you take a literal interpreation of John chapter 6 it makes absolutely no sense whatsoever when taken in its context. We can expound more on this but put very simply … if Jesus is the bread of life in a physical way as he spoke to his hearers in Jn 6, then is he not also a plant because in John chapter 15 he says with equal force “I am the true vine” or a beam of light “I am the light of the world”?

Also when we turn to the very source that Rome claims is the “constant faith of the church” we find one of the most prominent doctors of the early chruch defining exactly how the text at hand is to be tranlsated. He states in unambiguous terms…
St. Augustine: on Christian Doctrine Chapter 16
Rule for Interpreting Commands and Prohibitions.
24. If the sentence is one of command, either forbidding a crime or vice, or enjoining an act of prudence or benevolence, it is not figurative. If, however, it seems to enjoin a crime or vice, or to forbid an act of prudence or benevolence, it is figurative. “Except ye eat the flesh of the Son of man,” says Christ, “and drink His blood, ye have no life in you.” 35 This seems to enjoin a crime or a vice; it is therefore a figure…
In John chapter 6 Jesus’ own interpreation of his own words are simple and explained in verses 61-65. What does the literal flesh profit according to the context? Where would the literal flesh of the Son of man be according to verse 62?

Consider these words from Augustine in Homilies on the Gospels

Sermon LXXXI.

On the words of the gospel, John 6:53, “Except ye eat the flesh,” etc., And on the words of the apostles. And the psalms. Against the Pelagians.
Delivered at the Table of the Martyr St. Cyprian, the 9th of the Calends of October, -23 Sept., on the Lord’s day.
  1. We have heard the True Master, the Divine Redeemer, the human Saviour, commending to us our Ransom, His Blood. For He spake to us of His Body and Blood; He called His Body Meat, His Blood Drink. The faithful recognise the Sacrament of the faithful. But the hearers what else do they but hear? When therefore commending such Meat and such Drink He said, "Except ye shall eat My Flesh and drink My Blood, ye shall have no life in you; " 1 (and this that He said concerning life, who else said it but the Life Itself? But that man shall have death, not life, who shall think that the Life is false), His disciples were offended, not all of them indeed, but very many, saying within themselves, "This is an hard saying, who can hear it? " 2 But when the Lord knew this in Himself, and heard the murmurings of their thought, He answered them, thinking though uttering nothing, that they might understand that they were heard, and might cease to entertain such thoughts. What then did He answer? “Doth this offend you?”“What then if ye shall see the Son of Man ascend up where He was before?” 3 What meaneth this? “Doth this offend you?” “Do ye imaginethat I am about to make divisions of this My Body which ye see; and to cut up My Members, and give them to you? ‘What then if ye shall see the Son of Man ascend up where He was before?’” Assuredly, He who could ascend Whole could not be consumed.
Peace in Christ,
theLogos
 
Greetings all,

On vacation but the hotel had online service so thought I’d read up here a bit.

Hi Ellan,

Actually if you take a literal interpreation of John chapter 6 it makes absolutely no sense whatsoever when taken in its context. We can expound more on this but put very simply … if Jesus is the bread of life in a physical way as he spoke to his hearers in Jn 6, then is he not also a plant because in John chapter 15 he says with equal force “I am the true vine” or a beam of light “I am the light of the world”?

Also when we turn to the very source that Rome claims is the “constant faith of the church” we find one of the most prominent doctors of the early chruch defining exactly how the text at hand is to be tranlsated. He states in unambiguous terms…

In John chapter 6 Jesus’ own interpreation of his own words are simple and explained in verses 61-65. What does the literal flesh profit according to the context? Where would the literal flesh of the Son of man be according to verse 62?

Consider these words from Augustine in Homilies on the Gospels

Sermon LXXXI.

On the words of the gospel, John 6:53, “Except ye eat the flesh,” etc., And on the words of the apostles. And the psalms. Against the Pelagians.
Delivered at the Table of the Martyr St. Cyprian, the 9th of the Calends of October, -23 Sept., on the Lord’s day.
  1. We have heard the True Master, the Divine Redeemer, the human Saviour, commending to us our Ransom, His Blood. For He spake to us of His Body and Blood; He called His Body Meat, His Blood Drink. The faithful recognise the Sacrament of the faithful. But the hearers what else do they but hear? When therefore commending such Meat and such Drink He said, "Except ye shall eat My Flesh and drink My Blood, ye shall have no life in you; " 1 (and this that He said concerning life, who else said it but the Life Itself? But that man shall have death, not life, who shall think that the Life is false), His disciples were offended, not all of them indeed, but very many, saying within themselves, "This is an hard saying, who can hear it? " 2 But when the Lord knew this in Himself, and heard the murmurings of their thought, He answered them, thinking though uttering nothing, that they might understand that they were heard, and might cease to entertain such thoughts. What then did He answer? “Doth this offend you?”“What then if ye shall see the Son of Man ascend up where He was before?” 3 What meaneth this? “Doth this offend you?” “Do ye imaginethat I am about to make divisions of this My Body which ye see; and to cut up My Members, and give them to you? ‘What then if ye shall see the Son of Man ascend up where He was before?’” Assuredly, He who could ascend Whole could not be consumed.
Peace in Christ,
theLogos
theLogos, it seems you have taken a commonly mistaken practice in reading Scripture - snipping out a verse, and ignoring everything else that supports a varying opinion - and applied it to the Early Church Fathers.

It’s ironic that to some people we have to defend the accusation that “Transubstantiation” was invented by St. Augustin, and then turn around and defend that Augustine did not believe in the Presence - Very Real Presence - in the Eucharist.

Here are three snippets I was able to find immediately on Augustin from the Catholic Answers web-site that should show that Augustin truly believed in the Eucharist;
“Christ was carried in his own hands when, referring to his own body, he said, ‘This is my body’ [Matt. 26:26]. For he carried that body in his hands” (*Explanations of the Psalms *33:1:10 [A.D. 405]).
“I promised you [new Christians], who have now been baptized, a sermon in which I would explain the sacrament of the Lord’s Table. . . . That bread which you see on the altar, having been sanctified by the word of God, is the body of Christ. That chalice, or rather, what is in that chalice, having been sanctified by the word of God, is the blood of Christ” (*Sermons *227 [A.D. 411]).
“What you see is the bread and the chalice; that is what your own eyes report to you. But what your faith obliges you to accept is that the bread is the body of Christ and the chalice is the blood of Christ. This has been said very briefly, which may perhaps be sufficient for faith; yet faith does not desire instruction” (ibid., 272).
 
Actually if you take a literal interpreation of John chapter 6 it makes absolutely **no sense **whatsoever when taken in its context.
That is exactly the point that Jesus was trying to make when He said “the flesh is of no avail”. He was introducing a divine mystery that cannot be understood with the carnal mind. It is a spiritual truth that must be understood spiritually.
We can expound more on this but put very simply … if Jesus is the bread of life in a physical way as he spoke to his hearers in Jn 6, then is he not also a plant because in John chapter 15 he says with equal force “I am the true vine” or a beam of light “I am the light of the world”?
Yes. I think such things cannot be apprehended with the carnal mind. If one is bound my the senses, and cannot apprehend by the Spirit, the meaning will be lost. That which is Spirit is Spirit.
Also when we turn to the very source that Rome claims is the “constant faith of the church” we find one of the most prominent doctors of the early chruch defining exactly how the text at hand is to be tranlsated. He states in unambiguous terms…[/qupte]

Yes, there are many levels of meaning to be found in Eucharist. However, this rendering does not undo the other testimonies by the same authors of the Real Presence. Those are the ones you have to explain away, if you can!
theLogos;3903526:
In John chapter 6 Jesus’ own interpreation of his own words are simple and explained in verses 61-65. What does the literal flesh profit according to the context? Where would the literal flesh of the Son of man be according to verse 62?
Are you suggesting that Jesus did not give his literal flesh and blood, but only a “symbolic” body was crucified? I have read from another poster that it was not actually Jesus that died on the cross, and that after Jesus survived the crucifixion, he went into India…

What do you believe?
Consider these words from Augustine in Homilies on the Gospels

Sermon LXXXI.

On the words of the gospel, John 6:53, “Except ye eat the flesh,” etc., And on the words of the apostles. And the psalms. Against the Pelagians.
Delivered at the Table of the Martyr St. Cyprian, the 9th of the Calends of October, -23 Sept., on the Lord’s day.
  1. We have heard the True Master, the Divine Redeemer, the human Saviour, commending to us our Ransom, His Blood. For He spake to us of His Body and Blood; He called His Body Meat, His Blood Drink. The faithful recognise the Sacrament of the faithful. But the hearers what else do they but hear? When therefore commending such Meat and such Drink He said, "Except ye shall eat My Flesh and drink My Blood, ye shall have no life in you; " 1 (and this that He said concerning life, who else said it but the Life Itself? But that man shall have death, not life, who shall think that the Life is false), His disciples were offended, not all of them indeed, but very many, saying within themselves, "This is an hard saying, who can hear it? " 2 But when the Lord knew this in Himself, and heard the murmurings of their thought, He answered them, thinking though uttering nothing, that they might understand that they were heard, and might cease to entertain such thoughts. What then did He answer? “Doth this offend you?”“What then if ye shall see the Son of Man ascend up where He was before?” 3 What meaneth this? “Doth this offend you?” “Do ye imaginethat I am about to make divisions of this My Body which ye see; and to cut up My Members, and give them to you? ‘What then if ye shall see the Son of Man ascend up where He was before?’” Assuredly, He who could ascend Whole could not be consumed.
Peace in Christ,
theLogos
He says right there that the faithful recognize the Sacrament (Real Presence). I marvel that you can quote this, and not recognize what it says, but I should not, seeing as you can also quote Jn. 6. I have a question. What would happen if you were to (just hypothetically speaking) accept the Catholic understanding of these passages?
 
Nay, verily, I didft reade it wythout paufe nor cumberance. Whence learned ye to wryte in the kingf goode englifht?
Funny, when Mr. Sola Scriptura was in here talking, I don’t remember any of his scripture postings in the original KJV 1611 translation…Uh-oh that means it wasnt the REAL translation! He got one of those MODERN translations that changed the words…tsk tsk!!
 
