Were the crusades done correctly?

  • Thread starter Thread starter scimitar60
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
S

scimitar60

Guest
I have got a question. Howcome the intention of the crusades was apparently good, but the way they were done was very bad? The crusaders pillaged and looted towns, murdered and raped women, and did things that we would call sin (Im not 100% sure but that’s what most sources say). The crusades in the east from the Teutonic Knights were pretty darn brutal too.
Thoughts?
 
I have got a question. Howcome the intention of the crusades was apparently good, but the way they were done was very bad? The crusaders pillaged and looted towns, murdered and raped women, and did things that we would call sin (Im not 100% sure but that’s what most sources say). The crusades in the east from the Teutonic Knights were pretty darn brutal too.
Thoughts?
What year was that?

Seems like life in general back then was pretty brutal.
 
I have got a question. Howcome the intention of the crusades was apparently good, but the way they were done was very bad? The crusaders pillaged and looted towns, murdered and raped women, and did things that we would call sin (Im not 100% sure but that’s what most sources say). The crusades in the east from the Teutonic Knights were pretty darn brutal too.
Thoughts?
Can you find an objective source to back up the allegation of abuse against the Crusaders?

It’s well known that the Fourth Crusade was a disaster, with the ground commanders disobeying orders and attacking the Byzantines instead of the intended targets. But other than that the Crusades were basically just the medieval equivalent of the War on Terror, with some abuses as would be expected in any war, but nothing systemic like the black legends insinuate.
 
No they were left unfinished. Sinners existed then and now. The objectives of the crusades were not the sins and moral failures of a few (these sins exist in all organizations for it is human to sin). It doesnt make it right or just that we sin because we are human, nor dos it make a nessary and good movement (the crusades) wrong.:knight1:
 
Well, in the first crusade, when the crusaders breached Jerusalem they went around murdering all the inhabitents. It is said 40,000 were massacred. How is that not a war crime.
 
Well, in the first crusade, when the crusaders breached Jerusalem they went around murdering all the inhabitents. It is said 40,000 were massacred. How is that not a war crime.
The casualties in the First Crusade are unknown. The larger numbers come from Muslim sources and are therefore unreliable.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top