Z
Zynxensar
Guest
Does the rule “If you’re not sure whether something is mortal and you commit it anyway, you commit mortal sin” apply to scrupulous people? The rule is in parentheses below.
(’'Let us now proceed. We have spoken of the examination regarding mortal and venial sins. But were a person to do an action with a doubt whether it was a mortal or a venial sin, what kind of sin would he commit?
He would be guilty of mortal sin, because he exposes himself to the danger of grievously offending God. Hence, before he acts he must lay aside the doubt; and if he has not hitherto done so, he must confess it, at least, as it is before God. But the scrupulous, who have doubts about everything, must follow another rule: they must obey their confessor. When he tells them to conquer their doubts, and to act against scruples, they should obey with exactness; otherwise they will render themselves unable and unfit to perform any spiritual exercise.’’
St. Alphonsus Maria de Liguori)
To normal people, yes, this is in most cases a mortal sin because even if the external act committed isn’t a grave matter, the grave matter that was committed was the willingness to offend God mortally, by risking it I.e “I don’t know whether it’s mortal or not but I don’t care I’m still going to do it anyway”
Well, does such a rule apply to potentially scrupulous people or is it somewhat different? If scrupulous people think they’re sinning mortally by doing normal everyday actions that others don’t even find sinful, then aren’t scrupulous people guilty of a large amount of offenses against God because they chose to do the action anyway?
This doesn’t make sense to me. Scrupulous people desire to please God and avoid sin above all else; otherwise scrupulosity won’t have an effect on them in the first place! But if they have such absurd thoughts prompting them to do bizarre actions, I don’t believe we have to adhere to them, even if we do not have complete certitude because one thing I do know is that it isn’t something NORMAL (does this count as enough certitude?)
Then again, another part of me is saying I better do it “just to be safe” because “maybe the Church hasn’t figured it out yet” and “I technically still am not completely certain whether the action is sinful. Yeah I mean no one else does it but acting on a doubtful conscience is a sin”
(’'Let us now proceed. We have spoken of the examination regarding mortal and venial sins. But were a person to do an action with a doubt whether it was a mortal or a venial sin, what kind of sin would he commit?
He would be guilty of mortal sin, because he exposes himself to the danger of grievously offending God. Hence, before he acts he must lay aside the doubt; and if he has not hitherto done so, he must confess it, at least, as it is before God. But the scrupulous, who have doubts about everything, must follow another rule: they must obey their confessor. When he tells them to conquer their doubts, and to act against scruples, they should obey with exactness; otherwise they will render themselves unable and unfit to perform any spiritual exercise.’’
St. Alphonsus Maria de Liguori)
To normal people, yes, this is in most cases a mortal sin because even if the external act committed isn’t a grave matter, the grave matter that was committed was the willingness to offend God mortally, by risking it I.e “I don’t know whether it’s mortal or not but I don’t care I’m still going to do it anyway”
Well, does such a rule apply to potentially scrupulous people or is it somewhat different? If scrupulous people think they’re sinning mortally by doing normal everyday actions that others don’t even find sinful, then aren’t scrupulous people guilty of a large amount of offenses against God because they chose to do the action anyway?
This doesn’t make sense to me. Scrupulous people desire to please God and avoid sin above all else; otherwise scrupulosity won’t have an effect on them in the first place! But if they have such absurd thoughts prompting them to do bizarre actions, I don’t believe we have to adhere to them, even if we do not have complete certitude because one thing I do know is that it isn’t something NORMAL (does this count as enough certitude?)
Then again, another part of me is saying I better do it “just to be safe” because “maybe the Church hasn’t figured it out yet” and “I technically still am not completely certain whether the action is sinful. Yeah I mean no one else does it but acting on a doubtful conscience is a sin”
Last edited: