Wedding Dilemma - Who should stand up?

  • Thread starter Thread starter MelissaMarie
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
La Chiara:
John, I understand where you are coming from but I think you are harsh in your judgement that Melissa is “cutting off the opportunity…to be grace” for her sister. I agree that she should not be harsh in her assessment of her sister and cut her any relationship with her. But I don’t think she is doing that from what she has shared with us. It is a less than ideal situation–a situation created by her sister’s choices.

I don’t think Melissa has to parade her 8 1/2 months pregnant sister in all of her wedding pictures just to prove that Melissa is a good sister. At a projected 8 1/2 months pregnant, the sister (even if married) is likely to be unreliable for her wedding as she could easily have the baby two weeks early. Furthermore, Melissa chose her sister as bridesmaid when she was living a virtuous life. Melissa is the bride and has every right to be the center of attention, not her sister the bridesmaid who is ready to be an unmarried mother at any minute. I think we should support Melissa in the decisions she has chosen.
👍

I competely agree with you. A wedding is not a time for the bride and groom to feel that they have to please every member of their family in order to ‘build bridges’. If I had my druthers- there would only be the couple and one attendent each! I think the additional members of the wedding party add additional stress (for planning and arranging) which ultimately pulls our attention further away from the reason why these two people are there to begin with!

I had my child out of wedlock - that is not virtuous. Did I make good decisions after the bad? Yup. Does that mean that people should look over the bad decision to begin with? Nope. It was my feelings of guilt and sadness, and the uncomfortable situations like this, which led me BACK to the Church- after I had lived for a time making unholy and bad decisions.

MelissaMarie- You need only to be in the church for your wedding day, prepared and resolute, in your mind, body and spirit, to offer yourself to your groom in Holy Matrimony for your life. You can mend fences with your sister outside of this.

There are often negative reprocussions for our bad decisions. You are not punishing her for being pregnant out of wedlock! You are making sure your Wedding Day has an appropriate sanctity to it. Now if you were having a groomsman who was a known and flagrant adulterer stand up for your husband- I would say the very same thing… Invite him to the wedding, enjoy his presence in the ‘audience’ but do not involve him in the religious ceremony.

I think you are making a valiant effort to include your sister in your day, and in your ceremony- without making the situation uncomfortable for you, your family and friends (outside of your sister), or the priest. She will hopefully realize that you love her very much- but that you do not support her lifestyle- nor do you want to make an example of it by including her in the religious ceremony per se.

I’m sure, like La Chiara, I will receive rebukes of uncharitable, and be relegated as old fashioned or out of touch. But if we agree that the big problems in this our society have a lot to do with the structure of the family, then why not start supporting family values at the earliest possible place? We need not coddle unwed pregnant sisters just because ‘she wants to be involved in the ceremony’, which, as her actions indicate, she obviously does not have a full communion with. Let’s support family values during dating, at the marriage ceremony, AND during the married life.
 
Have you spoken to the priest about this yet? When I got married, the maid of honor and the best man were expected to be practicing Catholics in much the same way as a godparent. In fact, my husband is from South America and the witnesses at weddings there ARE the godparents. The other attendants have no official role according to the Church’s position so the priest may be ok with whoever you chose.
 
Shiann–What a beautiful, thoughtful post! Thank you for articulating exactly what I feel but was unable to express so well. God bless you for sharing the road you have traveled. You clearly are a deeply devout person and a loving woman too. :blessyou:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top