Heavens, yes! They ain’t just for ol’ folk, you know. 😉 I highly recommend the Sunsweet Cherry Essence, Lemon Essence and Orange Essence pitted prunes. Now go get yourself a bag! 😃
I think I’ll pass…I’m more than regular lol
 
I think I’ll pass…I’m more than regular lol
But gads, the antioxidant and potassium punch they give you! Just eat, like, three or four at a time if yer already reg’lar. . .

(geeze, talk about topic digression. . . )😛
 
But gads, the antioxidant and potassium punch they give you! Just eat, like, three or four at a time if yer already reg’lar. . .

(geeze, talk about topic digression. . . )😛
I know…we go from a sola scriptura debate to prunes…Somehow both topics seem to lead to the same place however LOL
 
Since this thread is on scriptures and everything, which Bibles does everybody use? Back when I was a Protestant, I mostly used the KJV and the NIV (or the Non-Inspired Version as my preacher used to joke and say lol). I also have the Amplified Bible somewhere…When it comes to complete Bibles with all 73 books in them, the only one I have so far is the NAB from my RCIA class last year but I have major issues with it. Thinking about getting a Douay-Rheims Bible or the RSV…They both seem a lot better than the NAB in my opinion…what about everybody else?
 
Hi i am very drawn to the catholic faith and am still reading up on things i use the catholic answer bible at the moment. I do have a st josephs nab version what issues do you have with it. I have heard that the rsv is a very good translation i may get one myself.
 
Since this thread is on scriptures and everything, which Bibles does everybody use? Back when I was a Protestant, I mostly used the KJV and the NIV (or the Non-Inspired Version as my preacher used to joke and say lol). I also have the Amplified Bible
somewhere…When it comes to complete Bibles with all 73 books in them, the only one I have so far is the NAB from my RCIA class last year but I have major issues with it. Thinking about getting a Douay-Rheims Bible or the RSV…They both seem a lot better than the NAB in my opinion…what about everybody else?I also have that Amplified Bible and it’s miserable for general reading, but actually a fairly handy study version. By no means toss that one, though it lacks the Deuterocanonicals.

I have both the DRB and The new RSV-CE 2nd Edition and love them both. Douay-Rheims can be a little odd sometimes, even as its contemporary KJV is, but I still like it better.

I also have a couple of NABs and they remind me of the NIV with all the books sometimes. It’s okay, but not my favorite.
Hi i am very drawn to the Catholic faith and am still reading up on things i use the catholic answer bible at the moment. I do have a st josephs nab version what issues do you have with it. I have heard that the rsv is a very good translation i may get one myself.
It’s not so much the translation itself as some of the notes which are not as orthodox as they should be. In some cases they actually contradict the teaching of the church, and that ain’t good.

As I said, the RSV-CE 2nd Edition is a good one as is the Douay-Rheims Bible if you want something with that era English, but with a very Catholic flavor. The notes are very orthodox.
Pax Domini sit semper vobiscum.
 
Nay, verily, I didft reade it wythout paufe nor cumberance. Whence learned ye to wryte in the kingf goode englifht?
I tarried ten and two yearf a ‘1611 KJV’ Baptift Churcheth. 😉

(Which was actually the 1885 KJV but you can’t tell *them *that.)
 
John chapter 6
King James Version
56 He that eateth my flesh, and drinketh my blood, dwelleth in me, and I in him.
57 As the living Father hath sent me, and I live by the Father: so he that eateth me, even he shall live by me.

57 As… I live by the Father:** so **he that eateth me…shall live by me.

Hosea chapter 12
10 I have also spoken by the prophets, and I have multiplied visions, and used similitudes, by the ministry of the prophets.

Prov 11:22 as

Prov 17:14 as

Job 10-21-22 as x 2

Job 11:22 like

Mt 13:24 is likened

Mt 13:31 is like

Mt 13:44 **is like
**
Mk 13:34 is as

Lk 17:26-28 as x 2

John 3:14 as

Heb 1:11-12 as

John 6:63 “…the flesh profiteth nothing”

John 6:56 “…dwelleth in me, and I in him”

Col 1:27 “…Christ in you”

1Cor 6:19 “…Holy Ghost which is in you”

John 3:6 “…Spirit is spirit”

John 4:24 “God is a Spirit”

Rom 14:17

17 For the kingdom of God is not meat and drink; but righteousness, and peace, and joy in ***the Holy Ghost.

John chapter 6
63 It is the spirit that quickeneth; the flesh profiteth nothing: the words that I speak unto you, they are spirit, and they are life.

Ephesians chapter 4
4 There is one body, and one Spirit, even as ye are called in one hope of your calling;

Colossians chapter 1
24 Who now rejoice in my sufferings for you, and fill up that which is behind of the afflictions of Christ in my flesh for ***his ***body’s sake, which is the church:

1 Corinthians chapter 12
12 For as the body is one, and hath many members, and all the members of that one body, being many, are one body: so also ***is Christ.

 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top