We sin when we think the action we're doing is sin?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Zynxensar
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Z

Zynxensar

Guest
Does the rule “If you’re not sure whether something is mortal and you commit it anyway, you commit mortal sin” apply to scrupulous people? The rule is in parentheses below.

(’'Let us now proceed. We have spoken of the examination regarding mortal and venial sins. But were a person to do an action with a doubt whether it was a mortal or a venial sin, what kind of sin would he commit?

He would be guilty of mortal sin, because he exposes himself to the danger of grievously offending God. Hence, before he acts he must lay aside the doubt; and if he has not hitherto done so, he must confess it, at least, as it is before God. But the scrupulous, who have doubts about everything, must follow another rule: they must obey their confessor. When he tells them to conquer their doubts, and to act against scruples, they should obey with exactness; otherwise they will render themselves unable and unfit to perform any spiritual exercise.’’

St. Alphonsus Maria de Liguori)

To normal people, yes, this is in most cases a mortal sin because even if the external act committed isn’t a grave matter, the grave matter that was committed was the willingness to offend God mortally, by risking it I.e “I don’t know whether it’s mortal or not but I don’t care I’m still going to do it anyway”

Well, does such a rule apply to potentially scrupulous people or is it somewhat different? If scrupulous people think they’re sinning mortally by doing normal everyday actions that others don’t even find sinful, then aren’t scrupulous people guilty of a large amount of offenses against God because they chose to do the action anyway?

This doesn’t make sense to me. Scrupulous people desire to please God and avoid sin above all else; otherwise scrupulosity won’t have an effect on them in the first place! But if they have such absurd thoughts prompting them to do bizarre actions, I don’t believe we have to adhere to them, even if we do not have complete certitude because one thing I do know is that it isn’t something NORMAL (does this count as enough certitude?)

Then again, another part of me is saying I better do it “just to be safe” because “maybe the Church hasn’t figured it out yet” and “I technically still am not completely certain whether the action is sinful. Yeah I mean no one else does it but acting on a doubtful conscience is a sin”
 
Last edited:
That is precisely why the scrupulous person should follow the advice of a confessor.

But a person having a scrupulous thought that “X might be a sin!” I don’t think will necessarily mean he has sinned when he commits the action. When scruples are recognized it is not possible to overcome them by giving in to the doubt. I can’t say I’m qualified to advise on specific matters or even give general principles here, the best thing to do is to ask your confessor and follow what he says.
 
Last edited:
Is there anything I can do until I meet my Confessor? Because what I’m doing now is mostly the “safe route” which is giving into these doubts.

I considered the Ten Commandments for the Scrupulous. The 9th commandment for the Scrupulous states that if we’re uncertain whether the act of commission or omission is a sin we should regard it as not sinful and proceed anyway. But then Fr Santa later says that those 10 Commandments for the Scrupulous are intended specifically for the Sacrament of Reconciliation so I don’t know if he’s saying:

1/ If you’re not sure whether something is a sin, just do it anyway and don’t fear whether it is sinful because you’re Scrupulous

Or

2/ If, during Confession, you’re not sure whether something is a sin, just assume it isn’t and you don’t need to CONFESS it
 
Last edited:
Does the rule “If you’re not sure whether something is mortal and you commit it anyway, you commit mortal sin” apply to scrupulous people ?
I can’t see how this “rule” can be accurate .

If you are not sure whether a sin is mortal and you commit this sin it is not a mortal sin .

For a sin to be mortal it has to be grave matter , and you have to have FULL knowledge of its gravity .

As the Catechism clearly states , “For a sin to be mortal, three conditions must together be met: Mortal sin is sin whose object is grave matter and which is also committed with full knowledge and deliberate consent.”

A link to an article you may find useful https://bishopdowd.net/home/node/30
 
Does the rule
“If you’re not sure
whether something is mortal ( ummm…hmmmm…ummmmm )
and you commit it anyway, ( hey hey here we go, yahoo !!! )
you commit mortal sin”
apply to scrupulous people?
What rule is that ?
It’s not a Saint Benedict rule. That I know.
Is that from your very own personal rule book ?
 
This is from St Alphonsus.

I don’t remember the exact quote but he said if a person is unsure whether a sin is mortal or venial and still commits it anyway, he commits mortal sin because it shows he is willing to offend God mortally.
 
It makes sense, actually.

If I see a silhouette in the forest while I’m hunting, and I’m uncertain whether it is the outline of a deer or a human. I do not have certainty that it is a deer. If I choose to shoot anyway, I commit mortal sin EVEN IF I shoot the deer, because I was willing to take the risk of murdering a human being
 
Well, until you can show me that he didn’t say that, I’m taking that quote that St Alphonsus – as a matter of fact – did say that.
 
As the deer panteth after the water brooks,
So panteth my soul after thee, O God.
2 My soul thirsteth for God, for the living God:
When shall I come and appear before God?
3 My tears have been my food
day and night,
While they continually say unto me,
Where is thy God?
 
Last edited:
Sin can occur in ignorance when one is indifferent to being good. A person that has learned the moral teachings of the Catholic Church is not ignorant. Such sources of moral teachings are the Catechisms.

Catechism
1791 This ignorance can often be imputed to personal responsibility. This is the case when a man "takes little trouble to find out what is true and good …
 
In case # 1, since i’m not part of SA, i imagine doing the “sin” ahead of time, and think will it make me feel guilty? Often not.
 
He is quite clear that the 2013 version revision doesnt apply to just Confession.
 
He does state that Commandments 1 to 4 “focus on the Sacrament of Reconciliation”

But on the next chapter in his book he says those (All 10 of them) are intended specifically for the Sacrament of Reconciliation.

After reading it, it seemed quite clear that some of those Commandments can be used for Everyday life as well, such as #8 I think. A dated version of these Ten Commandments phrased the ninth much clearer so if I were to use that one, I would know that I can act even if I’m doubtful as to whether that action is sinful, because I’m scrupulous.

Now I’m not sure if he “changed” it in his 2013 version or whether I can still interpret it as “if I’m uncertain if an action is sinful I can act anyway, because I’m scrupulous”
 
Last edited:
Stop being scrupulous about things to help with scrupulosity. Fr. Santa would not want you to agonize over this.
 
Perhaps you should find this quote for us since it us your claim that it exists. It just seems a bit off.

Please read Rob2’s post carefully.
 
The gravity of a sin is an objective moral issue. Licit behavior does not become mortally sinful due to misunderstanding it’s nature. Mortal sin and subjective guilt requires a grave sin, and wilful consent to commit that grave sin. The destruction of sanctifying grace cannot occur without both elements.

A classic example can be found in literature. In Huck Finn, Huck believes aiding a black man escape slavery will send him to Hell. Huck wilfully chooses to go to Hell, rather than betray Jim. Of course, aiding the oppressed is objectively a cardinal act mercy.

It is the objective nature of the action, rather than the subjective misunderstanding, that determines the sinfulness.
 
Thanks for the link. I will paste the quote here for others.

''Let us now proceed. We have spoken of the examination regarding mortal and venial sins. But were a person to do an action with a doubt whether it was a mortal or a venial sin, what kind of sin would he commit?

He would be guilty of mortal sin, because he exposes himself to the danger of grievously offending God. Hence, before he acts he must lay aside the doubt; and if he has not hitherto done so, he must confess it, at least, as it is before God. But the scrupulous, who have doubts about everything, must follow another rule: they must obey their confessor. When he tells them to conquer their doubts, and to act against scruples, they should obey with exactness; otherwise they will render themselves unable and unfit to perform any spiritual exercise.’’

St. Alphonsus Maria de Liguori
 
To the OP…

I suggest you meditate upon Romans 7

an excerpt…

The Law and Sin
7 What then shall we say? That the law is sin? By no means! Yet, if it had not been for the law, I should not have known sin. I should not have known what it is to covet if the law had not said, “You shall not covet.” 8 But sin, finding opportunity in the commandment, wrought in me all kinds of covetousness. Apart from the law sin lies dead. 9 I was once alive apart from the law, but when the commandment came, sin revived and I died; 10 the very commandment which promised life proved to be death to me. 11 For sin, finding opportunity in the commandment, deceived me and by it killed me. 12 So the law is holy, and the commandment is holy and just and good.

The Inner Conflict
13 Did that which is good, then, bring death to me?[a] By no means! It was sin, working death in me through what is good, in order that sin might be shown to be sin, and through the commandment might become sinful beyond measure. 14 We know that the law is spiritual; but I am carnal, sold under sin. 15 I do not understand my own actions. For I do not do what I want, but I do the very thing I hate. 16 Now if I do what I do not want, I agree that the law is good. 17 So then it is no longer I that do it, but sin which dwells within me. 18 For I know that nothing good dwells within me, that is, in my flesh. I can will what is right, but I cannot do it. 19 For I do not do the good I want, but the evil I do not want is what I do. 20 Now if I do what I do not want, it is no longer I that do it, but sin which dwells within me.

21 So I find it to be a law that when I want to do right, evil lies close at hand. 22 For I delight in the law of God, in my inmost self, 23 but I see in my members another law at war with the law of my mind and making me captive to the law of sin which dwells in my members. 24 Wretched man that I am! Who will deliver me from this body of death? 25 Thanks be to God through Jesus Christ our Lord! So then, I of myself serve the law of God with my mind, but with my flesh I serve the law of sin.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top